Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts with the label Subsidies

Featured Post

Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park FAQ, timeline, and infographics (pinned post)

Downtown Brooklyn Partnership claims (nah) city & state governments have already funded platform over LIRR railyard, claims $686M (!) in arena public support.

Downtown Brooklyn Partnership growth map; Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park is at right The Downtown Brooklyn Partnership (DBP), the "not-for-profit local development corporation that serves as the primary champion for Downtown Brooklyn as a world-class business, cultural, educational, residential, and retail destination," recently released DOWNTOWN BROOKLYN: 20 YEARS OF GROWTH . It's an interesting project, using maps and graphics to show the remarkable transformation of the area--not just the rezoning area--since the 2004 Downtown Brooklyn rezoning, with 32 million square feet of new development. What shocked me was the claim, discussed further below, that city and state governments have already funded the platform, which I first suspected was an inadvertent disclosure of an upcoming subsidy but turned out to be a bogus overreach.  From DBP report Also, it was surprising that the DBP, rather than trying to minimize--as is typical for boosterish business groups--the public s...

New state Enhanced Database of Economic Incentives excludes Atlantic Yards, because it was approved before 2018. Database also omits tax breaks & local subsidies.

What are the economic incentives, past and present, behind Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park?  (They include direct city and state subsidies of $305 million and far more in tax breaks, roughly summarized in my  FAQ .) Well, a new Database of Economic Incentives from New York State isn't that helpful, since 1) it doesn't provide information on projects that were approved prior to 2018 and 2) even if it did, it ignores city subsidies and most tax breaks.  Note: ESD says "Details on [previously-approved] projects can be found in historical ESD reports," but I haven't been able to find anything related to Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park.   A trumphant announcement Governor Hochul Launches Enhanced Database of Economic Incentives to Increase Transparency Around Key Economic Development Projects , the state announced Nov. 8, updating a project first launched in 2021 and updated quarterly "New York State’s Database of Economic Incentives [ link ] is nation-leading in terms of...

For now, the 421-a tax break is dead. But another revision might get on the legislative agenda in January.

The June 15 deadline to get residential buildings to qualify for the 421-a tax break has passed, and many now have the beginnings of foundations--and a three-year deadline, by 6/15/26, to complete construction. And that means, likely, a temporary stall on new construction, at least that which is not fully market-rate or significantly subsidized by the city. Dead and buried: 421a is gone. Will it ever return? , the Real Deal reported 6/15/22, noting that Gov. Kathy Hochul's proposed replacement program, 485-w , failed in the Legislature. That proposal, I'd note, would've required deeper affordability than the previous iteration (aka "Affordable New York"), passed in 2017, which allowed for 30% of units for households at 130% of Area Median Income (AMI)--people essentially earning six figures  and potentially paying more than $3,000 per unit. What next? The Real Deal noted, "In a joint statement, the Real Estate Board of New York, 32BJ SEIU and the New York Bui...

In 2013, incoming Mayor de Blasio said of Atlantic Yards, "On my watch, [the affordable housing] will happen." It's not close to complete (or at income levels promised). Now what?

Two days ago, as I wrote , lame-duck Mayor Bill de Blasio sounded all gung-ho about the Barclays Center, though there was reason to be a little more tempered.  For example, even after the current four towers under construction are completed, 876 more affordable housing units are required to be delivered in less than four years, by May 31, 2025, and that seems unlikely. Plus the definition of "affordable housing" has been stretched so the units delivered serve a far greater percentage of middle-class residents than initially promised. A too-sunny profile So eight years later, let's look back at a 10/31/13 New York Times profile of Public Advocate and Mayoral front-runner de Blasio, hadlined On Council, de Blasio Blended Idealism With Push for Power . It ended with the following paragraphs, which I reproduce in full, with some comments: But it was the Atlantic Yards project, a gigantic housing and arena development at the intersection of Flatbush and Atlantic Avenues, that...

Brooklyn Nets tickets now start at $70/game, at least for season-ticket plans. Times have changed. Shouldn't public support for Barclays Center (& MSG) be revisited?

Remember the promise, nine years ago, of $15 tickets to Brooklyn Nets games (and how it was rarely   fulfilled )? And remember that tickets soon rose to $25 and $45, then went back to $25 (and went lower on the secondary market), once the novelty wore off--after three years--and the team struggled? Well, those days are long in the past, now that the Nets have superstars. Game tickets are now on sale, at least for full- and half-season plans, with individual ticket sales--presuming some are being held back, for premium pricing against top rivals--announced at a later moment.  Season tickets for 43 games (41 regular season, plus two pre-season) cost a minimum $3,010, or $70/game, as shown in the screenshot at right. When I checked two days ago, however, there were no tickets available at that price, but rather a handful at $80 and $90 per game in the upper (200) section, at $3,440 and $3,870 (see screenshot) for the season. Tickets in the 100 section started at $5,590 , or $13...

As 421-a tax break faces June 2022 sunset, the real-estate industry is unsettled. Would Cuomo's departure affect legislative "fix" to enable Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park housing obligation?

Real Estate Developers Already Worrying About 421a Expiring Next Year , the Commercial Observer reported 8/3/21, and that has to include the developers behind Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park. As I've previously written , they have to get the next building started by 6/15/22--less than a year away!--under the current tax break, and the lack of a succession to the current policy makes it difficult to plan ahead. (See NYC Department of Finance FY 2021 report, at bottom, on tax expenditures including 421-a.) The tax break requires as much as 30% affordability, but those can be all middle-income units, at 130% of Area Median Income (as with 18 Sixth Ave., aka Brooklyn Crossing ), so that's diverged significantly from original Atlantic Yards plans. And a deadline of May 2025 looms to deliver the project's required affordable housing, in at least two more buildings. But getting a new building launched is not simple. Six towers rely on construction of the two-phase platform over the Va...

Where's New York State's Database of Deals? Revinvent Albany says Empire State Development is dragging on subsidy transparency. (I wonder what it will say about Atlantic Yards)

Reinvent Albany 4/29/21 published  Subsidy Sheet: What the Heck Will It Take to Get NY to Publish Its Database of Deals? , noting: Every single year, New York State government spends $4.4 billion in business subsidies, incentives, and tax breaks (our local governments spend an additional $5.5 billion). But after decades of spending – and six years since the Buffalo Billion bid-rigging scandal of 2015 , taxpayers still cannot see how much they are paying to individual businesses to create jobs or whether jobs are even being created. A Database of Deals is a fundamental transparency reform that would list all of the taxpayer subsidies received by a corporation, including the type of subsidy, jobs created or retained, and the cost per job to taxpayers. NYC, Florida, Maryland, and Indiana all have one. But efforts to make it a reality in New York State have been much tougher than expected. Their posting offers a litany of delay, from--guess who?--Empire State Development (ESD), the st...

Amid discussion of sports facilities and banking regulations, Barclays Center suggested as a "net positive." I'm not so sure. Nor does it fit the CRA

The new Sports Illustrated has, I guess, pseudonymous blog contributors, so on 12/30/19 we got Development of Sports Facilities Usually Regarded as a “Net Negative” for Local Municipalities, Multi-Use Arenas Can Be the Exception , from someone known as JohnWallStreet. That was stimulated by potential revisions in the federal Community Reinvestment Act to allow banks--which must make loans in lower-income areas, to fulfill that requirement by assisting sports venues. Sen. Ron Wyden (D-OR) warned about “ handouts for billionaires with no benefit to the low-income communities this program [is] supposed to help.” So, does it help those low-income communities? That doesn't quite get answered. But the author notes that sports venues are now "integrated as anchor tenants within a greater neighborhood development project" and quotes sports economist Roger Noll as saying a busy venue "can actually enhance the value of the [neighboring] investments" and suggests th...

Updating NYC subsidy level, thanks to 2010 document: $185 million, or $205 million?

How much did New York City give to Atlantic Yards in direct subsidy? In a February 2005 Memorandum of Understanding , the city and state each promised $100 million, with the state money for infrastructure and the city money for infrastructure or land purchases. Later we learned that the latter all went to reimburse Forest City Ratner's  seemingly generous payouts  for property owners. Only after the project was passed in 2006 did the city announced additional subsidies: apparently $105 million, as claimed by Forest City (see screenshot at right), leading to total of $305 million from city and state. The city later claimed its total subsidies are $179 million or $171.5 million , not $205 million. Another number Here's another estimate: $185 million, courtesy of the 2010 City Participation Agreement that covered potential reimbursement for public property, among other things. As highlighted below, the document cites $154 million in public subsidies, with...

DBP's Reed: land values in Downtown Brooklyn go from $80/sf to $500/sf (so MTA should've driven harder bargain); the perils of BK = "Silicon Valley" prediction

"I think the speed and pace and scale of what's happening in the borough now is why I think everyone's pinching themselves, and find it hard to believe," says Tucker Reed of the Downtown Brooklyn Partnership in the video below, produced by the Brooklyn Eagle, part of its coverage of Make It In Brooklyn: Inaugural innovation summit attracts top business leaders . "Land values in Downtown Brooklyn alone, over the last 18 months, have gone from $80 a square foot to 500 [dollars]," he continued. "That pace of change is hard to get your mind around." (I'm not sure those numbers are average, as opposed to the outliers.) Such change is part of why it has become more cost-effective to build Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park using conventional construction, despite developer Bruce Ratner's past claim that it was impossible (though that's what he proposed, and got approved). And it's also why, as I wrote , the expected prices for condos now...

Forest City: "100% affordable" building skewed toward six-figure earners fits "vision for all of Pacific Park"

It's "100% affordable," as Forest City Ratner executive Ashley Cotton several times described the coming B3 tower at the corner of Sixth Avenue and Pacific Street. But don't look behind the curtain: it's fine, according to Forest City Ratner, to  skew  affordable housing for Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park to middle-income households rather than, as long promised, spread more broadly.  Nothing's changed, Cotton claimed, adding that Forest City's community partners--who long advocated for low-income households as part of ACORN--signed on. (Who knows?) Looking more closely I wrote 4/7/15 how B3, which will break ground in June, will include 303 subsidized, below-market units, but most two-bedroom units will cost over $3,000, and well over half the units will go to households earning more than $100,000 . Instead AYR estimates; note that chart shown at meeting had lower 2014 AMI and cited 152 units in Band 5 Questioning Forest City Tonight,...

New they get it: Times editorial page suggests mayor should support libraries over sports facilities

It's a trifle ironic to read today's New York Times editorial, New York City’s Libraries Need Money , which states: Mr. de Blasio leads a city where the corporate and entertainment infrastructure are seldom neglected. Citi Field, Yankee Stadium and the Barclays Center, to name just three, are beneficiaries of hundreds of millions of dollars in taxpayer funds, as Jim Dwyer of The Times recently  pointed out , while schools and libraries languish. If the mayor wants to make this city better from the bottom up, he should do right by New Yorkers like those who gather most mornings on the steps of the shiny library on Main Street in Flushing, waiting for the doors to open. After all, after initially criticizing proposed public money for Atlantic Yards/Barclays Center, the Times editorial page went silent .

As predicted, Ratner looks to get government help--state-funded parking--for the Nassau Coliseum revamp

Where's the catch? I asked in August 2013, when Bruce Ratner's Nassau Events Center won the bid to renovate and revamp the antiquated Nassau Coliseum. As I wrote, I have to wonder when Nassau County Executive Ed Mangano announced "a historic public-private partnership... a 100% privately financed Coliseum that will share revenue with the County at zero expense to the taxpayer." We've since learned that Ratner will be able to sell naming rights to the project--a giveaway of sorts--and that he admitted he'd ask "the county’s Industrial Development Agency for some tax exemptions," as the Times reported. But Professor Dennis Coates warned they might "back out of the deal at some point and come back to the county and say we need more money, and the county will be on the hook.” From Cuomo's Opportunity Agenda That's not what has happened (yet), but Newsday reported yesterday that Gov. Andrew M. Cuomo has proposed spending $150 ...

When it was politically prudent in 2009, de Blasio said "no more subsidies" for Atlantic Yards; now, a hint of more

Remember how, as the Times reported 4/19/14 about another subsidy push for Atlantic Yards: In recent days, [Forest City Ratner CEO] Ms. [MaryAnne] Gilmartin has met with Alicia Glen, the deputy mayor for housing and economic development, to talk about the next three buildings and the possibility of additional housing subsidies for apartments for poor and working-class families.“We’re going to drive a tough but fair bargain so we can get this project moving,” Ms. Glen said. “We’re not happy about the pace of construction. But we think that modular is something we should continue to pursue across the city.” Hyping rents to immigrant investors As I wrote 5/5/145, one thing to watch is whether the additional subsidy will be designed for Atlantic Yards exclusively or whether it will be a new citywide policy--perhaps to ensure larger apartments--applicable to all developments. After all, the next three towers are supposed to be built via conventional construction, not modular. ...