Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts with the label 421-a

Featured Post

Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park FAQ, timeline, and infographics (pinned post)

(Updated) ESD says it didn't approach Related to become designated developer for project. Did Related pull out because the state wouldn't re-create 421-a?

Updated 4 pm : I got the following statement from Empire State Development (ESD), which asserts that my initial conclusion, based on a secondhand statement, was incorrect: ESD had not approached additional entities to step into the project, including Related. Greenland USA has and as of today remains to be the developer of the Atlantic Yards project pursuant to the project documents. For USIF to pursue foreclosure proceedings given Greenland’s EB-5 default, the project documents require ESD to approve an entity as a permitted developer. USIF had presented a JV including Related, Fortress, and themselves as a permitted developer, but opted not to proceed. As discussed at the April [March, actually] 2025 AYCDC meeting, we have communicated timelines and milestone expectations to relevant parties regarding advancing the project and the collection of liquidated damages. --- We don't know why Related Companies, the developer of Hudson Yards, pulled out of a contemplated joint venture to...

While B5 tower could qualify for 421-a extension, the all middle-income "affordable" option is off the table. But Option B still looks pretty good, compared to 485-x.

In a previous version of the graphic describing plans for Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park, below, I assumed that the B5 tower, the first built over the railyard, would contain 30% affordable units at 130% of Area Median Income (AMI). Hence the green and red shading indicating a 70%/30% breakdown. After all, that reflected predictions from the Downtown Brooklyn Partnership, as I wrote in December 2022, as the building--as with B4, B15, and B12/13--would take advantage of the 421-a tax break which, allows 130% AMI units as long as 30% of the total apartments are below-market. Outdated graphic by Ben Keel & Norman Oder That won't happen, though it's the deadline hasn't yet expired. Because the building (apparently) had foundations installed by June 15, 2022, it could qualify for the 421-a tax break as it existed then, but only if it were completed by June 15, 2026. That deadline won't be met without 24/7 construction and a miracle. Building even a piece of the platform, p...

Real estate lawyer admits that allowing "affordable" units at 130% of Area Median Income was "a mistake." Last four Atlantic Yards towers had only 130% AMI.

From an April 24 article in the Real Deal about the new 485-x tax break, a successor to 421-a,  Developers have a new tax break. Now they must figure it out : The new one provides property tax exemptions for up to 40 years, and eliminates the highest income band permitted for “affordable” units under the previous program: 130 percent of the area median income. “We knew that 130 percent AMI was going out the window,” said Alvin Schein, a founding partner at Seiden & Schein. Some landlords actually had a difficult time renting out those units . The 130 percent AMI units forced owners and prospective tenants to navigate city bureaucracy and were a punching bag for critics, who ridiculed their “affordable” label. “I think 130 was a mistake,” Schein said. “It helped give 421a a bad name.” Indeed, "affordable" merely means rents targeted to 30% of household income, so the baseline matters--and the term "income-linked" or "income-targeted" are more accurate. ...

New 485-x tax incentive would require (at Atlantic Yards) 25% "affordable" units for households averaging 60% of AMI (now $83,880 for 3 people, but will rise)

Might the state's recently approved 485-x tax incentive re-start Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park? Of course not. Remember, there's an expensive platform, and fines for missing affordable housing to be reckoned with. Zone A in yellow, Zone B in orange  (Department of City Planning) Might it help any potential bidder or developer better assess the bottom line regarding future investment? Surely. A 421-a successor Future buildings would qualify under 485-x ( bill text ), a successor to the since expired 421-a, as a "Very large rental project," defined as a site in in Zone A or Zone B, which includes the Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park site, with 150 or more rental units. The carrot: a 40-year exemption from property taxes. That's more than the most recent iteration of 421-a , which for Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park buildings offered a 25-year full exemption, and ten years of exemption applied to the 30% affordable units, at 130% of Area Median Income (AMI).  (Note that the an...

In state budget: 485-x, a yet-unspecified incentive for rental housing, plus an extension of 421-a deadline. Both presumably somewhat helpful to Atlantic Yards.

A state budget recently announced, if not fully specified, should incentivize new rental housing and also provide a lifeline to projects that started construction--put footings in the ground--under the only 421-a program. That should make construction of the remaining Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park towers somewhat more viable, though 1) the devil's in the details and 2) these aren't the only factors. Notably, the six development sites over the Metropolitan Transportation Authority's (MTA) Vanderbilt Yard face a foreclosure auction of developer Greenland USA's stake. That is scheduled for April 30, after being postponed twice, and it's unclear if it will go forward. Not only is a tax incentive needed to make the numbers work, any bidder must factor in the cost of a platform to enable vertical construction, the remaining cost to pay the MTA for development rights, and the pending damages of $2,000/month for each of the 876 affordable housing units not delivered by May 20...

As legislature faces April 1 budget deadline, approval of a successor to 421-a tax break could nudge the future of Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park

For various reasons, it's not surprising that the foreclosure auction of six Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park development sites has been postponed twice, most recently to April 30 . The most obvious reason is the complexity of a future deal, since the development rights are attached to obligations to build a costly platform as well as obligations to build affordable housing, which come with liquidated damages for units not built by May 2025. That means the parties include not just the debt holders, funds formed with money from EB-5 investor visa borrowers, and future bidders, but also Empire State Development (ESD), the state authority that oversees/shepherds the project and could clarify/renegotiate/subsidize the obligations.  Of course, the gubernatorially-controlled ESD shouldn't do that without input from elected officials and the public. The 421-a quandary But there's another issue. By April 1, the state budget is due, and should include new policies to support housing cons...

Hochul to propose letting city replace 421-a tax abatement, affordability unclear. She'll propose extending completion for vested projects. B5 could qualify.

Governor Hochul Announces Next Phase in Long-Term Housing Strategy Will Focus on Increasing Housing Supply in New York City , Gov. Kathy Hochul announced Jan. 9, as part of her State of the State address. The notable section for Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park watchers is this: Incentivizing Construction of New Housing, Including Affordable Housing The expiration of the 421-a tax abatement program in 2022 put the construction of an estimated 30,000 units of housing in New York City at risk. To avoid losing thousands of units of housing already under construction, Governor Hochul launched a pilot program in July 2023 to replicate the 421-a program’s benefits and obligations for projects located within the Gowanus rezoning area in Brooklyn that were already vested in the tax abatement program when it expired. As of December 2023, the Governor’s Gowanus program has received 19 applications that could yield up to 5,500 units of housing, including 1,400 units of affordable housing. To help the...

With proposed new city financing program for 70% affordable housing, a way forward for Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park? Proposals due in February.

Is this the bailout that Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park was waiting for? Not necessarily, but it could be part of the way there. It was heralded yesterday in a scoop fed to the New York Times under the headline New York City Aims to Build Affordable Housing in Wealthier Neighborhoods . Instead of using city money to subsidize "100% affordable" projects, now the city will provide a rough substitute for the state 421-a tax break, which has lapsed and previously incentivized 25% or 30% below-market units, albeit some at rather high income levels.  This instead would require 70% affordability, at various income levels, and could get support from advocates arguing for more affordability in the project. The devil, of course, is in the details. "Limited Affordability Areas" The city is offering a preference to proposals with the deepest affordability levels and in "Limited Affordability Areas," as shown in the map below. That Park Slope segment highlighted includes ...

Looking at the ESD's 421-a subsitute plan for Gowanus, a possible template for Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park. The devil's in the details, and the timeline might be flexible.

If a Gowanus-style deal is under consideration for Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park, with the Empire State Development--the state authority that oversees/shepherds the project--re-creating the impact of the 421-a tax benefit (as I wrote ), what might that mean? I wrote last month quoting the press release,  Governor Hochul Announces New Executive Action on Housing Crisis to Increase Supply, Create Affordable Housing, and Promote Broader Housing Growth , in which Gov Kathy Hochul: announced a program aimed at targeting specific benefits and housing obligations in line with the former 421-a(16) program for development proposals currently vested in the expired program in the Gowanus neighborhood in Brooklyn. Proposals would respond to a request for applications administered by Empire State Development. For eligible proposals, Empire State Development would purchase the privately owned properties for a nominal fee, lease the property back to the original owners for a long-term lease term t...

Hochul finds workaround to replace 421-a tax break, for Gowanus at least. Will it extend to other neighborhoods? To Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park?

In what the New York Times called "stopgap measures," on 7/18/23, Governor Hochul Announces New Executive Action on Housing Crisis to Increase Supply, Create Affordable Housing, and Promote Broader Housing Growth . Notably, in response to the state legislature's failure to approve her proposed replacement for the 421-a tax break, seen as crucial to advancing much rental housing, Gov. Kathy Hochul: announced a program aimed at targeting specific benefits and housing obligations in line with the former 421-a(16) program for development proposals currently vested in the expired program in the Gowanus neighborhood in Brooklyn. Proposals would respond to a request for applications administered by Empire State Development. For eligible proposals, Empire State Development would purchase the privately owned properties for a nominal fee, lease the property back to the original owners for a long-term lease term that would parallel the 421-a(16) benefit period, and deed the propert...

State stalls on new housing policies, including 421-a extension likely contemplated by Atlantic Yards developer as necessary for next tower

Maybe it isn't over--legislators are expected to return to Albany later this month for an additional session--but a complicated set of negotiations and, apparently, differences with Gov. Kathy Hochul, meant that no new major housing policies were passed by the state Legislature. In  N.Y. Democrats, at Odds Over Tenant Protections, Fail to Reach Housing Deal , the New York Times reported: Democratic lawmakers in New York had scrambled this week to assemble a plan to tackle the state’s housing crisis: They said it included measures to protect tenants from eviction and cap rent increases, incentives to remodel empty offices into apartments and an extension of a tax break for developers to build affordable housing. But it all unraveled on Thursday, when Democrats who control the State Legislature and Gov. Kathy Hochul failed to reach a deal, leading to a new round of finger pointing among Democrats in Albany. Lawmakers blamed Ms. Hochul for opposing their housing measures, particularl...