Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts with the label 840 Atlantic

Featured Post

Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park FAQ, timeline, and infographics (pinned post)

As case regarding McDonald's and its landlord at 840 Atlantic (at Vanderbilt) moves closer to trial, pre-trial rulings lean toward tenant.

About a year ago, I provided an update ( link ) on the long-running lawsuit by McDonald's, tenant of a drive-through restaurant at the corner of Vanderbilt and Atlantic avenues, against its landlord Vanderbilt Atlantic Holdings (VAH), which would build an 18-story residential tower at the site--if it could get its tenant out. U.S. District Court Dora Irizarry denied VAH's motion to dismiss and motion for summary judgment, pointing toward a bench trial on whether each party failed to act in good faith in the fair market value appraisal process. More recently, the judge handed McDonald's another procedural victory. In a pre-trial ruling Sept. 30, the court denied the landlord's motion to preclude testimony and documentary evidence related to appraisals conducted prior to April 15, 2019, which is when McDonald's told VAH they couldn't agree on the fair market value.  The court. which earlier cited "credibility concerns" regarding the landlord's condu...

While long-running lawsuit versus landlord (and developer) percolates, McDonald's at corner of Vanderbilt & Atlantic invests $60K on interior renovation.

While Yelp ( link ) reports the drive-through McDonald's at Vanderbilt Avenue and Atlantic Avenue as closed, and Google ( link ) no longer says "temporarily closed," the fast-food restaurant has reopened. It was closed for an interior renovation, estimated to cost $60,000, to "relocate/install new front counter registers, kiosks, partitions, menu boards, and related finishes," according to Department of Buildings records. There's a clear emphasis on self-service, as shown in the photo at right, and at bottom.  Long-running lawsuit The investment, though it's likely to be recouped in the short term, is a sign that the federal lawsuit McDonald's filed in 2019 against its landlord, Vanderbilt Atlantic Holdings, isn't close to being settled.  As I wrote last October, the landlord's request for summary judgment--a full decision in their favor without a trial--on its claim that McDonald's failed to follow contractual rules for setting a new re...

Lawyers for developer at McDonald's site say they've been stiffed $176K, seek to withdraw from legal battle.

In another twist in the long-running battle between the landlord/developer of a site at Vanderbilt and Atlantic avenues and McDonald's, the tenant of the main parcel, the developer's lawyer has filed a request to withdraw as counsel, claiming Vanderbilt Atlantic Holdings (VAH) owes his firm  $176,139.58 and their relationship "has irrevocably broken down." That comes on top of a judge's ruling denying VAH's request for summary judgment--a full decision in their favor without a trial--on its claim that McDonald's failed to follow contractual rules for setting a new rent. McDonald's charges the opposite, saying VAH attempted to raise the rent significantly, in an effort to get McDonald's to leave. Because of litigation, the rent has since been stalled at the extension figure.  A trial awaits--unless VAH pays McDonald's to leave, thus allowing it to build an 18-story building, permission for which was granted in a rezoning. The site includes othe...

Judge refuses to dismiss claim by McDonald's that landlord at 840 Atlantic Ave. acted in bad faith. Will developer of tower at site raise buyout offer?

A developer in September 2021 got City Council rezoning approval for an 18-story building at the southeast corner of Atlantic and Vanderbilt avenues, largely occupied by a long-running drive-through McDonald's. But plans to develop 840 Atlantic have hit a setback--or maybe have just become more costly--as a federal judge has sided (opinion at bottom) with the fast-food tenant in a preliminary ruling in its legal battle with landlord/developer Vanderbilt Atlantic Holdings (VAH). The delay in 840 Atlantic has nothing to do with the advisability of constructing a denser building at a key crossroads, one that, upon the entry of McDonald's in 1999, was not ripe for development.  (It's directly across the street from the eastern boundary of the Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park project, announced in December 2003, though that parcel, known as B10, remains unbuilt and requires an expensive platform over the railyard below. Meanwhile, in the past decade, landlords and develop...

Digging on lot adjacent to McDonald's seems aimed at getting 840 Atlantic foundations in the ground before 421-a deadline June 15

Guess what--there's drilling equipment in the storage lot on Atlantic Avenue immediately adjacent to the McDonald's lot, which is the largest component of the 840 Atlantic project, approved last year. And that, I suspect, is an effort to get foundations--some foundations--in the ground by June 15 to take advantage of the current, and not yet renewed, 421-a tax break. The City reported 4/26/22, in Hochul Honeymoon Is Over for Livid Albany Lawmakers : In a blow to [Gov. Kathy] Hochul, a controversial tax abatement program that gives developers tax breaks in exchange for setting aside affordable housing seems likely to expire in mid-June, with no replacement. The governor had proposed a reformed version of the so-called 421-a program and assured the influential real estate industry — a major source of her campaign donations — that it would be re-upped in some form, according to several people familiar with the situation. But the votes needed to extend the program, or craft a ne...

As CPC gives blessing to revised Atlantic Avenue rezonings, more info emerges, but questions remain about enforcement and counter-parties. Nearby property owners to gain.

See collected coverage of M-CROWN rezonings: click here . Yesterday I reported that the developer of one of two properties that gained a rezoning had been less than candid in his statements about ownership, and seemingly delayed acknowledgment of the property sale--and the sale price--until after the rezoning was announced. Today, let's look at some other updates, and pending questions. A day after 35th District Council Member Crystal Hudson announced approval of the two rezonings along Atlantic Avenue, along with a city commitment for a rezoning in the so-called M-CROWN district, the City Planning Commission met to consider--and approve--the changes, and also elicited a little more information about the project. For example, there are limits on the scope of one rezoned area, as described below. However, that still, as far as I can tell, gives other property owners the benefit of the increased bulk without having to commit to the 35% affordable housing that Hudson negotiated with...

840 Atlantic may qualify for 421-a benefits well before McDonald's case is resolved.

See collected coverage of M-CROWN rezonings:  click here . Let's so how this works.  The developers of 840 Atlantic Ave., who've apparently proposed two separate buildings  on a lot currently occupied mostly by a drive-through McDonald's, have filed plans to have foundations installed by June 15, to take advantage of the current 421-a tax break, as I wrote. They apparently plan to build foundations well before any litigation filed by McDonald's--which is aiming to block its eviction--is resolved.  According to a briefing schedule proposed by the landlord/defendant Vanderbilt Atlantic Holdings, as shown below, all papers must be filed by June 27.  That's after the 421-a deadline. That suggests the possibility that initial footings will persist for a significant period, while the case is being resolved.  Update: no communication with CB 8 Just as the developers of 840 Atlantic did not respond to questions from me, they have not been in communication wit...

The mysterious 840 Atlantic project: filings now suggest two buildings, with more (and thus smaller) apartments. Is affordability locked in? Is it just about 421-a filings?

See collected coverage of M-CROWN rezonings:  click here . Something odd is going on regarding 840 Atlantic Avenue, the tower approved last year by the City Council at the southeast corner of Vanderbilt Avenue, at a parcel largely occupied by a still-operating McDonald's. (It's right across the street from the Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park parcel known as B10.) Even as McDonald's and landlord/developer Vanderbilt Atlantic Holdings (VAH) battle in court over the latter's effort to end the lease, VAH has filed permits to construct not one but two buildings, one 17 stories and one 11 stories, in an effort to get foundations placed by June 15 to take advantage of the expiring 421-a tax break. Why two buildings? From PincusCo Unclear, but--I speculate--it might be easier to get the Department of Buildings to approve a foundation for the smaller building, designated 851 Pacific Street, than for a larger 840 Atlantic, which relies more significantly on the McDonald's parc...

840 Atlantic has new permit filing, indicating two towers instead of one, but that's about it (and McDonald's still operates)

Yes, I saw yesterday's post on New York YIMBY, Permits Filed For Two-Tower Development At 840 Atlantic Avenue In Prospect Heights, Brooklyn , unhelpfully coupled with a rendering of a previous design for a single tower, one that was presumably revised before the project went through small revisions at Community Board 8 and thus at the City Council. YIMBY doesn't offer links, but  a search  at the Department of Buildings for Filing Details: Job# B00657569 Filing# I1 does indicate, as YIMBY says, two towers, a new (or additional) architect, Hamish Whitefield Archtects of Albany, and a professed total square footage of 237.197, which may be subject to change. No renderings are available. The site is at the southeast corner of Atlantic Avenue, just across from the Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park B10 site, perhaps the last to be built on (if at all). "Demolition permits have not been filed yet," says YIMBY, because, guess what, litigation involving McDonald's, which occu...

Did "luck" help an "unheralded developer" win approval for the 840 Atlantic rezoning? TRD's account obscures the strategy and discounts the Council Member's role.

Well, this was curious. To be sure, luck was part of the reason the 840 Atlantic Avenue rezoning overcame pushback to win @NYCCouncil approval https://t.co/HIOf8zV4rh — The Real Deal (@trdny) November 9, 2021 Was it really "luck" that Vanderbilt Atlantic Holdings' (VAH) 840 Atlantic rezoning--across the street from the northeast corner of the Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park site--triumphed?  I doubt it, and am disappointed that The Real Deal--an industry-insider publication--was both unable to get candor from the developer and unwilling to dig deeper to describe what really happened, obscuring the developer's strategy and discounting the key direction from Council Member Laurie Cumbo. Leading off The 11/9/21 article is headlined How an unheralded developer survived NYC’s fraught rezoning process , with the subheading "Builder’s foresight, flexibility won approval to replace Atlantic Ave McDonald’s with apartments." The lead: Two weeks before the New York City...