Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts with the label foreclosure

Featured Post

Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park FAQ, timeline, and infographics (pinned post)

As foreclosure auction adjourned yet again, Greenland USA remains (zombie) developer for railyard sites

It's the foreclosure auction that never happened--apparently because it won't happen until there's a new deal in place. Wall Street Journal, Feb. 26, 2025 However, given all the moving parts on a potential deal, it won't be easy. A foreclosure auction of developer Greenland USA's rights to develop six towers (B5-B10, see below) over the Vanderbilt Yard--specifically, "membership interests in" AY Phase II Development Company--was announced Nov. 15, 2023, and then illuminated 12 days later in a bombshell Real Deal article . At that point, the foreclosure auction was announced for Jan. 11, 2024.  It's been postponed again and again. Most recently, as shown in the screenshot at right, it was postponed to March 24, 2025. Delays possible likely As I wrote  Jan. 11, 2024, the notice states the Secured Party "reserves the right to cancel the sale in its entirety, or to adjourn the sale to a future date." That's what's happened, even as a Ma...

Is oft-postponed Atlantic Yards foreclosure auction really on for Jan. 27? The pattern has been delay.

Maybe it's nothing.  After all, the announced foreclosure auction of developer Greenland USA's interest in six towers over the Vanderbilt Yard, once scheduled for Jan. 11, 2024, has been postponed so many times I've stopped tracking it. But I will point out, for the record, that the auction, with six tower sites as collateral, has recently been rescheduled for Jan. 27, 2025, according to a notice in the Wall Street Journal. Technically there are two foreclosures: one on a loan (from AYB Funding 100) which has the sites B5-B8 as collateral, and the other (from AYB Funding 200) which has the sites B9-B10 as collateral. Both funds are creations of the U.S. Immigration Fund (USIF), a "regional center" that recruits immigrant investors under the federal EB-5 program. (About $286 million has remained unpaid, from $349 million borrowed.) The USIF, as manager, controls the funds, though it didn't put the money up, and has reportedly organized a joint venture, involv...

Bad shorthand: "the lender" in EB-5 funding isn't the (middleman) regional center, but the immigrant investors. Also, Related's questionable EB-5 record.

As the foreclosure auction of rights to six Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park railyard sites remains pending, it's worth trying to untangle the parties, and to recognize that common public shorthand about "the lender" is misleading and wrong. The EB-5 Immigrant Investor Program , in which immigrants investing in a purportedly job-creating enterprise in exchange for green cards for themselves and their families, isn't like banking at all. The "lender" doesn't face the kind of regulation banks face.  It isn't even like private lending in the real-estate industry.  Rather, the "lender" regularly cited is the manager of a fund created not from his own company's assets, but from the immigrant investors. Better to call Nicholas Mastroianni II "the guy in control of the lender." Drilling down Greenland USA, initially with partner Forest City Ratner, raised $249 million and $100 million in two tranches. After a partial repayment, it owes ab...

With meeting set for first-ever Executive Session, big questions about whether Atlantic Yards CDC can impose that restriction. It doesn't transact, just advises.

It's perplexing that, for the first time ever, a meeting of the advisory Atlantic Yards Community Development Corporation (AY CDC) will consider ( link ) an important matter in Executive Session, which seems designed to exclude the public and press. That matter is described as "Platform Site Update (Oral Report)." The agenda was disclosed yesterday, less than 48 hours before the meeting and less than 24 hours before the deadline for public comment.    That refers to the six development sites over the Vanderbilt Yard and, presumably, the foreclosure of master developer Greenland USA's interest in the companies holding rights to develop them. The sites currently offer 3.5 million square feet of development rights, though Greenland has previously sought an additional 1 million square feet. Those rights were assigned as collateral for two loans from immigrant investors under the EB-5 visa program, and the failure to repay those loans has led to a foreclosure process. But...

Greenland paid the MTA for Vanderbilt Yard development rights through June 2023. Now it's a mystery. Is all stalled until Related makes its bid?

Developer Greenland USA is current on payments for Vanderbilt Yard development rights--well, sort of. Greenland, through June 2023, had paid the Metropolitan Transportation Authority cumulatively $96 million towards development rights towards six towers over the MTA's Vanderbilt Yard, with an additional $77 million due, in annual $11 million increments, by June 1, 2030. That's per a schedule outlined in 2009, when original developer Forest City Ratner renegotiated the original 2005 pledge of $100 million into $20 million for the railyard parcel needed for (part of) the arena block, and $80 million for the remainder, payable through 2030 at an implied 6.5% interest rate, which one analyst called "a real coup."  By my estimate, as explained below, the payments may have been enough to purchase the rights to build the first three towers, with the remainder should cover the final three towers.  It’s unclear whether Greenland can realize any value for that investment, giv...

Related Chief Executive Blau: talks regarding Pacific Park "have a lot of moving parts," but "could be a great opportunity."

A July 11 Wall Street Journal exclusive, Stephen Ross Is Launching His Second Act at 84: A New Florida Real-Estate Firm , describes how "Related’s founder and chairman is stepping down and taking Palm Beach properties to his new company." Related, a privately owned New York-based firm founded by Ross 52 years ago, began by building affordable housing, then took on larger projects, like Hudson Yards, built over railroad tracks on Manhattan's Far West Side. The firm, which has a whopping $60 billion worth of completed and ongoing projects, is seeking to build a casino and much more in the second half of Hudson Yards. It will be led by a triumvirate, including Chief Executive Jeff Blau. About Pacific Park The article also adds slightly to news The Real Deal broke a week earlier, about Related's interest in Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park: Related also has been trying to take advantage of the increasing distress in the commercial-property market. For example, the firm is in ...

Did the new 485-x tax break make railyard development sites more viable? Site 5, too? More sunlight needed on transactions.

The new 485-x tax break may not be as lucrative as the predecessor 421-a tax break, even if limited in the extension that could apply to the B5 tower, as I wrote earlier this week ( link ). But does 485-x now make development of the six tower sites, offering nearly 3.5 million square feet of development rights over the Vanderbilt Yard, more viable? Likely, because the certainty of a tax break--even if less lucrative than its 421-a predecessor and requiring deeper affordability--offers potential developers a way to fill in their spreadsheets.  That's surely part of why Empire State Development (ESD), the state authority that oversees/shepherds Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park last week said that a new developer for the six railyard sites, offered as collateral in a foreclosure auction, was expected to emerge.  The Real Deal since reported that The Related Companies, a major firm that developed Hudson Yards, is apparently the candidate. Of course, the cost for the "land"--the ...

TRD: Related Companies, which built Hudson Yards, said to be developer interested in Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park railyard sites

Related in talks to take over Pacific Park megaproject , the Real Deal reported last night, noting that The Related Companies, having built (the first half of) Hudson Yards, has experience decking over below-grade railyards. TRD couldn't get any more details. Related, a privately owned company, as of 2023 was the ninth-largest owner of apartments (75,023) in the country. It would presumably buy development rights--or, more precisely, the entities, in foreclosure, that can control development rights--to six towers over the Vanderbilt Yard, approved for some 3.5 million square feet of development. Questions pending What's unclear, for now, is what concessions Related would request from Empire State Development (ESD), the state authority that oversees/shepherds the project. As I wrote on Twitter/X, it shouldn't be behind closed doors. ESD said last week it was expecting a proposal from the "lender"--actually the middleman "regional center" that recruited ...

Breakthrough? ESD anticipates new developer proposed for six foreclosed railyard sites, but no details yet about who, or contours of (likely) concessions requested

This is the first of two articles about the meeting yesterday ( link ) of the advisory Atlantic Yards Community Development (AY CDC). held at offices of the parent Empire State Development (ESD) in Manhattan. The second concerns the future of Site 5. At the  little-publicized  AY CDC meeting yesterday, an executive at ESD, the state authority that oversees/shepherds Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park, offered the first hint that the six railyard development sites (B5-B10), encompassing nearly 3.5 million square feet but which are now in foreclosure, may have interest from a developer. But details were scarce, including the name of the company and whether and how much ESD would accommodate changes in project requirements to make it a deal more attractive. For example, would it  enforce or waive/delay $2,000/month fines for the 876 affordable housing units supposed to be completed by May 2025?  Also, how much would a new developer, taking over those sites from Greenland USA,...

For the fourth time, the foreclosure auction of six railyard development sites has been postponed, this time to July.

Yes, the foreclosure auction of developer Greenland USA's rights to six development sites (B5-B10) over the Metropolitan Transportation Authority's Vanderbilt Yard has been postponed, for the fourth time, this time to July.  (I didn't get a date yet, but will update when I know more.) That's according to a spokesman for the developer, which is not in charge of the auction. Rather, a representative of the lenders, controlled by the U.S. Immigration Fund--a "regional center" that recruited immigrant investors under the EB-5 program--initiated the foreclosure, announcing auction dates in January, February, April, and June.  The development rights, which encompass about 3.5 million square feet, served as collateral for the initial $249 million and $100 million loans. I had predicted that the auction would be postponed, because there's a lot of moving parts.  After a partial repayment, Greenland owes about $286 million to the investors, who invested in two tra...

Will thrice-postponed foreclosure auction proceed June 5? Seems doubtful, but who knows.

After three postponement, most recently ( link ) to June 5, will the foreclosure auction of developer Greenland USA's rights to six development sites over the Vanderbilt Yard finally proceed? Well, my query to a representative of the developer didn't get an answer yet, but the track record--as well as the complexity of finding a qualified developer and resolving aspects of the deal--suggests it's unlikely. Then again, Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park, as I've said, is a "never say never project," which means there are always twists.

Foreclosure auction of six development sites over railyard postponed for the third time, to June 5. Don't bet on it.

The foreclosure auction of developer Greenland USA's rights to six development sites over the Vanderbilt Yard, originally  announced for Jan. 11,  postponed until Feb. 12, and  then to  April 30, has been postponed again, until June 5, according to a representative of the developer. The postponement seemed inevitable once we learned, at the April 18 meeting of the Atlantic Yards Community Development Corporation, that state officials had no expectation that the foreclosure auction of would proceed, as the entity controlling the debt had not presented a potential developer to them. In 2014-15, a Greenland affiliate borrowed $249 million and then $100 million in two low-interest loans, under the EB-5 investor visa program, with $500,000 investments from Chinese nationals organized by the U.S. Immigration Fund, a "regional center" or middleman.  About $63 million of the first loan has been paid back, but the rest has languished past the due date, and a USIF enti...

At Atlantic Yards meeting, state says no expectation foreclosure auction will proceed April 30. Quorum allows AY CDC budget passage.

This is the first of two articles on the April 18 meeting of the Atlantic Yards Community Development Corporation (AY CDC), charged to advise on the project and monitor obligations. The second concerned a revised affordable housing analysis. The meeting was brief and mostly uneventful--though my update tomorrow will address the effort by Empire State Development (ESD), the state authority that oversees/shepherds the project, to update its official affordable housing chart. Notably, ESD officials said they had no expectation that the foreclosure auction of the rights to six development sites over the Vanderbilt Yard, scheduled for April 30 but already postponed twice, would proceed, as the entity controlling the debt has not presented a potential developer to them. Budget approved With a quorum, the AY CDC directors were finally able to approve--as they were precluded form doing, at their March 26 meeting--of approving the body's $250,000 budget, which is provided by the developer,...

Does ESD have discretion over a potential transfer of development rights in foreclosure? Yes, but the conditions may not be onerous.

As I've written, the foreclosure auction of developer Greenland USA's interest in six development sites over the Vanderbilt Yard has been postponed twice, most recently until April 30 . It's likely to be postponed again. After all, there are a lot of complications, including a winning bidder's obligation to comply with project requirements--or to evade them--regarding affordable housing liquidated damages, and more. That likely involves negotiation with Empire State Development (ESD), the state authority that oversee/shepherds the project. And yesterday, ESD reps said no developer has surfaced. If a bidder does emerge, it's also worth looking at the conditions imposed by ESD on such a transfer. One unit, or two? First, note that, while the six development sites might be seen as a unit, they represent two separate auctions: one for the sites B5-B8, the collateral for the $249 million "Atlantic Yards II," and another for B9-B10, the collateral for the $100 m...