Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts with the label Alexander Garvin

Featured Post

Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park FAQ, timeline, and infographics (pinned post)

Planner Garvin on the importance of parks; his checklist explains why publicly-accessible open space (as in AY) doesn't measure up

On Monday I attended a lecture by planner Alexander Garvin, academic , consultant (self-described "public realm strategist"), former Dan Doctoroff aide , and author of the recently-published Public Parks: The Key to Livable Communities . While Garvin wasn't addressing publicly-accessible, privately-managed open space like that planned for Atlantic Yards, it's clear that it doesn't measure up to the standards of public parks. AY open space comes later It also should be pointed out that the Atlantic Yards open space would not come until Phase 2 of the project, and then in increments as each building is finished, which means the full eight acres would not arrive for ten years, under the non-credible official timetable, and more likely 25 years, the official deadline. By contrast, at Battery Park City, much of the park space was built first . Indeed, as Garvin described using examples from Paris (boulevards, parks, small parks) and San Antonio (the Riverwalk), su...

Planner Garvin on Atlantic Yards: “A single site rezoned for a single owner with a set of towers and an arena. That's not a public realm."

Architect, planner, and educator Alexander Garvin is hardly an anti-development NIMBY. He calls himself pro-development and is proud of his work steering the Lower Manhattan Development Corporation (LMDC) and serving as managing director of the NYC 2012 Olympics effort. But Garvin, stubbornly enough, is a believer in the public realm--streets, parks, transit system--and thinks that’s where government investment should go, and the private development will follow. He believes in clear rules and an even playing field, rather than a governmental attempt to pick winners. And that means that he can’t avoid taking shots at Atlantic Yards as an example of where things went wrong, a project where the public realm was scanted in favor of a single developer and the city's land use review process was circumvented. Last night, he discussed the major planning ventures with which he’s been involved, part of “Conversations on New York,” sponsored by the Architectural League, in conjunction with ...

Gentrification, "Brooklyn's Roommate Belt," and how housing code changes could produce more affordable housing

You can't just blame developers, or Wall Streeters with cash to burn. One important driver of gentrification may be the housing code, which makes it hard for developers to build low-cost studio apartments, instead aiming at larger apartments and luxury studios. Former Citizens Housing and Planning Council (CHPC) fellow Denali Dasgupta , now a Policy Analyst in the New York City Comptroller's Office, at the Dreamland Pavilion Conference last October contended that the cause may be less market forces than market failure. And a revision in regulations might produce a lot more affordable housing, I'd suggest, leaving less opportunity for projects like Atlantic Yards, however questionable, to be seen as saviors . The "Roommate Belt" Thus, Dasgupta described what she called "Brooklyn's Roommate Belt," zones of Brooklyn--originally neighborhoods like Park Slope and Fort Greene, now extended to Kensington, Prospect Heights and Bedford-Stuyvesant--which cont...

ESDC debuts new, more transparent web site; drops "New York Loves Business" but does claim it's "Open for Business"

The Empire State Development Corporation (ESDC) has managed a long-overdue revamping of its web site, adding significantly more background information and transparency, thus bringing it (belatedly) up to par with some other state agencies and authorities. Notably, the ESDC--mainly referred to simply as Empire State Development (though the names seem interchangeable )--has finally dropped the "New York Loves Business" slogan and nylovesbiz.com web address. Now, the home page proclaims that New York is "Open for Business." While that doesn't exactly suggest that the ESDC plans to eschew "collaborative" relationships with developers--which, as I've pointed out , raise questions about the "arm's length" negotiation of a developer agreement with Forest City Ratner--it's not smitten. The web site was created in-house for less than $1000, a sign, according to the ESDC , of fiscal responsibility. ESDC history Also, there's finally a...

An F train express, East Side Access, and affordable housing

Mayor Mike Bloomberg's plan for better transit includes some good ideas, such as restoring express service on available F train tracks. However, this idea wasn't new at all, though that was ignored in some initial coverage last month. Bloomberg's had eight years to make progress, as the Brooklyn Paper editorialized . And the idea for an F train express has been around for a while, with the most recent push beginning in 2007 with a petition launched by Carroll Gardens activist (and now 39th District Council candidate) Gary Reilly . (Also see coverage by Second Avenue Sagas' Benjamin Kabak.) The impact on housing Also, hardly mentioned is an important side-effect of such improved transit: increased production of housing, and thus more affordable housing. In other words, boosting infrastructure might be a better bet to produce affordable housing than unquestioning support for Atlantic Yards, a lesson AY boosters like Bill de Blasio (who also supports the F express) m...

Another gentrification discussion, the hard to find "sweet spot," and the "public realm"

It's getting a little frustrating to hear, as on yesterday's Brian Lehrer Show , yet another lament/debate about gentrification without any discussion of policy responses and solutions like investing in the "public realm" --transportation, parks, etc, as detailed by planner Alexander Garvin--to share the benefits of growth. Yesterday's episode featured Fort Greene/Clinton Hill residents Rosie Perez (actress, etc.) and Nelson George (author, etc.), in a preview of a live program slated for Thursday at 10 am at The Greene Space called The Places that Bind: Examining Preservation and Culture in a Changing City . Brownstoner, which hosted a lot of comments on the show, found George's "nostalgic but realistic take" interesting, while calling Perez on her lack of nuance in lamenting how few people she knows today. After all, if people fight over access to tennis courts in Fort Greene Park, how much worse is that than, as a one-time transplant to Brooklyn...

Overdevelopment, zoning, and the public realm (and AY)

If you listened to a panel on overdevelopment at the Museum of the City of New York two weeks ago, there were some curious disconnects. Everyone--the defender of the real estate industry, the developer, the community planner, the public official--seemed to make at least some sense, but it sure didn’t hang together. And there wasn’t enough time in the Q&A to tease out the tensions. Some clarity emerged when I attended a panel October 28 at the Municipal Art Society, featuring planner Alex Garvin--a mainstream figure but clearly not part of the Bloomberg consensus. (The panel, called Growing Greener Cities , took off from a new book, Growing Greener Cities: Urban Sustainability in the Twenty-First Century , to which Garvin is a contributor.) At the very least, said Garvin, in words that show some commonality with sometime antagonists like community planner Tom Angotti, we should stop relying on zoning as planning, recognize the importance of public investment, and stop expecting mega...