Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts with the label Timetable

Featured Post

Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park FAQ, timeline, and infographics (pinned post)

Some questions for today's BrooklynSpeaks press conference on the missed affordable housing deadline

Today at 4 pm, as I wrote ( link ), the coalition BrooklynSpeaks will hold a press event/rally with state Assemblymembers Bobby Carroll and Jo Anne Simon, City Council Members Crystal Hudson and Shahana Hanif, and various community leaders "to call on Governor Hochul to bring accountability to the long-delayed Atlantic Yards project." I can't be there, though I am sending a videographer. So I wanted to float some questions for the leaders of BrooklynSpeaks and the elected officials who, I suspect, largely take their cue from them. In 2014, averting a threatened lawsuit , BrooklynSpeaks reached a settlement with New York State that set a new May 31, 2025 deadline for the project's 2,250 affordable units, with $2,000/month liquidated damages for each missing unit, with the money directed to a city trust fund for affordable housing. With 1,374 completed, that leaves 876 to go, so $1.752 million/month, which ESD has refrained from pursuing, saying that, with a new deve...

Though advisory Atlantic Yards CDC asked for a financial analysis of Pacific Park's future by Oct. 3, parent ESD says report still in process. No target date.

At the Aug. 2 meeting of the Atlantic Yards Community Development Corporation (AY CDC), as I reported for City Limits, the directors voted unanimously to ask parent Empire State Development (ESD), to prepare a financial analysis of the future of the Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park project, of which seven development sites--six over a railyard, requiring an expensive deck--remain. They asked for it to be delivered in 60 days, by Oct. 3, presumably before the next AY CDC meeting. (The board is supposed to meet quarterly, so three months would be the first week of November, but it hadn't met since April 11, so it was behind schedule.) The report is not finished, perhaps not surprisingly, and no new AY CDC meeting has been scheduled. "Empire State Development is coordinating with the developer on a financial analysis of the remaining Atlantic Yards sites," a spokeswoman for ESD stated in response to my query. "This is not yet complete. ESD will share this analysis with the...

From City Limits: "State Weighs Tax Deal, Plans ‘Public Engagement’ for Atlantic Yards as Housing Deadline Nears" (plus bonus material)

Yesterday City Limits published my article,  State Weighs Tax Deal, Plans ‘Public Engagement’ for Atlantic Yards as Housing Deadline Nears .  While a key outline of the potential compromise emerged two weeks ago--The Real Deal reported on the possibility of a substitute for the 421-a tax break--my new article teases out how, based on discussions at the Aug. 2 meeting of the Atlantic Yards Community Development Corporation (AY CDC), state officials do not seem ready to push developer Greenland USA. As I wrote, some AY CDC directors, notably Gib Veconi and Ron Shiffman, were skeptical that ESD’s proposed “community engagement process” regarding the project’s future, including affordability of future units. could be taken seriously when the state has not enforced previous promises or pushed to ensure that the developer would meet the 2025 affordable housing deadline or be held accountable. For the rest of the article, go here , but let me add a little more below. Bonus material ...

Another Atlantic Yards renegotiation is inevitable. Forest City started use of tactic. Greenland has picked it up. Plus: common Chinese business practice.

With the departure of Greenland USA's Scott Solish, and Empire State Development's Tobi Jaiyesimi, both the public faces of Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park for their respective entities, the project seems adrift. At the same time, however, Greenland, which owns nearly all of Greenland Forest City Partners, faces a looming May 2025 deadline to deliver 2,250 units of affordable housing, with $2,000/month fines for each missing unit--as of now 876 (or 877). But Greenland surely doesn't want to pay $1.75 million a month in fines, part of a settlement agreement announced in 2014, which set that new affordable housing deadline. Though Solish had long said Greenland would meet its obligations, at the June 2022 meeting of the (purportedly) advisory Atlantic Yards Community Development Corporation (AY CDC), he hinted that the developer might ask ESD, the state authority that oversees/shepherds the project, for an extension or other accommodation. ESD posture This past April, at a meeti...

With AY CDC set to meet July 26, possible discussion of big-picture issues (platform start, affordable housing obligation & renegotiation of fines)--or not.

Well, the Atlantic Yards Community Development Corporation (AY CDC), which is supposed to advise the parent Empire State Development (ESD) is almost on schedule. The (purportedly) advisory body, which is supposed to meet quarterly but has had big gaps between meetings, will meet on Wednesday, July 26 at 3 pm, according to an ESD spokeswoman. No agenda or other information has yet been posted yet , but the meeting likely will be held in person at ESD offices, with a webcast, The AY CDC  last met April 11 , with a presentation by ESD Project Director Tobi Jaiyesimi but no representative of the development team since Scott Solish of Greenland USA had  left his job . Since then, Jaiyesimi has departed as well. What's the agenda? Without the agenda (and, maybe, even with it), it's unclear what the ambit of the meeting will be. Will it be simply to get the AY CDC up to speed on changes at ESD? Will a replacement for Jaiyesimi be announced and presiding, or will it be pres...

Jersey City developer LeFrak: project expected to take 20 years should take 50 years (or maybe 60 years)

From The Real Deal, 5/22/23, Richard LeFrak to step back from day-to-day role at firm : LeFrak said he originally expected the waterfront redevelopment [in Jersey City] to take 20 years. But with 22 project sites left in the Newport area, he said it will likely take at least 50. His sons estimate 60. Now the Newport project is far larger than Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park--a 300-acre site vs. a 22-acre one--so they're not directly comparable. What is comparable is that optimistic assumptions about a project's buildout--remember, Atlantic Yards was long supposed to take ten years, but now would likely take 25+ years--are not uncommon in big, complicated, multi-part real estate projects.

WSJ: yes, there's a market for cities, outside office buildings. That helps Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park, but there are other headwinds.

American Cities Are Starting to Thrive Again. Just Not Near Office Buildings. , the Wall Street Journal reported 5/30/23: The pandemic and remote work have done little to dent the overall appeal of cities such as New York, Chicago and Los Angeles, foot-traffic and rent data show. Instead, the pandemic has shifted the urban center of gravity, moving away from often sterile office districts to neighborhoods with apartments, bars and restaurants. "We're now back to what cities really are—they're not containers for working," said Richard Florida, a specialist in city planning at the University of Toronto. "They're places for people to live and connect with others." So--and this observation isn't new--that's ultimately a vote of confidence for residential developments like Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park, which offer access to urban amenities. The caveats on that are the upfront cost of the platform, needed for six approved towers; the pending fines of $2...

The clock ticks: the May 31, 2025 affordable housing deadline is two years away. The developer will try to avoid fines. Will renegotiation serve public interest?

From 2/22/18 Forest City Realty Trust annual report : On June 27, 2014, the City of New York and State of New York entities revised certain project requirements with the goal of accelerating the construction of affordable housing. Among the requirements, affordable units are required to constitute 35% of all units for which construction has commenced until 1,050 affordable units have been started, after which the percentage drops to 25%. Failure to meet this requirement will prevent the joint venture from seeking new building permits, as well as give the State the right to seek injunctive relief. Also, temporary certificates of occupancy (“TCOs”) for a total of 2,250 affordable housing units are required to be issued by  May 31, 2025  or a $2,000 per unit per month penalty will be imposed for those affordable units which have not received TCOs by such date, until issued. (Emphasis added) That deadline won't be met, given the failure to start a platform over the Metropolitan T...

From The Real Deal: developer Elghanayan says "you must have a super-optimistic view of life" to be a developer (or, as AY suggests, an unfounded one)

From The Real Deal's 20th Anniversary issue, excerpts from "The Closing" interviews: Henry Elghanayan Rockrose Development (2013)  Do you need to have a certain amount of ego to be a successful developer in New York City? You must not only have an ego, you must have a super-optimistic view of life. I have an unnaturally optimistic view on life — it’s a sickness. If you understood the real dangers involved in doing a project, you would never do one. That echoes a 2016 valedictory quote from Atlantic Yards developer Bruce Ratner, who told Crain's New York Business, in the publication's paraphrase, "If he knew the true economics [of Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park] at the outset, he said, he would probably have passed." But he surely knew some of them. And with what might be called an "unnaturally optimistic view" or perhaps a "completely unfounded view," Ratner claimed , in a May 2008 New York Daily News op-ed, "We anticipate finishi...

Metro IAF's Gecan: outcomes of projects obfuscated, counterfactuals absent. Same goes for Atlantic Yards, where a rigorous study of past and future is needed.

There's an important lesson for Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park watchers in the New York Daily News op-ed yesterday,  Development’s struggle for sites and subsidies: New York should not copy projects like Baltimore’s struggling Harborplace but aim for those like Nehemiah , by Michael Gecan. senior adviser to the leaders of Metro IAF . The latter, which organizes low-income communities on affordable housing, education, and other issues, is an affiliate of the Industrial Areas Foundation , founded by Saul Alinsky in Chicago in 1940. Gecan notes the big plans, approved or floated, that come with major promises and major public subsidies (both direct and indirect): a stadium for the Buffalo Bills; a soccer stadium (and more) in Willets Point; casinos around the state. He sets out a basic template: Why, after decades of examples, many falling far short of original projections, there is not a clear, public upfront way to examine each proposal and to weigh each against other plausible al...

AY CDC: with developer absent, questions persist; platform delays blamed on LIRR negotiations. Will ESD collect fines for affordable housing delay? Will there be a public bailout for the platform?

This the first of four articles on the 4/11/23 meeting of the Atlantic Yards Community Development Corporation (AY CDC). The second concerned the timing and affordability of the income-targeted housing. The third concerned plans for the Urban Room and possible new public engagement. The fourth concerned AY CDC transparency. Yesterday’s meeting of the (purportedly) advisory Atlantic Yards Community Development Corporation (AY CDC) didn’t answer key questions about the future of Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park: with representatives of master developer Greenland Foreset City Partners (GFCP) absent, there were no substantive updates on the future of the project nor plans for the two-block platform over the Vanderbilt Yard, crucial to six future towers and the majority of the project’s open space. Moreover, there’s no evidence that Empire State Development (ESD), the gubernatorially-controlled state authority that oversees/shepherds the project, knows if the project is currently viable o...

Flashback 2008, when project was stalled, prescience & myopia from city's Thompson: other developers might join, but a "good idea" can be diminished by delay

In May 2008, when the Atlantic Yards project had been stalled by the recession, the project, as I wrote , was the most contentious element of a panel discussion at the New School’s Center for New York City Affairs titled "Maintaining Momentum: Can New York’s Ambitious Development Agenda Survive an Economic Downturn?" My headline quoted City Comptroller (and mayoral candidate) William Thompson: "Thompson says other developers might join AY; 'I’m not sure what that project is any longer'." He was, if unwittedly, prescient, as other developers did join, notably Greenland USA, in 2014 buying a majority stake in the project, 70% going forward (excluding the B2 tower, 461 Dean, and the arena company), and, after building four towers with original developer Forest City Ratner/Forest City New York, in 2018 taking all but 5% of the remaining project. Greenland Forest City Partners then sold development rights to the B12/B13 sites (595 Dean) to TF Cornerstone. It sold...

In 2017 study, the Brooklyn Chamber unwisely hailed seeming success of Barclays Center and predicted 2025 delivery of required affordable housing

From the Brooklyn Chamber of Commerce's 2017 COMPREHENSIVE ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT STRATEGY (CEDS) for Brooklyn: The Next 100 Years : The Atlantic Yards development has repurposed former railyards to create a new entertainment center at the Barclays Arena that generated $47 million in gross ticket sales revenue in its first year, positioning it as the top-grossing US venue for concerts and the second globally. The development project will also create at least 2,250 new units of affordable housing by 2025. Well, both sunny statements deserved caveats back then, and red flags now. First, $47 million in "gross ticket sales" for concerts in the arena's debut year, 2012-2013, does not represent profits. The arena (reportedly) made generous deals with performs so it could open big. Madison Square Garden was still under renovation. (The source of that $47 million statistic was apparently the trade magazine Pollstar, as ...

Latest six-month look-ahead from developer again offers boilerplate: "Platform construction may commence." But there's no proof it will proceed.

Master developer Greenland Forest City Partners (GFCP) still doesn't sound completely confident that work on the first phase of the platform over the MTA's Vanderbilt Yard, crucial to the construction of three towers, will start in the first half of this year. That's according to the latest six-month look-ahead (bottom), covering the first half of 2023, that the master developer is supposed to file with Empire State Development (ESD), which oversees/shepherds the project. (I received the document via a Freedom of Information Law request.) That document, dated 12/6/22, again says--as it did in four previous iterations --that "Platform construction may commence during the reporting period." The workforce would average 50 to 100 workers. Previous to those documents, in the 5/6/20 memo covering the second half of 2020, GFCP pronounced, unwisely in retrospect, that "Platform construction will commence." It didn't. (This would be the first block of the t...

Has developer Greenland asked NY State about extending May 2025 affordable housing deadline (which surely can't be met)? Records request turns up blank.

It's a near impossibility that master developer Greenland Forest City Partners, dominated by Greenland USA, can deliver the required 2,250 affordable housing units by May 31, 2025, as established in a June 2014 agreement , which assigns $2,000/month fines for each missing unit. After all, the 876 (or 877) units needed haven't even started, despite plans floated to start B5, 700 Atlantic Avenue, which would be built in tandem with the first block (of two) of the platform over the Vanderbilt Yard, which was supposed to start in 2020 and then to start this spring. No wonder that, in March 2021, then Empire State Development (ESD) Chair Steven M. Cohen suggested a legislative “fix” might be needed to enable the project to meet its affordable housing obligations. Nothing has emerged, though I speculated that it could mean a targeted extension or modification of the Affordable New York tax break, which expired in June 2022, or a relaxation of the deadline, though GFCP had previously...

Belated candor and weasel words: ESD says project "completion date" is 2035; affordable housing means "abiding by the Project documents" (which could change); no fines for missing Urban Room

Empire State Development (ESD) finally--within the past few days--updated  its Atlantic Yards page  with notes from the previous two Quality of Life meetings, in July and September. (See documents at bottom.) Those notes were supposed to come as quickly as possible. They didn't.  My guess is that officials at and advisors to ESD, the state authority that oversees/shepherds the project, were carefully wordsmithing a few key issues, perhaps in consultation with the project's developer.   The big news: for the first time, ESD has acknowledged a glaring truth about the project: it won't be done until 2035. Completion date 2035 As I wrote at the time, if master developer Greenland Forest City Partners (GFCP) aims to complete the project in eight or nine years , as Greenland USA executive Scott Solish claimed at a June 2022 meeting of the Atlantic Yards Community Development Corporation, what are the milestones?  After all, there's a two-phase platform to be bui...