Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts with the label Chuck Schumer

Featured Post

Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park FAQ, timeline, and infographics (pinned post)

Schumer part of bipartisan effort to gut reforms in EB-5, aid projects in cities like New York

Backing EB-5 power players is always bi-partisan, isn't it? In Graham Backs a Bill Friendly to Real-Estate Industry , the Wall Street Journal's Konrad Putzier reported 1/14/20 that not only is Trump ally Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-SC) a co-sponsor of a new bill, but so too are Sens. John Cornyn (R-TX) and Chuck Schumer (D-NY) The pending bill would essentially restore primacy for immigrant investor projects in major cities like New York. As I reported 10/31/19, new program rules raised the minimum investment from $500,000 to $900,000 (but not $1.35 million, as originally proposed), as long as the project is in a Targeted Employment Area (TEA), which is a rural area or an area of high unemployment.  The non-TEA investment, generally ignored in recent years, increased from $1 million to $1.8 million, and it also made it much harder to define such a TEA, long gerrymandered by developers, the middlemen known as regional centers, and local governments eager to attract low-cost capi...

City & State NY's 2019 Brooklyn Power 100: Jeffries at the top, Adams #5; Cumbo under-ranked; Gilmartin (ex-Forest City) but, oddly, not Greenland's Hu

City & State New York's listing of  The 2019 Brooklyn Power 100  is, of course arbitrary, but it's also intriguing. And it includes some Atlantic Yards-related references. The ranking is... interesting, starting with: Rep. Hakeem Jeffries Sen. Charles Schumer State AG Letitia James Rep. Nydia Velazquez Brooklyn Borough President Eric Adams The description for Adams: No Brooklyn borough president has ever become mayor, and the last borough president in New York City to ascend to Gracie Mansion was Manhattan’s David Dinkins. But Eric Adams hopes he could become the first. With Letitia James preoccupied enforcing state law, the former state senator and ex-police officer may have an opening in what will no doubt be a crowded field in 2021. He has outraised his opponents recently, hauling in more than $500,000 over the first six months of the year, although his rival City Comptroller Scott Stringer has more than $2.5 million in his war chest. Adams has been noticeab...

EB-5 reform stymied by Schumer (and allies); most investors' capital simply bolsters profits, doesn't jump-start projects

In a 12/22/15 article, How Efforts to Overhaul Visa Program Failed on Capitol Hill: Sen. Grassley, allies pushed hard for reform, but developers’ lobby prevailed , the Wall Street Journal's Eliot Brown explained how even relatively modest reforms of the EB-5 investment visa program failed: For more than a year, U.S. Sen. Charles Grassley had been pushing to overhaul a controversial program that gives green cards to foreigners who invest at least $500,000 in certain businesses. So when congressional leaders last week moved forward with a 10-month extension of the so-called EB-5 program without any changes, the Iowa Republican was less than pleased. “Maybe it is only here on Capitol Hill—an island surrounded by reality—that we can choose to plug our ears and then refuse to listen to commonly accepted facts,” he said in a 33-minute diatribe on the Senate floor Thursday. The program, he said, is “riddled with flaws and corruption.” Despite broad agreement that EB-5 is in need of ch...

Dirty secret behind Brooklyn's DNC 2016 bid: likely major impacts to area around Barclays Center, as Charlotte example suggests

As the Democratic National Committee deliberates among Brooklyn, Philadelphia, and Columbus for the 2016 DNC Convention, there's been a strong effort to portray elected officials and especially Brooklynites as united behind the bid--or, at least, quietly neutral. That happens when political heavyweights--notably Mayor Bill de Blasio and Sen. Charles Schumer, both Brooklynites--drive a moving train. At a press conference/pep rally two weeks ago , Schumer airily dismissed any logistical concerns. Street closures in downtown Charlotte, via Charlotte Observer "We'll make sure that everything works out just fine," he said. "When the Barclays Center was built, people said, Every time there's a Nets game, every time there's a concert, there will be bottlenecks. There isn't," Schumer insisted. "Everything is handled great. I live there, I know, I come home." That's not quite true, and it's not quite relevant. The DNC woul...

Campaign contributions: Forest City bundles for Thompson, de Blasio, Squadron, even gets Republican subcontractor in Virginia to pony up

So, does developer Forest City Ratner support any candidates in the 2013 election? Campaign finance reports suggest significant support via bundling for mayoral candidates Public Advocate Bill de Blasio and former Comptroller Bill Thompson, as well as some support for Council Speaker Christine Quinn. Notably, a prominent Republican executive in Virginia, whose steel company produces key components for both the arena and the first modular tower, has contributed $1,000 to Democrats Thompson and Quinn, in one case through an FCR intermediary. (Do the candidates know his company is non-union ?) Comptroller John Liu, probably (and perceivedly) the main candidate most critical of Atlantic Yards and development, has received no FCR-related contributions. (His campaign also has some ethical question marks .) In the race for Public Advocate, where anti-Atlantic Yards Council Member Letitia James is one of three candidates, Forest City-related contributions clearly favor fundraising lead...

Looking back at the Group of 35's wrongheaded boost of Downtown Brooklyn (not the AY site) for office jobs

The showing of the "My Brooklyn" documentary sent me back to the wrongheaded June 2001 report Preparing for the Future: A Commercial Development Strategy for New York City , relied on by Atlantic Yards boosters. The report was the work of the Group of 35, organized by Sen. Chuck Schumer and including major developers, landowners, and business officials. While the report unwisely suggested there was a huge untapped market in New York City for business space--including 12 million more square feet in Downtown Brooklyn--it did not extend the boundaries of Downtown Brooklyn to the Atlantic Yards site. So, when Schumer appeared as an enthusiastic (or "enervated") booster of Atlantic Yards for the purported 10,000 office jobs in some 2 million square feet, he was in some ways going off-message. As it's turned out, most of that planned office space is gone, the rest delayed, and the 6 million-plus square feet of potential commercial space from the 2004 Downtown Bro...

Schumer sponsors bill to bail out housing industry by selling temporary visas to immigrant investors; wouldn't this distort the market (and maybe even help AY)?

Apparently, essentially selling green cards through the questionable EB-5 program --under which prospective immigrants must create ten purported jobs with their $500,000 investment--was only the start. Now Congress is considering selling three-year residence visas to foreigners who invest $500,000 in the housing market, and co-sponsor Sen. Chuck Schumer (D-NY) somehow thinks "it won't cost the government a nickel." Schumer doesn't seem familiar with opportunity cost , the notion that we might choose a different alternative that could prove more beneficial. For example, immigration analyst David North of the conservative Center for Immigration Studies thinks EB-5 investors should also have to buy a $50,000 U.S. bond for each visa issued. So why not ask prospective home purchasers do more than bail out the housing industry in exchange for those visas? Schumer's proposal could have major unintended consequences, such as rising prices in prime areas (Hello, ...

NY Magazine's Chris Smith on Battle for Brooklyn and the "urban outrage" of AY (also, why Schumer's jobs claim is even worse than billed)

In New York Magazine's Daily Intel, Chris Smith (author of a fundamental 2006 article on Atlantic Yards), writes Chris Smith on the Atlantic Yards Documentary Battle for Brooklyn : Early in the new documentary Battle for Brooklyn , Senator Chuck Schumer appears at a rally in support of the proposed Atlantic Yards stadium and housing development. “What really enervates me about this project,” Schumer says, “are the jobs.” Sure, it’s an innocent slip of the tongue: Schumer meant to say “energizes” or “excites” or something equally booster-y. Yet he inadvertently cut to the core of this eight-years-and-counting urban outrage: “Enervate” means lacking in energy or vitality, and the promises of developer Bruce Ratner — that he was bringing world-class architecture, affordable housing, and, most important of all in his sales pitch, tens of thousands of jobs to the corner of Flatbush and Atlantic Avenues — are turning out to be expensive fictions. First, I don't give Schu...

Chuck Schumer's dilemma and Marty Markowitz's return to candor: footnoting the Observer's article on the Knicks-Nets rivalry

A couple of observations on the New York Observer's long article about the owners of the area's two hoops teams, headlined B-Brawl! Prokhorov, the Nets’ Rakish Russian, Aims A.K. at Garden Party as Dolan’s Knicks Brace for Red Scare : 1) They weren't able to interview either owner, Jim Dolan or Mikhail Prokhorov, so all the talk of rivalry is secondhand. But the Knicks are, yes, on the defensive--somewhat. 2) Somehow they didn't quote my observation about the meaning of the EB-5 investment. 3) I would wager I know who said this: (A person familiar with the plans said Mr. Prokhorov is assembling an in-house retreat for himself 10 times the size of a standard luxury box "for he and his Russian friends.") That's Brett Yormarkian tactics, and grammar. 4) Sen. Chuck Schumer, who's a Brooklynite, admits to dilemmas, since "I've been a Knicks fan all along." What? Schumer's been a huge supporter of Atlantic Yards. If the prospect of 10,000...

The initial Atlantic Yards rhetoric was all about dreams

A second look at that first Atlantic Yards flyer (Live. Work. Play…), sent to Brooklynites in May 2004, turns up some remarkably echoey rhetoric. "It's more than just basketball. It's a dream, it's jobs and it's housing," said Sen. Chuck Schumer. "This is something that has been the dream of so many people in this great borough for decades, that major league sports would come back to a major league town," declared Gov. George Pataki. "This is a dream come true for Brooklyn," asserted Borough President Marty Markowitz. Little did they know. Maybe the overstated headline--"What Brooklyn Leaders are saying about Atlantic Yards"--should've been a hint. Only one of the four was a Brooklyn leader, and only two of the four are Brooklyn residents. And their Atlantic Yards claims, as of now, are more fantasy than reality.

Lesson not learned by Schumer, Peyser, Hamill: “Just building office buildings doesn’t mean you’re creating jobs”

From a New York Observer article headlined The Business of Ground Zero : This, of course, is not how office towers typically get built. Developers, particularly in a recession, traditionally must have a large private tenant in hand to get anything but a laugh from lenders, and speculative office space very rarely flies on such a large scale. This has sparked concerns that the office towers could be slow to lease up, potentially languishing for years without enough rent to even cover the mortgage payments. “Just building office buildings doesn’t mean you’re creating jobs,” said Barry Gosin, CEO of brokerage Newmark Knight Frank. “It’s not like the field of dreams. We’ve learned that lesson before.” (Emphasis added) Who never got that message? Among others, Sen. Chuck Schumer and columnists Andrea Peyser and Denis Hamill , all of whom concluded that Forest City Ratner's announced plan to build office towers meant 10,000 jobs.

Brutally weird Schumer flashback: "But you know what really enervates me about this? 10,000 jobs."

Perhaps the most brutally weird moment in the trailer (below) for the documentary-in-progress Battle of Brooklyn comes at about 2:48. "This is a great project," declares Sen. Chuck Schumer, at the 2004 State of the Borough address, which, as the Brooklyn Paper reported , focused on Atlantic Yards. "But you know what really enervates me about this? 10,000 jobs." The filmmakers follow that with an implied rebuttal from City Council Member Charles Barron, who points to the "jobs" mantra as a cover for eminent domain. Battle of Brooklyn Trailer by rumurtv Footnotes needed But the Schumer segment deserves its own footnotes. Let's put aside the fact that the Harvard-educated lawmaker doesn't know the difference between enervate and energize . More importantly, the figure of 10,000 jobs was bogus from the start . There was no market for that many office jobs. Forest City Ratner overstated the number of jobs that could fit in the four tow...

Schumer touts stimulus funds for Moynihan Station, waves off question on Atlantic Yards

For New York, the big stimulus news of the day yesterday was Senator Chuck Schumer's plan to seek $100 million in federal funds to jump-start the Moynihan Station project, as the New York Times reported . And Schumer followed up on his Moynihan Station vision at a breakfast speech sponsored by Crain's New York Business. That got a headline in Crain's, which additionally reported that Schumer's call for new, smarter regulation on financial transactions represents an about-face from his position two years ago. But I wanted to ask him about Atlantic Yards, given that, a little more than two weeks ago, Schumer expressed quizzical ignorance regarding whether AY would be eligible for stimulus funds. Waiting for Schumer After Schumer's speech, and the 25-minute Q&A, the Senator stuck around the stage at the Hilton in midtown and greeted well-wishers and supplicants, among them the developers of the New Domino project in Williamsburg, who wanted him to know they need...

Decoding "shovel-ready": AY railyard may seem eligible, but with a huge bailout asterisk (and wouldn't be "fully vetted")

Last Wednesday, the Empire State Development Corporation's (ESDC) Atlantic Yards Ombudsman, Forrest Taylor was asked the definition of “shovel-ready,” the term used in discussion of projects eligible for federal stimulus funding. “I think that ‘shovel-ready' will be a federal term,” Taylor said. Perhaps, but there's no formal federal definition of shovel-ready, according to NPR. But the Federal Highway Administration's (FHA) "ready to go" designation seems a rough equivalent, NPR suggested last week, encompassing projects that have gotten through design work and environmental approval. And a New York definition, as I describe below, seems similar. AY bailout? The Atlantic Yards railyard might seem to qualify, though not the project as a whole, given that Forest City Ratner does not control the property. But the railyard would require a huge bailout asterisk, connected to FCR's lobbying . As I've written , the difference between using federal funds fo...