Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts with the label Dan Doctoroff

Featured Post

Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park FAQ, timeline, and infographics (pinned post)

AY down the memory hole: Doctoroff credited by NY Times for Atlantic Yards' "larger plan for 17 high-rises." No, project wasn't abandoned.

OK, when a New York Times profile of former Deputy Mayor Dan Doctoroff, posted online 9/6/23, bizarrely credited the former city official with the Atlantic Yards plan but also said the recession forced its abandonment, I tweeted the following "Apartment towers... rise" far more slowly than originally planned, and delay means that baseline for #affordablehousing calculations rises steadily. In his book, Doctoroff admitted he thought #AtlanticYards was a "crazy risk," but he played good soldier https://t.co/m1DNHH5pDc — Norman Oder (@AYReport) September 6, 2023 Following up When I saw the article in print three days later,  His Mind Helped Rebuild New York. His Body Is Failing Him.  with the mistake intact, I wrote a letter to the newspaper, seeking a correction: By no stretch of imagination should Doctoroff be credited with "larger plan for 17 high-rises." Rather, the plan was developed by developer Forest City Ratner/Bruce Ratner, and shepherded/ap...

"What the Builder Built:" a profile of Bloomberg's Deputy Mayor Doctoroff in New York Magazine sends Atlantic Yards down the memory hole.

So I'm late to this, but New York Magazine's big 8/2/23 profile of former Deputy Mayor Dan Doctoroff,  What the Builder Built  is worth a critical read.  In the magazine's Table of Contents, the subheading is "Dan Doctoroff, the stubborn advocate for a new New York City, reckons with his legacy," while the article is appended with a slightly differnt framing: "Under Mayor Bloomberg, Dan Doctoroff remade the city at top speed. Now, as New York is again mired in crisis, he faces his own." Architecture critic Justin Davidson is a deft writer, and captures much of what Doctoroff (empowered by Mike Bloomberg, of course) shepherded, including: On the day I meet  Dan Doctoroff , I walk across Manhattan from the Shed, which he created, to the East River Esplanade, which he planned; catch a ferry, which he launched; get off at the  Long Island City  waterfront, which he reclaimed from industrial neglect; and enter a café overlooking  Hunters Point South Pa...

A revelation from Doctoroff: despite his public enthusiasm, he thought Atlantic Yards was a "crazy risk" (but considers it transformative)

As I write in Gotham Gazette, former Deputy Mayor Dan Doctoroff, in his  Greater Than Ever: New York's Big Comeback , adds some new insights about Atlantic Yards, but his triumphant narrative ignores some countervailing evidence. While Doctoroff gets wrong the location of the project, the amount of subsidies, and the fact that the city's money paid for land rather than infrastructure, and he looks rosily at the arena without acknowledging problems for neighbors, he makes one interesting revelation, and one shocking one, which I expand on below. (He also says, dubiously, that Bruce Ratner first wanted to buy the New Jersey Devils, not the New Jersey Nets, while evidence suggests only that it was once a package deal.) The shocking revelation: Atlantic Yards too risky from the start? As I write in Gotham Gazette: A more important revelation from Doctoroff is that, while he and the Bloomberg administration were public cheerleaders for Atlantic Yards--“My role in this was...

A year after Ratner/Gilmartin got Onassis Medal, award goes to former Deputy Mayor Doctoroff; some caveats

Last year, it was Forest City Ratner's Bruce Ratner & MaryAnne Gilmartin . Now it's former Deputy Mayor Dan Doctoroff. For the second straight year, the Municipal Art Society has chosen a figure associated with aggressive building for the Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis Medal , which "bears Mrs. Onassis’ name in recognition of her tireless efforts to preserve and protect New York’s great architecture" but surely is being awarded for broader reasons. From the announcement: This year, MAS is proud to recognize Daniel L. Doctoroff for his tireless dedication to the people and places that make New York so diverse and inspiring. From his visionary leadership of New York City’s economic revitalization to his spearheading of the city’s comprehensive sustainability plan; his commitment to creating new cultural destinations and parks throughout the five boroughs to his bold visions for the future of New York City, our 2015 recipient has had and will continue to ha...

Muddying Atlantic Yards (more than once) in the city's Olympics saga

Ah, Atlantic Yards down the memory hole, more than once... In today's Daily News, columnist Linda Stasi slams the idea of another Olympics bid: Dear Gov. Cuomo, I’m writing to applaud your announcement last week that you’re considering a bid to bring the 2024 Olympics to New York City under the leadership of Mayor Bloomberg’s failed Olympic point man, Daniel Doctoroff. ...Doctoroff has been quoted in the New York Times, among other outlets, stating that Bloomberg’s bid for the 2012 Olympics actually helped New York so much it’s nearly incalculable. For instance? Well, he believes it was the catalyst for the new Yankee Stadium, as well as for the development of the Atlantic Yards (including Barclays Center) and, yes, the High Line. Well, so what if Yankee Stadium planning began well before Doctoroff and Bloomy were in office? And who cares that Bruce Ratner had already bought the Nets with a plan to move the team to a new facility in Brooklyn before the Olympics bid was in play? ...

Did Bloomberg's Olympic legacy really pay off? Some dissent to the new narrative, and an odd attempt to shoehorn in Atlantic Yards

A new report, How New York City Won the Olympics (also embedded below), argues that most of the benefits of the city's 2012 Olympics bid have been achieved, and without the crushing costs of the event. It has drawn supportive coverage from the New York Times (though see this cautionary comment ) and an enthusiastic New York Daily News editorial , plus coverage in The Bond Buyer . But it should be taken with significant skepticism. The report is authored by the much-quoted Mitchell L. Moss, Director, Rudin Center for Transportation Policy and Management, Robert F. Wagner Graduate School of Public Service, New York University. Moss, an advisor to Mayor Mike Bloomberg's 2001 mayoral campaign, has often defended Bloomberg and the Olympic Plan's chief architect, former Deputy Mayor Dan Doctoroff, so--despite failure to mention that connection in press coverage--that connection must be layered on his academic credentials. Also, the report includes some strained atte...

Doctoroff, updated, with video: was there really any "citywide planning"

So I updated my July 15 post on Deputy Mayor Dan Doctoroff's Atlantic Yards revisionism with a link to video and additional verbatim comments. The Atlantic Yards discussion comes about two-thirds of the way through. The video confirmed my observation that Doctoroff was, in his wry and easygoing way, evasive, suggesting that Atlantic Yards was needed as a "center" for Downtown Brooklyn. But the really disingenuous part came at the end of the segment. Doctoroff said, "But there are situations where the imperatives for the city from the strategic perspective demand that you have sort of a broader audience that you're appealing to than just the local community." "That's in fact the whole principle of citywide planning," responded architectural critic Paul Goldberger, his interlocutor. Both are conceptually correct, but the concepts don't apply in this case. Citywide planning: what if? Had there been citywide planning, then Winston Von Engel,...

Doctoroff posits justification for Atlantic Yards: Downtown Brooklyn “needed more of a center” (but there was no plan until FCR stepped forward)

Updated July 19 with link to video and additional verbatim comments. The AY discussion comes about two-thirds of the way through. Former Deputy Mayor for Economic Development Dan Doctoroff has to be feeling pretty good. He didn't bring the Olympics to New York, and that smarts, and he couldn't get the West Side Stadium passed. But he got most of the Bloomberg administration's ambitious land use agenda passed during his six-year tenure, which ended in 2007 . Now, in his genial, confident way, Doctoroff can look back and contend, as he has before , that he managed to thread the needle between Jane Jacobs and Robert Moses, to get projects passed with sufficient public input and without much displacement, to make omelets (in Moses's famous formulation) but without breaking eggs. And if he's not challenged--as he was back in 2007 by Majora Carter , then of Sustainable South Bronx--he just might get away with it. Doctoroff had said, as he's said since, that he and th...

Greg David of Crain's: Deputy Mayor Dan Doctoroff "orchestrated" Atlantic Yards

Within a 25th anniversary retrospective headlined New York City: Then & Now: Whether in a real estate boom or fiscal bust, NYC revolves around Wall Street's siren song , Greg David of Crain's New York Business offers a section about former Deputy Mayor for Economic Development Dan Doctoroff, with a paragraph about Atlantic Yards: Even without the Olympics as a rationale, he made remarkable progress. At the end of 2006, he conceived of a way for the city to finance a subway-line extension to Hudson Yards on the West Side, where he envisioned a multibillion-dollar residential and commercial neighborhood. Behind the scenes, he orchestrated the approval of a massive mixed-used project at Atlantic Yards in Brooklyn, anchored by an arena for the New Jersey Nets basketball team. Well, he helped orchestrate the approval--it's a state project, not a city one--and, more likely, orchestrated the package of city subsidies and the city's unswerving commitment to the project. Not...

Missing from the New Yorker's Bloomberg profile: public authorities and the real story of Atlantic Yards

A profile in this week's New Yorker, clocking in at more than ten thousand words, is headlined The Untouchable: Can a good mayor amass too much power? , and presents this tension: Thanks to his money, Bloomberg has managed, perhaps more than any democratic politician ever before, to govern strictly with what he considers to be the greater good in mind. And, thanks to his money, the counterargument goes, he has essentially corrupted the system itself. Is it always the greater good? In other words, should the Mayor be seen, at worst, as using questionable means for good ends, or do questionable means lead to questionable ends? I think Bloomberg's record is mixed, but on Atlantic Yards and development issues, he's vulnerable to much criticism. So Ben McGrath's New Yorker profile, while reasonably thorough and hardly a valentine, could've been much tougher. Notably, had McGrath waited until this week to write, he would've learned that Bloomberg is the prime culprit...