Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts with the label noise

Featured Post

Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park FAQ, timeline, and infographics (pinned post)

Perspective: $3200 fine for noise violation deemed "stunning" by Times (but not to the arena)

From today's  Ask Real Estate column in the New York Times. A Pianist Silenced When I bought my apartment in 2008, the co-op board knew I was a pianist. At my interview, the board agreed that I could practice until 10 p.m. For four years, my piano playing was never a problem. But in 2012, new shareholders moved in and complained about the noise. In response, the board instituted a policy that requires me to stop practicing at 9 p.m. It also restricts shareholders from conducting business in their apartments after 5 p.m., meaning I can no longer teach private evening lessons. These changes are damaging my career as a musician and teacher. Is the board allowed to renege on a previous agreement and enforce a rule that did not exist when I bought my apartment? Harlem, Manhattan When you buy into a co-op, you agree to abide by the co-op’s proprietary lease and house rules. Most building rules allow boards to adopt or amend house rules from time to time. And all owners are bound by t...

Basketball tournament on arena plaza Saturday never announced; noise intruded on long-planned community garden event

Via  Barclays Center/Twitter The 5 am start to the mural-painting block party Saturday was only one of the Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park-related intrusions that came without appropriate notice to neighbors that day. To the surprise of many, the plaza outside the Barclays Center was turned over to a 12-hour event (including set-up): Nike's basketball Tournament of Champions, aka #ConquerAllCourts . It came with a DJ and announcer, both amplified to the point where they could be heard one long block away, at Fourth Avenue. That meant the sound was blaring on Pacific Street between Fourth and Flatbush avenues, and at the Brooklyn Bear's Garden , which just happened to have scheduled its 30-year anniversary party well before any word of the "When the [Flatbush Avenue] traffic goes, you're gardening next to a highway," observed garden coordinator Jon Crow, indicating that gardeners were no strangers to noise while still carving out an oasis. "We'v...

Does Barclays Center green roof really work to dampen noise? Noise complaints from Mötley Crüe concert

Remember, the green roof at the Barclays Center was not built to attract bees , and its environmentally friendly aspects are secondary to its "aesthetic and noise and vibration dampening benefits." According to a couple of complaints noted on Atlantic Yards Watch after a Mötley Crüe concert at the arena on Wednesday, August, 12, however, those "noise and vibration dampening benefits" may not be working so well. There are few details about the duration, extent, and location of the problem, other than the comment that "resident thought that new roof would help but it didn't." (A resident tells me the concert was audible from the Newswalk building a half-block away: "unbelievably loud.") (Update: Note that there haven't been too many noise complaints recently; whether that's due to the green roof is unclear, because there haven't been many of the type of bass-heavy concerts that provoke such complaints. I'm also told th...

Consultant says developer is "actively fulfilling" requirements regarding noise control, but neighbor says letters about air conditioners came late

At the 7/28/15 meeting of the Atlantic Yards Community Development Corporation (AY CDC), a representative of Henningson Durham and Richardson (HDR), the outside mitigation monitor for Empire State Development, the state agency overseeing/shepherding the project, reported on the developer's compliance with noise control requirements. "HDR considers the Developer to be actively fulling these mitigation requirements," declared HDR project manager Jennifer Bienemann, though one neighbor later pointed out that Greenland Forest City Partners was actually delayed in alerting neighbors. The issue remained unresolved. Project requirements Tracking the slides in the presentation above (extracted from the  board materials  posted on Monday), Bienemann explained the project's  Memorandum of Environmental Commitments  (MEC; see p. 22-23) requires double-glazed or storm windows and one air conditioner per bedroom or main living room with a window along a facade predicted to...

From the latest Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park Construction Update: more evening work "to address field conditions"; outreach regarding noise control

The latest Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park Brooklyn Construction Update, covering the two weeks beginning Monday August 3 and delivered yesterday by Empire State Development after preparation by Greenland Forest City Partners, announces that Saturday work continues at the B3 and B14 tower sites, and evening work until 9 pm weekdays continues at the latter site. The explanation is "to address field conditions," which I surmise is another way to say "to meet our schedule." The 9 pm work was announced last Monday at the very last minute. B3 is at the corner of Dean Street and Sixth Avenue, and B14 is at the corner of Dean Street and Carlton Avenue. Also notable: for the first time, as far as I know, the Construction Update explains how neighbors in a very specific radius of the site can apply for double-pane windows and/or air conditioners to block some of the noise from construction. Below are verbatim excerpts, with some commentary by me, in italics. The headin...

From the latest Construction Update: Saturday work coming; gates with acoustic blankets being added to block noise

The latest Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park Construction Update (bottom), released Thursday and covering the weeks dated July 6, 2015 and July 13, 2015, indicates that "Saturday work to address field conditions" will begin this week at two construction sites, B3 (Sixth Avenue and Dean Street), and B14 (Carlton Avenue and Dean Street). That seems to be a euphemism for "we need to work weekends to meet our schedule." That adds additional noise to the neighborhood. Also new is the replacement, at two work sites on the southeast block of the project site, of 16’ chain link gates with 8’ chain link with acoustics blanket. Given that chain link is porous regarding noise, presumably the smaller gates plus acoustic blankets will block more noise. The Construction Update, released by Empire State Development (ESD) after preparation by Greenland Forest City Partners, is an "effort to keep the Pacific Park Brooklyn Community aware of upcoming construction activities....

Lowbrow/Brilliant? New York Mag's Approval Matrix misses mark on Barclays Center green roof (which aims to block leaking bass)

Well, New York Magazine calls its Approval Matrix "Our deliberately oversimplified guide to who falls where on our taste hierarchies." It's usually quite savvy. But not always. Consider the Lowbrow/Brilliant designation for the Barclays Center's green roof. The print version is brief. The  online version  links to a 5/27/15 WABC report,  BARCLAYS CENTER INSTALLING SOUND-MUFFLING GREEN ROOF , which states: The lush greenery will absorb rainwater, and therefore put less stress on the sewer system. Then, there's the acoustic component, as the roof will absorb sound that is outside the building and muffle sounds inside the center. ...And another thing that will be fascinating to watch is how all of this will actually change to reflect the seasons. Somehow missing is the fact Barclays Center has regularly leaked bass into the surrounding neighborhoods like a giant neighborhood sub-woofer, leading to a fine . Or that the green roof promised in the early days wa...

Disruptive late night noise for residents near project last week; what about this week?

For some residents near the Vanderbilt Yard, the last couple of nights have been a welcome respite from overnight construction work over the previous week . New overnight work is planned at the intersection of Atlantic and Sixth avenues beginning Tuesday night, though it's not clear how loud it's expected to be, given that no extra steps to dampen noise have been announced, as with the work last week. Such steps only went so far. On Wednesday night, reported one resident of the Newswalk condo between Dean and Pacific streets and Carlton and Vanderbilt avenues, "a constant 'beep beep' sound that trucks make backing up" kept her family awake all night--and they don't even live on the side of the building facing the railyard and the Atlantic/Sixth work site. "When you’re lying awake at night trying to sleep any kind of intermittent, irregular noise like that will make you crazy," the resident reported. That compounds the impact from the noi...

Attention (some) project neighbors: double-paned windows and air conditioners available to dampen noise

Just three days after the question of how much Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park neighbors had been informed of the requirement that they be offered double-paned windows and air conditioners for noise attenuation, new notices were distributed yesterday. I spotted the notices yesterday posted on Dean Street properties between Carlton and Vanderbilt avenues, and on Vanderbilt Avenue between Dean and Pacific street. (A residents adds that they were also placed on Dean Street between Sixth and Carlton Avenue, in part, and on Vanderbilt from Dean to Bergen, in part, and on Carlton Avenue from Dean to Bergen, in part. They were not visible on Carlton Avenue from Pacific to Dean, right opposite the project site.. That's a prime area, so it's possible the neighbors were informed already, or via other means.) Updating the list The issue came up May 19 at the meeting of the Atlantic Yards Community Development Corporation (AY CDC)n, where directors were told by Forest City Ra...

Atlantic Avenue crane for arena green roof will block traffic for three times longer than initially projected

The Barclays Center green roof is certainly showing progress, as sedum is being laid on the new metal structure (see photo at left from yesterday, via Atlantic Yards web cam ). But the process is in some ways more delayed than ever. Notably, the crane flanking the arena on Atlantic Avenue, which was only supposed to block traffic on that boulevard for three months--from August through October 2014--instead is expected to last some ten months.  It was  installed in late October last year and, we learned last night, is expected to persist through August of this year. After Forest City Ratner Chief of Staff Ashley Cotton revealed that timetable at a Community Update meeting last night, I asked why the crane will have taken so long. "I don't know" was the response.  No one from Empire State Development, the state agency overseeing/shepherding the project, or the subsidiary Atlantic Yards Community Development Corporation, aimed to provide some input i...

Will there be accountability? Waiting for new AYCDC, as project leads to narrowed streets, idling trucks, concert noise, delayed fire trucks

Narrowed Dean Street leads to congestion The Atlantic Yards Community Development Corporation, promised to be active this month, now has its first meeting delayed until January 30. It was supposed to enhance oversight, even if it it has just an advisory role, but the delay suggests construction trumps accountability. Its members should be consulting--and enhancing-- Atlantic Yards Watch, where neighbors post incident reports. Here's a round-up of some recent ones. A delay for fire trucks This  report , regarding a mid-afternoon incident on 12/8/14, describes how congestion on Dean Street, compounded by the closure of Sixth Avenue between Bergen and Dean Streets, stalled a fire truck in Dean Street traffic for more than two minutes. In recognition of the fire truck's siren and honking, several drivers on Dean--already narrowed for construction on adjacent Block 1129, with the sidewalk constrained by construction on part of the south side--pulled their cars up on ...

Construction noise and the prospect of quieter electric jackhammers

The New York Times yesterday had an intriguing article,  With Electric Jackhammers, Plans to Quiet an Earsplitting City Sound : While most contractors still rely on the clangorous pneumatic drills driven by compressed air that were invented over 150 years ago, some are experimenting with new electric jackhammers that are demonstrably quieter. City officials are close to embracing regulations that would encourage contractors and construction crews to switch to the quieter models — at least at night. “It’s a result of an outcry from the public,” said Alyssa Preston , deputy director of air and noise policies for the Department of Environmental Protection’s Bureau of Environmental Compliance . While experts say it makes a difference--and reduce the "noise trauma" to workers and residents--the General Contractors Association of New York says the quieter jackhammer can't break the densest concrete and would slow construction. The Second Amended Memorandum of Environmental...

Halloween dance music event moved from Barclays Center, averts bass leakage to neighbors

An electronic dance music show (EDM), BOO!, scheduled for the Barclays Center on Halloween night, Friday, has been moved by the promoters to Pier 94 in Manhattan, with less than a week before the debut. All tickets for the "massively spooktacular night"  will be honored at the new venue, where the planned lineup will be combined with other acts,  or can be refunded. No explanation has been offered, but some commenters on promoter Insomniac' Facebook page concluded the promoter was combining two events because not enough tickets were sold. Others noted the Barclays Center tickets were far more expensive than the Pier 94 tickets. Averts bass leakage Given that Halloween Massive was advertised as "a twisted Halloween party [with] bone-rattling beats," the event, like Sensation and Swedish House Mafia, is of the ilk that has caused the most problems in leaking bass into neighborhood residences. That was supposed to be addressed first by a...

From the latest (on time) Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park Construction Update: overnight work on Atlantic Avenue starts Wednesday

After releasing the previous two-week Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park Construction Update  more than two business days late , on 9/4/14, Forest City Ratner and Empire State Development did much better this week, releasing the latest alert, dated today, at 9:36 am. The document reveals that on or about Wednesday night, September 17, 2014, "the contractor will work to extend the exploratory work for the LIRR tunnel wall across the intersection of 6th Avenue." "A trench along the LIRR tunnel wall will be excavated and then plated over to maintain traffic over 6th Avenue," the document states. The work will take place over two to three nights form 10 pm to 6 am. How much noise and who monitors it? No mention is made regarding the steps taken to limit the noise. The Second Amended Memorandum of Environmental Commitments  (MEC), signed this June, documents the developer's commitment to meeting noise levels set forth in the city's Noise Control Code or even low...

In Wall Street Journal, Forest City spins arena's new green roof, claims noise complaints didn't play a role

Rendering by SHoP, provided to Wall Street Journal So the Wall Street Journal catches up with the plans for the arena green roof, and Forest City mostly gets to spin it their way, complete with a first look at a new rendering. A Roof Grows on Barclays: Brooklyn Arena Is Getting Dome Coated With Vegetation  begins: Brooklyn's Barclays Center is slated to get a lot greener on the outside and possibly become a quieter neighbor in the process. Barclays developer Forest City Ratner Cos. is planning to coat the arena's giant dome with a 130,000-square-foot "green roof" composed of small plants and a soil-like cover, resurrecting an idea that was cut years ago in an effort to contain costs. ..."We wanted to do the amenity for the benefits to the community and the residents that this green roof will bring, rather than having that traditional arena roof," said Linda Chiarelli, an executive vice president at Forest City. For the "community"? Nah....

Daily News salutes Barclays Center's new acoustics, downplays bass leakage, doesn't mention coming green roof

Isn't that special. The Daily News music critic, Jim Farber, has an article headlined Updated acoustics enhance sound at Barclays Center , subtitled "When Barclays opened in Brooklyn in September 2012 with a string of Jay Z shows, fans in the top tiers complained about distortion of the bass. Barclays responded by hiring a company to update the space and tweak the acoustics, and musicians and audiences have noticed the difference." I don't recall that he or any other critic reported about that distortion. But the article is essentially a salute to the arena's effort to be state-of-the-art, becoming the first arena in North America to use "audio techniques pioneered in Europe," beginning " to update the space and tweak the sound." The article states: It hinged on the installation of 1,800 panels, covering 15,000 square feet of the venue’s ceiling. “We added studio-grade, low-frequency sound-absorbing bass traps in a slightly thinner wedge...

Atlantic Yards paradox, Part 2: the footprint area doesn't count for "neighborhood character," but it sure did for blight

Yesterday I wrote Atlantic Yards paradox, Part 1 , observing that Empire State Development's dismissal of a multi-developer alternative to build Atlantic Yards was indeed plausible, but only because the state agency changed the rules, extending Forest City Ratner's deadline from ten to 25 years but leaving a complex series of transactions in place that would be extremely difficult to unwind. Another paradox shines through the court-ordered Draft Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS) issued last Friday, which evaluates the community impacts of a potential 25-year buildout for Phase 2 (11 towers east of Sixth Avenue) and concludes there are relatively few, and most of them can be mitigated. As in the Final EIS issued in 2006, the Draft SEIS concludes that the blocks around the Atlantic Yards site would experience "significant adverse localized neighborhood character impacts." Now they could extend 18 years rather than six years. But such "local...