Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts with the label IBO

Featured Post

Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park FAQ, timeline, and infographics (pinned post)

New state Enhanced Database of Economic Incentives excludes Atlantic Yards, because it was approved before 2018. Database also omits tax breaks & local subsidies.

What are the economic incentives, past and present, behind Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park?  (They include direct city and state subsidies of $305 million and far more in tax breaks, roughly summarized in my  FAQ .) Well, a new Database of Economic Incentives from New York State isn't that helpful, since 1) it doesn't provide information on projects that were approved prior to 2018 and 2) even if it did, it ignores city subsidies and most tax breaks.  Note: ESD says "Details on [previously-approved] projects can be found in historical ESD reports," but I haven't been able to find anything related to Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park.   A trumphant announcement Governor Hochul Launches Enhanced Database of Economic Incentives to Increase Transparency Around Key Economic Development Projects , the state announced Nov. 8, updating a project first launched in 2021 and updated quarterly "New York State’s Database of Economic Incentives [ link ] is nation-leading in terms of...

IBO confirms that 421-a has disproportionately incentivized "affordable housing" for the middle-class

In a report last week, How Many Units of Affordable Housing Were Built or Are Underway Through the 421-a Affordable New York Tax Exemption Program?  (also at bottom), the NYC Independent Budget Office confirmed what's been widely believed: the most recent iteration of the 421-a tax break has disproportionately incentivized not-so-affordable income-targeted housing, serving the middle-class. The IBO notes: Most affordable units created under Affordable New York were part of projects where the developer received no additional public subsidies. But about 21 percent of units, spanning 23 buildings, not only received the 421-a exemption, but also subsidies in the form of city capital funds, loans, tax credits, grants, or public land. These were overwhelmingly the units serving the lowest income bands. In fact, all of the units for extremely low-income households also received other subsidies; almost half of the units for very low-income and more than a third of those for lowincome house...

Foregone property taxes for Barclays Center continue to rise, now reaching $85 million. It's all part of "NYC's Perpetual Corporate Tax Break Machine."

The new web site Hell Gate on 5/16/22 published  Albany Problems: NYC's Perpetual Corporate Tax Break Machine , by Doug Turetsky, formerly of the city's Independent Budget Office (IBO). Starting with the 421-a tax break, he notes that "tax expenditures, or tax dollars the City forgoes, make up a sizable hunk of the City's budget—about $7 billion this year." And while some "seem intuitive, like forgoing property tax from the city's public housing authority," others are far more questionable. One prime example: Take Barclays Center. The arena hasn't paid property taxes since it opened in 2012. It's a tax expenditure that will cost the city $85 million this year alone, according to the City's Department of Finance Annual Tax Expenditure Report . Barclays' property tax break is part of a financing scheme that helped the arena's developers get around a 1986 federal law aiming to limit the use of tax-exempt bonds to finance stadium cons...

Council Members call to kill MSG's tax exemption, end tax breaks for sports venues like Barclays Center, and have PILOTs increased (?) to help city

No more tax-free ride for the Yankees, Knicks or Rangers, council members demand , Crain's New York Business wrote yesterday, citing a letter from nine members of the City Council to Mayor Bill de Blasio and Gov. Andrew Cuomo that also calls for the Barclays Center to pay taxes. “For far too long, this city has given a free pass to our beloved teams when it comes to property taxes, out of fear they’ll somehow pack up their bricks and beams and head across the Hudson River,” stated the letter, led by Council Member Costa Costantinides (a former Queens Borough President candidate) and signed by Brooklyn Council Member Brad Lander but no others representing districts near the Barclays Center. The arguments deserve teasing out, and mostly--though not completely--make sense to me. Then again, it's not necessarily the best time to make this case, since those venues aren't earning any money during the pandemic. MSG's property tax exemption The clearest case is Madison...

So, were Barclays Center tax revenues from direct spending in line with initial projections? Not even close (though numbers did change).

The sunny and (I believe) outlandish estimate by Nets/arena CEO David Levy that Barclays will host 285 a year got me thinking about another, even more dubious set of numbers. Remember this 10/1/13 Daily News headline,  Barclays Center scores: City says arena generated $14 million in tax revenues in its first year ? I was  skeptical , since the New York City Economic Development Corporation is an arm of the mayor's office, and its  previous studies  of Atlantic Yards had been rather self-serving, But I didn't have the data and context at the time to refute it. Which I do below. The claims From the article: The $14 million in tax revenues includes sales tax associated with purchases inside and outside the sports and entertainment complex, as well as income tax generated by Barclays Center employees and the Brooklyn Nets. Forest City Ratner executive chairman Bruce Ratner called the numbers confirmation that the city and state's investment in the Barclay...

IBO: affordable units more likely to be low- or moderate-income (though that's not the case with AY)

The devil's in the details, as I like to say. From the New York City Independent Budget Office (IBO),  WHAT’S THE RENT? A SNAPSHOT OF THE RENTS FOR NEW AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN NEW YORK CITY  (or in PDF form , screenshot below): Most new housing built under the Mayor’s affordable housing plan is marketed to prospective tenants through NYC Housing Connect. To be eligible for an apartment, a tenant’s gross income must fall within a specific range. Income ranges are set based on the income group for which an apartment is reserved (from “extremely low” to “middle income”), with the upper limit of the range increasing with household size. Rents for each apartment, however, are generally a fixed dollar amount. Because rents are generally fixed, different households within each income range pay different shares of their income towards rent. This is different from the federal Section 8 program and public housing, which set rents at 30 percent of a qualified renter’s gross income. IBO...

IBO offers budget options, including tax revision, no exemption for MSG, and development impact fees (instead of CBAs)

The New York City Independent Budget Offices's always annual Budget Options for NYC  is out (coverage in Times , Daily News ), and there are several particularly intriguing and relevant options, all presented neutrally, with pros and cons. It should first be noted that some options would have far more impact than others: Tolling the East River and Harlem River Bridges would raise $1 billion annually--ideally for transit--while restoring the commuter tax would raise $900 million. Such sums mean fraught political battles. Eliminating the property tax exemption for Madison Square Garden would add $42 million in 2018, as the value of the tax exemption leaped after the arena's 2013 renovation. Both the Knicks and Rangers have rocketed in value, and the threat of relocation is far less, notes the IBO. The arguments against include there's a risk the teams might leave or the move would be seen as not business-friendly--both bogus. The only argument with a shred of resonance is...

IBO report: Hudson Yards projections were overoptimistic, leaving city on the hook

Rosy projections should be taken with a grain of salt regarding big development projects, right? From the Wall Street Journal, 4/23/13,  Hudson Yards Woes Leave City on Hook : When the city agreed to pick up the tab for the extension of the No. 7 subway line to ease the creation of a new office and residential district on the far West Side, it expected the project could begin paying for itself as early as 2008. Instead, a single 1.7 million square-foot office tower in the Hudson Yards area has broken ground, while the project envisions 25 million square feet of new office space. And the district generated 40% less revenue from taxes and other development fees than projected between 2006 and 2012, according to a report to be released Wednesday by the New York City Independent Budget Office. Hudson Yards was expected to produce $283 million in revenue through 2012, but it actually created $170 million, according to the report by IBO, an independent city agency that studies the local...

Uncounted savings on the Barclays Center: perhaps $131 million in free land for developer Forest City Ratner

Today, Mayor Mike Bloomberg delivers his final State of the City address at the new Barclays Center arena, chosen because it has generated “unprecedented economic activity in the area.” He may even salute some well-publicized elements: an  award to the 1 millionth visitor , a new gallery  honoring black basketball in Brooklyn, a mural at the Dean Street entrance. Surely he won't specify how much the arena has cost city taxpayers, and whether that money might have been directed at real public goods, things like open libraries and Head Start. The city  acknowledges  $179 million in direct subsidies for land and infrastructure. But the city contribution is far greater than previously analyzed. As I detail below, free land for the project has been vastly undervalued or not even counted, adding up to nearly $80 million, at least, and likely more than $124 million. The beneficiary: developer Forest City Ratner. ( Update 9/8/16: Note additional $7,168,...

Brooklyn arena financing (as well as the two NYC stadiums): an exception to the "exception to the exception" in the tax code

Would you believe that sports facility financing in New York City is so byzantine that it qualifies as an exception to the third power? Let's go to What’s the Easiest Way to Cheat on Your Taxes? , a column in today's New York Times Magazine about various questions "you always wanted to ask your accountant: Why is the tax code so complicated? The answer, according to most accountants, is simple: “exceptions to the exceptions,” which, typically, are extremely complicated. John Yeutter, a C.P.A. who teaches accounting at Northeastern State University in Tahlequah, Okla., offered the following example: RULE: When you buy a bond, you have to pay taxes on the interest payments you receive. EXCEPTION: You don’t have to pay taxes on interest from municipal bonds (because the federal government wants to make it easy for local governments to borrow money). EXCEPTION TO THE EXCEPTION: If a municipal bond is used to finance a professional sports arena, you have to pay taxes...

Revisiting that 7/4/04 Times editorial, The Brooklyn Nets, seven years later: parking, subsidies, cost/benefit analysis, and the dubious promise of 3,000 cheap seats

Seven years ago, in a 7/4/04/ City section editorial headlined The Brooklyn Nets , the New York Times published its first, and most skeptical, editorial about the Atlantic Yards arena and project. The editorial begins: The idea of bringing a professional sports team to the city almost always sounds great - and then the calculation of cost versus benefits begins. It seems a new team requires a new sports facility, and for some reason, owners of these lucrative franchises are seldom willing to build anything without enormous infusions of public money. That is one of the major concerns about the proposal to place the Jets football stadium on Manhattan's far West Side at a cost to taxpayers of $600 million. It is also an issue when it comes to the Nets and Brooklyn. While the plans to bring professional basketball to Atlantic Avenue are in many ways more attractive than the football proposal, the scale of public investment needs closer examination. The amount the city and state wi...