Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts with the label superblocks

Featured Post

Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park FAQ, timeline, and infographics (pinned post)

Our Cities Ourselves: 10 Principles for Transport in Urban Life (and the AY contradiction)

A nifty exhibition, Our Cities Ourselves , is on view until September 11, 2010 at the Center for Architecture in Greenwich Village (Mon-Fri: 9am to 8pm; Sat: 11am to 5pm). It shows ten architects' treatment of potential changes in ten world cities--nearly all in developing nations. Accompanying the exhibition is a publication titled "Our Cities Ourselves: 10 Principles for Transport in Urban Life," written by internationally famous Danish urbanist Jan Gehl and Walter Hook, Executive Director of the Institute of Transportation and Development Policy (ITDP). "Cities of the twenty-first century should be lively cities, safe cities, sustainable cities and healthy cities," said Gehl in a news release. "All of these qualities can be achieved if we embrace these ten principles, which means putting people first." The principles and Atlantic Yards Notably, two of the ten principles of sustainable transport don't quite work when it comes to Atlantic Yards....

Learning from Rockefeller Center: building during a downturn, the role of p.r., and the difficulty of effective urbanism

The late New York Times architecture critic Herbert Muschamp, in an unaccountably gushing 12/11/03 essay headlined Courtside Seats to an Urban Garden , heralded the just-announced Atlantic Yards project as "A Garden of Eden grows in Brooklyn." He later offered another superlative: Those who have been wondering whether it will ever be possible to create another Rockefeller Center can stop waiting for the answer. Here it is. Well, aside from the unending delays in the project, another Rockefeller Center ? As I've pointed out , the Atlantic Yards plan demaps city streets and creates a superblock, while Rockefeller Center (right) actually added a street, creating more liveliness for pedestrians. Muschamp, shamelessly, had it backwards. What Muschamp didn't say--and I didn't know until recently--is that Rockefeller Center occupies 22 acres , the size of the current Atlantic Yards footprint (announced at 21 acres). Rock Center has 19 commercial buildings; Atlantic Yards...

"New Improved Brooklyn" revisited more than 4.5 years later (with a hint about an architect helping Gehry)

Let's flash back to Alexandra Lange's 4/26/04 article in New York Magazine, headlined New Improved Brooklyn , subtitled "A glittering skyline, waterfront condos, new jobs, Frank Gehry buildings galore: Brooklyn is on the verge of a makeover even more extreme than you thought, re-creating itself in Manhattan’s image. What’s wrong with this picture?" It's a fascinating look back, given the promises unfulfilled, and it even contains a hint that Forest City Ratner, despite public orders to the contrary, once planned to have Hugh Hardy, the architect of the developer's Atlantic Terminal mall and Court Street cinema complex, collaborate with Frank Gehry on Atlantic Yards. The big rezonings Lange wrote about Department of City Planning director Amanda Burden's plans to rezone Downtown Brooklyn and the Williamburg-Greenpoint waterfront: Burden’s plans, enabled by two lengthy rezoning proposals, could add more than fifteen new towers, 4.5 million square feet of off...

Confidential but not at all correct: the latest AY footprint ownership map

Two years after the Empire State Development Corporation (ESDC) produced a deceptive map regarding the ownership and control of property within the Atlantic Yards footprint, developer Forest City Ratner (I believe) has produced an updated version of the map that maintains the deceptions and adds some more. Most notably, the developer's foothold has actually grown more tenuous, since FCR two years ago claimed it owned or controlled 90 percent of the land needed for the project, but the map now claims 86 percent, based spuriously on "recent acquisitions." It also omits the public streets that would be demapped for the project. The new map The following map, dated August 2008 and titled Brooklyn Arena and Atlantic Yards Block and Lot Map , was passed on by a reader. While I can't be certain of its provenance, the statement "All information is to the best of FCRC's knowledge" strongly suggests that the document was provided by the developer, or at least bas...

NYC's chief urban designer salutes continuity and vitality of streets (and what about AY?)

The Director of Urban Design for the Department of City Planning, Alexandros Washburn, only joined the administration in January 2007 , so he's presumably had little contact with the Atlantic Yards project, which got its final state approval a month earlier. (The City Planning Commission in September 2006 had endorsed the project, with minor changes.) Still, it was remarkable how, in a recent discussion of the city's planning practices, he saluted the High Line project, which began with public infrastructure, not a private developer, involved multiple developers, and emphasized streets rather than demapped them. The contrast with Atlantic Yards is stark. Washburn, who's had a distinguished career that included serving as the only staff architect ever working for a U.S. Senator (Daniel Patrick Moynihan), spoke October 18 at the Vertical Density Symposium sponsored by the Skyscraper Museum in conjunction with its Vertical Cities: Hong Kong | New York exhibition. (I'l...

Building a better superblock: FEIS defends AY

Several commenters on the Draft Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) criticized the plan to close public streets, including Fifth Avenue and Pacific Street, to create “superblocks.” They cited the poor record of superblocks in other projects, such as Stuyvesant Town. This generated a lengthy response in the Final EIS, which suggested that demapping streets was needed for the creation of open space and wastewater treatment. Curiously, the Empire State Development Corporation suggested that Fifth Avenue between Flatbush and Atlantic avenues "is not an important connector between neighborhoods," which might be challenged by anyone watching traffic to the nearby Atlantic Center mall. Stuyvesant Town, the ESDC points out, isn't the best comparison, because the AY project would do more to have buildings form a streetwall. The response: As discussed in Chapter 8, “Urban Design and Visual Resources,” streets would be closed and blocks would be joined to create the arena block (t...

The superblock that dares not speak its name

It's a word that Forest City Ratner and architect Frank Gehry dare not speak: superblock . Nobody loves a superblock. The discredited feature of 1960s mega-designs, according to the Getty Art & Architecture Thesaurus , "designates very large, usually residential, city blocks often formed by consolidating several smaller blocks and often barred to through traffic and crossed by pedestrian walks." (Overlay site plan from Develop Don't Destroy Brooklyn .) And that's what would happen in the eastern section of the proposed Atlantic Yards project: Pacific Street would be demapped . (See graphic below.) That allows Forest City Ratner, already facing the challenge of much too little open space for the expected population, to gain some three acres of the proposed seven acres for privately-run parks. The superblock also would allow the developer to claim a lesser Floor Area Ratio (FAR) than a project that didn't absorb the street. Note that Pacific Street and Fi...