Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts with the label platform

Featured Post

Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park FAQ, timeline, and infographics (pinned post)

As we await a new mayor, remember Errol Louis's 2010 warning: the bill for the railyard platform might "get handed to the city or state a decade from now"

The city's Democratic primary election is today--not that we'll know the mayoral results until ranked-choice voting is calculated July 1 .  Nor will that decide the city's next mayor, since both city-and-press-averse, establishment candidate Andrew Cuomo and buzzy, inexperienced socialist Zohran Mamdani, the two frontrunners, are likely to run on separate ballot lines, along with tarnished incumbent Eric Adams, in November. Very little has been said about the vexed Atlantic Yards project, unlike in some previous campaigns. Maybe because the project is confounding. Mamdani came to the Vanderbilt Yard to promote his housing plan, but didn't say anything about the project.  Cuomo outsourced his housing plan to ChatGPT and (apparently) supporters, so he (along with Adams) likely supports an emerging plan for the remainder of the Atlantic Yards site led by Cirrus Real Estate Partners, which has an agreement with construction unions. But he probably couldn't find the ra...

Today's deadline to start the platform over the Vanderbilt Yard, precursor to six towers, won't be met. It doesn't seem meaningful.

So, there's a deadline today that nobody seems to take seriously. And the penalties aren't meaningful. As I've written , there's a May 12 deadline to start the platform over the Vanderbilt Yard, necessary to construct six towers. It hasn't started. (It's two blocks, so it would be at least a two-phase process.) So, what does Empire State Development (ESD), the state authority that oversees/shepherds the project, think? I sent a query and got this response: The Development Agreement specifies that the Platform construction commence within 15 years of the “Project Effective Date”, subject to any unavoidable delays. 15 years from the Project Effective Date is on or about May 12, 2025. If the deadline is not met, the remedy available to ESD under the Project documents is to prevent the Developer from severing any parcels from the Development Agreement until platform constructing commences. Indeed, the penalty isn't so meaningful, though it could be construed a...

Even before May 31 deadline for affordable units, there's a May 12 deadline to start the platform. Time for an "Unavoidable Delays" escape hatch?

It's widely known that a May 31 deadline looms for 876 units of affordable housing, with penalties of $2,000/month for each unbuilt unit. Questions loom over whether Empire State Development (ESD), the state authority that oversees/shepherds the project, will enforce the deadline, and on whom. However, there's a May 12, 2025 deadline  to start the platform  over the Vanderbilt Yard, to protect the working railyard, used to store and service Long Island Rail Road trains, while towers are built above. (I previously wrote about this  April 21, 2024  and  Feb. 21, 2023 .) However, what I once thought "shouldn't be too hard to meet" now won't be met, because the project is stalled and no new development team is ready to take over the six railyard development sites facing a foreclosure auction. Those sites can't be developed without the platform, expected to be built on two parts between Atlantic Avenue and Pacific Street: one block between Sixth and Carlton av...

China Construction America, once said to be contractor for Vanderbilt Yard platform, found liable for $1.6 billion in Bahamas construction dispute.

As I reported in June 2022 ( link ), master developer Greenland USA confirmed it had signed a contractor to build the platform over the Vanderbilt Yard, one a Greenland rep said had "tremendous amounts of experience working with directly with the Long Island Rail Road." The contractor was identified in meeting notes  from an Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park Quality of Life meeting: a joint venture with Plaza Construction and China Construction of America, or CCA. Both are state-owned, essentially. China Construction of America is a subsidiary of Beijing-based China State Construction Engineering Corp. Ltd. (CSCEC), and in 2014 acquired Plaza Construction, which was founded in 1986 and continues to operate under that name. CCA does have experience working with the LIRR. It's unlikely that Greenland will resurrect its plan, given that it seems ready to lose development rights to six tower sites over the railyard, which require the two-block platform. Greenland, in documents ...

Did the new 485-x tax break make railyard development sites more viable? Site 5, too? More sunlight needed on transactions.

The new 485-x tax break may not be as lucrative as the predecessor 421-a tax break, even if limited in the extension that could apply to the B5 tower, as I wrote earlier this week ( link ). But does 485-x now make development of the six tower sites, offering nearly 3.5 million square feet of development rights over the Vanderbilt Yard, more viable? Likely, because the certainty of a tax break--even if less lucrative than its 421-a predecessor and requiring deeper affordability--offers potential developers a way to fill in their spreadsheets.  That's surely part of why Empire State Development (ESD), the state authority that oversees/shepherds Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park last week said that a new developer for the six railyard sites, offered as collateral in a foreclosure auction, was expected to emerge.  The Real Deal since reported that The Related Companies, a major firm that developed Hudson Yards, is apparently the candidate. Of course, the cost for the "land"--the ...

No surprise: in latest required six-month look-ahead, developer Greenland USA predicts no construction on the stalled project.

It's no surprise. The six-month look-ahead required of the Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park developer again indicated that no construction is planned for the second half of 2024. After all, the project's stalled, and the six development sites over the MTA's Vanderbilt Yard face a foreclosure auction, which has been postponed four times, likely awaiting a larger renegotiation of project terms. According to the document (below), Greenland USA's Jen Kuang told Empire State Development (ESD), the state authority that oversees Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park, that no construction activities are scheduled for Block 1120, which was supposed to be the first block of a two-block platform. Each block would support three towers. (I acquired the letter thanks to a Freedom of Information Law request.) Past pattern As I wrote last December, Greenland was once more optimistic. In the May 6, 2020  memo covering the second half of 2020, the developer pronounced, unwisely in retrospect, that ...

Daily News gets a vague quote from Gov. Hochul re Atlantic Yards, cites "myriad complications," uses stale photo of pre-arena railyard. Backroom deal coming?

There wasn't much new in the Daily News article yesterday,  With the Atlantic Yards project stalled, Gov. Hochul offers scant details about a path forward : “Any way that the influence of the state will result in the building of more housing, I’m all in,” Hochul said at a press conference Thursday, when asked about the status of Atlantic Yards. That could mean anything.  What next? In 2014, the state, under pressure from the coalition BrooklynSpeaks regarding a threatened fair-housing lawsuit, agreed to a new 2025 deadline for the 2,250 below-market, "affordable" units, with $2,000/month fines for each missing apartment. There are 876 left to build, and the deadline won't be met. Developer Greenland USA faces a thrice-postponed foreclosure auction of its development rights to build six towers over the Vanderbilt Yard, but a new developer must factor in the fines as well as the cost of the platform that precedes vertical construction.  From the article: “The practical ...

Looming: the May 12, 2025 deadline to start the platform. But there's an "Unavoidable Delays" escape hatch and a penalty that might not be painful.

More than a year ago, on Feb. 21, 2023, I wrote ( link ) that the May 12, 2025 deadline to start the platform  over the Vanderbilt Yard "shouldn't be too hard to meet." After all, various plans had been announced for the first platform block, between Sixth and Carlton avenues and Atlantic Avenue and Pacific Street. Filed with Department of Buildings Well, maybe it will be hard to meet, after all. The project is stalled, and it's hardly clear that developer Greenland USA is ready to move forward--as it had previously indicated--nor that any new developer yet wants to take over the six railyard development sites facing a foreclosure auction. They can't be developed without the platform. But it's unlikely anyone would bid without knowing whether they face May 2025 penalties for not delivering 876 more units of affordable housing, or what tax breaks might be available for new construction. Also, interest rates are currently high. Looking east from Sixth Avenue ne...

In latest six-month project look-ahead, developer Greenland USA is stark: the platform won't start. Previously, it had promised (or hinted at) progress.

It's not surprising, but it is stark. For the first time in three-and-a-half years, Greenland USA, the embattled master developer that for now has the rights to develop Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park, won't say it might start developing the platform--key to three and later six future towers--over the Metropolitan Transportation Authority's (MTA) Vanderbilt Yard. "There are no construction activities scheduled for the reporting period," Greenland USA executive Jen Kuang wrote regarding the platform to Empire State Development (ESD), the state authority that oversees/shepherds the project, in a Dec. 4 letter (bottom) that constitutes the required six-month look-ahead for the project in the first half of 2024.  Kuang wrote under the letterhead of under Pacific Park Development LLC. owned nearly completely by Greenland. Hence my lack of reference to Greenland Forest City Partners, as per previous practice. Kuang has never spoken at a public meeting related to Atlantic Y...

What are the six development sites worth? Huge clouds over sale, given platform & affordable housing (?) obligation. Could only first block get built?

How much are the six development sites over the Vanderilt Yard, scheduled to be sold at a foreclosure auction in January, worth? Would the holders of the debt, incurred by master developer Greenland USA (which owns nearly all of the project going forward) be paid back? And might it be worth it for a buyer to build on the first block, including only three of the development sites, between Sixth and Carlton avenues? The answers to those questions are murky, since neither the private parties involved nor the state authority overseeing the project have released any details, though I'll attempt some ballpark estimates below.  Looking west from Vanderbilt Avenue at two railyard blocks needing platform Big platform cost One obvious conclusion: the cost of the platform cuts deeply into the value of the sites, and the potential fines for affordable housing cut even further. As estimated in 2016--and costs surely have risen--the platform over the first block, in two parts (for B5, and B6/B7...

If "China's 40-Year Boom Is Over" (per WSJ), what's next for companies like Greenland facing complex calculations, and big upfront costs, in Brooklyn?

From the Wall Street Journal today, China's 40-Year Boom Is Over. What Comes Next? , with the subheading, "The economic model that took the country from poverty to great-power status seems broken, and everywhere are signs of distress." From the article: What worked when China was playing catch-up makes less sense now that the country is drowning in debt and running out of things to build. Parts of China are saddled with under-used bridges and airports. Millions of apartments are unoccupied . Returns on investment have sharply declined. Beyond the broken model, China faces "unfavorable demographics"--the impact of the one-child policy on a shrinking labor force--and some economic de-linking by former trade allies. That said, the authors cite "China's burgeoning electric-vehicle and renewable energy industries," as well as the country's capacity to focus investment on innovation. However, the "housing bubble has since popped," major dev...

Does "Atlantic Yards Deal Pave Way for Pacific Park Towers"? Not quite. Financing questions run up against 2025 deadline for affordable housing.

An overenthusiastic newsletter headline from the real-estate industry publication The Real Deal, apparently reliant on the initial version of the article (see the URL and this tweet ), claims "Atlantic Yards Deck Deal Paves Way for Pacific Park Towers."  The article is now more prudently headlined  Greenland, MTA reach deal for Atlantic Yards deck, but not 421a . Indeed, The Real Deal reported yesterday that, based on statements at the 8/2/23 meeting of the Atlantic Yards Community Development Corporation (AY CDC), Greenland USA, which owns nearly all of the Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park project going forward, has resolved differences with the Metropolitan Transportation Authority over building the first phase of the platform over the Vanderbilt Yard, which would support three towers. (A second phase would support three more towers.) Such differences were previously posited--unreliably--as the main stumbling block to building the platform over the working railyard. Financing q...

From the latest (non-) Construction Update: no new work, but work continues in open space at 595 Dean, on southeast block

The latest Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park Construction Update (bottom), covering the two weeks beginning  Monday, Aug. 7, has  not  (yet) been circulated by email, as it should have been by Empire State Development (ESD), the state authority that oversees/shepherds the project. Update : it was circulated by Monday at 9:48 am, a bit late.  But it was available Friday (lead time) at ESD's  Atlantic Yards page , as shown in the screenshot below. Perplexingly, ESD does not see fit to list previous updates.  (The document has traditionally been prepared by the master developer, long Greenland Forest City Partners, but operating as Pacific Park Development LLC.) Reason for confusion Perplexingly, after two two-week periods ( June 12 ,  June 26 ) in which ESD claimed that there were no new construction activities for the coming two weeks and thus didn't circulate a document, it has three times essentially issued a duplicate of the May 29 document, again with no ...

From the latest (non-) Construction Update: document again repeats from late May, with no new information (but still that hint about the platform).

The latest Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park Construction Update (bottom), covering the two weeks beginning yesterday, Monday, July 24, has  not  been circulated by email, as it should have been by Empire State Development (ESD), the state authority that oversees/shepherds the project. But I did notice it yesterday, after it should've been circulated, at ESD's  Atlantic Yards page . (The document has traditionally been prepared by the master developer, long Greenland Forest City Partners, but operating as Pacific Park Development LLC.) Reason for confusion Perplexingly, after two two-week periods ( June 12 ,  June 26 ) in which ESD claimed that there were no new construction activities for the coming two weeks and thus didn't circulate a document, it has twice essentially issued a duplicate of the May 29 document, again with no new activities. As with two weeks ago , while it states that there are no construction activities for the platform, long planned to be built over t...