Skip to main content

Document reveals Greenland, Chinese investor, will control Atlantic Yards; Forest City Ratner said otherwise or left ambiguity

Despite a clear statement when the sale of the remaining Atlantic Yards project--15 towers--was proposed in August that developer Forest City Ratner would be "managing member" of a potential joint venture, newly revealed documents show that the new investor, the Chinese government-owned Greenland Group, will be in charge and may ultimately buy out Forest City's remaining 30% stake.

The internal memo by an official at Empire State Development, the state agency that oversees/shepherds Atlantic Yards was revealed in a press release yesterday by BrooklynSpeaks, headlined Greenland Holdings Group to Control Build Out of Affordable Housing at Atlantic Yards. According to the memo, Greenland’s approval would be required prior to the start of any new building at the Atlantic Yards site.

Though Forest City Ratner and parent Forest City Enterprises would have veto power since the assent of one of its appointees would be required for major decisions, that situation could change if the ownership percentages change, according to the memo.

(The memo was provided to BrooklynSpeaks, the coaltion that has pushed for changes in Atlantic Yards, by ESDC’s attorneys in response to an inquiry about the Greenland transaction.)

Speed, or uncertainty?

According to the press release:
The revelation that Greenland Holdings, a developer owned by the government of China, will control the joint venture responsible for completing Atlantic Yards contradicts previous statements made by FCRC executives. In August, FCRC CEO MaryAnne Gilmartin told the New York Times in an article announcing a prospective sale, “We’ll retain our position as the managing member."
But that's not going to happen with Greenland, the largest real estate enterprise in China, with more than $35 billion in revenues.

Expect Forest City and the state to argue, as the memo suggests, that the new investment will accelerate development of the 15 towers, which contain the bulk of the 6430 units and 2250 subsidized "affordable" apartments. (The Barclays Center and the first tower, B2, which will have 363 units--181 of them subsidized--are not part of the deal.)

But the uncertainty involved in the deal, which does not promise to change the 25-year deadline Forest City was able to renegotiate in 2009, prompted criticism from BrooklynSpeaks.

“It’s outrageous that a project receiving hundreds of millions of taxpayer dollars in exchange for badly-needed affordable housing for working people from Brooklyn could soon be controlled by a foreign government. ESDC has repeatedly abdicated its responsibility to the people of the State of New York with the Atlantic Yards project and is poised to do so again.” said Michelle de la Uz, Executive Director of The Fifth Avenue Committee.

This is more fodder for BrooklynSpeaks's ongoing call for a revision of the project deadline and new oversight. “It’s clear we can’t rely on more promises. The ESDC has an obligation to get ironclad guarantees that Atlantic Yards provides the affordable housing and other public benefits that FCRC promised and originally committed to before the ESDC and MTA approve this deal,” said Jo Anne Simon, Democratic District Leader for Brooklyn’s 52nd A.D. “And the people of New York State need real oversight to hold this project accountable until those benefits are delivered.”

Note that some project neighbors stress that the oversight must focus well beyond the delivery of benefits to offer more scrutiny of project impacts.

Strategic ambiguity

Despite Gilmartin's statement in August, Forest City was subsequently more ambiguous about who would control the project going forward.

When the potential deal involving Greenland was announced in October, the Wall Street Journal reported that Forest City would "continue to manage the development." But the word "manage" is ambiguous--it could mean manage operations or manage decision making.

Forest City's press release at the time suggested "manage" meant operations, while leaving management of the joint venture unclear: "Under the proposed joint venture, Greenland Group would acquire 70 percent of the project, co-develop the project with FCRC, and share in the entire project costs going forward at the same percentage interest. FCRC would manage the day-to-day activities on behalf of the joint venture, which would develop the project consistent with the approved master plan."

The potential for change became clear, as I wrote 11/3/13, when Crain's New York Business quoted Kit Kwok, an attorney for Greenland, who said, "Atlantic Yards is going to be a joint effort; Greenland is not going to be a purely financial partner of Forest City."

According to a December 2013 Forest City Enterprises Investor Presentation, Forest City would manage the day-to-day activities on behalf of the joint venture, but there was no clarity about who would steer the joint venture.

However, the 12/9/13 Form 10-Q filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission allowed for the possibility that Forest City would either share control or lose control.

Either of those cases, Forest City said, would require deconsolidation of and allocation of site acquisition costs--which has since meant an "impairment" of some $250 million. Forest City, which has invested more than $500 million, is expecting to get a $200 million payment from Greenland, which seemingly got a bargain for its pro rata share. Greenland will then control 70% of the project going forward and will invest at that percentage.

The ESDC memo: how joint venture will work

According to the 12/13/13 memo to the "Atlantic Yards file" by ESDC VP of Planning and Environmental Review Rachel Shatz, the Development Agreement signed in 2009 allows FCR to transfer its interest to another party. That sale would also transfer obligations in the Memorandum of Environmental Commitments.

A five-person board of directors would be established, with Greenland appointing the Chairman, CEO, and CFO, and Forest City Enterprises appointing Vice Chairman and President. Decisions of particular importance, including starting a new building, require a majority vote, including a vote from one appointee from both, which "in effect requires that both Greenland and FCRC agree to such decisions," according to Shatz.

Day to day operations would be the responsibility of a Management Team and a Development Team. The Management Team would consist of seven FCR executives, plus up to five additional people appointed by Greenland. The Development Team would consist of at least 14 current FCR executives, plus other members that may be appointed by Greenland. There may be overlap among the two teams.

The agreement does provide for a possible buy-out in the event of a deadlock among the members of the Board of Managers and it also provides for a dilution of a member's interest if it fails to meet certain obligations. "Accordingly, it cannot be assumed that the 30%-70% divisions of interests described above is a permanent arrangement," Shatz wrote.

The ESDC memo: MTA issues

Given pending work on the Vanderbilt Yard, where Long Island Rail Road trains are stored and services, Forest City Ratner has also asked the MTA to consent to joint venture, according to the memo.

FCR, which has built a temporary railyard after moving the railyard functions east from the site--in part--of the Barclays Center, has until 90 days past 9/1/16 to finish the permanent railyard. The original completion guarantee was to be posted by 6/30/12, but, after two extensions, is now 6/30/14.

The MTA requires a completion guarantee from Greenland, as well, and should Greenland buy out FCR, they must retain FCR as manager or another real estate company with at least 10 years of experience.

The ESDC memo: state approvals and SEIS?

FCR has told ESD it believes it can do the transfer without the agency's consent, but ESD is reviewing that, according to Shatz's memo.

That said, the rhetorical support offered by ESD suggests that there would be no opposition even if approval were required.

ESD has determined that a Supplementary Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS) in response to the Greenland deal, is neither required nor warranted in this case, since this will bring an infusion of capital and therefore facilitate construction according to the agreements already in place, according to Shatz.

The proposed sale, according to Shatz, "will do nothing to hamstring ESD's ongoing environmental review," which was ordered by a state judge to study the potential impacts of a 25-year buildout.

Then again, it could be argued, that the sale has already delayed that review, which has already taken about as much time as did the original 2006 environmental review--a far more extensive effort, though in that case with pressure to move quickly, while now there's reason to believe ESD has delayed or slowed the review so Forest City could market the project.

The issue of foreign control

As I wrote 10/11/13, as with the sale of the Brooklyn Nets to Russian oligarch Mikhail Prokhorov, the bottom line is: after Forest City did the heavy lifting to get subsidies, tax breaks, and regulatory approval, gaining what they call in the real estate development business "entitlement," Atlantic Yards became a pure investment opportunity, and global capital knows no boundaries, neither ethical nor geographic.

And that means public assistance from New Yorkers will help the Chinese government earn profits.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Barclays Center/Levy Restaurants hit with suit charging discrimination on disability, race; supervisors said to use vicious slurs, pursue retaliation

The Daily News has an article today, Barclays Center hit with $5M suit claiming discrimination against disabled, while the New York Post headlined its article Barclays Center sued over taunting disabled employees.

While that's part of the lawsuit, more prominent are claims of racial discrimination and retaliation, with black employees claiming repeated abuse by white supervisors, preferential treatment toward Hispanic colleagues, and retaliation in response to complaints.

Two individual supervisors, for example, are charged with  referring to black employees as “black motherfucker,” “dumb black bitch,” “black monkey,” “piece of shit” and “nigger.”

Two have referred to an employee blind in one eye as “cyclops,” and “the one-eyed guy,” and an employee with a nose disorder as “the nose guy.”

There's been no official response yet though arena spokesman Barry Baum told the Daily News they, but take “allegations of this kind very seriously” and have "a zero tolerance policy for…

Behind the "empty railyards": 40 years of ATURA, Baruch's plan, and the city's diffidence

To supporters of Forest City Ratner's Atlantic Yards project, it's a long-awaited plan for long-overlooked land. "The Atlantic Yards area has been available for any developer in America for over 100 years,” declared Borough President Marty Markowitz at a 5/26/05 City Council hearing.

Charles Gargano, chairman of the Empire State Development Corporation, mused on 11/15/05 to WNYC's Brian Lehrer, “Isn’t it interesting that these railyards have sat for decades and decades and decades, and no one has done a thing about them.” Forest City Ratner spokesman Joe DePlasco, in a 12/19/04 New York Times article ("In a War of Words, One Has the Power to Wound") described the railyards as "an empty scar dividing the community."

But why exactly has the Metropolitan Transportation Authority’s Vanderbilt Yard never been developed? Do public officials have some responsibility?

At a hearing yesterday of the Brooklyn Borough Board Atlantic Yards Committee, Kate Suisma…

No, security guards can't ban photos. Questions remain about visibility of ID/sticker system.

The bi-monthly Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park Community Update meeting June 14, held at 55 Hanson Place, addressed multiple issues, including delays in the project, a new detente with project neighbors,concerns about traffic congestion, upcoming sewer work and demolitions, and an explanation of how high winds caused debris to fly off the under-construction 38 Sixth Avenue building. I'll have more coverage.
Security issues came up several times at the meeting.
Wayne Bailey, a resident who regularly takes photos and videos (that I often use) of construction/operations issues that impact residents, asked representatives of Tishman Construction if the security guard at the sites they're building works for them.
After Tishman Senior VP Eric Reid said yes, Bailey asked why a guard told him not to shoot video of the site, even though he was on a public street.

"I will address it with principals for that security firm," Reid said.
Forest City Ratner executive Ashley Cotton, the …

Barclays Center event June 11 to protest plans to expand Israeli draft; questions about logistics

At right is a photo of a poster spotted in Hasidic Williamsburg right. Clearly there's an event scheduled at the Barclays Center aimed at the Haredi Jewish community (strict Orthodox Jews who reject secular culture), but the lack of English text makes it cryptic.

The website Matzav.com explains, Protest Against Israeli Draft of Bnei Yeshiva Rescheduled for Barclays Center:
A large asifa to protest the drafting of bnei yeshiva in Eretz Yisroel into the Israeli army that had been set to take place this month will instead be held on Sunday, 17 Sivan/June 11, at the Barclays Center in Downtown Brooklyn, NY. So attendees at a big gathering will protest an apparent change of policy that will make it much more difficult for traditional Orthodox Jewish students--both Hasidic (who follow a rebbe) and non-Hasidic (who don't)--to get deferments from the draft. Comments on the Yeshiva World website explain some of the debate.

The logistical questions

What's unclear is how large the ev…

Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park graphic: what's built/what might be coming (post-dated pinned post)

Click on graphic to enlarge. This is post-dated to stay at the top of the blog. It will be updated as announced configurations change and buildings launch. The August 2014 tentative configurations proposed by developer Greenland Forest City Partners will change, and the project is already well behind that tentative timetable.


Not quite the pattern: Greenland selling development sites, not completed condos

Real Estate Weekly, reporting on trends in Chinese investment in New York City, on 11/18/15 quoted Jim Costello, a senior vice president at research firm Real Capital Analytics:
“They’re typically building high-end condos, build it and sell it. Capital return is in a few years. That’s something that is ingrained in the companies that have been coming here because that’s how they’ve grown in the last 35 years. It’s always been a development game for them. So they’re just repeating their business model here,” he said. When I read that last November, I didn't think it necessarily applied to Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park, now 70% owned (outside of the Barclays Center and B2 modular apartment tower), by the Greenland Group, owned significantly by the Shanghai government.
A majority of the buildings will be rentals, some 100% market, some 100% affordable, and several--the last several built--are supposed to be 50% market/50% subsidized. (See tentative timetable below.)

Selling development …

Atlanta's Atlantic Yards moves ahead

First mentioned in April, the Atlantic Yards project in Atlanta is moving ahead--and has the potential to nudge Atlantic Yards in Brooklyn further down in Google searches.

According to a 5/30/17 press release, Hines and Invesco Real Estate Announce T3 West Midtown and Atlantic Yards:
Hines, the international real estate firm, and Invesco Real Estate, a global real estate investment manager, today announced a joint venture on behalf of one of Invesco Real Estate’s institutional clients to develop two progressive office projects in Atlanta totalling 700,000 square feet. T3 West Midtown will be a 200,000-square-foot heavy timber office development and Atlantic Yards will consist of 500,000 square feet of progressive office space in two buildings. Both projects are located on sites within Atlantic Station in the flourishing Midtown submarket.
Hines will work with Hartshorne Plunkard Architecture (HPA) as the design architect for both T3 West Midtown and Atlantic Yards. DLR Group will be t…