Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts with the label office space

Featured Post

Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park FAQ, timeline, and infographics (pinned post)

With new Brooklyn office buildings struggling to fill space (even with "HUGS"), that again suggests Site 5 project would be residential, not office.

Hey, remember when, eight years ago, a representative of joint venture Greenland Forest City Partners, justifying plans to move the bulk of the unbuilt "Miss Brooklyn" tower, once slated to loom over the arena, across Flatbush Avenue to create a giant two-tower project at Site 5, stated , "We think the time is right for the borough to have an iconic office building." Well, as one of the Atlantic Yards mantras goes, "Projects change, markets change." (Thanks, Jim Stuckey.) Given the pandemic and the shift to remote work, office space is less desirable, hence articles like Office Building Losses Start to Pile Up, and More Pain Is Expected , from the New York Times. And the market for office space, especially in Brooklyn, seems to be receding.  That means, at least in the near term, that the still-pending project at Site 5, which requires governmental action to unlock the new development rights, is far more likely to contain residential space than office spa...

If New York becomes (in part) "the Playground City," what might that mean for Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park (and Site 5)?

From the New York Times 5/10/23:  26 Empire State Buildings Could Fit Into New York’s Empty Office Space. That’s a Sign. , from Edward L. Glaeser, chair of the economics department at Harvard, and Carlo Ratti, director of the Senseable City Lab at M.I.T. Their lead: New York is undergoing a metamorphosis from a city dedicated to productivity to one built around pleasure. Many office buildings still feel eerily empty, with occupancy around 50 percent of prepandemic levels, harming landlords and the local economy. But 56 million people visited New York last year, making Fifth Avenue in December feel as crowded as Ipanema Beach during Carnival. The economic future of the city that never sleeps depends on embracing this shift from vocation to recreation and ensuring that New Yorkers with a wide range of talents want to spend their nights downtown, even if they are spending their days on Zoom. We are witnessing the dawn of a new kind of urban area: the Playground City. That, ...

Ominous outlook for Manhattan office space can't be good for Site 5, catercorner to arena and long-planned for big complex.

A front-page article in today's New York Times, headlined "Office Market In Dire Straits In Manhattan (and online as  A Bleak Outlook for Manhattan’s Office Space May Signal a Bigger Problem ) has to be sobering to Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park developer Greenland Forest City Partners, dominated by Greenland USA. The twin hammers of remote work and rising interest rates make office buildings, especially older ones, less attractive to tenants in Manhattan. That could lead to a city budget crisis and--more parochially--make it far less likely that new office space, at least in the near term, will be needed. After all, Vornado has put its big plan for office towers around Penn Station on hold. And in Brooklyn For Greenland, the question is what to do with Site 5, the parcel catercorner to the arena that for years housed the big-box stores Modell's (now closed) and P.C. Richard. Greenland Forest City in 2015-16 started  floating plans  to move the unbuilt bulk of the B1 tower (...

Commercial Observer: much unleased office space in Brooklyn, with more product coming online. Would there be any market for offices at (well-located) Site 5?

Brooklyn’s Office Market Post-COVID Sows Green Shoots , David M. Levitt wrote for the 1/31/23 Commercial Observer, with the acknowledgement that the pre-pandemic challenges remain: "lots of available space and uneven demand." The article starts with the Bedford Stuyvesant Restoration Corporation's big plans for "840,000 square feet of potential mixed-use property," a potential $700 million project that has a $50 million city commitment.  But that's hardly a benchmark or bellwether, given the likely significant government and nonprofit support for the venerable nonprofit organization. Meanwhile, the post-pandemic landscape shows bargains in Manhattan, given downsizing tenants, which diminishes Brooklyn's potential cost advantage. Lots of inventory One "nagging reality" is this: “With a 21.1 percent availability rate and additional inventory scheduled for delivery over the next several quarters, the Brooklyn office market is challenged with an ab...

An office rebound in Brooklyn? A marketing plan for a unique property in Williamsburg offers only partial parallels for Site 5, still waiting for proposals.

Would Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park ever get more office space? Well, let's look at the prospects for such space in Brooklyn. Remember, several versions of the plan --as of 2016, at least--for development at Site 5, catercorner to the arena block, included a significant amount of office space, but building office space is a question mark in pandemic-era Brooklyn.  So it's likely that developer Greenland Forest City Partners is hedging its bets, in a proposal I'd expect to be unveiled within the next year (possibly much sooner, but everything has been delayed).  Surely the plan for two towers, incorporating a shift of bulk from the unbuilt B1 (aka "Miss Brooklyn") tower once slated to loom over the arena, would emphasize residential space. But maybe they'd leave open the option for some office space, since that of course can be defended with "jobs." A bit of hype Consider the 5/30/22 New York Times article, N.Y.C. Companies Are Opening Offices Where Th...

In advertisement, Brookfield pitching former Forest City office space (big vacancies) and crediting arena for helping form "desirable" neighborhood

In an ad on page 21 of the Sept. 14 Commercial Observer , Brookfield--which absorbed Forest City Realty Trust in 2018 --touts office space "at the Center of Brooklyn's most Desirable Neighborhoods." Those towers, originally developed by Forest City Ratner/Forest City New York, include 1 Pierrepont Plaza at the edge of Downtown Brooklyn and Brooklyn Heights and 2 Hanson Place, rising over the Atlantic Terminal mall. And there's a lot of space available. (The retail at the mall is owned by Madison International now.) Below the images of those two towers, as well as one at Forest City-developed MetroTech, is a statement about "Reimagining Real Estate": At Brookfield Properties, we look behind what is to see what could be. We work closely with communities, tenants, and residents to understand what makes them unique. We build and manage to standards of quality and design that enhance entire neighborhoods, elevate entire cities, and raise the bar for real estate e...

The pandemic is shifting what tenants want from office space, which some say is good for Brooklyn. Though it doesn't point to the Site 5 project.

Landlord commentary can of course be self-serving, but do note Bisnow's 7/30/21 report, Brooklyn Office Market Could Benefit From Pandemic Shifts In Demand : Tenants are currently looking for shorter lease terms, coworking space in the building and something of an experience when they come into work, according to speakers on an office panel during Bisnow’s Brooklyn’s Rally To Reopen event on Thursday. “It feels like we live now in the year 2035 … working from home used to be 5%, now it’s 30%,” said Matthias Hollwich , founder of architecture firm HWKN . “The future is, we have to offer experiences to people to work for our companies … that's changing everything in the way we think about these buildings.” Since the coronavirus pandemic hit, design has shifted away from focusing primarily on efficiency to focusing on quality, amenity and location, he said. And in addition to space, tenants want events, concerts and ways to connect the public with their workplaces. That said, only...

As residential real estate "bounces back," office vacancies continue in Manhattan and Brooklyn. Implication: no push for a Site 5 office tower.

Wait, there's a New York Times headline 7/2/21,  Manhattan Real Estate Finally Bounces Back to Normal . But that refers to  residential real estate, where the volume of apartment sales--if not price appreciation--has recovered, in the wake of the coronavirus crisis. Meanwhile, as the Times reported 7/1/21, Office Vacancies Soar in New York, a Dire Sign for the City’s Recovery , noting how enduring patterns of work-from-home have been a drag on leasing: Across Manhattan, home to the two largest business districts in the country, 18.7 percent of all office space is available for lease, a jump from more than 15 percent at the end of 2020 and more than double the rate from before the pandemic, according to Newmark, a real estate services company. This is, um, worrisome: Kathryn Wylde, the president of the Partnership for New York City, an influential business organization, said that New York City was facing its biggest crisis since the 1970s, when half of the city’s 125 Fortune 5...

If "Shrinking Need for Office Space Could Crush Landlords," then (I speculate) new work-from-home plan--and platform--nudged by embattled governor?

For the nth time, another warning, on today's New York Times front page,  After Pandemic, Shrinking Need for Office Space Could Crush Landlords : Businesses have discovered during the pandemic that they can function with nearly all of their workers out of the office, an arrangement many intend to continue in some form. That could wallop the big property companies that build and own office buildings — and lead to a sharp pullback in construction, steep drops in office rents, fewer people frequenting restaurants and stores, and potentially perilous declines in the tax revenue of city governments and school districts. In only a year, the market value of office towers in Manhattan, home to the country’s two largest central business districts, has plummeted 25 percent, according to city projections released on Wednesday, contributing to an estimated $1 billion drop-off in property tax revenue. Notable, the city's largest private employer, JPMorgan Chase, expects office "seats...

Another caveat on (Manhattan) office space, the danger of return-to-work predictions, and the future of Site 5

Remote Work Is Here to Stay. Manhattan May Never Be the Same. , the New York Times reports today. Here's the crux: A year after the coronavirus sparked an extraordinary exodus of workers from office buildings, what had seemed like a short-term inconvenience is now clearly becoming a permanent and tectonic shift in how and where people work. Employers and employees have both embraced the advantages of remote work, including lower office costs and greater flexibility for employees, especially those with families. Still, about 90 percent of Manhattan office workers are working remotely, a rate that has remained unchanged for months, according to a recent survey of major employers by the Partnership for New York City, an influential business group, which estimated that less than half of office workers would return by September. Across Midtown and Lower Manhattan, the country’s two largest central business districts, there has never been more office space — 16.4 percent — for lease, m...

Office space glut in Brooklyn likely casts further clouds on plans for office project at Site 5

How Brooklyn’s Office Market Is Getting Through COVID , the Commercial Observer reported 2/23/21, quoting broker Chris Havens of TerraCRG that, even though it was a tenant's market before the pandemic, now it's even more so: "There’s really nothing large happening.” So prices for office/industrial properties are going down, to $327 per square foot at the end of 2020 from $467 psf a year earlier, and rents to $39.03 a square foot from $40.37, with an availability rate in 2020 to 18.3% (Colliers Intl.) to 22.4% (CBRE). The article notes several major projects haven't panned out, including the former Jehovah’s Witnesses headquarters in Fulton Ferry, now called Panorama; Dock 72 at the Brooklyn Navy Yard; The Refinery at the Domino Sugar site in Williamsburg; and 25 Kent Avenue in Williamsburg.  (The Refinery strikes me as the most attractive property, given its placement near open space, but maybe people would rather work from their apartments.) Meanwhile, some 4 million ...

As the "Power Brokers" panic, questions about the future of real estate and the city's precariousness (and p.r. fluff)

The Panic Attack of the Power Brokers , wrote New York Magazine's Andrew Rice 10/13/20, quoting real estate machers as deeply unsettled by both the coronavirus crisis, notably its effect on building and sustaining use of office space, and the city's political rejection of development projects.Writes Rice: If the entire real-estate industry is filled with anxiety, there’s still a hierarchy of distress. The multigenerational family companies, like Spitzer’s, tend to be less heavily leveraged, which should allow them to ride out the pandemic. (Or so they say — they’re extremely private companies, so who knows?) The public real-estate companies are more exposed to market forces.... More imperiled still are the adventurous investors — the ones who are building condo towers catering to foreign billionaires or who borrowed heavily to buy high on speculative trends.  What about AY? What does that mean for Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park? Well, there are family companies, like TF Cornersto...

Whither commercial real estate? Brookfield says tenants are paying; brokers say Brooklyn may beckon

Well, there may be a market for Brooklyn office space, but not--I'd still contend--a ground-up office building at Site 5 of Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park, not at least until there's a vaccine. Brian Kingston, CEO of Brookfield Property Partners, in a 6/18/20  interview  with The Real Deal, was asked if they were having trouble collecting rent from non-retail tenants: No. A lot of the other public office and multifamily companies have reported their rent collections are at normal levels, and that’s consistent with ours as well. Our office collections are exactly the same as last year, and multifamily is actually slightly higher than it was in 2019, so there are no issues there. That suggests that the company's MetroTech complex, built by and bought from Forest City Ratner/Forest City Retail Trust, is doing fine. That's plausible, given that larger tenants are financial or governmental entities, but there are also numerous smaller tenants, some of which may be strugg...

Killing the city? New federal office guidelines suggest very limited mass transit, elevator use

Effectively, the CDC recommends that midtown Manhattan remain a ghost town indefinitely. https://t.co/FHRvQoxYg5 — Justin Davidson (@JDavidsonNYC) May 29, 2020 in essence: the CDC is recommending the end of offices, the end of mass transit, the end of carpooling... and basically the end of cities https://t.co/GlIy5NbaSB — Edward-Isaac Dovere (@IsaacDovere) May 29, 2020 New guidelines from the federal Centers for Disease Control have been summarized ominously, such as in the New York Times article headlined  C.D.C. Recommends Sweeping Changes to American Offices , with the subheading "Temperature checks, desk shields and no public transit: The guidelines would remake office life. Some may decide it’s easier to keep employees at home." Any wiggle room? Actually, the guidelines,  COVID-19 Employer Information for Office Buildings , seem to leave some wiggle room: For employees who commute to work using public transportation or ride sharing, consider offering the following s...

If at least 20% of office workers decide to keep working from home, "that's a huge blow to office demand"

Yesterday the Real Deal published (broadcast?) an interview with Dror Poleg, author of Rethinking Real Estate , subtitled "A Roadmap to Technology's Impact on the World's Asset Class," and his business partner Antony Slumbers. The summary is that they believe "the office market will begin to emulate the hotel market in terms of the way it's owned and operated," with branding companies like WeWork partnering with landlords to market office space. (Of course, WeWork, however successful at branding, was terrible at business.) Most interesting to me was the exchange that began around 11:14. The Real Deal's Hiten Samtani noted that, given the coronavirus crisis, "New York City suffers from systemic challenges that might impact its attractiveness," including public transit and extremely high density. "If I'm a New York City office landlord, or an office REIT [real estate investment trust]," he asked, "what I am thinking...

As experts ponder the "coronavirus-era office," higher costs and extra space disadvantage New York

Yesterday, the Wall Street Journal published Reopening the Coronavirus-Era Office: One-Person Elevators, No Cafeterias . Bottom line: everything requires more space and barriers in the social-distancing era. That means high-rise buildings and high-priced land/buildings face a squeeze, as do co-working spaces. All of that makes office space in New York and Brooklyn less attractive than it was, and should give pause to any developer aiming to build a new office tower. So that should hamper or suspend plans for that ambitious two-tower at Site 5 of Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park, as I've written . Also, presumably the level of safeguards would be different if and when a vaccine for the coronavirus is achieved. This article is great, but also: post-reopening pre-vaccine office life sounds so grim, I propose an alternative where we just WFH but have lots of scheduled meetings in parks https://t.co/TreBSFe8cQ — Tom Gara (@tomgara) May 11, 2020 Every “future of” story I read describes a...

More short-term doubts for Site 5, since the market for a new office tower in NYC surely tanked

The coronavirus crisis is upending the world of real estate in multiple ways; as I wrote recently, a lesser demand for market-rate units in New York City suggests a possible shift to a greater number of affordable units, at least in the short term. That said, none among the two Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park towers under construction and the two scheduled to start later this year were supposed to be finished by 2021, which is the best case for a vaccine and a key step--but only a step--to the recovery of the New York economy. So perhaps a stalwart developer build for that potential future demand. Or, perhaps, without significant government support, the shock to the system might last for years. What about office space? The crisis has also changed the outlook for office space, notably the long-percolating but long stalled plans for a two-tower complex at Site 5, opposite the Barclays Center and currently home to Modell's and P.C. Richard. Condemnation has been stalled by resis...

For now, there's a glut of office space around Brooklyn. What does that mean for Site 5?

25 Kent Lands A 65K SF Short-Term Occupant As Its Anchor Search , Bisnow reported 12/5/19: Rubenstein Partners and Heritage Equities Partners reached a deal with online publication Refinery29 to bring its pop-up 29Rooms to an almost 65K SF space at 25 Kent Ave., the half-a-million square foot ground-up office development on the Brooklyn waterfront.  But that's a deal for a month. Smorgasburg is taking less than half that space for the winter. Meanwhile, as Bisnow notes, "The building has 350K SF of office space, 80K SF of light manufacturing space and 70K SF of retail." Brooklyn has nearly 7 million square feet of new office space in the next two years, including Dock 72 at the Brooklyn Navy Yard, and the Panorama complex, formerly the Jehovah’s Witnesses' headquarters, down the hill from Brooklyn Heights. What about Site 5? So what does that mean for Site 5, the s ooner-rather-than-later parcel to be developed for Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park, currently home...

In Amazon bid, Site 5 was proposed as single, 28-story office building with significant lot coverage

Site 5, the parcel catercorner to the arena--bounded by Flatbush, Atlantic, and Fourth avenues and Pacific Street--that's currently home to P.C. Richard and Modell's, has had multiple potential futures. It was proposed in 2016 as a two-tower project with Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park stretching perhaps 785 feet, with additional bulk to be transferred from the unbuilt "Miss Brooklyn" (aka B1) tower at what's now the arena plaza, but that doesn't seal its fate. (For now, the plan has been  delayed  by litigation.) Consider: a shorter single building, with more lot coverage and thus similar bulk, was proposed for Site 5 as part of New York State's bid to win the Amazon HQ2 competition. (Later, Amazon split the decision and last year picked Long Island City as one of two sites, but ultimately backed off in the wake of pushback.) As the screenshot at left shows, the Amazon office building at Site 5 was proposed at 28 floors, likely under 350-400 feet, ...