Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts with the label Brooklyn Behemoth

Featured Post

Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park FAQ, timeline, and infographics (pinned post)

If "supertall" near Junior's would close Flatbush during day for three years, similar impact likely from Pacific Park tower

Guess what: when you build big buildings, there are infrastructure consequences. The Brooklyn Paper, in a 6/30/16 article headined  Growing pains: Supertall construction to close Flatbush Ave. Ext. lane , reports: The developer behind the forthcoming “supertall” high-rise plans to close a lane of traffic on Flatbush Avenue Extension for up to three years while it builds the gargantuan structure between Dekalb Avenue and Fleet Street, its rep revealed during a Community Board 2 transportation committee meeting last week. Builder JDS Development plans to take over one of three Prospect Heights-bound traffic lanes and the parking spots adjacent to it during times the city considers “non-rush hours” — between 7 am and 4 pm — according to spokesman James Corral. But the thoroughfare is pretty much busy at all hours — especially when Barclays Center hosts big events — and locals are already shuddering at the thought of traffic backing up for years to come. It's unclear how far the...

Next "Quality of Life Community Update Meeting" scheduled for Tuesday, 6 pm

The next Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park "Quality of Life Community Update Meeting"--there's an AKA missing somewhere, given that the state calls it a Community Update meeting- will be held at 6 pm Tuesday, June 14 at the Shirley Chisholm State Office Building at 55 Hanson Place. There's no agenda yet. But maybe we'll hear about plans for the Brooklyn Behemoth  tower at Site 5, the timetable to meet affordable housing requirements , or why dangerous debris would blow off the B3 construction site.

Forest City's Gilmartin: Brooklyn residential bet depends on spread vs. Manhattan; incentives needed for office market

There are some interesting quotes from Forest City's CEO in the Real Deal's Downtown Brooklyn’s second act: Q&A, part I: Forest City's MaryAnne Gilmartin and RXR's Seth Pinsky offer their takes . First, the reasons So, why did residential outpace office development after the 2004 rezoning? I don’t think anybody, including Forest City, ever imagined the residential market would kick in like it did. We thought we’d see a third central business district thrive and an expansion of the office market as a result of the zoning, but that didn’t happen. It started with the food movement and then the artists. They all flocked to Brooklyn. Certainly, government policies, including the allowance for taller buildings to spur the office market, allowed for market forces to respond so that residential development took over. It started with the food movement? C'mon, Smorgasburg didn't start until 2011. The artists were in Williamsburg, not Downtown Brooklyn decades e...

A continued snag in Site 5 (and giant planned building): court schedule suggests P.C. Richard case won't be resolved until next year

Plans for development of a giant building on Site 5, currently home to P.C. Richard and Modell's, were snagged in March, as I wrote,  when a state judge granted a preliminary injunction stalling the process by which Empire State Development would condemn the property for the ultimate use of Greenland Forest City Partners. They were further stalled after an appeals court denied an appeal by Forest City Ratner, which signed a disputed letter of intent (LOI) with P.C. Richard parent A.J. Richard.  Now, according to an order (below) signed 5/10/16 by Kings County Supreme Court Justice Sylvia G. Ash, the two adversaries face a court schedule for document production, depositions, and more, to be completed by 3/31/17, presaging a trial. (Of course, the case may settle at any point.) "There are no updates on Site 5," ESD official Marion Phillips III said at the meeting yesterday of the Atlantic Yards Community Development Corporation. "The condemnation has been halte...

Jane Jacobs, skepticism, and Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park

On today's rain-or-shine free Jane's Walk , starting 5:30 sharp outside the Barclays Center (get there early), I'll take people through the complex history of Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park, starting with the project announcement in 2003, and the many plans, twists, and turns. But what of the great urbanist Jane Jacobs, whose 100th birthday is being celebrated? I'll sit out for now the various "What Would Jane Do?" speculations, but rely on a wise observation from architecture critic Paul Goldberger, who suggested, "So if there is any way to follow Jane Jacobs, it is to think of her as showing us not a physical model for city form but rather a perceptual model for skepticism." Ah, there are many triggers for skepticism. Modular and Jacobs Forest City Ratner executive (now CEO) MaryAnne Gilmartin, in 2013, contended that the developer's cutting-edge plans for modular construction were Jacobsian: To my mind, the modern redux of Jane Jacobs ...

History lesson: B1 was not supposed to block the bank, but even B2 would do so (and now does)

The photo below, showing the nearly finished B2 (aka 461 Dean Street) tower from Flatbush Avenue and Sterling Place to the north, reminded me of a fundamental deception behind Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park, one that may be relatively small (in the grand scheme of the project) but still telling. When the project was announced in 2003, Forest City Ratner's  promotional material  stated that the largest tower, the (then) office building at Flatbush and Atlantic avenue since known as B1, would be "set back slightly from the intersection... to maintain the view corridor to the Williamsburg Bank building." But that didn't make sense. Not only would the "Miss Brooklyn" tower block the view corridor whether it would be 620 feet tall as proposed or 511 feet as reduced, the tower to the south, B2, would also block the view, as Empire State Development Corporation, the state authority overseeing/shepherding the project, later acknowledged : However, given the loca...

Ratner and Gilmartin ranked #66 in Commercial Observer's Power 100

So here's the gentle profile (written by a 2014 college grad!) of Forest City Ratner's executives in the Commercial Observer's Power 100 (here's last year's short blurb ): 66. MaryAnne Gilmartin and Bruce Ratner (79 in 2015) President and CEO of Forest City Ratner Companies and Executive Chairman of Forest City Ratner Companies and Executive Vice President of Forest City Enterprises “If I have to leave my kids everyday, it better be good,” MaryAnne Gilmartin said. And as president and CEO of Forest City Ratner Companies, she certainly makes it worthwhile. Ms. Gilmartin, who is in charge of the New York City office wing of its Ohio-based parent company, works closely with Bruce Ratner, together spearheading many of the $1.5 billion in projects FCRC has under development. The company officially started operating as a real estate investment trust under the moniker Forest City Realty Trust on Jan. 1 of this year, which Ms. Gilmartin said has helped the company...

If B4 tower won't include affordable units, will they go into Site 5? Developer won't say.

Unofficial mock-up of proposed plan, with larger Site 5  tower and no B1 tower over the arena/plaza  On 6/27/14, Governor Andrew Cuomo and other officials announced a plan that set 2025 as the deadline for the Atlantic Yards affordable housing--after the longstanding ten-year timetable had been extended to 25 years, with an "outside date" of 2035. The compromise also included this pledge: Ensuring sustained development of affordable housing by requiring that the project developers will provide 35 percent of the completed units at the site as affordable housing units until 1,050 affordable housing units are built. This new deal ensures that the delivery of affordable units does not lag behind the creation of market rate units. After 1,050 units, then the percentage of affordable units could drop, for a time, to 25 percent, until it was raised with a final buildout of three 50/50 (affordable/market-rate) towers. Gib Veconi of the Prospect Heights Neighborhood Devel...

Resorts World NYC Casino Plaza: public amenity or fan gathering space?

Oh, remember that one justification for moving the bulk of the unbuilt B1 tower across Flatbush Avenue to build what I've dubbed the "Brooklyn Behemoth," according to Forest City Ratner executive Ashley Cotton, is that "a key thing we think we can accomplish with this is keeping the plaza permanent open space." That positions it as a public amenity, rather than a branded business deal, since the official name is the Resorts World NYC Casino Plaza. It's also a key safety valve for arena attendees. In fact, as WPIX-11 (a partner with the Barclays Center, remember) reported yesterday, in Islanders fans swarm Barclays Center for playoff festivities , it was the scene for a modified tailgate: attendees "were greeted by live bands, team gear and a chance to hang out with some hockey legends."

When office jobs were discussed in 2005, developer acknowledged they had nothing to do with CM Barron's "struggling folk"

Unofficial mockup of planned building at Site 5 I've previously written skeptically about two of the three justifications for shifting the bulk of the tower planned over the arena plaza and creating what I've dubbed the " Brooklyn Behemoth," a giant tower of 1.55 million square feet at Site 5, now occupied by Modell's and P.C. Richard. The notion of "activating" the Atlantic Avenue corridor is pretty thin , and the idea of keeping the arena plaza as permanent open space positions it as a public amenity, rather than a branded business deal . But what about the the third notion, "delivering jobs," to quote Forest City Ratner spokeswoman Ashley Cotton, representing the developer, Greenland Forest City Partners? Building an office tower delivers space for jobs, and the jobs come if there's a market for it. And the market depends on, among other things, the cost of construction. And building the tower at the site originally approved, n...

Could this be why Greenland Forest City Partners wants to build such a huge tower in Brooklyn?

Note the signage on this tower in Beijing. I'd bet, actually, that if possible that Greenland Forest City Partners would sell naming rights to the planned "Brooklyn Behemoth," but Greenland might want to put its name on it for a while, as part of its corporate promotion. I'm back from a trip to China. Here's a picture of a Greenland Group building in Beijing. #bciza #PacificParkbk @atlanticyards_pacificpk_report #Greenlandforestcitypartners @empirestatedev A photo posted by @pplegacy on Apr 10, 2016 at 5:40pm PDT

Public amenity or business deal? How odd silence about arena's Resorts World Casino NYC Plaza bolsters "Brooklyn Behemoth"

Resorts World Casino NYC signage over door; click to enlarge It's pretty hard to miss, the signage over the Barclays Center entrance announcing Resorts World Casino NYC Plaza, as I reported last September. But the Barclays Center has been curiously reticent about this new sponsor. Perhaps they're reticent about the taint of gambling. But I suspect that arena operators, as well as developer Greenland Forest City Partners, seek to avoid attention to the branding of a plaza that GFCP promotes as a public amenity. And that's part of a strategy to get state permission--after public hearings--to transfer the huge bulk of the unbuilt tower over that plaza at Flatbush and Atlantic avenues across the street to Site 5, which is today home to Modell's and P.C. Richard and already approved for a substantial 250-foot, 439,050-square-foot building. Site 5 from southern border at Pacific Street; Bear's Garden in foreground is not part of planned project The ...

The new (bogus) buzzword: revised plan for office towers would "activate" Atlantic Avenue corridor

This is among multiple articles covering issues raised at the March 15 Atlantic Yards Community Development Corporation (AY CDC) meeting. "Activate the Atlantic Avenue corridor." That's one confounding justification by Greenland Forest City Partners for its brazen, highly questionable plan to shift 1.1 million square feet of bulk from the tower planned for the arena plaza across the street to Site 5, creating what I've dubbed the "Brooklyn Behemoth," with 1.6 million square feet--and then turn B4, the large tower planned at the northeast corner of the arena block, from residential to office uses. The jargon-y claim--as if somehow office workers from one building would cross broad Flatbush Avenue to commune with the other building--strikes me as a fig leaf to get a plan passed that exceeds previously disclosed ambitions. The rationale begins Speaking at the 3/15/16 meeting of the Atlantic Yards Community Development Corporation, Forest City spokes...

Remember that Site 5 tower in the 2007 ad? Now, imagine it much larger.

Mock-up of the bulk of the tower at Site 5 Remember the 1/19/07 ad  below in the New York Times? It was the first time the paper showed Atlantic Yards in street perspective. Instead of looking at the unbuilt Miss Brooklyn tower, looming over the arena, consider, in the foreground, the planned tower at Site 5, currently home to P.C. Richard and Modell's. In the ad, that building looms too--check the contrast with the Times Plaza control house at center, or the MTA bus--but the brick section is only 16 stories tall. The whole building is supposed to max at 250 feet/439,050 square feet, though there look to be at least 12 additional floors in the rendering. Now, the proposed but under-wraps tower I've dubbed the "Brooklyn Behemoth"--see above right for mock-up--would add the bulk of Miss Brooklyn, more than 1.1 million square feet, to the Site 5 building, producing the largest tower in Brooklyn and one of the largest in the city,  comparable in bulk  to the 1,...

A (vague) agenda for Tuesday's Atlantic Yards CDC meeting (must RSVP)

Yesterday, Empire State Development sent out both an advisory and an agenda for the meeting news Tuesday of the Atlantic Yards Community Development Corporation (AY CDC), a subsidiary that's supposed to advise the parent authority (but has had relatively little impact). When: Tuesday, March 15, 2016, at 3:00 p.m. Where: Long Island University’s Brooklyn Campus Library Learning Center – 515 Conference Room (5th Floor) One University Plaza (at Flatbush and DeKalb Avenues) Brooklyn, New York 11201 This meeting is open to the public. Web casting of the meeting will be available at http://www.esd.ny.gov/webcasts . Those wishing to attend at LIU’s Brooklyn campus must RSVP by 5:00 p.m. on Monday, March 14, 2016. RSVP press line (800) 260-7313; RSVP public line (212) 803-3795. The agenda It's progress that they've released an agenda, but it's pretty vague Beyond approval of minutes and an operating budget, there's a "President'...

The "Brooklyn Behemoth" would have the bulk of the New York Times tower, on half the site. It must be a gambit.

I'll say it again: it's utterly preposterous to consider building the "Brooklyn Behemoth,"  a tower with 1.55 million square feet at Site 5, the plot of land currently occupied by Modell's and P.C. Richard, by moving 1.1 million square feet of bulk from B1 (over the arena and temporary plaza) across the street. Consider this comparison: it would be about the same bulk as the New York Times tower, currently the sixth-tallest building in New York City, which has 1,545,708 square feet . (And was built by Forest City Ratner.) It's 319 meters, or 1,046 feet, the height of the Chrysler Building. But it's a two -acre site. Site 5 is little more than an acre. (See p. 89 of the Atlantic Yards Design Guidelines.) That suggests the proposal should start with half the bulk, less then 800,000 square feet, which would still be oversize for the site. It's a gambit I think Greenland Forest City Partners is floating this untenable, and unbuildable, pla...

How might two office towers be financed? Condos? Anchor tenant? EB-5? Government commitment? Greenland?

The bulk from B1 would move across the street to Site 5 The momentum with which Greenland Forest City Partners is pursuing a plan to move the bulk of an enormous 1.1 million-square-foot building from the arena block to Site 5, currently home to Modell's and P.C. Richard, is surprising. Same with  the plan announced last week to turn B4, at the northeast corner of the arena block, from residential (condos + rentals, half of the latter affordable). The two buildings would total more than 2.3 million square feet, which would be an enormous amount of office space, even in a situation with reported demand for more office space. (Consider 250 square feet per job--it's sometimes 200 sf--and 2 million square feet translates to 8,000 jobs.) So how could they finance this project? And what might they really be planning? Unofficial massing model of Site 5 A hybrid building at Site 5 First, as hinted by Forest City Ratner CEO MaryAnne Gilmartin, it's likely the top...

Before "Brooklyn Behemoth" plan surfaced, BP Adams suggested transferring development rights from Pacific library across street

Site 5 tower at left The proposed "Brooklyn Behemoth" office tower (+ condos/retail) at Site 5 of the Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park project, currently home to P.C. Richards and Modell's, would be created by moving the bulk planned for the B1 tower over the arena/plaza and adding it to the already substantial building planned there. In other words, a building some 511 feet and 1.1 million square feet would be added to one 250 feet and 439.050 square feet. That would make a giant building, perhaps the tallest and bulkiest largest tower in Brooklyn. This dramatic, preposterous building--one I bet would be shaved down, at minimum, as a planned "compromise"--wouldn't be accomplished by a simple "transfer" of rights. Rather, it would require a change in the Atlantic Yards Design Guidelines and General Project Plan, which would require public hearings and then a vote--likely pro forma--by the gubernatorially appointed board of Empire State Developme...