Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts with the label legal battles

Featured Post

Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park FAQ, timeline, and infographics (pinned post)

Former ESDC/DCP general counsel Laremont about to join law firm Fried Frank, which works on big projects (including Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park)

It seems like the law firm Fried Frank--which represented developer Forest City Ratner on all aspects of Atlantic Yards, including bond financing, the override of zoning, and litigation--is the destination of choice for lawyers making the jump from New York City's Department of City Planning. Along with  Melanie Meyer s, who joined the firm in 2003 after serving as DCP's general counsel, and  David Karnovsky , who joined in 2014 after serving in the same post, former general counsel and then acting director Anita Laremont has signed on, according to The Real Deal, and will start in September. Note: Meyers, Karnovsky, and Jonathan Mechanic were  ranked  #67 in City & State's 2022 Real Estate Power 100, given the firm's role in numerous big projects. Past service Laremont previously spent 16 years as general counsel at Empire State Development Corporation (now simply Empire State Development, or ESD), famously defending Atlantic Yards to the hilt. Remember, ...

Yes, the big law firms in real estate have intersected with Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park

From The Real Deal The Real Deal's 10/1/19 article,  NYC’s barrister brain trust , by Eddie Small, covers the universe of big law firms and ranks them on several metrics. And while the article is keyed to recent issues, including changes in rent regulation, it's a useful reminder that some of the firms named have been involved in Atlantic Yards. The number one firm in dollar volume of sales, Fried, Frank , long served as an outside counsel and lobbyist for Forest City Ratner/Forest City New York on zoning/planning issues. It has the single largest corps of real estate attorneys, ranked on another chart . The number eight firm, Kramer Levin , represented Forest City in various legal cases, including those involving eminent domain, environmental review, and promises of construction jobs.  It continues, (as far as I know) representing the Forest City entity within new parent company Brookfield, regarding the condemnation of the P.C. Richard site and the tussle...

"Unavoidable Delay": as Pacific Park faces timetable questions, some flex in the 2025 affordable housing deadline

Given ongoing question marks over the future of Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park, with the developer acknowledging  the full buildout should take until at least 2035, rather than 2025 as previously projected, it's worth another look at the settlement announced in June 2014. We know that the community negotiators, representing the BrooklynSpeaks coalition , were able to get the developer and state to commit to a May 2025 deadline for the project's 2,250 units of affordable housing, with seemingly stiff penalties for delay. (Here are the deal documents .) But it's worth looking at that commitment again, since a close read suggests it came with some flexibility, given its connection to the Development Agreement. So I've  bolded  some passages for emphasis (Also, of course, Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park agreements have been modified in the past, though this one would seemingly require participation of a third party, the potential plaintiffs.) Flex in the timetable? The m...

Forest City wins skirmish in modular case after Court of Appeals decision, but battle continues

The long-running legal battle between Skanska USA Building and Forest City New York (and affiliates) over responsibility of cost overruns in the ill-fated modular project recently saw a partial win for the latter in the New York Court of Appeals. In a decision  dated 4/26/18 (but only recently made public), the court agreed that lower courts properly dismissed part of Skanska's claim, which alleged that Atlantic Yards B2 Owner, the special purpose entity that owned the building now known as 461 Dean, had breached the Construction Management and Fabrication Services Agreement (CM Agreement) by allegedly failing to comply with a state law. Skanksa noted that Forest City's lease with Empire State Development (ESD), which formally owns the project site, requires that it to "satisfy all requirements of Section 5 of the New York State Lien Law . . . as such requirements and law are interpreted from time to time by [ESD]." Skanska alleged that B2 Owner breached the CM ...

More than ten years later, a judge's decision recognizing developer's commitment to community use of the arena looks unwise

The recent Public Schools Athletic League (PSAL) championship games at the Barclays Center, the second such school tournament in the arena's 5.5-year history, sent me back to the promises that the arena would be more of a community arena, given promises in the 2005  Community Benefits Agreement (CBA) signed by project developer Forest City Ratner to make it available at least ten times a year to community groups, at modest cost. (An ownership group led by Forest City owned 55% of the arena operating company until 2016 , when minority owner Mikhail Prokhorov bought the rest. The arena itself is owned nominally by the state to enable tax-exempt financing and exemption from property taxes.) And that sent me back to the January 2008 decision , by state Supreme Court Justice Joan Madden, in the case challenging the project's environmental review. Denying the community challenge, she wrote: Petitioners argue that the sports arena portion of the Project does not fall within th...

Skyscraper site ready? Site 5 dispute between P.C. Richard and Forest City would go to trial no earlier than February

"Next to Barclays Center, there is a site for a 1 million-square-foot tower," the New York Times recently reported, summarizing bids to lure Amazon's second headquarters. As I pointed out , that site--Site 5 of Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park, catercorner to the Barclays Center--is by no means ready. A lawsuit filed in January 2016 by P.C. Richard parent A.J. Richard, claiming it was promised space in the replacement development, soldiers on, with regular delays and extensions of deadlines. According to a document in the case file (below), the parties have a compliance conference scheduled for 1/11/18, with the case expected to be ready for trial by 2/1/18. Of course, that timetable can again be extended. My bet is that the case does not go to trial, given the costs (and risks) of litigation. The document upon which P.C. Richard asserts its right to future space is not public, and defendant Forest City Ratner (now Forest City New York) disputes P.C. Richard's claim. ...

NYC sues Forest City over terms of Times Square retail lease

The Real Deal's Katherine Clarke reported yesterday,  City slaps Forest City with lawsuit over Times Square ground lease : The city has filed suit against developer Forest City Ratner over the terms of a ground lease for an entertainment complex the developer operates on West 42nd Street. Forest City and the city are at loggerheads over whether or not, in determining the terms of the lease, the rents being paid by sublease tenants in the space should be taken into account. Forest City says they should, while the city claims the value should be determined by current market conditions rather than old leases. Forest City has held the ground lease on the 312,000-square-foot complex at 234 West 42nd Street, which is home to AMC Theaters and Madame Tussauds, since 1996, but it’s due to enter its second term in 2018 and is therefore due for renegotiation. Forest City paid a base rent of $1.17 million a year for the first 20 years of the lease, according to public filings. That's...

The P.C. Richard case drags on, as one deadline is extended four months; Site 5 question marks remain

The fate of a potential massive project at Site 5-- floated , but not officially proposed--is again delayed, thanks to an extension of time in the litigation between P.C. Richard, owner of a building on the site, and Forest City Ratner. The electronics store last year sued to stall the planned eminent domain proceeding regarding its store at Site 5, across from the Barclays Center, claiming that original project developer Forest City Ratner promised the company space in the replacement building.  Greenland Forest City Partners, now the joint venture developer of Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park, was not sued, but the separate LLC representing Greenland independent of Forest City has been served with a subpoena for a depositions and documents. According to a document filed this week in New York State Supreme Court, the final date for all parties to disclose experts in the litigation was to have been 5/15/17, this past Monday. The parties have agreed to extensions, and now the dead...

Legal case involving 664 Pacific and neighbor appears resolved, but plans for tower (& school) unclear

A roadblock in the development of the 27-story B15 (aka 664 Pacific) site, which is slated for market-rate rentals and a school across from the Barclays Center, has been removed, but plans for that tower remain unclear. Developer Greenland Forest City Partners was in a legal  dispute  with the owner of the adjacent 497 Dean property regarding the safety of planned excavation activities for 664 Pacific, as well as a license fee for access.  The case, as shown in the documents below, is now discontinued, which implies an out-of-court resolution.  What's next?  A spokesman for GFCP declined comment, so we don't know when and whether construction will start. (The market for rentals may also be a factor in deciding to build.) Perhaps the issue will come up at the upcoming Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park Quality of Life meeting, next Tuesday, May 2, at 6 pm at 55 Hanson Place . As I wrote, given that the projected time for pre-construction and construct...

In key preliminary ruling, judge rejects some Skanska arguments in dispute with FCR over modular factory

B2 from Flatbush Avenue Forest City Ratner has won what seems a significant preliminary victory in one  legal battle over its ill-fated partnership with Skanska USA to build the world's tallest modular tower. The decision does not resolve any of the three pending cases, but does show a judge rejecting some Skanska arguments. Among them: the claims that Forest City had promised to build the first three Atlantic Yards towers using modular techniques and that the Opportunity Brief, a business proposal from Forest City, made binding promises. That judge, state Supreme Court Justice Saliann Scarpulla, is hearing all the cases, which face a 10/19/16 hearing. Both Forest City and Skanska, when queried, declined comment. For the 461 Dean Street tower flanking the Barclays Center, aka B2, Skanska USA agreed to fabricate, deliver, and erect the modules, and perform construction management services. Skanska USA then hired FC+Skanska Modular (now FC Modular) to supply modules a...

Barrett puts a damper on praise for retiring Chief Judge Lippman; I suggest eminent domain case also should provoke skepticism

In City & State NY, SECRETS OF THE SILVER TRIAL: A MYSTERY POWERBROKER AND THE CHIEF JUDGE , veteran muckraker Wayne Barrett offers an acidly revisionist view of the mostly praised reign of Court of Appeals Chief Judge Jonathan Lippman, who recently retired. Lippman's path to the Court of Appeals, as Barrett famously wrote in a 2/10/09 Village Voice article, was steered by his childhood friend, longtime Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver, whose career recently ended in disgrace and criminal conviction. Thanks to information that recently surfaced in Silver's case, Lippman, Barrett now writes, was the key vote in a dubious decision--involving a Silver crony, Daniel Chill, "an obscure embodiment of the permanent government." That decision overturned a unanimous Appellate Division that found a very high law firm fee "both procedurally and substantially unconscionable.” Barrett writes: Lippman wanted all of the upside of his familial relationship with Si...

Lawsuit against Forest City, BUILD over "sham" Atlantic Yards jobs program ends in murky settlement for 19 plaintiffs

Daily News exclusive , 11/15/11 The lawsuit over a coveted training program expected to deliver union construction jobs related to Atlantic Yards began four years ago with public drama . "I was robbed," claimed a plaintiff. (The story made the Daily News , the Times , NY1 , the Brooklyn Paper , and others.) It proceeded with some high-stakes legal arguments and provocative press releases, as plaintiffs' lawyers called the program a "sham" and legal filings illuminated flaws in the highly promoted Atlantic Yards Community Benefits Agreement (CBA). But the suit against Forest City Ratner and ally Brooklyn United for Innovative Local Development  (BUILD), a key CBA signatory and vigorous Atlantic Yards cheerleader, ended last month in murk, enforced almost completely by the ironclad laws of confidentiality so often required by legal settlements involving Forest City. Murky numbers We don't know how much the 19 trainees got for their dashed hopes ...

In modular tower dispute, judge mostly rejects Forest City effort to narrow Skanska's case for damages

Ruling in the preliminary stages of a bitter legal battle, state Supreme Court Justice Saliann Scarpulla rejected most of Forest City Ratner's efforts to narrow one of the three lawsuits between it and Skanska USA regarding their ill-fated and now dissolved partnership over the delayed modular tower known as B2. Forest City Ratner and its affiliate Atlantic Yards B2 Owner aimed to get most of Skanska's lawsuit dismissed before the case moved further toward trial. The decision (see bottom), dated 7/16/15 and released on 7/20/15, mostly favored Skanska, although it's still early in the process and does not portend an ultimate victory. Forest City did win on a few arguments. Neither side publicized the decision, perhaps because neither could claim unambiguous good news. But I suspect that had Forest City won more, given its aggressive press strategy, it would have pitched the news to a receptive reporter. The background Skanska agreed to lead the fabrication of the m...

After drunk concertgoer falls on her, injured woman sues Barclays Center over upper-deck design, alcohol service; lawsuit cites prior warnings of design flaws

The tight upper bowl of the Barclays Center means some very steep rows, and has left a certain fraction of arenagoers alarmed by the potential hazard, especially given narrow aisles, large people, and alcohol. Now a lawsuit shines a spotlight on those issues. As first reported by DNAinfo yesterday, Billy Joel Fan Injured at Concert Sues Barclays Center Over Seating Design , a Long Island couple, Elizabeth and Lewis Silver, 53 sued the Barclays Center's operators after Elizabeth was injured when an unnamed "visibly intoxicated" man carrying beer fell on her during the New Year's Eve concert on 12/31/13. Newsday followed up,  reporting  that Elizabeth Silver required arm surgery. "She shielded her daughter and ended up taking the brunt of the impact," lawyer Michael Castro told the publication. The lawsuit, filed against Brooklyn Events Center, Levy Restaurants, and three affiliates of operator AEG, charges "an unreasonably unsafe, hazardous a...

What's a "building"? Appeals court hears challenge to DOB's approval of Forest City's modular plan

Today at a session that begins at 2 pm, a state appeals court will hear an effort to overturn a judge’s December 2013 decision upholding the New York City Department of Buildings’ (DOB) conclusion that modular construction could proceed in a factory using cross-trained workers without the presence of licensed plumbers and fire suppression contractors. While the case was brought in response to Forest City Ratner’s B2 modular tower, should the courts rule in favor of the appellants, two industry groups representing plumbers and mechanical contractors, it could have significant ripple effects regarding the growing modular industry in New York. At issue is whether the modules built in the Navy Yards for the tower qualify as "buildings" under the law. They clearly are not standalone structures--and at least two modules are needed for an apartment--but as nearly-finished apartments they also differ from the pre-fabricated materials or equipment which otherwise can be built of...