Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts with the label B5

Featured Post

Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park FAQ, timeline, and infographics (pinned post)

While B5 tower could qualify for 421-a extension, the all middle-income "affordable" option is off the table. But Option B still looks pretty good, compared to 485-x.

In a previous version of the graphic describing plans for Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park, below, I assumed that the B5 tower, the first built over the railyard, would contain 30% affordable units at 130% of Area Median Income (AMI). Hence the green and red shading indicating a 70%/30% breakdown. After all, that reflected predictions from the Downtown Brooklyn Partnership, as I wrote in December 2022, as the building--as with B4, B15, and B12/13--would take advantage of the 421-a tax break which, allows 130% AMI units as long as 30% of the total apartments are below-market. Outdated graphic by Ben Keel & Norman Oder That won't happen, though it's the deadline hasn't yet expired. Because the building (apparently) had foundations installed by June 15, 2022, it could qualify for the 421-a tax break as it existed then, but only if it were completed by June 15, 2026. That deadline won't be met without 24/7 construction and a miracle. Building even a piece of the platform, p...

DOB filings, lobbying contract suggest that Greenland is moving toward the platform project, crucial to new towers. But what are the terms & assumptions?

Yesterday I expressed skepticism  about the likelihood that Greenland USA, which owns nearly all of Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park going forward, would proceed with the first phase of the platform over the Vanderbilt Yard in the second half of this year. That platform over Block 1120--between Atlantic Avenue and Pacific Street and between Sixth and Carlton avenues--would ultimely support three residential towers, with retail at the base. The first of three towers, B5 (700 Atlantic Avenue), would start going vertical a year after the platform started, according to a previous Greenland statement. After all, despite the developer's incentives to do proceed, including looming fines for affordable housing not built by May 2025, there are macro disincentives, such as high interest rates and the absence of the 421-a tax break, as well as the financial struggles of Shanghai-based parent Greenland Holdings Corp. Other evidence points to progress That said, other evidence, as noted b...

In Hochul's proposed 421-a extension, a lifeline for B5 tower (and others with foundation starts). Gov. will work with Legislature on renewal of tax break.

In her proposed FY 2024 Executive Budget, Gov. Kathy Hochul, among her housing proposals , has offered real estate developers a significant benefit, with an extension of the construction deadline for projects fueled by the 421-a tax break for more than 4.5 years:  In order to unlock thousands of units of housing currently under construction, the Executive Budget extends the 421-A construction deadline through 2030. The Budget also expands HCR’s Tenant Protection Unit as part of a multi-year investment to provide targeted support for tenants in upstate New York. Of course "currently under construction" is a bit of a dodge, since many developers simply did preliminary work on foundations by June 15, 2022 to qualify for the tax break--and may not have proceeded since then. There are many reasons for delay, but one, as the Real Deal has reported , is that the June 15, 2026 deadline for construction was getting tenuous, since lenders wanted the buildings completed a year early. If...

REBNY survey: June 2026 construction deadline jeopardizes projects (B5?) that already qualified for 421-a tax break. Banks said to want 1-year buffer.

First it was the 6/15/22 deadline to get foundations in the ground to qualify for the expiring 421-a tax break. Now it's the 6/15/26 deadline to get the buildings finished. Expired 421a deadline jeopardizes 33K housing units , the Real Deal reported yesterday, based on a survey by the Real Estate Board of New York (REBNY). The survey  states that, among the total, 16,000 units are in Brooklyn and over 8,200 of the total are affordable units. REBNY states that many of the projects at risk are in recently rezoned areas, such as Gowanus, which has a pipeline of about 7,000 apartments, including more than 2,000 "affordable" ones. The implication is that any renewal of the lapsed 421-a tax break should include an extension of time for those projects that have already qualified. The contours of such an extension are, of course, highly contested, so keep watch on what REBNY might be willing to cede during future negotiations. It's unclear how comprehensive the survey is; not...

If B5 rises, developers seek 30% (middle-income) affordability, under expired 421-a benefit. Tax break deadline: 2026. But affordable housing deadline: 2025.

As I wrote this week, documents confirmed that developers of the B12/B13 towers--TF Cornerstone, after leasing the sites from master developer Greenland Forest City Partners--plan 30% affordable units at 130% of Area Median Income (AMI), or middle-income households likely earning six figures. TF Cornerstone, not surprisingly, had refused to acknowledge that publicly, since such "affordable" housing--better termed "income-targeted"--hardly serves those who marched for the project. It's hardly surprising the developers would seek to maximize their economic return: that configuration is the most lucrative under the various options presented by the now-expired 421-a tax break , which required buildings to start by 6/15/22--even with just one foundation--and be completed by 6/15/26. 700 Atlantic, as well Similarly, and unsurprisingly, a document shows that the long-gestating B5--700 Atlantic Avenue, the first tower built over the Vanderbilt Yard--is also planned to ...

DCP: expiration of 421-a tax break drove spike in building permits; June 15, 2026 deadline for completion is not that far off. Whither Gov. Hochul on housing?

According to the NYC Department of City Planning's recent information brief, New Housing Permits in the First Half of 2022 (also at bottom), the first half of 2022 saw a significant spike in building permits, as the Department of Buildings (DOB) issued permits for about 58,600 homes. That's more than double any previous full year since 2015 (60,500 permits), which, not coincidentally, also was the last period before the expiration of the 421-a state tax break, later renewed and revised as Affordable New York. This year, the tax break expired June 15, 2022. DCP noted that the spurt likely related to developer uncertainty about whether the state legislature and governor will agree--as they were not able to do--on a renewal. In the interim, it's likely that far fewer permits will be filed--and that they'll not be for rentals, like the most recent Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park buildings, with 30% middle-income affordable housing. What's next As Greg David of The City, wh...

Precursor work for railyard platform finally coming? Fence could start in a few (business) days. After delay, Construction Update coming today.

This is the second of four articles about the July 12, 2022  Quality of Life meeting . Finally, it's coming? At least a month after the previous expectation , a representative of developer Greenland USA--which dominates Greenland Forest City Partners--said precursor work for the railyard platform is expected to start soon. "We're still in the process of pulling the final permits necessary to commence construction around Block 1120," said Scott Solish, referring to the Vanderbilt Yard block bounded by Sixth and Carlton avenues, and Atlantic Avenue and Pacific Street. That includes permits for the construction fence and for changing parking and sidewalk access. Below is an image of the expected fencing around that block, from a presentation at the recent Atlantic Yards Community Development Corporation meeting. Page 11 of  AYCDC-Meeting-Project-Update June 7, 2022 Contributed to  DocumentCloud  by Norman Oder (NormanOder (Individual)) •  View document  or...

Will B5 tower qualify for 421-a benefits? Developer says yes, as deadline approaches. (Next two towers won't.) AY CDC would like confirmation from HPD.

This is the fourth of ten articles on the 6/7/22 meeting of the Atlantic Yards Community Development Corporation. The  first  concerned the affordable housing timetable. The  second  assessed an estimated 2031 completion date. The  third  addressed the impact of a potential Greenland default. The  fifth  concerned the deadline for the Urban Room. The  sixth  addressed timing for the school.  The  seventh  concerned plans for the platform. The  eighth  discussed community impacts of construction.  The  ninth  concerned plans for B12/B12 affordable housing.  The  tenth  concerned the Open Meetings Law. During his slide presentation , Scott Solish of Greenland USA pointed to the location for the first phase (of two) of platform development: Block 1120 of the Vanderbilt Yard--from Sixth to Carlton avenues and Pacific Street to Atlantic Avenue. That will support three towers, the first of...

Project Update for tomorrow's Atlantic Yards CDC meeting shows schematic for platform at B5 site, but other details vague. (Comments due 4:30 pm today.)

Well, unusually, an Atlantic Yards Project Update (bottom) is posted  on the page for the 3 pm meeting tomorrow of the (purportedly advisory) Atlantic Yards Community Development Corporation (AY CDC). The webcast will be here . That Project Update might typically be part of a President's Report, but there's no President, as far as I know, given the departure of Marion Phillips III, an executive for the parent Empire State Development, the state authority that oversees/shepherds Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park. The document offers a few details, which expand on the typically vague agenda , though, as I explain below, it show some new schematics for the site of B5, 700 Atlantic Ave., the first tower (of six) over the MTA's Vanderbilt Yard, just east of Sixth Avenue between Atlantic Avenue and Pacific Street.  See screenshots at right and below, as well as the presentation at bottom. Notably, the number of concrete foundations will increase significantly to support the platform t...

In slide from recent meeting, a new view of B4 tower, plus the site for the future B5

OK, sometime in the past few days Empire State Development (ESD), the state authority that oversees/shepherds the Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park project, posted the presentation from the 5/10/22 Quality of Life meeting, which I've added below, and also to  my coverage  the next morning.    There isn't much revealing in the slideshow, but I have excerpted, at right, one slide, which is a helicopter perspective, looking west/southwest, at the western end of the railyard and the B4 tower (aka 18 Sixth Ave., or Brooklyn Crossing), which flanks the Barclays Center. The arrow, which I added, points to the location of the planned B5 tower, the first one over the railyard. The railyard platform is expected to start next month. I suspect at least one foundation for the tower will also be installed by the June 15 deadline to qualify for the current 421-a tax break. The tower is expected to go vertical next year, and should take two years to build. B5 is slated to be about 77% of ...

As construction starts for platform at first railyard block, pedestrian & traffic flow limited; parking truncated; questions about work hours, trucks, sanitation

The most important news, in my view , from last night's appearance of a Greenland USA executive at a meeting of the North Prospect Heights Association regarded the timetable for construction of the first phase of the platform, the first tower (B5), and the question marks over the remaining project. But Scott Solish was there to talk to the project's immediate neighbors about the significant changes to traffic and pedestrian flow from the establishment of construction fences around the perimeter of the first block of the MTA's Vanderbilt Yard, between Atlantic Avenue and Pacific Street, and Sixth and Carlton avenues. This could last three years. Both topics likely will be amplified at tonight's public, online  Quality of Life meeting , hosted at 6 pm by Empire State Development (ESD), the state authority that oversees/shepherds the project. Another close-up view of Block 1120 was also shown; see below Solish, the head of development for Greenland USA, noted he was approa...

Developer: B5 tower won't rise until Spring 2023, finish 2025; next rely on (unresolved) 421-a replacement; →more doubts re 2025 affordable housing deadline

Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park is moving ahead, belatedly, with plans to build a platform over the first of two railyard blocks, which will support three towers--but there are still significant clouds over the potential progress. Last night, a representative of developer Greenland USA appeared at an online meeting of the North Prospect Heights Association (NPHA), mainly to talk about the coming changes to neighborhood traffic and pedestrian flow (separate article coming) from construction at the first block of the MTA's Vanderbilt Yard, between Atlantic Avenue and Pacific Street and Sixth and Carlton avenues. That means construction of a platform and the start of the first of three towers, B5, at the western end of that block. It was a rare public appearance by a Greenland representative at a neighborhood meeting, separate from the bi-monthly public meetings hosted by Empire State Development (ESD), the state authority that oversees/shepherds the project. At far left, B4, already buil...

For Tuesday's Quality of Life meeting, an uninformative agenda, but big questions about platform construction, new tower(s), affordability levels & 2025 deadline

The agenda has been released by host Empire State Development (ESD) for the upcoming bi-monthly Atlantic Yards/Pacific Project Quality of Life Meeting, to be held virtually Tuesday, May 10 at 6 pm and--of course--it states nothing substantive. But it's not a routine meeting. Master developer Greenland Forest City Partners (dominated by Greenland USA) is starting (or will have started) construction activities for the long-delayed platform over the western block of the Vanderbilt Yard, including the first tower (of six), B5, aka 700 Atlantic Avenue. During the meeting, attendees will be able to submit questions and comments via the virtual platform’s chat feature or via email to  AtlanticYards@esd.ny.gov . (Questions also can be submitted beforehand.) The virtual format, at least as managed by ESD--the state authority that oversees/shepherds the project--does not allow for interactive chat or for participants to see others' questions, or for participants to speak, as in IRL meet...