Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts with the label charter commission

Featured Post

Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park FAQ, timeline, and infographics (pinned post)

Charter reform proposals include modest tweak to ULURP, ranked-choice voting; early voting starts today

Hey, there's an election. Not a big one--the only citywide vote is whether incumbent Jumaane Williams gets re-elected as public advocate --but, as City Limits' Jarrett Murphy put it,  Charter Reform Proposals: One Big Change and Lots of Modest (But Important) Tweaks . And people can start early voting now on those proposals . (Find your poll site location here. ) The big change is in Question 1, to allow ranked-choice voting, allowing up to five preferences. If there is no majority winner, the last place candidate would be eliminated and any voter who had that candidate as their top choice would have their vote transferred to their next choice. This would eliminate the possibility, for example, of a disliked incumbent getting re-elected with 30% of the votes, while a set of challengers split the opposition. In the latter case, presumably those voting for a challenger would limit their secondary choices to other challengers, thus eventually electing a challenger. ...

"Leaving the REBNY vs NIMBY Doom Loop"? Maybe not this time.

In a 7/31/19 op-ed headlined  Leaving the REBNY vs NIMBY Doom Loop , Council Members Brad Lander and Antonio Reynoso pointed to what they call a missed opportunity in the ballot proposals approved by the 2019 Charter Revision Commission. They write: Currently, the process of developing a capital plan to invest in our infrastructure constitutes just making a big list – a list that is in no way informed by plans for rezoning or development. How can we plan which neighborhoods should get resilient infrastructure like levees and seawalls when land-use and growth decisions are happening elsewhere? Shouldn’t we include capital budgeting for infrastructure like transit and schools as part of the process of planning for the new residential growth that will require it? Meanwhile, New York City’s Uniform Land Use Review Procedure (ULURP) is a reactive, project-by-project process for considering changes – bereft of strategic vision, shared values, or a connection to long-term infrastructu...

The Vanishing City: film focuses on the fruits of a corporate-friendly mentality and the "luxury city"; AY gets a cameo

Trying to understand the arc of the city that led to such projects as Atlantic Yards, I've been writing recently about the loss of manufacturing . That's part of a larger story, told intriguingly--if incompletely--in the 55-minute 2010 documentary, The Vanishing City , by Fiore DiRosa and Jen Senko. The overview: Told through the eyes of tenants, city planners, business owners, scholars, and politicians, The Vanishing City exposes the real politic behind the alarming disappearance of New York’s beloved neighborhoods, the truth about its finance-dominated economy, and the myth of “inevitable change.” Artfully documented through interviews, hearings, demonstrations, and archival footage, the film takes a sober look at the city’s “luxury” policies and high-end development, the power role of the elite, and accusations of corruption surrounding land use and rezoning. The film also links New York trends to other global cities where multinational corporations continue to victimize th...

The Charter Commission's missed opportunity to address real change, and the "Morton's fork" faced by voters Tuesday on term limits, reform package

New York City voters on Tuesday will turn over their ballots to see two ballot referenda in small type, the relatively minor but not unimportant results of a Charter Revision Commission, appointed by Mayor Mike Bloomberg, that, this summer, heard much concern about issues such as land use reform . Instead, the commission devised a question on term limits that's quite cynical--the current three-term limit, enacted after the City Council did Bloomberg's bidding, would be replaced by the old two-term limit, but not apply to current incumbents. And, rather than offer yes-no voting on several other issues, the commission-- claiming it was told that ballot strictures required it--lumped seven disparate reform measures into one vote. On term limits, cynicism time Wrote Craig Gurian in a Remapping Debate commentary headlined And then they’ll say we ratified their scheme : We won’t know the outcome, of course, for another week. But there is something that we can safely predict. If v...

From City Pragmatist: behind the Charter Revision Commission, an effort to shift power to the mayor

So, it turns out that the Charter Revision Commission did nothing--beyond a hearing--to grapple with issues like land use reform . And while a complicated term limits vote is one of the two proposals on the November ballot, the real import of the Commission's work is the second proposal, which--despite a fig leaf of reform--would essentially strengthen an already strong mayor. Credit CityPragmatist blogger Alvin Berk, who's been following the Commission closely, concluding, NYC Charter Revision Proposals: A Hobson’s Choice . He writes: Here are the proposals being placed on November’s ballot by the New York City Charter Revision Commission. The commission has restricted voters’ options by lumping the changes into just two ballot questions, putatively because this year’s new paper voting forms are too small to show the proposals individually. He's skeptical--and any serious reader of these long and thus confusing ballot questions would have reason to agree. (The Daily ...

The land use issue won't go away, even if the Charter Commission won't get to it this year

After spending the day today at Land Use and Local Voices , a conference co-sponsored by the Municipal Art Society and Manhattan Community Board 1, I can safely say that both experts and engaged citizens know there's something wrong with the current process. There's a significant need to give local voices more credence (though not a veto), while recognizing that land use has borough-wide and city-wide implications. And while the Charter Revision Commission doesn't have time this year to address land use, if it's reappointed, it should--though some at the conference were doubtful the commission would go beyond the promised issue of term limits. (I'll have a report on the conference, in which Atlantic Yards was again invoked as an example of a Community Benefits Agreement gone wrong, at a later date.) At the Charter Commission The marquee issue at the Charter Revision Commission hearing Monday night (featuring a Citizens Union presentation ) at Brooklyn College was n...

Citizens Union to Charter Commission: some sharing of power needed, but not fundamental change (hearing tonight)

The venerable good-government group Citizens Union (CU), as I wrote in March, has played it carefully regarding Atlantic Yards, in December 2006 calling for a “limited delay” but saying it “does not align itself with those who oppose the project"--and never speaking out further. Now the CU, which has a special role in the Charter Revision Commission's work, is also playing it carefully, proposing reforms--some of which (land use review regarding security and architectural character) could affect future Atlantic Yards-like projects, at least if they are be subject to city review. But those reforms would not fundamentally change the power balance in the city. CU will present its 49 recommendation to the Commission at a hearing tonight at 6 pm at Brooklyn College, the first of five hearings in response to a preliminary staff report . That report scanted issues of land use and concerns about local decisionmaking (as pointed out by Brooklyn representative Carlo Scissura, B...

Virtually ignored by the Charter Commission report: a strong mayor, weak Borough Presidents, and the fact that there's "no real local government"

The news from the city's Charter Revision Commission is that a vote on term limits (and maybe Instant Runoff Voting) are apparently on the agenda , but more substantive change, regarding issues like more public input into land use and expanded power of Borough Presidents, is not. That's plausible, given the tight schedule to get measures on the November ballot, but the commission's staff report was dismissively brief, ignoring many legitimate criticisms posed by the Borough Presidents and others. As the Staten Island Advance reported yesterday , that ticked off one Commission member: "The fact the conversation on borough presidents and community boards warrants maybe two paragraphs, to me is utterly disrespectful to the communities," said Carlo A. Scissura, who is chief of staff to Brooklyn Borough President Marty Markowitz. The fundamental problem The failure to address the BPs' concerns reflects a larger issue, one that doesn't get traction in the ...

At Charter Commission hearing, most invited panelists support ULURP; Angotti, BPs, civic groups, call for planning, not zoning; AY gets a cameo

The New York City Charter Revision Commission hearing on June 24 aired some important testimony on land use reform, to relatively little coverage, and though land use is not on the agenda this year , the issues deserve discussion. The gist of the expert testimony--four of five those invited--was that the city's Uniform Land Use Review Procedure (ULURP) pretty much works, and shouldn't be amended. (There was also a lot of criticism of Community Benefit Agreements, as I've written .) The one outlier, urban planning professor Tom Angotti of Hunter College--also an advisor to the Council of Brooklyn Neighborhoods on Atlantic Yards issues--disagreed, laying out in great detail the flaws in ULURP. He suggested that greater weight (though not a veto) be given to the advisory opinions of local Community Boards and arguing for greater transparency in the pre-ULURP negotiations. Also see Angotti's essay in the July Gotham Gazette, headlined Charting a Better Way for Pl...