Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts with the label Herbert Muschamp

Featured Post

Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park FAQ, timeline, and infographics (pinned post)

Critic suggests Atlantic Yards "needed a Jane Jacobs to stop it;" I suggest that a failure of eloquence was by no means the largest failure

Updated with comments from Daniel Goldstein Architecture critic Alexandra Lange, who wrote a devastating takedown of Nicolai Ouroussoff, talked about her new book Writing About Architecture  with Project for Public Spaces. An excerpt from the discussion : In the last chapter of my book I discuss Jane Jacobs, and how she might have reacted to the Atlantic Yards project. I think it needed a Jane Jacobs to stop it — an advocate as eloquent about the costs, and the alternatives, as those seductive Gehry renderings — and for whatever reason, one did not appear. But the activist spirit was by no means dead. It just got diffused into activist non-profits and activist blogs and activist essays. The diffused media landscape made it easier to follow the saga week by week, but perhaps made it harder for any one person to become the voice. My comments: I question whether a Jane Jacobs was possible for Atlantic Yards. She would have needed a big media megaphone, and they were not ...

The "sheen of cultural legitimacy" Gehry provided, confounding one critic from afar

In the Los Angeles Times, Notes on a Year: Christopher Hawthorne on architecture begins: If you were looking for symbolic bookends to the year in architecture, you could do worse than to start with the January opening of Dubai's Burj Khalifa skyscraper and finish with the recent run of "In the Footprint: The Battle Over Atlantic Yards," a musical-theater production about controversial plans to build a mammoth Frank Gehry-designed development in Brooklyn. Critic Hawthorne didn't actually see the show, but read the script: After the credit crunch hit the project was significantly downsized and Gehry was fired by Ratner; the only portion going forward is an arena designed by a young New York firm called SHoP. The Civilians' treatment of the story does the work of cultural historians with unexpected flair and an effectively light touch, as when one resident says of the SHoP design, which to put it kindly was produced rather hurriedly, "Some people think i...

A collection of writings from Times architecture critic Muschamp omits his Atlantic Yards embarassment

The new collection Hearts of the City: The Selected Writings of Herbert Muschamp memorializes the late New York Times architecture critic (who died in 2007 ) in 912 pages. Guess what: his error-filled, cheerleading 12/11/03 appraisal of Atlantic Yards, headlined Courtside Seats to an Urban Garden , is not included. Credit the book's editors, perhaps, for spotting a dud and maintaining a compendium of Muschamp's best work. Even in a book this size, they had to prune a good deal. The Gehry connection Still, it would have been worth including the Atlantic Yards piece, albeit with some asterisks, given Muschamp's enthusiasm for Atlantic Yards architect Frank Gehry. After all, as current Times critic Nicolai Ouroussoff writes in his introduction: It was Frank Gehry's work, however, that brought out Muschamp's most rapturous writing. Muschamp sometimes referred to Gehry as a father figure, and he saw him as the standard bearer of an American, democratic archit...

Rereading Muschamp on AY and Gehry: the "Garden of Eden" wilts

This is the first part of a two-part look at the appraisals by New York Times architecture critics of Frank Gehry's evolving Atlantic Yards design, and also at some of their other Gehry coverage. Architecture may be "the only art form we still battle over," according to the 5/21/06 New York Times Magazine , but there's been little sign of battle in the appraisals of the Atlantic Yards plan by the Times's two architecture critics. Both Herbert Muschamp (right) and his successor Nicolai Ouroussoff have enthusiastically, even rapturously, endorsed Frank Gehry's design, meanwhile making fundamental errors in describing the site, failing to add important context about scale and density , and failing--completely in Muschamp's case--to acknowledge Forest City Ratner's poor architectural track record in Brooklyn. Heralding the project's announcement Muschamp's 12/11/03 essay, headlined Courtside Seats to an Urban Garden , undoubtedly gave the proje...