Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts with the label Neil deMause

Featured Post

Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park FAQ, timeline, and infographics (pinned post)

In Worcester, MA, sports economist Zimbalist backs a stadium deal, citing contingencies; other experts disagree

Remember Andrew Zimbalist, the sports economist who, boosting his clients, unwisely predicted Atlantic Yards would be a gold mine for the city and state? Not only were his methods non-credible, he assumed a full buildout on the most optimistic schedule--which, of course, didn't happen. Well, he's back, working for a city helping recruit a team, rather than warning--as he has for most (but not all) of his career--that such deals are dangers. Stadium deal watchdog Neil deMause has been keeping track of the effort by Worcester, MA, to draw the Pawtucket (RI) Red Sox, a Triple A team. As he wrote 11/7/17, Zimbalist was actually working for both Worcester and the state of Rhode Island at the time. deMause, noting a similar episode, pointed out a January 2013 post  that Zimbalist was working as a consultant for Major League Baseball while supporting a new stadium for the Tampa Bay Rays, while omitting that client when talking to the Tampa Bay Times. Fast forward to last wee...

As concerts begin, traffic chaos, noise on nearby Pacific Street

There have been a couple of well-attended Bad Boy Family Reunion Concerts the past two nights at the Barclays Center. And, accordingly, Pacific Street just east of the arena--constrained by construction fencing, with two-way traffic, and having one garage open to the public--has been a madhouse during the early hours of the event. The two videos below were shot between 8:30 and 9 pm. As Wayne Bailey's title on the videos suggests, the city Department of Transportation might well consider adjusting the traffic pattern, such as restoring the street to one-way service.

"Epic train wreck"? The Barclays Center's way, way behind, but...

So, writing in the Village Voice, Neil DeMause (taking off from his Field of Schemes post , based on my reporting ) writes THREE YEARS IN, BARCLAYS CENTER IS MORE OR LESS AN EPIC TRAIN WRECK . I agree the arena is doing far, far worse than predicted, though I can't be that definitive.  After losses in one year, the arena should--if it finally meets predictions--be able to cover financing costs, including the second tranche of financing (from then-minority owner Mikhail Prokhorov) beyond the tax-exempt arena bonds. But profits will continue to lag enormously. The year 2014-15 was a very bad year after a not so good year, and the arena operating company is doing far worse than predicted. The $38 million in net operating income (NOI) was not enough to cover the $47 million combination of bond repayments (with required cushion) plus additional financing.  The previous year NOI reached $46 million, enough to cover payments of $45 million. And even if you accep...

From Neil deMause in The Nation: Why Do Mayors Love Sports Stadiums?

In The Nation's special issue on sports , Neil deMause's Why Do Mayors Love Sports Stadiums? (or, on NPR, Stop The Subsidy-Sucking Sports Stadiums ) begins with an Atlantic Yards anecdote: On a busy streetcorner in downtown Brooklyn, the steel girders are starting to rise.... Yet Atlantic Yards, as Ratner has dubbed his twenty-two-acre development project on the edge of the bustling neighborhood of Prospect Heights, won't look much like the image he first unveiled in 2003. The "Miss Brooklyn" office tower, which was supposed to bring jobs to the community, is gone, a victim of the virtual collapse of New York's commercial real estate market. Meanwhile, the condo towers that were supposed to provide more than 2,250 units of affordable housing are unlikely to be built anytime soon, if at all. (The latest plan involves a "modular" building, akin to stacking shipping containers thirty-four stories high.) The Nets, meanwhile, are spending two seasons ...

The inconsistency of the New York Times editorial page: Islanders owner should build new arena on his own, but 2005 request that Ratner "pay his own way" since forgotten

Is the New York Times editorial page consistent when it comes to public subsidies for sports facilities? Of course not. An editorial in yesterday's New York Times was headlined Voters Nix $400 Million Hockey Tix : Voters in Nassau County, showing far better sense and grasp of arithmetic than their elected leaders, have rejected a scheme to raise their taxes so their county could borrow $400 million to build a new hockey arena. The Times, sounding like it's channeled the collected works of Neil deMause , observes: 1. The deal stunk. That’s usually so when governments throw money at sports teams. Mr. Mangano was asking for a 4 percent tax increase, an estimated $14 to $58 more a year per household, in return for gauzy promises of new jobs and tax revenue... ...3. If [Islanders owner] Mr. [Charles] Wang needs a new arena, let him build it. Last we checked, professional sports was still a private (and highly lucrative) business, not a public utility. What happened to ...

Public vote (!) tomorrow to replace Nassau Coliseum; demise would boost Barclays Center; Daily News, Post, slam (!) public arena funding; economist warns of "corporate welfare to pro sports team owners"

There's a referendum Monday in tax-strapped Nassau County on a $400 million plan to replace the Nassau Coliseum (and build a minor league ballpark), and you can bet that Barclays Center backers are hoping the whole thing blows up, thus sending events--no, not the main tenant, the hockey Islanders, but concerts and shows--to that new arena rising near the Long Island Rail Road terminal in Brooklyn. There's reason for question the plan, as I'll describe below, but it's notable how the New York Daily News and New York Post editorial pages, steady backers of Atlantic Yards, have discovered their inner Daniel Goldstein , fervently denouncing the "scheme." (It's also notable that the public gets a voice decide--though it should be pointed out that a Monday in August is not exactly designed for mass turnout. Neither the public nor local elected officials voted on support for Atlantic Yards. Note that the Nassau County Legislature and then the Nassau Interi...

Flashback, 2003: “What happens if he builds the arena & one office tower & says, 'I can’t get the banks to lend me all that money for the housing'?"

Shortly after the Atlantic Yards plan was announced, the 12/22/03 Brooklyn Paper, in an article headlined BULLDOZED: Nets arena would skirt city review , reported on the questionable--and never-implemented--plan to finance the project with tax-increment financing, using taxes the project would generate. The paper quoted a skeptic: Neil deMause, co-author of “Field of Schemes,” a book delving into “how the great stadium swindle turns public money into private profit,” is not convinced. DeMause, who lives in Flatbush, says that the city is actually losing money on the Ratner arena plan because people have a limited amount of entertainment dollars. Money spent at the Nets arena means money not spent at the movies or shopping, which would generate taxes free and clear for the city. “The worry is that he’s talking about scaled development,” deMause said. “What happens if he builds the arena and one office tower and then says, ‘I can’t get the banks to lend me all that money for the housing...

That outrageous claim from the groundbreaking: "We did not at the time appreciate that Atlantic Yards would be such an important economic engine."

An outrageous claim from the press release (below) issued with the March 11 groundbreaking deserves another look: “When we announced Atlantic Yards in December 2003, we anticipated that this project would create buzz and excitement for the borough and the City as well as needed jobs and affordable housing,” said Mr. [Bruce] Ratner. “We did not at the time appreciate that Atlantic Yards would be such an important economic engine. The fact that we can start construction in this financial environment is testament to the lasting appeal of New York City. We are a City that continues to grow and prosper and Atlantic Yards will for many years stand as a reminder that we can build and create jobs and homes and dreams even during the most difficult of economic times.” Oh, come now. The fact that they can start construction in this financial environment is less "testament to the lasting appeal of New York City" than the lasting appeal of Brooklyn and New York for Barclays Capital and M...

Brutally weird holiday news from NYT: Stadium Boom Deepens Municipal Woes (no mention of AY or other NYC projects)

From today's New York Times, an article headlined Stadium Boom Deepens Municipal Woes : CINCINNATI — Years after a wave of construction brought publicly financed stadiums costing billions of dollars to cities across the country, taxpayers are once again being asked to reach into their pockets. From New Jersey to Ohio to Arizona, the stadiums were sold as a key to redevelopment and as the only way to retain sports franchises. But the deals that were used to persuade taxpayers to finance their construction have in many cases backfired, the result of overly optimistic revenue assumptions and the recession. Nowhere is the problem more acute than in Cincinnati. In 1996, voters in Hamilton County approved an increase of half of one percent in the sales tax that promised to build and maintain stadiums for the Bengals and the Reds, pay Cincinnati’s public schools and give homeowners an annual property tax rebate. The stadiums were supposed to spur development of the city’s dilapidated rive...

Neil deMause: gaps in bond offering statement add skepticism regarding returns for arena project and Nets

In a Village Voice piece headlined As Atlantic Yards Gets Pricier, How Much Red Ink Can Ratner Absorb? , Neil deMause suggests that the bond offering document released by Goldman Sachs suggests reasons to be concerned about the profitability of the arena project. He notes some gaps: [I]t doesn't account for the fact that Ratner and Prokhorov will presumably want to be repaid for their cash outlay on the arena, currently estimated at $293 million. Not to mention the $300 million Ratner spent to buy the Nets originally, or the tens of millions he's lost since then while running the team into the ground. And what could be more interesting is what's not on the chart: the projected finances of the Brooklyn Nets once they land in the borough of overpriced Asian fusion cuisine. With all those other arena revenues dedicated to paying off the arena, that would leave the Nets to survive mostly just on ticket sales — which, while no doubt higher than they're getting in the Meadow...

Did Prokhorov get his shares of the team and arena at a two-thirds discount? It looks that way, reports the Times, but the deal's not simple

A little more than two days later, the major media are waking up to the notion that the agreement between Bruce Ratner and Mikhail Prokhorov might be a bargain for the oligarch, despite Ratner calling it "a great deal." In an article headlined Russian’s Stake in Nets Seems to Be a Bargain , the New York Times reports: Mikhail D. Prokhorov’s $200 million investment for 80 percent of the Nets and 45 percent of the team’s proposed Barclays Center is just one-third of what his share of the team and arena should be worth, according to Michael K. Ozanian, the national editor of Forbes, which compiles an annual list of professional team valuations. Ozanian, in response to my query, explained that he valued the Nets at $295 million and the arena, as reported, at $800 million. Prokhorov's share of the team would be worth $236 million and his share of the arena at $360 million. More to the deal "What we don’t know of course is the amount Prokhorov has promised to invest in th...

The $6 billion lie goes unchallenged: forgetful sports economist Zimbalist gets gentle treatment in the New Yorker

A seemingly defensive Andrew Zimbalist, Forest City Ratner's paid consultant, gets gentle treatment from the New Yorker, which should've enlisted Neil deMause  as the interviewer. The online-only interview is headlined CONVERSATION: THE SPORTS RECESSION . Q. You were a consultant to Bruce Ratner on the Atlantic Yards project— A. I haven’t consulted with him since I wrote my last report, which I think was in 2004. Zimbalist issued his main report in May 2004 , just in time for a City Council hearing, then updated it in June 2005 . Sports facilities a boon? Q. Part of the idea was that building Atlantic Yards—the arena, all the development—would be a major boon for business. How much economic benefit do stadiums and arenas actually bring when they are built with public money? A. Arenas and stadiums, by themselves, cannot be expected to produce an economic benefit to the local community. It can’t be expected to increase the employment level in the community, and it can’t be expec...

The sports bubble pops, and the Nets can't help but notice

Neil deMause in Metro got there first, with a piece headlined Popping the sports bubble : I went to a Mets game last week, and speaking as a Yankee fan, I have to admit that in the battle of the ballparks, the Mets won. Citi Field is far from perfect, but at least it feels like you’re at a baseball park — unlike the new Yankee Stadium, which bears an uncanny resemblance to a new Marriott with a really garish big-screen TV in the lobby. What I noticed most, though, was something I’d never seen at a baseball game: The upper deck was packed to the gills, while the acres of hyper-pricey seats down below were half-empty. It’s something you first saw in NBA games over the winter, as penny-pinching fans scurried for the rafters. The Times piles on Then the Times piled on, in a front-page article today headlined Is This Seat Taken? In Front Rows of New Ballparks, No : Instead, the Mets and the Yankees face a public relations nightmare and possibly millions of dollars in lost revenue after fai...

Documents emerge about stadium subsidies; mayoral candidates shy away from criticism

The big news in today's papers is that, as the New York Times reports, in an article headlined City Gives Up Its Stadium Suite in Exchange for Cash : After intense criticism, the Bloomberg administration has given up a perk it worked fervently to secure: a free luxury suite at the new Yankee Stadium. But lower down in the article there's a hint at the larger story: “Does the Bloomberg administration really think that giving up a suite at Yankee Stadium is going to soften the blow that this project has had on city taxpayers?” said Bettina Damiani, director of Good Jobs New York... Indeed, though Rep. Anthony Weiner, a stated mayoral candidate, criticizes the suite deal in the Times, Tom Robbins in the Village Voice points out that both Weiner and Comptroller William Thompson, a fellow candidate, are unwilling to criticize the larger question of taxpayer funds supporting the stadium via tax-exempt bonds. If they're unwilling to raise that issue, it's unlikely they'd ...

Someone at The Simpsons has been reading Field of Schemes

I'm not sure the the episode of The Simpsons aired last Sunday, The Burns and the Bees , was about Atlantic Yards as much as asserted on NoLandGrab , but it sure does look like the design for the arena, wrapped in buildings--in this case, hives--was inspired by Frank Gehry's models. One key difference: the new state-of-the-art arena for the Springfield Excitement emerges not from the vote of an unaccountable public authority, as with AY, but by public referendum. "All those in favor of building this decadent monument to excess, say aye," asserts Mayor Joe Quimby. Having achieved success in the vote, Montgomery Burns (above), in his self-satisfied way, declares, "Welcome to the American dream: a billionaire using public funds to construct a private playground for the rich and powerful." Maybe Neil deMause of the book and web site Field of Schemes should get a royalty.

A dozen Atlantic Yards stories that have gotten scant or no coverage

Given tomorrow's IFC Media Project segment on Atlantic Yards, I'll list some recent AY-related stories that most media sources--especially the three major dailies--either haven't picked up or have gotten wrong. 1) Forest City Ratner's bailout of the national organization ACORN. It did get coverage on WNYC. 2) The work stoppage at the Metropolitan Transportation Authority's Vanderbilt Yard, Forest City Ratner's lame explanation , and the fate of the Carlton Avenue bridge . Only the Daily News has covered that, among the dailies, relegating the story to the Brooklyn section. 3) Forest City Ratner's attempt to evade paying $159,000 in partial restitution to the city for demolished trees because the trees in the Atlantic Yards open space eventually would compensate for the loss. 4) The revelation that the seemingly-generous payments by the developer to buy out residents of the AY footprint were reimbursed by city taxpayers . Note that the Daily News got a f...

On CityTalk: "How much welfare do you think the Steinbrenners should get?"

The Yankee Stadium deal was the subject of a scathing episode of the CUNY-TV talk show City Talk , taped November 11, which raised many issues that should be pursued regarding the planned Atlantic Yards arena. Host Doug Muzzio, a Baruch College political scientist, was joined by two forceful guests. Bettina Damiani, Project Director, Good Jobs New York (GJNY), declared, "If somebody could write a book on how to make an opaque democratic process and screw over poor people, this would've been it." Baruch professor Neil Sullivan, author of The Diamond in the Bronx: Yankee Stadium and the Politics of New York (2001, updated 2008), said the fundamental question was "how much welfare do you think the Steinbrenners [Yankee owners] should get? (Note that the video for me was fuzzy, but I downloaded the audio.) Opening up Muzzio brought up the recent spate of critical news coverage. DM: OK, the last week, stories all over the place, Jim Dwyer in the Times, For Yankees, May...