Skip to main content

Posts

Featured Post

Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park FAQ, timeline, and infographics (pinned post)

Details on AY housing point to 80/20 rentals, not condos, in a smaller Phase 1

As far back as May, developer Forest City Ratner was planning to convert at least one of the first three residential towers on the Atlantic Yards arena block from condos to rental housing, a recognition of the tough lending and consumer market for condos--and of the opportunities in gaining tax-exempt financing. That's the indication from a fact sheet prepared (but not actively distributed) to accompany the release in May of new designs for the arena block, as well as from news emanating from a meeting Monday between local officials and the Empire State Development Corporation. The fact sheet stated that the first of the three residential buildings, the 34-story, 350-unit B2 (in red), would have 50% affordable housing--and thus participate in the New York City Housing Development Corporation's (NYC HDC) 50/30/20 program, involving 50% market rate, 30% subsidized for middle- and moderate-income households, and 20% subsidized for low-income households. The fact sheet said nothin...

Looking at the NBA's (and Nets') history of inflated attendance figures

When I suggested that a 25 percent fudge factor should be applied to attendance at Nets games--and was criticized by the "homerest of homers " Bobbo/NetIncome/Mr. W. for lacking the expertise or metrics--it turns out that my eyeball estimate is close to the overstatement at other basketball arenas and for one of the Nets' highest-profile games. I should acknowledge that the Nets operation is no different from most others in professional sports, since teams routinely--as per league policy--announce tickets distributed rather than report actual gate count. Opening day, 2005 On opening day in 2005, the first full season Nets CEO Brett Yormark led the team, however, the Nets made a particular point of announcing a full house, and some media outlets bought it. The New York Times, in an 11/3/05 article headlined Sellout Crowd Sees the Nets Stumble , reported unskeptically: Judging by the sellout crowd -- the first for a home opener at Continental Arena since 1997 -- ...

Who's in control? Forest City and the indirect subsidy value of its "entitlements"

Even though the Atlantic Yards project may be in question , the toughest month for developer Forest City Ratner had to have been December 2006, when the project received two crucial approval votes. First, the board of the Empire State Development Corporation (ESDC), controlled by AY supporter Gov. George Pataki, approved the project ; that was expected, though the need to revise the Final Environmental Impact Statement meant that consultant AKRF--paid for by FCR, actually--had to work through Thanksgiving to get it all done before Pataki's administration left office. Then the Public Authorities Control Board (PACB)--the "three men in a room"--had to approve the project , and there was some (unfounded) suspense over whether Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver, who scotched the West Side Stadium, might vote no. Carrying costs & "entitlement" After that, Forest City Ratner gained its "entitlement," a word favored by Forest City Enterprises CEO Chuck Ra...

Was the Izod Center 81.6% full last night?

The announced attendance at the Izod Center last night, when the New Jersey Nets met the Houston Rockets, was 16,303 , meaning that the arena, which has an official capacity of 19,968 (and peaked last year at 19,990), was 81.6% full. ( Update : the New York Times called it "a generously announced 16,303.") This photograph from the first quarter shows a good number of seats full in part of the upper bowl--"there was some extra juice in the building," wrote the Record's Al Iannazzone--but many empty seats closer to the floor. Here are a couple of other photos (time taken unclear), plus one from near the game's end . Then again, with the NBA, official attendance does not refer to gate count but rather all tickets sold or distributed. That bolsters my estimate of a 25% fudge factor .

Genius or desperation (or both)? Nets unload 100,000 tickets via Saveology.com

Saveology.com™ , a consumer comparison-shopping portal based in Fort Lauderdale, FL, has announced "it has purchased 100,000 Nets ticket vouchers that are being distributed to charities, hospitals, and people in-need in the New York metropolitan area, as well as to Saveology.com customers." "During this sharp economic downturn we felt it was important to provide people with the opportunity to enjoy attending a Nets game on us," said Saveology.com CEO Benny Aboud in the press release. "This initiative also will enable our customers to attend Nets games and to receive future promotions, as well. We are thrilled with our partnership with the Nets as we continue our goal to help people. " (Emphasis added) Besides helping people, Saveology.com is seeking customer leads: those "who sign up for tickets will have the chance to receive beneficial information on how to save on their essential services, which include home phone service, Internet, wireless phone...

As analysts call Forest City Enterprises stock worthless, local elected officials get a vague update on Atlantic Yards

Yesterday, Brooklyn elected officials representing areas around the Atlantic Yards footprint met at the offices of the Empire State Development Corporation (ESDC) in Manhattan with ESDC officials and representatives of developer Forest City Ratner (FCR) for a status report on the project. The meeting came shortly after investment analysts at Morningstar brutalized parent company Forest City Enterprises (FCE) as essentially worthless, in an article headlined Five More Stocks with Zero Value: We'd prefer a pack of gum to these businesses . The analysis, which was picked up by the Washington Post (though not yet by the New York Times) hints at the pressure facing FCE and FCR officials to get Atlantic Yards going, ideally (from their perspective) with some additional government aid. Timetable uncertain I have only secondhand reports from the meeting, but it seems plausible that FCR officials would've said that, while they're committed to Atlantic Yards, they can't be certa...

Confidential but not at all correct: the latest AY footprint ownership map

Two years after the Empire State Development Corporation (ESDC) produced a deceptive map regarding the ownership and control of property within the Atlantic Yards footprint, developer Forest City Ratner (I believe) has produced an updated version of the map that maintains the deceptions and adds some more. Most notably, the developer's foothold has actually grown more tenuous, since FCR two years ago claimed it owned or controlled 90 percent of the land needed for the project, but the map now claims 86 percent, based spuriously on "recent acquisitions." It also omits the public streets that would be demapped for the project. The new map The following map, dated August 2008 and titled Brooklyn Arena and Atlantic Yards Block and Lot Map , was passed on by a reader. While I can't be certain of its provenance, the statement "All information is to the best of FCRC's knowledge" strongly suggests that the document was provided by the developer, or at least bas...

Sports Business Daily: Ratner a person to watch in 2009

Sports Business Daily recently listed eight people as People To Watch: Who Will Shape The Industry In The New Year? (subscribers only). The third name listed: NETS OWNER BRUCE RATNER: Everyone remains intrigued by the prospect of an NBA team in Brooklyn, but can Ratner fight back the legal opposition and a sour economy to pull off the Atlantic Yards project? Ratner's inclusion was notable, given that only one other sports team owner was part of the list. That suggests that the Brooklyn controversy is significantly on the national sports radar. The list Detroit Lions Vice Chair William Clay Ford Jr. Major League Baseball Network President and CEO Tony Pettiti Nets Owner Bruce Ratner NBA China CEO Tim Chen PGA Tour Executive VP & CMO Tom Wade U.S. Olympic Committee Chair Larry Probst U.S. Tennis Association Executive Director Gordon Smith Versus President Jamie Davis

Lupica on Yankee Stadium: "It's a wonderful lie" (and NY mag on "perversely perfect symbols")

Most of Daily News sports columnist Mike Lupica's column today, headlined It's a wonderful lie , concerns the revelations, many from his collegue, Metro columnist Juan Gonzalez, about the strange and sudden leap in the valuation of the land under Yankee Stadium. He writes: So how come no politician in New York except Rep. Richard Brodsky seems to be asking the questions and carrying the fight on this? Or maybe the cozy relationship between the Yankees and City Hall that began when Yankee groupie Rudy Giuliani was mayor was turned over to Bloomberg like a well-turned double play. As always with the current mayor, pay close attention to what he does, not what he says. And I'll add: And will any politician look closely at the valuation of the land under the Atlantic Yards arena, assuming the construction plan and issuance of tax-exempt bonds moves forward? In New York magazine In the year-end Reasons to Love New York 2008 issue, New York magazine's Chris Smith offers: 27. ...

As Columbia plan gets approved, a fight over blight and eminent domain emerges

Well, as the New York Times reported Friday, in an article headlined State Officials Approve Expansion by Columbia , the Empire State Development Corporation (ESDC), as expected, approved the Columbia University expansion project in West Harlem, aka Manhattanville. The vote, however, "came after two hours of impassioned testimony against the plan by more than two dozen people, including residents, local business owners and their lawyers." (I don't think testimony was allowed when the ESDC approved the Atlantic Yards plan two years ago. Post-Gargano progress?) Civil rights lawyer Norman Siegel, who represents Tuck-It-Away storage company owner Nick Sprayregen, the main (of two) landowners resisting eminent domain, said he'd file a lawsuit. Approval by the state's Public Authorities Control Board (PACB) is still necessary. Sponsor blight? The Times quoted Sprayregen: He claims that the university purposely blighted the area by buying up property and then neglecting...

Ouroussoff on boom-time architecture: "somewhere along the way that fantasy took a wrong turn"

In an essay headlined It Was Fun Till the Money Ran Out , scheduled for Sunday's paper but already online, New York Times architectural critic Nicolai Ouroussoff makes a backhanded reference to Atlantic Yards in a lament that, maybe, architecture during the boom years was focused on the wrong things. Ouroussoff writes: WHO knew a year ago that we were nearing the end of one of the most delirious eras in modern architectural history? What’s more, who would have predicted that this turnaround, brought about by the biggest economic crisis in a half-century, would be met in some corners with a guilty sense of relief? Before the financial cataclysm, the profession seemed to be in the midst of a major renaissance. Architects like Rem Koolhaas, Zaha Hadid, Frank Gehry, and Jacques Herzog and Pierre de Meuron, once deemed too radical for the mainstream, were celebrated as major cultural figures. And not just by high-minded cultural institutions; they were courted by developers who once sco...

With Senate candidate and transportation policy, new politics look like old politics

In some cases, the new politics seems a bit too much like the old politics, and some tangents connect to Atlantic Yards. Locally, the Kennedy coronation First, the ascension of Caroline Kennedy as the front-runner for the soon-to-be-free Senate seat in New York has already drawn the endorsement of Rupert Murdoch's New York Post, support from Mayor Mike Bloomberg, and will involve the influential consultants Knickerbocker SKD, who work for Bloomberg, Sen. Chuck Schumer, and--of course--Forest City Ratner. Wayne Barrett of the Village Voice laid it out , and NoLandGrab linked to a couple of pieces I've written about Knickerbocker SKD's propaganda for FCR and candidate Tracy Boyland. In the Times, Judith Warner deftly disagreed with those plumping for Kennedy. National transportation policy On the national scene, President-elect Barack Obama's appointment of Ray LaHood as transportation secretary has provoked dismay from sustainable transport and smart growth advocates,...

Good game, bad weather, low attendance for the Nets

Given that last night began the weekend and the New Jersey Nets were playing the Dallas Mavericks, to whom fading star Nets point guard Jason Kidd was traded earlier this year for emerging star Devin Harris (and more), the Izod Center should have drawn a crowd larger than the 15,621 average . However, due to some lousy weather, many people stayed home and the Nets drew an announced 9889 people to watch what Nets Daily described as Harris Scorches Kidd and Mavs , a sign that the trade has worked out quite well. (ESPN's Mark Stein says Harris , so far, is the league's Most Improved Player.) The AP reported : With so many seats unfilled, the Nets allowed fans sitting in the upper section to move to the lower bowl during a second-quarter timeout. (Pregame photo .) Is that the future of crowd management in low-attendance arenas ? I suspect it will be reserved for special cases, like last night. Otherwise it runs the risk of making those paying full freight feel like suckers.

Trouble spot: Nets' attendance should be on the NBA's (and Times's) radar

The New York Times today, in a Sports section article headlined In Some N.B.A. Arenas, the Crowds Are Thin , describes how, while National Basketball Attendance is flat and arenas are reported at 89% of capacity, at par with last season, some teams and cities are "trouble spots." At the top (or bottom) of the list is the Sacramento Kings: The Kings are suffering from the twin perils of a poor economy and poor play, with a 7-19 record and no certified stars. The problems are mirrored in Indianapolis, Philadelphia, Minneapolis, Charlotte, N.C., and Memphis, which comprise the bottom fifth of the N.B.A. attendance list. Missing from the article is any mention of the New Jersey Nets, which should be very close to that bottom fifth. Consider that the Indiana Pacers are drawing 14,180 fans, or 78.06% in an arena with the capacity of 18,165. The announced Nets' attendance is just a fraction better. As of today, the Nets are averaging 15,621 fans, or 78.14% in an arena with the...

Indirect subsidies: how Forest City Ratner might save another $8 million (and a whole lot more)

The New York Observer's scoop this week--that developer Forest City Ratner is seeking all sorts of ways to indirectly increase subsidies --was accompanied by a subtext: that AY's "projected returns were apparently very marginal," especially compared to other developments. That conclusion was based on an analysis of the project's internal rate of return (IRR); I pointed out that IRR is not profit, because it does not, for example, address Forest City's 5% development fee. Also, and equally important, neither set of documents cited--a report by KPMG and Forest City Ratner's own projections--fully account for all the subsidies and benefits the developer would gain. For example, I estimated last month that Forest City gained nearly $55 million when the city reimbursed the developer $100 million for property in the AY footprint for which it spent $103.5 million--but was more likely worth $158.1 million. And think I've identified another $8 million, given ...

Good timing, bad timing on AY naming rights deal, arena subcontractors, and construction materials

The Barclays Center naming rights deal for the Atlantic Yards arena, announced in January 2007 , was clearly good timing for the Nets, with a record deal reported at $400 million over 20 years. When Barclays announced its recommitment last month, neither the bank nor Forest City Ratner made clear that deal had been maintained at the same dollar value. I had suggested that Barclays had had some leverage to renegotiate . New pressure on naming rights Even with renogitiation, New York, as the country's media capital, offers an especially good platform for naming rights The AP reported December 15 that the New Orleans Hornets will not have an easy time selling naming rights. The source was none other than sports economist Andrew Zimbalist (who served as a paid consultant to Forest City Ratner, producing a spurious report on the fiscal impact of AY): "The advertising expenditure is going to have a lower payoff during a time of recession, especially during a time of severe recessi...

Heartwood Studios: digital storytelling used (still?) to market the Barclays Center

Heartwood Studios , which offers "Digital Storytelling® through Visual Extravaganza®!" is--or at least was--working on marketing the Barclays Center and suites there. In the illustration at right, the graphic of the Barclays Center has been widely circulated and the Nets Sales Center has at least opened; however, the rendering at bottom is new to me. (Click to enlarge) Is campaign paused? It's also a bit stale, which offers further evidence that the project is paused. The figure in the background of the graphic is point guard Jason Kidd, wearing number 5, who was traded to Dallas in February. Also, an anonymous commenter on NetsDaily said November 13 that "I happen to know they let go of almost ten key internal employees earlier this week and several that were selling for the new arena suites and seating." First, the Cowboys The East Bay Business Times explained last year that Heartwood gained attention with an animated presentation of the new stadium for the...

Would Gehry's staffers come back after the credit markets unfreeze?

The Architect's Newspaper warns against reading too much into Frank Gehry's laying off staff members working on the Atlantic Yards project. AN's Matt Chaban quotes Kermit Baker: "What we’re seeing, as a result of the credit freeze, is a lot of projects, even a lot of good projects, being put on hold. Once the credit markets begin to unfreeze, though, a lot of this work will come back." Baker was not speaking directly about AY, but Chaban suggests that situation could apply. That's plausible. Then again, Forest City Ratner could have been a lot more enthusiastic in talking about the issue. Why not say Gehry's on sabbatical? Chaban also warns not to read much into Gehry's unwillingness to comment, calling it par for the course. Olin vs. Gehry? The Architect's Newspaper reported last month that AY landscape architect Laurie Olin, said to be on sabbatical, may be at odds with Gehry: Even if Atlantic Yards does build a second phase with Olin on the ...

Hedge fund head says she's short on Forest City, which has a lot of debt coming due in 2009

In Trading the Real Estate Bounce on CNBC's Closing Bell yesterday, it's worth watching the segment to hear all the comments from Karen Finerman of Metropolitan Capital (a hedge fund ) about Forest City Enterprises. Where do you stand after the rate cut by the Federal Reserve, she was asked by Dylan Ratigan. "Generally, we are still short," she replied. "I don't really think that the Fed's action has materially changed the commercial real estate picture." How are you defining the commercial real estate picture, Ratigan asked. "Well, it really depends on the area, of course, and how levered, but things that have development projects," Finerman replied. "And a name that we're short is Forest City, FCE slash A is the ticker. This is one probably best known for the Atlantic Yards development, which is in Brooklyn, which is where the Nets will be playing. They were and touted themselves as a development company and now that’s not a b...

MTA: $1 billion refers to capital plan, not Atlantic Yards

No, the Metropolitan Transportation Authority does not expect $1 billion from Atlantic Yards, as reported erroneously by Reuters yesterday. As announced umpteen times, the authority would be paid $100 million cash for the Vanderbilt Yard. MTA spokesman Jeremy Soffin says that the reporter wasn't at the MTA meeting at issue. The MTA's 2005-2009 capital plan assumes $1 billion in asset sales, he says, "which obviously includes Hudson Yards, not just AY." Thus the reporter erred in attributing the $1 billion to one project. It took Reuters more than four hours to post a correction .