Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts with the label stimulus

Featured Post

Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park FAQ, timeline, and infographics (pinned post)

Stimulus funds for CityPoint; could there be stimulus funds for AY? Not from Recover NYC

The New York Times reports today: The Bloomberg administration, moving to restart stalled development in the heart of Downtown Brooklyn, has picked a big housing and retail complex to receive $20 million in tax-exempt bonds financed by the federal stimulus program. The complex, City Point, would bring hundreds of apartments and a large shopping center to the eastern end of the Fulton Mall. One other project was selected from numerous applicants . This is part of the Recover NYC program : The Recover NYC Program provides financial assistance to private-sector for-profit companies seeking lower-cost financing for shovel-ready construction projects. Available assistance is mainly in the form of access to triple tax-exempt bond financing authorized under the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009. The program is administered by NYC Industrial Development Agency (NYCIDA) and NYC Capital Resource Corporation (NYCCRC), both staffed by New York City Economic Development Corporation (N...

"Because it is shovel-ready construction": FCR's lame explanation for seeking federal stimulus funds for an essentially private arena

It was one of the more astonishing exchanges at the informational meeting last Wednesday--Forest City Ratner's MaryAnne Gilmartin's explanation for why the developer has sought stimulus funds to boost its essentially private project. Remember, the developer has lobbied for federal stimulus funds, and is almost certainly still lobbying for such help, even though former Empire State Development Corporation CEO Marisa Lago said at a May 29 state Senate oversight hearing that the ESDC hadn't sought such funds. Why not? Because, as I note below--it's not a public project. (Video shot by Jonathan Barkey; edited by Norman Oder) “Can Forest City Ratner comment on why there have been public requests for federal stimulus funds to help with the construction of the arena?” asked moderator Craig Hammerman. “It’s shovel-ready construction,” shouted Marie Louis of BUILD (Brooklyn United for Innovative Local Development), a Community Benefits Agreement (CBA) signatory. Gilmartin at ...

Correction: Yes, Atlantic Yards has been submitted for stimulus funds, but not by ESDC

[ Update and correction 6:55 pm ] I had written this morning, based on a state document, that "apparently, Atlantic Yards is shovel-ready, according to the Empire State Development Corporation (ESDC), which had gone back-and-forth on that issue." A cryptic entry in the massive, 774-page Second Draft List - Project Proposals ( PDF ), issued March 25 by the New York State Economic Recovery and Reinvestment Cabinet , mentions AY but, in contrast to most other projects, without a budget or a description. (Click to enlarge) Not submitted by ESDC My error. I should've emphasized the caveat (below), which cited "projects submitted by municipalities, organizations and individuals throughout New York State." Before I left for a day-long conference, I sent a query to the ESDC. When I returned at nearly 6 pm, I saw the response, which said all questions about stimulus funding should be directed to the governor's office. I contacted Erin Duggan, who's handling pres...

The Xanadu story: a reminder about "public authorities largely operating out of public view" and some sobering AY parallels

The saga of New Jersey's ill-fated Meadowlands Xanadu project-- newly delayed or worse --suggests some sobering parallels with the Atlantic Yards project, including overly optimistic projections, decisions involving political connections, and opaque oversight of a public-private enterprise. Xanadu--the construction of which, along with the new Meadowlands Stadium , has made going to New Jersey Nets games at the Izod Center that much more complicated--has been in the news a lot this week. WNYC radio and the nonprofit public interest news organization Pro Publica have been looking into federal stimulus spending, in a project called ShovelWatch ; a piece March 17, headlined NJ's Xanadu: Lessons for Stimulus Spending? , began with a shot at the New Jersey Sports and Exposition Authority (NJSEA) and especially the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey: Billions of dollars in federal stimulus aid is on the way to our region. But while local politicians are applauding the aid, ma...

Elected officials call for public hearing if AY is considered for stimulus funds; Senator Adams flatly says no

Six elected officials, along with a district leader, have sent a letter to Gov. David Paterson asking him to make public any documents requesting stimulus funds for Atlantic Yards, to hold a public hearing with opportunity for public comment regarding such allocation of funds, and to have "responsible state officials"meet with them before any decision is made regarding such funds. While the letter, dated March 3, does not go so far as to oppose stimulus funds for AY, as several community groups did in a recent letter , it essentially sets up many more roadblocks beyond those faced by any other request. And the letter points out that not only the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) but also the Empire State Development Corporation (ESDC) have not requested stimulus funds for the project. (It was known that AY was not on the initial MTA list, but there's been no public disclosure of ESDC requests.) The Times reports that, though the state has $4 billion to spend, l...

Schumer touts stimulus funds for Moynihan Station, waves off question on Atlantic Yards

For New York, the big stimulus news of the day yesterday was Senator Chuck Schumer's plan to seek $100 million in federal funds to jump-start the Moynihan Station project, as the New York Times reported . And Schumer followed up on his Moynihan Station vision at a breakfast speech sponsored by Crain's New York Business. That got a headline in Crain's, which additionally reported that Schumer's call for new, smarter regulation on financial transactions represents an about-face from his position two years ago. But I wanted to ask him about Atlantic Yards, given that, a little more than two weeks ago, Schumer expressed quizzical ignorance regarding whether AY would be eligible for stimulus funds. Waiting for Schumer After Schumer's speech, and the 25-minute Q&A, the Senator stuck around the stage at the Hilton in midtown and greeted well-wishers and supplicants, among them the developers of the New Domino project in Williamsburg, who wanted him to know they need...

Paterson on stimulus spending: transparent, immediate, and effective

At a Leaders Briefing on Economic Recovery yesterday, Gov. David Paterson laid out ( video ) the areas in which the state expect to spend federal stimulus funds. They include transportation, housing (especially weatherization), energy issues, water and sewer treatment programs, and the establishment of broadband service. "Those are the areas we want to get shovels in the ground and people working as soon as we possibly can," Paterson said. "We want these projects to be transparent, so that there is no waste in the process. We want them to be immediate, so we can get people back to work as soon as we possibly can. And we want them to be effective, meaning that they will put the most people back to work on the projects that will serve the greatest public policy and also public need at the same time. Those are the three principles that we wish to operate from." During the session, Timothy Gilchrist, who heads the Economic Development Recovery Cabinet, explained that $...

DDDB, CBN, Good Jobs NY, clergy oppose stimulus for Atlantic Yards

First, BrooklynSpeaks and NYPIRG's Straphangers Campaign issued statements Tuesday opposing the awarding of federal stimulus funds for Atlantic Yards. (Earlier, I'd argued that, if the project was shovel-ready, it had a huge asterisk.) Yesterday, an even more forceful letter was sent to Gov. David Paterson, signed by some expected project opponents, the coalitions Develop Don't Destroy Brooklyn and the Council of Brooklyn Neighborhoods , several (but hardly all) of their constituent groups, and several other civic groups, including the Straphangers, the Sierra Club, and the Four Borough Neighborhood Preservation Alliance. Among those signing the letter were Good Jobs New York , notable for its scrutiny of subsidies; Majora Carter Group, LLC, run by the MacArthur Prize-winning consultant and founder of Sustainable South Bronx (and Dan Doctoroff antagonist in a 2007 development debate); and The Open Planning Project , which has championed smart infrastructure via projec...

Post: MTA isn't seeking stimulus funds for Atlantic Yards

The New York Post reports that the Metropolitan Transportation Authority is not seeking stimulus funds for Atlantic Yards "It's not on any of our lists [of projects]," an MTA official told the Post. (We knew it wasn't on any of the preliminary lists. Are we sure it's not on the final list?) However, the Post reported, developer Bruce Ratner "still has a shot at getting some of the federal pork directly through Gov. [David] Paterson." As far as I can tell, that's a generic reference to the fact that Paterson will control discretionary funding , not an assurance that Atlantic Yards is on a specific Paterson list.

Will the Times comment on Ratner's blatant bailout bid? Based on past performance, no

Will the New York Times editorialize against the private bailout Forest City Ratner apparently seeks, deploying federal stimulus funds to complete the new railyard the developer had committed to build? It's doubtful, given the newspaper's steady path from criticizing AY subsidies to studious silence, even though a stimulus for Atlantic Yards is so contentious that it's drawn criticism from not only Develop Don't Destroy Brooklyn but also BrooklynSpeaks and the New York Public Interest Research Group's Straphangers Campaign . But maybe the news desk, if it truly believes in small-d democracy, will do some more reporting. Inconsistent silence Nearly two years ago, I pointed to the Times's inconsistency on public subsidies for Atlantic Yards. In a 3/27/05 editorial, the Times opposed having the city and state each contributing $100 million to support the project: That’s unnecessary: Mr. Ratner should pay his own way. In an 11/27/05 editorial, the Times reiterate...

Decoding "shovel-ready": AY railyard may seem eligible, but with a huge bailout asterisk (and wouldn't be "fully vetted")

Last Wednesday, the Empire State Development Corporation's (ESDC) Atlantic Yards Ombudsman, Forrest Taylor was asked the definition of “shovel-ready,” the term used in discussion of projects eligible for federal stimulus funding. “I think that ‘shovel-ready' will be a federal term,” Taylor said. Perhaps, but there's no formal federal definition of shovel-ready, according to NPR. But the Federal Highway Administration's (FHA) "ready to go" designation seems a rough equivalent, NPR suggested last week, encompassing projects that have gotten through design work and environmental approval. And a New York definition, as I describe below, seems similar. AY bailout? The Atlantic Yards railyard might seem to qualify, though not the project as a whole, given that Forest City Ratner does not control the property. But the railyard would require a huge bailout asterisk, connected to FCR's lobbying . As I've written , the difference between using federal funds fo...

And where in the stimulus bill might money for AY come from?

So, where in the stimulus bill might there be money for Atlantic Yards? There aren't too many places and there's surely much competition for relatively limited funds. Discretionary funding There's some discretionary money for governors; the emphasis is on education but "other government services" are included. Take a look at Division A of the Recovery Bill and go to p. 429 of PDF: (b) OTHER GOVERNMENT SERVICES. (1) IN GENERAL -- The Governor shall use 18.2 percent of the State's allocation under section 14001 for public safety and other government services , which may include assistance for elementary and secondary education and public institutions of higher education, and for modernization, renovation, or repair of public school facilities and institutions of higher education facilities, including modernization, renovation, and repairs that are consistent with a recognized green building rating system. (Emphasis added) Of $53.6 billion, 18.2% would mean $9.8...

Jeffries: no stimulus funds for railyard, but maybe for affordable housing

If City Council Member Letitia James, a staunch opponent of Atlantic Yards, opposes the use of federal stimulus funds for the project, Assemblyman Hakeem Jeffries, who's more on the fence, thinks money might be spent on housing--but not a new railyard. "I’m unconvinced that the railyards are the appropriate place for the money to be spent," Jeffries said yesterday after I asked whether federal money should relieve developer Forest City Ratner of a previous obligation. "It’s clear to me that a much stronger case could be made to spend stimulus money on affordable housing," given that it responds to "a permanent need." I had queried him to amplify some quotes in an article in this week's Courier-Life chain, which could have left the impression that he supported stimulus money for a new Vanderbilt Yard as long as Phase 1 of the project contained affordable housing. Courier-Life article The article states: "The highest priority should be placed o...

Gramercy loan extended for Ratner; "some" state officials skeptical of stimulus funds for AY

The big news in this afternoon's New York Times City Room post, headlined Atlantic Yards Project Gets a Reprieve is that the developer got an extension on a loan. The Times reports: Forest City’s loan of $177 million from Gramercy Capital Corporation for the 22-acre property was due this month, which caused much speculation in political and real estate circles about the fate of the project. According to executives familiar with the negotiations, Forest City will sign an agreement soon as today in which the company will make a $15 million payment immediately, as well as additional large payments in the future, in return for a two-year extension. While I initially didn't make a prediction , it's not that surprising to me that Gramercy, which loaned Forest City Ratner money to buy property within the AY footprint, negotiated an extension; the prospect of owning certain buildings on the site could not have been attractive. And Gramercy did get some cash. Its stock is barely $1...

It's official: D'Amato lobbyied feds for AY stimulus funds; state list to emerge in a few weeks

The New York Observer's Eliot Brown has the scoop : Now, according to a federal disclosure report filed by former Senator Alfonse D’Amato’s lobbying firm, Park Strategies, stimulus money is very much on Mr. Ratner’s mind. The disclosure form, filed last month, lists Forest City Ratner–related lobbying issues as: “funding for real estate-linked transportation projects; real estate project infrastructure development; stimulus spending." Brown notes that the project does not appear yet on any federal or state list and that a prioritized list of Metropolitan Transportation Authority projects should appear in a few weeks. Political bind Brown observes: Should the project turn out to be eligible to get money, it would require a major political step by Mr. Paterson to allocate the relatively scarce stimulus money. The project has always been a political hornet’s nest, and to date, neither Mr. Paterson nor his predecessor Eliot Spitzer have had to take any overt, highly public steps i...