The KPMG report, the marketing of 80 DeKalb, and Forest City Ratner's deceptive promises about AY "housing for Brooklyn"
The only problem: market-rate housing follows the market, natch, so renters and buyers come from anywhere.
As shown in the Atlantic Yards market study by KPMG, commissioned by the Empire State Development Corporation (ESDC) and released Wednesday, most new residents of market-rate units (4180 of 6430 units) would come from outside Brooklyn:
Although any new and upscale development in Brooklyn that offers transportation benefits similar to the Subject Property will likely attract residents from within New York City as well as the suburbs, a significant number of residents will likely come from Manhattan and to a lesser extent Brooklyn. Those from Brooklyn will likely involve "move-up" residents.
Keep in mind that 450 units of the 2250 subsidized units would be close to the top of the market, while another 450 would be well over the minimum.
Also, FCR's marketing for the 80 DeKalb Avenue tower in Fort Greene, which the developer considers a test run for the AY market-rate units, seems geared to introducing Manhattanites and others relocating to Brooklyn to a chic neighborhood.
The "for Brooklyn" mantra
While half of the 2250 subsidized AY units would be reserved for residents of the three Community Board districts encompassing the project site, the rest would be distributed via lottery.
And the 2250 market-rate rentals and 1930 (as of now) condos would be available to those willing to pay the freight.
In an 11/06/05 New York Times article, published after I and others had pointed out how office space had been traded for condos, Forest City Ratner officials claimed they were "already contemplating adding 1,500 condominium units, in part because community leaders had pushed Mr. Ratner to include more housing in the project"--though, as I pointed out, ACORN certainly didn't want more market-rate housing.
October 2006 brochure
The claims continued in the October 2006 brochure at right, released less than two months before the project went before the Empire State Development Corporation for approval, in which the developer asserted:
Atlantic Yards will create over 6,800 units of badly needed mixed-income housing for Brooklyn.
Again, there's no reason to believe that most of the housing would be "for Brooklyn," for established Brooklyites, or somehow contributing to a mythic borough tax collection agency.
It's just rhetoric, part of the endless "Brooklyn" invocations practiced by Borough President Marty Markowitz and other project supporters.
Learning from 80 DeKalb
Forest City Ratner sees its 80 DeKalb tower, which would include 80% market-rate units and 20% low-income units, as a test run for the market rate housing planned for Atlantic Yards.
(ACORN, FCR's partner on Atlantic Yards, has praised the developer for "not going the ordinary 80-20 route and building a lot of luxury apartments for people who hang out in luxury skyboxes." It hasn't criticized FCR for 80 DeKalb.)
As FCR's MaryAnne Gilmartin in October 2007 described 80 DeKalb as “the first opportunity for our company to capitalize on… the residential renaissance that we see in Brooklyn. And it allows to sample the market firsthand as a preview for Atlantic Yards. So in many ways it will inform the rollout of our residential product for the Atlantic Yards project.”
(Graphic via Brownstoner)
As I wrote after the second and final community forum (aka extension of public hearing) in September 2006, though there had been much testimony about the 2250 units of affordable housing, nobody spoke for the unmentioned 4610 (as of now) households that would move into the market-rate rentals and condos.
Now we have some clues.
Take a closer look at the new DKLB web site. It claims:
You can actually feel the vibe coming off the streets in Fort Greene. Boutique shops bustling with designer and vintage wares, a world-renowned arts and music scene, upscale wine bars, bustling cafes, artisanal restaurants with a penchant for Greenmarket ingredients, and about half the world's cuisines in the span of a few blocks. But turn a corner and you're on a quiet, tree-lined street with classic Brooklyn brownstones, or lush and hilly Fort Greene Park...
At the heart of it all is DKLB BKLN, a high-rise rental offering the very best in amenities and conveniences. Plus, it's LEED certified, making eco-living as easy as walking in your door. Distance-wise, it's one subway stop from Manhattan, but attitude-wise, it's world away.
The web site promises such amenities as concierge services and a screening room. (The web site, in its early iteration, even professed to teach people Brooklynese, as in the word Yous.)
Conspicuously missing: any indication that the tower would be close to the planned Atlantic Yards arena.
From the community forum: "You're not from Fort Greene"
Given the way Forest City Ratner and Atlantic Yards supporters have framed the issue, you'd think Atlantic Yards was some kind of low-income housing project. It's not. (Only 900 of 6430 planned units would be available to low-income households.)
So, I'll remind newcomers to Fort Greene what Carpenters Union leader John Holt Sr. said at that community forum, asserting that Atlantic Yards was about "the haves and the have-nots," and suggesting a lack of Fort Greene authenticity among anyone who dared to question the project.
What he might say to the newcomer renting at 80 DeKalb?
From the transcript:
MR. JOHN HOLT: My name is John William Holt, Sr., Thomasina (phonetic) Holt's baby boy. I am from Fort Greene. I remember Fort Greene from a long time ago from Jay Street to Broadway when the train used to run over my head. It was traffic then. We knew about this Ratner project for years.
I don't want to hear about the sewers. I don't want to hear about the electric. I don't want to hear about your air conditioner. We build it and we build it big. We build sewer plants. We build electrical plants. We build anything that you need in this world --
MR. JOHN HOLT: -- you understand what I'm saying?
MR. JOHN HOLT: I am the Executive Delegate for the Carpenters Union and I also speak for them. This is about the have and the have-nots. This is a classification thing, that's all this is. We didn't ask you to come to Fort Greene, okay, Fort Greene has been this way for the longest, all right.
If you didn't play scullies, stickball, okay, catch kick the can, you not from Fort Greene, okay;
MR. JOHN HOLT: If you didn't play hot peas and butter, you not from Fort Greene, you just moved here, okay; If you didn't play red rover, red rover, send Forest Ratner over, you understand what I'm saying, you're not from Fort Greene. I'm from Fort Greene.
I remember when we used to have the Fox Theatre, okay. I remember when we had the Paramount. I remember when I couldn't go into Juniors. But it's a different day now, I can walk into Juniors and eat anything I want in there because of the unions.
Now, I can show you a big thing and you will protest until the days go long. But I can show you little, lot of things that they're building around here and you won't say nothing, nothing at all, nothing.
MR. JOHN HOLT: There's a lot of little things that's going on. Like a fair days' wages for our union brothers and sisters, okay.
MR. JOHN HOLT: We're not illegal aliens. We pay our taxes and all we want is to send our children to school. We don't want to see them in jail. Our children go to the same school that we live in, not private school like you people who live here, okay? We don't have nannies, okay.
MR. JOHN HOLT: We don't have nannies. We don't have people coming in to clean our houses. And if they did, we won't be like you people and pay taxes on them. And we would give them a fair wage because that's what we believe in.
I once heard a great general say, man cannot live without war. Well, my philosophy is - and I've been preaching it since I've gotten into the unit - we cannot live if we do not build. If we do not build, my philosophy is we will die.
Ladies and gentlemen, I am for the stadium, for the have-nots --
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: Twenty seconds.
MR. JOHN HOLT: -- the people from Fort Greene because they deserve something nice, they deserve to be part of it, okay. I am for the stadium, for the men and hard women that come into our business.
And first of all, you got to understand, we employ of lot of minority people, okay, black people. I'm not --
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: Time is up.
MR. JOHN HOLT:-- a minority, I'm colored, all right. I'm black.
We have a lot of black people --
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: Time is up.
MR. JOHN HOLT: We build careers.
THE PRESIDING OFFICER: Time is up.
MR. JOHN HOLT: Thank you.