Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts with the label housing

Featured Post

Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park FAQ, timeline, and infographics (pinned post)

To meet city housing goals, do we simply have to build bigger? What about infrastructure (and the region)?

At a press conference last week organized by BrooklynSpeaks, as I wrote ( link ), Assemblymember Jo Anne Simon pointed to the state's failure to collect damages for unbuilt affordable housing "We want this housing," she said. "We want it built now. It was a public benefit that was promised to everybody and whether you like the project or not, whether you wanted it here, there or whatever, this is a public benefit that was promised to the people of New York and it has not been delivered on." She's right that, the longer the wait, the longer it takes to serve people vulnerable to displacement. Not so fast As I wrote, that statement deserves a "Yes, but." If the only way to get that housing is to build at Site 5 , catercorner to the arena, at unprecedented density, then, no, not everyone wants the housing. (Quick, who said of Atlantic Yards, exaggerating the numbers, "If it’s built the way it was approved, we’re going to end up with 16 60-story b...

"Affordable" rents rise with 2025 Area Median Income, so a 1-bedroom at 60% of AMI could now rent for $1,822. That may not be realistic. But ceiling will rise.

Sometime in the last week, the updated 2025 New York City Area Affordable Monthly Rents surfaced on the website  of the city Department of Housing Preservation and Development (HPD), with an increase of about 4.3% over 2024 figures, correlating with the rise in Area Median Income, or AMI. See more on this below (I wrote about the rise in AMI April 28.) Bottom line: for low-income units at 60% of AMI, which is the average affordable unit required under the 485-x tax break (likely for the next Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park towers) and under Mandatory Inclusionary Housing Option 1 in the recently-passed Atlantic Avenue Mixed-Use Plan (AAMUP), the 2025 maximum rents would be: studio: $1,701, up from $1,640 1-BR: $1,822, up from $1,747 2-BR: $2,187, up from $2,097 3-BR: $2,527, up from $2,422 HPD notes that those are the maximum rents, while specific rent amounts may vary by program. So it's likely those rent ceilings may not correlate to most or all of the units rented this year at 60...

As legislature faces April 1 budget deadline, approval of a successor to 421-a tax break could nudge the future of Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park

For various reasons, it's not surprising that the foreclosure auction of six Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park development sites has been postponed twice, most recently to April 30 . The most obvious reason is the complexity of a future deal, since the development rights are attached to obligations to build a costly platform as well as obligations to build affordable housing, which come with liquidated damages for units not built by May 2025. That means the parties include not just the debt holders, funds formed with money from EB-5 investor visa borrowers, and future bidders, but also Empire State Development (ESD), the state authority that oversees/shepherds the project and could clarify/renegotiate/subsidize the obligations.  Of course, the gubernatorially-controlled ESD shouldn't do that without input from elected officials and the public. The 421-a quandary But there's another issue. By April 1, the state budget is due, and should include new policies to support housing cons...

In a New York Times package regarding places to build more housing, curious treatment of Atlantic Yards, as some sites ignored.

There's something curious in  How to Make Room for One Million New Yorkers , a New York Times guest essay yesterday (so far, online only) by Vishaan Chakrabarti, founder of NYC-based Practice for Architecture and Urbanism, and the NYC Department of City Planning's former director of planning for Manhattan. To accommodate those needing housing, Chakrabarti dismisses arguments for rent regulation and banning pieds-à-terre and converting vacant office towers as inadequate solutions He contends the city could in fact build 500,000 housing units—Mayor Eric Adams' “moonshot goal”--and at the scale of their neighbors. His team focused on areas within a half-mile of train stations and ferry terminals and excluded zones at risk of flooding--so, nope, Red Hook--and identified more than 1,700 acres of underutilized land, including "vacant lots, single-story retail buildings, parking lots and office buildings that could be converted to apartments." Screenshot from New York Ti...

In plan for Brooklyn, Borough President Reynoso will advocate for more housing, especially near transit and in the borough's southern and eastern sections.

I wrote recently about the illuminating graphics found in  The Comprensive Plan for Brooklyn: A Vision for a Healthier, More Equitable Borough (also bottom), released by Brooklyn Borough President Antonio Reynoso.  One key bottom line is that he will push for more housing where it has lagged. Now let's take a closer look. According to the report: Our comprehensive plan is many things at once: 1) It is a vision of a Brooklyn for all. 2) It is a recognition that the well-being of a neighborhood and of our borough is dictated by how we use our land, allocate our funding, and administer our programs. 3) It’s a tool with which we can measure the merits of a proposal, advocate for community needs, and push for changes to our neighborhoods that make sense. 4) It is an information and data resource that can be useful to anyone and everyone. 5) And, critically, it is a space where dialogue can coalesce and a comprehensive plan for our entire city can grow. He acknowledged he can...

With Hochul's housing plan scuttled, no lifeline for 421-a sites like B5 (700 Atlantic), the delayed first tower proposed for the railyard

The failure of Gov. Kathy Hochul's ambitious housing plan has big-picture implications--today's New York Times front-page article was headlined New York Officials Failed to Address the Housing Crisis. Now What? --but for Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park watchers, one provision is probably the most important. The governor had proposed to extend for four years the deadline to complete projects using the 421-a tax break--which had to start by June 15, 2022 and be finished in 2026--but that, as well as other elements of her proposed Housing Compact--didn't pass. Nor was 421-a renewed. B5, center-left, plus (built) B4. Dattner Architects So June 15, 2026, the deadline for construction under the recently expired 421-a tax break, looks ever more challenging--though theoretically possible--for the first tower slated for the Vanderbilt Yard, B5, or 700 Atlantic Avenue. The site supposedly had sufficient footings to qualify as having started under 421-a's loose requirements. After al...

Adams proposes process changes to enable 50,000 more homes over 10 years. Announced 500,000 "moonshot" would require far more.

The headline on the city press release yesterday was Mayor Adams Unveils "Get Stuff Built," Bold Three-Pronged Strategy to Tackle Affordable Housing Crisis, Sets "Moonshot" Goal of 500,000 new Homes . Actually, the 111 bureaucratic changes announced yesterday, from the Building and Land use Approval Streamlining Taskforce (BLAST), are aimed at speeding processes to unlock 50,000 more homes (as indicated in Politico's preview ). That's a big difference--though, as noted below, a good number of press outlets bought the hype. From Mayoral press release Most of the proposed changes can be completed without any legislative approval, but with some not insignificant hurdles, like hiring more people. To get to 500,000 homes would require a lot more, including rezonings and other legislative changes, likely including some revamp of the state's 421-a tax break, which expired in June and has not been renewed. A development-friendly analyst (and former Department of...