Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts with the label tax-exempt bonds

Featured Post

Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park FAQ, timeline, and infographics (pinned post)

Foregone property taxes on Barclays Center now estimated at $122.7M, tiny decrease. Other venues see growth. PILOTs pay off tax-exempt construction debt.

OK, it's time for the annual look at the foregone property taxes for the Barclays Center and the other major New York City sports venues.  While the non-paid taxes for the Brooklyn arena had risen from $53.7 million to $123.6 million, as of last year, as I  reported , this year, there's been a slight reversal, to $122.7 million, as indicated in the screenshot below, according to the New York City Department of Finance's  Annual Report on Tax Expenditures . That, of course, dwarfs the $5 million a year "invested"  since 2020 by the Social Justice Fund of the Joe and Clara Tsai Foundation, the philanthropic venture of the arena company owners By contrast, as shown in the screenshot below, the tax exemption for Citifield, home of the New York Mets, rose from $159.7 million to $165 million and the exemption for Yankee Stadium (NYC Dept. of Parks and Recreation), home of the New York Yankees, rose from $129.5 million to $133.3 million. They get their tax break via th...

Foregone property taxes on Barclays Center now estimated at $123.6 million. Payments in lieu of (some) taxes go not to NYC but pay off cheap construction debt.

So, the foregone property taxes for the Barclays Center have continued to rise, from $53.7 million in 2018 all the way to $110.2 million last year ( link ) and now $123.6 million, as shown in the screenshot below. (See the red outline.) That's according to the New York City Department of Finance's  Annual Report on Tax Expenditures . Note the larger tax expenditures for the two addresses directly above Barclays, Citifield and Yankee Stadium, which also benefit from tax-exempt land.  (They get their tax break via the city Industrial Development Authority, or IDA, while the arena gets its via the Urban Development Corporation, or UDC, which operates as Empire State Development, or ESD.) Also note the oddly depressed tax break, as calculated by the city, for MSG Arena, only $42.9 million. Surely Madison Square Garden site is more valuable than Barclays. That's because, as the Independent Budget Office has  suggested , the valuation is artificially depressed, given that ...

Foregone property taxes on Barclays Center site now estimated at $110.2M. Payments in lieu of (some) taxes go not to NYC but pay off cheap construction debt

In May 2022, I reported that foregone property taxes for the Barclays Center continued to rise, reaching $85 million, from $61.3 million in 2017 and, oddly enough, $53.7 million in 2018. Today they're more than double the low point, according to the New York City Department of Finance's Annual Report on Tax Expenditures , reaching $98.6 million last year and $110.2 million this year. That's all a nice gift to arena operators and team owners. FY 2023 In Fiscal Year 2023 , the foregone taxes for the arena reached $98.6 million. Note the larger tax expenditures for the two addresses directly above it, Citifield and Yankee Stadium, which also benefit from tax-exempt land. Also note the oddly depressed tax break, as calculated by the city for MSG Arena, only $42.4 million. Surely Madison Square Garden is more valuable than Barclays.  That's because, as the Independent Budget Office has suggested , the valuation is artificially depressed, given that the city, knowing of the ...

New guidance from the Treasury Department would further affordable housing, but only for low-income units

If the 421-a tax break doesn't return soon, are there any alternatives for developers of the Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park project? An 8/26/22 Bloomberg article Affordable Housing Developers Look to the White House for Help  notes that, nationally speaking, "supply-chain disruptions, inflation and a shortage of construction workers drive costs up and extend development timelines." But the White House will allow use of American Rescue Plan funding for affordable housing: The new guidance from Treasury enables the use of these funds to fully finance long-term affordable housing loans. That would make a lot more financing available for projects built using Low-Income Housing Tax Credits, the nation’s primary vehicle for building new affordable housing. That's low-income affordable housing, not middle-income "affordable housing," as enabled by the most recent iteration of the 421-a. What Treasury said From a 7/27/22 press release from the U.S. Treasury Department...

Foregone property taxes for Barclays Center continue to rise, now reaching $85 million. It's all part of "NYC's Perpetual Corporate Tax Break Machine."

The new web site Hell Gate on 5/16/22 published  Albany Problems: NYC's Perpetual Corporate Tax Break Machine , by Doug Turetsky, formerly of the city's Independent Budget Office (IBO). Starting with the 421-a tax break, he notes that "tax expenditures, or tax dollars the City forgoes, make up a sizable hunk of the City's budget—about $7 billion this year." And while some "seem intuitive, like forgoing property tax from the city's public housing authority," others are far more questionable. One prime example: Take Barclays Center. The arena hasn't paid property taxes since it opened in 2012. It's a tax expenditure that will cost the city $85 million this year alone, according to the City's Department of Finance Annual Tax Expenditure Report . Barclays' property tax break is part of a financing scheme that helped the arena's developers get around a 1986 federal law aiming to limit the use of tax-exempt bonds to finance stadium cons...

Ratings agency Moody's: Barclays Center has "strong recovery prospects," given pent-up demand, though chance remains for another COVID hit

Moody's announces completion of a periodic review of ratings of Brooklyn Arena Local Development Corporation , the ratings agency announced 10/13/21.  In other words, it didn't attempt to change the credit rating, which in October 2019 was downgraded to junk (Ba1), but it tried to survey the arena's prospects, which should be improving thanks to resumption of events. This came after the arena operating company released its FY 2021 results , which reflected a very rough year, given that the arena was mostly closed. From the announcement: Moody's Investors Service ("Moody's") has completed a periodic review of the ratings of Brooklyn Arena Local Development Corporation and other ratings that are associated with the same analytical unit. The review was conducted through a portfolio review discussion held on 7 October 2021 in which Moody's reassessed the appropriateness of the ratings in the context of the relevant principal methodology(ies), recent devel...

Does underinformed de Blasio really want MSG, Barclays Center to pay more in taxes? Who knows, but he's right that sports franchises in NYC have "gained incredible value"

De Blasio wants Madison Square Garden, other sports venues to pay more taxes , the New York Post reported yesterday, as did FoxBusiness, in De Blasio says Madison Square Garden, other NYC sports venues should pay more taxes . However, as WBAI producer Jillian Jonas, who raised the question during the mayor's press conference yesterday, commented when she circulated the exchange via email, "Pretty certain the answer is no." After all, the famously underinformed mayor said that, since he hadn't seen the 9/3/20 letter circulated by nine Council Members raising the issue, he was speaking "broadly," without knowledge of the legal specifics. Still, de Blasio's surely right that sports franchises have "gained incredible value," and part of that relates to their location in the world's media capital, so there's a good case--as was made by Slate after Mikhail Prokhorov sold the Brooklyn Nets to Joe Tsai--that some of that value increase ...

Ratings agency S&P (citing Nets' deal) joins Moody's (citing Islanders) in warning that Barclays Center bonds verge on junk

Mikhail Prokhorov may have gotten a record-setting valuation  in the sale of the Nets--partial, so far--to Joseph Tsai, but apparently there was a sweetener in the deal--and that may be putting bondholders at risk, according to the ratings agency Standard & Poor's (S&P).  The sweetener--instead of the arena operator keeping all food and beverage revenues from Nets games, it would only keep 30%--advantages the team owner, and offers less to the arena operator and thus bondholders expecting secure payments, according to S&P. On 4/20/18, the ratings agency  affirmed the debt rating of the Brooklyn Arena Local Development Corporation (the state  entity that issued the debt) of  BBB- , just barely within "investment grade" and above junk, but with a negative outlook, indicating that the rating was unstable.  Crain's New York Business first wrote about this yesterday, with the headline  Barclays Center bonds are just about jun...

The O&M bump: NY official claims arena bond refinancing didn't benefit Prokhorov (it did)

It's a rather astounding footnote to the $493.7 million refinancing last August of bonds for the Barclays Center, which are paid off by the arena operating company, now owned by Mikhail Prokhorov's Brooklyn Sports & Entertainment (BSE). A New York State official said publicly that refinancing at a lower interest rate didn't benefit Prokhorov, because the savings get put into a separate fund for arena maintenance and capital improvements. Not quite. That lowers Prokhorov's obligation. Everyone else reported the refinancing as a benefit, as noted in the Bloomberg headline above right, "Barclays Center Refinancing Saves $90 Million for Prokhorov." After all, according to the  arena lease  between the state landlord, the Brooklyn Arena Local Development Corporation (BALDC), and tenant Brooklyn Events Center (parent of the arena operating company), the tenant must pay for operations and maintenance (O&M). Operating & maintenance over the p...

Brookings: no justification for federal subsidies that supported Barclays Center, two NYC stadiums

On 9/8/16, the centrist Brookings Institution posted a summary of its new report, with the provocative headline, Why the federal government should stop spending billions on private sports stadiums . It pointed out that the use of tax-exempt municipal bonds to fund venue construction constitutes a major federal subsidy, estimated as $431 million for the new Yankee Stadium. That concept has been raised before, but the study points to an additional loss in federal tax revenues, a "windfall tax break" for bondholders, such as $61 million for Yankee Stadium. So that reaches $492 million. The Barclays Center figure is $122 million and, thanks to that tax break, $161 million (though both totals deserve a caveat, as I explain below). The Real Deal summarized it as  Three NYC stadiums received $867M in federal subsidies: study . Those three venues--Yankee Stadium, Barclays Center, and CitiField--represented about one-quarter of the national total. The report In the ...

Bloomberg: bond refinancing saves Prokhorov $90 million (but it's actually more); estimated income well below earlier projections

Yes, the bonds sold, and quickly. As Bloomberg reported yesterday,  Barclays Center Refinancing Saves $90 Million for Prokhorov : Charles Mierswa, chief financial officer of the Nets and Barclays Center, said the amount is based on present value savings, or the current worth of a future steam of cash flows. Investors placed orders for almost 10 times the amount of bonds available, he said. ...The largest piece of the deal, $228.5 million of uninsured bonds with a 5 percent coupon maturing in 2042, was priced to yield 2.88 percent. The debt, which is callable in January 2027, yields 1.44 percentage point more than top-rated debt of the same maturity, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. The bonds, which were issued by the Brooklyn Arena Local Development Corporation and are backed by payments in lieu of taxes, will refinance debt issued in 2009 at a top yield of 8 percent. While the tax-exempt financing, enabled by the nominal state ownership of the arena, would save Prok...