Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts with the label urban planning

Featured Post

Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park FAQ, timeline, and infographics (pinned post)

470 Vanderbilt office building, across Atlantic Ave. from Atlantic Yards site (and once contemplated for AY housing), sold again, this time for a big loss

2014 ad Nearly 11 years ago, in October 2014, I reported ( link ) on the "spiffy future" of the 470 Vanderbilt office building--a former tire plant and then data center--at the northwest corner of Atlantic and Vanderbilt avenues, across from the northeast corner of the Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park site. "470 Vanderbilt Avenue," new leaseholder RXR Realty said in the ad, "is a Class A office building prominently situated on a 3-acre, full city block bounded by Atlantic Avenue and Fulton Street." "Just minutes away from the Barclays Center and the Atlantic Yards Development, 470 Vanderbilt has recently undergone a $74 million dollar capital improvement program transforming it into one of the most state-of-the-art assets in this emerging neighborhood," the ad said, otherwise identifying it as "in the emerging Atlantic Yards neighborhood." (Technically, it's the edge of Fort Greene, near the border of Clinton Hill. But it's also acro...

To meet city housing goals, do we simply have to build bigger? What about infrastructure (and the region)?

At a press conference last week organized by BrooklynSpeaks, as I wrote ( link ), Assemblymember Jo Anne Simon pointed to the state's failure to collect damages for unbuilt affordable housing "We want this housing," she said. "We want it built now. It was a public benefit that was promised to everybody and whether you like the project or not, whether you wanted it here, there or whatever, this is a public benefit that was promised to the people of New York and it has not been delivered on." She's right that, the longer the wait, the longer it takes to serve people vulnerable to displacement. Not so fast As I wrote, that statement deserves a "Yes, but." If the only way to get that housing is to build at Site 5 , catercorner to the arena, at unprecedented density, then, no, not everyone wants the housing. (Quick, who said of Atlantic Yards, exaggerating the numbers, "If it’s built the way it was approved, we’re going to end up with 16 60-story b...

On WBAI's CityWatch, lessons from Atlantic Yards: the need for sober predictions, the cost of delay, the "rational basis" advantage, & the project's big winners

I was invited on WBAI's CityWatch yesterday ( link ) to talk about Atlantic Yards, which also touched the Atlantic Avenue rezoning and the plans for Brooklyn Marine Terminal in Red Hook The conversation, with former Council Member Carlos Menchaca, starts at around 9:12 in the audio below and goes about 21 minutes. One takeaway: don''t trust projections for ambitious plans. All scenarios should be offered in a range: best-case to worst-case. With Atlantic Yards, market-rate housing was supposed to cross-subsidize affordable housing and--I didn't say explicitly--the costly infrastructure, a platform or deck, over the MTA's Vanderbilt Yard. (One block was used for the arena parcel, below grade, without a platform; the other two blocks await platforms.) However, the plethora of new market-rate housing from the Downtown Brooklyn rezoning, which was relatively under the radar, cut into the market for Atlantic Yards housing. The Downtown Brooklyn rezoning didn't requir...

BrooklynSpeaks seeks meeting with Empire State Development over future of Atlantic Yards. Fair enough, but NY State should also speak to public at large.

With a foreclosure sale on the development rights to six Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park parcels, what next? I wrote yesterday about coalition BrooklynSpeaks' argument for a new plan , but that's not the most pressing thing. After all, the primary question, to me, regards transparency regarding the foreclosure sale. It's unclear who's responsible for delivering 876 more affordable housing units by May 2025, as established in a 2014 settlement the coaltion negotiated, with $2,000/month fines for each missing unit, and whether the deadline and damages would be attached to the parcels. Empire State Development (ESD), the state authority that oversees/shepherds the project, owes the public more transparency. So I followed up with a few questions for BrooklynSpeaks. Responses below, in italics, are from Gib Veconi of the Prospect Heights Neighborhood Development Council, on behalf of the coalition. I've added a few observations, as well. *** What might BrooklynSpeaks sponso...

In plan for Brooklyn, Borough President Reynoso will advocate for more housing, especially near transit and in the borough's southern and eastern sections.

I wrote recently about the illuminating graphics found in  The Comprensive Plan for Brooklyn: A Vision for a Healthier, More Equitable Borough (also bottom), released by Brooklyn Borough President Antonio Reynoso.  One key bottom line is that he will push for more housing where it has lagged. Now let's take a closer look. According to the report: Our comprehensive plan is many things at once: 1) It is a vision of a Brooklyn for all. 2) It is a recognition that the well-being of a neighborhood and of our borough is dictated by how we use our land, allocate our funding, and administer our programs. 3) It’s a tool with which we can measure the merits of a proposal, advocate for community needs, and push for changes to our neighborhoods that make sense. 4) It is an information and data resource that can be useful to anyone and everyone. 5) And, critically, it is a space where dialogue can coalesce and a comprehensive plan for our entire city can grow. He acknowledged he can...

In Comprehensive Plan from Brooklyn Borough President Reynoso, a clear sense of divisions in Brooklyn by race, class, and more.

I'll write more about this shortly, but two weeks ago Brooklyn Borough President Antonio Reynoso released The Comprensive Plan for Brooklyn: A Vision for a Healthier, More Equitable Borough (also bottom) to guide his response--mostly in an advisory capacity--to growth and change in Brooklyn. As City Planning Commissioner Leah Goodridge (and others) noticed, there are some illuminating charts in the document that clearly show how Brooklyn is divided by race and class, among other identifiers.  That helps Reynoso argue for shared responsibilities for, say, adding density and affordability. Wow! If you’re from Brooklyn and still live here, you can SEE the gentrification. But to have it laid out in graphs + charts in the Bklyn Borough President’s report is striking. NYC is the 7th most segregated U.S. city. And it’s gotten worse in Brooklyn. pic.twitter.com/tOluas5Xee — Leah Goodridge (@leahfrombklyn) October 6, 2023 <

"City of Yes" proposals for 100K new homes include density bonus for below-market units, but affordability level unclear. Info session tomorrow.

Mayor Adams Launches Historic Effort to Build "A Little More Housing in Every Neighborhood,"  the city announced 9/21/23. Translation: a potential 100,000 more homes over 15 years, or 6,667 a year. The  “City of Yes for Housing Opportunity” proposal  is part of Adams’ “moonshot” goal of delivering 500,000 new homes to New Yorkers over the next decade, given that population and jobs exceeds the supply of residences. The top feature is "Ending Parking Mandates for New Housing," which drives up costs--and helps explain why applicants for spot rezonings propose eliminating a parking requirement. But that proposal may face challenge in certain neighborhoods less connected to public transit. New affordability More crucial for those watching development in the area around Atlantic Yards is the "Universal Affordability Preference," which is a 20% density bonus for all affordable housing--including additions to existing buildings but most likely for new constructi...

WSJ: yes, there's a market for cities, outside office buildings. That helps Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park, but there are other headwinds.

American Cities Are Starting to Thrive Again. Just Not Near Office Buildings. , the Wall Street Journal reported 5/30/23: The pandemic and remote work have done little to dent the overall appeal of cities such as New York, Chicago and Los Angeles, foot-traffic and rent data show. Instead, the pandemic has shifted the urban center of gravity, moving away from often sterile office districts to neighborhoods with apartments, bars and restaurants. "We're now back to what cities really are—they're not containers for working," said Richard Florida, a specialist in city planning at the University of Toronto. "They're places for people to live and connect with others." So--and this observation isn't new--that's ultimately a vote of confidence for residential developments like Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park, which offer access to urban amenities. The caveats on that are the upfront cost of the platform, needed for six approved towers; the pending fines of $2...

CM Hudson plans meeting Saturday to shape land use priorities in District 35, invites constituents to complete survey. (I think it should drill down more on renters.)

Updated with location. There's more land-use discussion before the April 16   rescheduled  Community Planning Workshop for the Atlantic Avenue Mixed-Use Plan (AAMUP), the city-sponsored rezoning of blocks around Atlantic between Vanderbilt and Nostrand avenues (though maybe it should extend farther east, given a proposed spot rezoning ). 35th District Council Member Crystal Hudson has proposed a related effort, a public meeting on land use in the district, aimed to "ensure that community priorities are integrated in land use processes in District 35."  On Twitter, she suggested "Think of it like #ParticipatoryBudgeting , but for #LandUse ." The meeting will be this Saturday, April 1, from 1-3 pm. The location will be the Co-Cathedral of St. Joseph, 856 Pacific Street, between Vanderbilt and Underhill avenues--another location (like P.S. 9, site of the meetings on the AAMUP) toward the western (and more affluent) side of the district. Hudson is working with Heste...

At Housing/Land Use workshop for Atlantic Avenue rezoning plan, general agreement on preferences, but no push to assess trade-offs posed in private upzonings

As the March 12 Community Planning Update approaches for the Atlantic Avenue Mixed-Use Plan , which aims to rezone blocks near that artery from Vanderbilt to Nostrand avenues--following a surge of private rezonings that transformed an area long zoned for low-rise manufacturing space--it's worth a look at not just the online-only  kickoff session (my coverage ), but also the three in-person workshops last month: Feb. 13: housing and income-restricted housing Feb. 15: job creation and support services Feb. 16: the public realm and infrastructure needs, including open space and improvements to Atlantic Avenue and surrounding streets However, we can't, not fully. Those sessions weren't recorded, so there's no online documentation, nor have any of the digital presentations been posted. (They'd be here .) My request to the Department of City Planning for digital materials did not get a response. Focusing on the blocks to be rezoned, with neighborhood context. From DCP ....

What a law review article gets right, and wrong, about the objections to Atlantic Yards and the perils of anticipating faster change than actual

Vanderbilt Law School Professor Christopher Serkin, a former Brooklyn Law School professor, in February 2021 published  The Wicked Problem of Zoning  in the Vanderbilt Law Review. Serkins sugggests that the speed of perceived development change, more than the change itself, is what drives opposition, and uses Atlantic Yards as an example.  I think he makes some good points, but also misses some key elements of the Atlantic Yards story, notably that the project Brooklyn neighbors have grown to live with is hardly what was planned, promised, or pending. Here's the abstract: This essay is part of the Vanderbilt Law Review Symposium, Wicked Problems. In real-world zoning disputes, existing residents often oppose change. Development proponents respond with accusations of “opportunity hoarding.” Zoning is the battleground, and both sides act as if it reflects a zero-sum binary choice: more development or less, neighborhood transformation or preservation. But zoning fights ...