Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts with the label megaprojects

Featured Post

Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park FAQ, timeline, and infographics (pinned post)

Revisiting the RPA's Next New York recommendations from 2012: not much improvement for Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park (third party monitor?)

Now that Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park has multiple new owners and leaseholders ( FAQ here ), and residents are trying to assess the project's progress and future, it's worth revising the May 2012 recommendations from the Regional Plan Association (RPA), in "Building the Next New York: Recommendations for Large Real Estate Projects." (The press release is here , and the report's embedded at bottom.) As I wrote at the time, "the RPA's recommendations for mega-projects implies avoidance of Atlantic Yards pattern, though the report suggests no verdict yet on project." (Former head Robert Yaro later wrote that the RPA not only saw the Atlantic Yards site as appropriate for a big project, it also recognized it couldn't  fight the mayor.) The most important recommendation, I think, was for an independent, third-party project monitor for costs and benefits. That, of course, hasn't happened. The RPA is a business-funded, mainstream group, w...

In 2012 Penn discussion of Atlantic Yards plan, some lessons for megaprojects: "be honest about phasing: nothing ever gets built at once"

Remember the 2011 documentary Battle for Brooklyn (my retrospective )? Well, there was also the 2010 “docu-musical” In the Footprint: The Battle over Atlantic Yards  by The Civilians (my review ), which also focused on the tensions behind the project, depicting polarized communities. The theatrical piece played in January 2012 at the University of Pennsylvania’s Annenberg Center for the Performing Arts. It was presaged by a community forum titled Megaprojects: Can we balance individual and social good? , featuring Penn faculty members in conversation with other plays in the real-estate world. I recently watched the video of the event, co-sponsored by the University of Pennsylvania's School of Design, and while it began awkwardly from a mistaken premise (more on that below), some panelists offered enduring, if in retrospect rueful, wisdom regarding megaprojects. So it’s worth a look back. Megaprojects: Can we balance individual and social goods? from PennDesign on Vimeo ....

The five criticisms of megaprojects: yes, some apply to AY/PP (lack of governance & public benefit)

This is the third of three posts reflecting on megaprojects and Atlantic Yards, responding to recent articles in Project Management Journal. Here are the first and the  second . In the December 2017 issue of Project Management Journal, Sydney-based researcher Mike Harris writes  Competitive Precinct Projects: The Five Consistent Criticisms of "Global" Mixed-Use Megaprojects . In attempting to classify challenges and criticisms regarding mixed-use projects on government-owned land, including Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park (one of the smallest), Harris understandably relies on secondhand and sometimes stale information, but still offers some useful food for thought. He calls them "Competitive Precinct Projects," because, beyond "their scale and mixed-use nature, they share the premise of elevating the competitive position of their metropolitan economies into regional and global economic networks." Indeed, that was a justification for Atlantic Yards/Pa...

Megaprojects pose particular challenges; Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park ticks many of those boxes (+needs better governance)

This is the second of three posts reflecting on megaprojects and Atlantic Yards, responding to recent articles. Here are the  first  and the third . In the December 2017 issue of Project Management Journal, The Past and Present of Megaprojects , Jonas Söderlund, Shankar Sankaran, and Christopher  Biesenthal explain ten factors, according to academic Bent Flyvbjerg, that make megaprojects challenging. I cite them with reflections on Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park. 1) Megaprojects are "inherently risky because of long planning horizons, nested interfaces, and complexity." Indeed, the project, circumstances, and market have changed, and institutional expertise has come and gone. 2) They are "led by planners and managers without complete understanding and domain experience."  Indeed, the government overseers have varied in expertise, while the developer has shorter-term goals. 3) It's difficult to govern across "multiple stakeholders with diverse an...

If "clear strategic vision, total alignment, and adapting to complexity" makes megaprojects succeed, how does AY do?

This is the first of three posts reflecting on megaprojects and Atlantic Yards, responding to recent articles in Project Management Journal. Here are the second  and third . In the December 2017 issue of Project Management Journal,  The Three Secrets of Megaproject Success: Clear Strategic Vision, Total Alignment, and Adapting to Complexity , by Aaron Shenhar and Vered Holzmann, has some indirect lessons for/about Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park. The summary: Past studies have often voiced concern that important megaprojects have repeatedly failed due to extensive overruns, misunderstanding of expectations, or both. In this article, we contend that this pattern may not be inevitable. In retrospect, despite painful delays, some megaprojects eventually achieved their longer-term objectives. In this study, rather than asking why megaprojects fail, we asked whether these notable (and rare) accomplishments have anything in common. We found that successful megaprojects are disting...

"Five Rules for Managing Large, Complex Projects" and some Atlantic Yards sobriety

The MITSloan Management Review brings us Five Rules for Managing Large, Complex Projects , published 8/31/17 and authored by UK- and Australia-based academics Andrew Davies, Mark Dodgson, David M. Gann, and Samuel C. MacAulay. They note that megaprojects, "defined as projects with budgets exceeding $1 billion — are important contributors to numerous sectors, including health care, defense, mining, telecommunications, transport, energy and water infrastructure, sporting events, science, and manufacturing," but "have proved notoriously difficult to deliver on time and on budget." The challenge: Why are megaprojects so difficult to manage? The reasons include technical challenges, changes in design and operational requirements, increases in costs, disputes over responsibility, and new regulations. Complexity usually increases with project scale, and complexity can give rise to uncertainty and an inability to foresee the difficulties, changing conditions, and unan...