Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts with the label Community Boards

Featured Post

Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park FAQ, timeline, and infographics (pinned post)

In Times coverage, Forest City claims neutrality regarding which Community Board oversees Atlantic Yards. But I don't think they want CB 8.

Yet another new Brooklyn reporter for the New York Times, Vivian Yee, gets a crack at Atlantic Yards coverage, and her first effort,  A Community Tug of War in Brooklyn , about the efforts to resolve the Atlantic Yards split among three community boards, isn't bad. But it does contain a couple of glaring errors that remind us why it's so important to have continuity among reporters or editors regarding this project. And though it doesn't really say so, the article leaves clues regarding why Forest City Ratner, though ostensibly neutral, might prefer Community Board 2 takeover of the project site, and reminds us to think about some history that I and others haven't recently ventilated. And that history supports an increased role for Community Board 8, as it seeks. Uniform take? The article states: For the members of these community boards, the issue has a personal resonance. Though many of them spent nearly a decade battling to keep Atlantic Yards from rising in ...

Community Board 2, despite warning about need for consensus, votes that district lines be revised to encompass all of Atlantic Yards

Update: see response from Community Board 8. Despite a warning from District Manager Robert Perris about the need for consensus with adjacent Community Boards 6 and 8, Community Board 2 last night voted 22-7, with 2 abstentions, to support a change in community district boundaries so that all of Atlantic Yards is placed in CB 2. CD 2 at top. CD 6 at left, CD 8 lower right. Inset east of 6th Ave. below arena drawn to put 78th Precinct in CB 6 If successful, that would likely extend the border from the current southern terminus, Pacific Street (in the middle of the Atlantic Yards site), to Dean Street. It also portends potential conflict. "I have friends on Community Board 6," said board member Kenn Lowy. "I know they're upset [about the potential for one board to encompass the entire project], for the same reasons we would be." "I think that we all know that anybody across the street from Atlantic Yards would be severely impacted [by the projec...

Common Cause, Citizens Union call for Borough Presidents to follow Stringer's reforms in selecting Community Board members; Markowitz's AY purge cited

Last Monday, 3/3/14, the City Council Committee on Governmental Operations held a hearing on the makeup of community boards, and good government groups weighed in with reformist recommendations. One suggested that an Atlantic Yards episode should be spur to reforms. Brian Paul, the Research and Policy Manager for Common Cause/New York recommended  best Practices  and included a history lesson: New York's community boards originated in the 1950's as "community planning boards." They were institutionalized in the 1963 charter revision with the intent to increase the role for local communities in the planning process. Their creation was in large part a reaction to the overreaches of urban planning "czar" Robert Moses, who from the 1930's to the 1960's oversaw numerous highway, park, and urban renewal construction plans that often ran roughshod over local neighborhoods. In 1968, Mayor John Lindsay led the passage of Local Law 39 which expanded the fu...

Panel discusses CBA reforms; in successful West Coast CBAs, signatories don't take developer cash; developer pays upfront for affordable housing

Even if experts disagree on some aspects of reforming Community Benefits Agreements (CBAs) in New York City, they pretty much agree on several factors that, in their absence, detract from the legitimacy of the Atlantic Yards CBA: signatories shouldn't take money from the developer the city's Uniform Land Use Review Procedure (ULURP) shouldn't be circumvented the CBA should have real teeth in it The panel discussion last night at the Bar Association of the City of New York was titled Community Benefits Agreements: Time for Reform? (Audio is here . Also see Michael D.D. White's take in his Noticing New York blog , which fills in some gaps below.) Beyond debate about whether the city should establish rules on CBAs--a recommendation in a Bar Association report (below) issued in March --panelists also agreed that policies on issues like local hiring and living wages should be institutionalized citywide rather than subject to project-by-project negotiations. The presence of ...

In Times, City Bar task force members warn against CBA abuses; Atlantic Yards examples are actually more egregious

A New York Times Real Estate page (Square Feet) article today headlined Community Pacts Questioned in the Zoning Process takes off from the critical report on Community Benefits Agreements (CBA) issued last month ( my coverage) . Notably, while the article makes but a glancing reference to Atlantic Yards, the abuses referenced all relate to projects that go before the City Council; Atlantic Yards didn't even face that level of oversight, given that it was shepherded by the unelected Empire State Development Corporation, ignoring the role of both the local Community Boards and the local Council Member. Moreover, the report contains what might be considered struck me as a slap at ACORN, given that one influential lawyer warns against a Council Member designating which affordable housing group should be selected. ( Update May 19 : That lawyer, Kenneth Fisher, says he was not speaking about ACORN.) In the case of Atlantic Yards, there was not even that minimal level of local involve...

Divided on development and AY, Marty Markowitz and Kevin Powell talk past each other in the Dreamland Pavilion

At the Dreamland Pavilion: Brooklyn and Development Conference held this weekend at Kingsborough Community College, Atlantic Yards was not only the theme of one panel but the central--yet divergent--example for the two main speakers at the inaugural dinner. Brooklyn Borough President Marty Markowitz, a longtime Atlantic Yards booster, maintained his support for the project, while writer and activist (and periodic political candidate) Kevin Powell offered a more critical take on AY and the process of development. Beyond greetings Markowitz, stopping in to offer ceremonial Opening Comments, spent nearly 20 minutes at the microphone, offering some entertaining anecdotes--joshing, for example, about how Brooklyn is an "inner borough" because you must exit through another borough to leave the city--but getting serious when it came to AY. "If there's anything that I've learned after eight years, it's that there's nothing more contentious than issues of devel...

The big news was the informational meeting, but the media mostly missed it

While the official required Atlantic Yards public hearing takes place over two days, Wednesday and Thursday, that, I think, will be something of a sideshow, an opportunity for both opponents and proponents to face off and to posture--though some substantive criticism surely will be lodged. The bigger news, I believe, already happened on Wednesday at the informational meeting before three Community Boards, given the unprecedented presence of both Empire State Development and Forest City Ratner representatives and their responses--both answers and evasions--to tough questions. And it got relatively little press coverage. None of the three dailies sent a reporter, nor did any TV stations, including NY 1 or local Brooklyn cable. Focus on conflict Beyond AYR, which referred in the headline to both disruption and tough questions, two reports chose the conflict as the main frame. Both the Brooklyn Paper and New York Times blog The Local produced reports with a reasonable amount of range, b...

Updates re Wednesday's meeting: the evasion of public responsibility, the orchestrated disruption, and more

I've updated and reorganized somewhat my post yesterday about the three-hour Atlantic Yards informational meeting held by Community Boards 2, 6, and 8. Most importantly, a look back shows clearly how the public, which is supposed to comment next Wednesday and Thursday at the official public hearing, is not provided with essential information and will not get it during the comment period that ends at the end of August. Notably, we weren't told--and won't be told--the total amount of subsidies required. We were told that the Empire State Development Corporation "constantly" updates its cost-benefit analysis--actually just an analysis of new revenue, without accounting for full costs--but that the analysis was not included in the 2009 Modified General Project Plan (GPP) issued last month. We were told that new numbers may be provided to the ESDC board when it votes to approve the project in September. Whether or not that analysis emerges, if it updates the previous ...

Mayor to Community Boards: drop dead (or, at least, wither away)

The city’s 59 Community Boards, according to the mayor’s office, “have an important advisory role in dealing with land use and zoning matters, the City budget, municipal service delivery, and many other matters relating to their communities' welfare.” They represent, on average, nearly 140,000 people each, a population larger than cities like New Haven, CT; Trenton, NJ; and Albany, NY. And while they obviously don’t run city agencies, they could try to fulfill their role--if they had the money. But Community Board budgets  average around $220,000 , and Mayor Mike Bloomberg’s budget proposes that those budgets go down 5%, not up.  Yes, the city budget is under stress, but, as Manhattan CB 7 Chair Helen Rosenthal notes in this March 16  Gotham Gazette commentary , the entire community board budget is some $15 million--essentially a rounding error in a $60 billion budget. (Actually, the budget this year looks like it'll be under $14 million. See p. 55 of this PDF budget document ...

Mayor's Office: maybe two new schools if AY is built, no to a new 78th Precinct stationhouse

The Mayor’s Office of Management and Budget, in budget documents ( PDF ) released Friday, revealed a couple of Capital Budget Priorities and Requests related to Atlantic Yards. In neither case does the city appear willing to commit more resources, stating that it would try to build more schools, should AY be built, with existing funds, and would not try to construct a new 78th Precinct stationhouse, despite the impact of an arena that would be built a block away. In the map, the arena would be the larger circle, while the stationhouse is the smaller circle. Note that, while it looks like the 78th Precinct stationhouse is located in the 77th Precinct, according to this map adapted from the Empire State Development Corporation's Blight Study , there's actually a carve-out for the stationhouse to keep it in the 78th. But the map (click to enlarge) clearly shows how the stationhouse is at the end of the district it serves. Each district has several sectors. From Community Board 6 R...

Markowitz on the relationship with donor FCR: "I don't see the slightest conflict"

As I wrote Tuesday , in his now-traditional end-of-the-year interview with the Brooklyn Paper's Gersh Kuntzman, Brooklyn Borough President Marty Markowitz curiously claimed there were chances for compromise in the Atlantic Yards design and asserted that a basketball arena would be a corporate magnet. A significant segment of the interview concerned Markowitz's frustration with the mayoral administration's apparent effort to squeeze his office and those of other borough presidents. Markowitz made a reasonable argument that the borough presidency exists to advocate for the borough in a way that other elected officials cannot, and that more local knowledge and contacts makes government more accessible. The argument for a redefined and clarified role for the BPs deserves discussion. (He wasn't asked how he uses governmental funds, as in the Brooklyn!! promotional publication , to further his re-election, but that's another story.) The effect of budget cuts, Markowitz c...