Skip to main content

Posts

Featured Post

Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park FAQ, timeline, and infographics (pinned post)

Puzzling: some units at "100% affordable" 535 Carlton are somehow labeled 549 Carlton

I wrote in March about how two middle-income units at the "100% affordable" 535 Carlton building were listed on StreetEasy with discounts. Those units are still available : a two-bedroom, two-bath unit, at an announced $3,223 rent, with one month free, generates a Net Effective Rent of $2,954 a studio at an announced $2,137 rent, with 1.5 months free, generates a Net Effective Rent of $1,870 A look on the 535 Carlton web site , however, shows not only those units but eight more apartments at the same building, though listed as 549 Carlton:  one studio, listed at $2,137 five one-bedrooms, listed at $2,457 two two-bedrooms, listed at $2,954 Other than the studio, which does not imply a discount, the other two represent a Net Effective Rent, with one month free.  (There's also a studio listed for the other "100% affordable" building, 38 Sixth, though no rent is listed.) It's not clear to me whether those listings are artifacts of previously rented units, or wh...

Atlantic Yards down the memory hole: why most of Block 1128, including Newswalk, was omitted from a "blighted" project footprint

I call it "Atlantic Yards down the memory hole" when journalists/authors, public officials, or government entities misreport or forget details of (or promises regarding) a project that has faced many gyrations since its announcement in 2003. We shouldn't hold regular people to the same standard, but it's still a learning moment. That third picture is behind my old apartment complex, the Newswalk, which was formerly the printing plant for the NY Daily News. I think it was the only condo/apartment building inside the Atlantic Yards footprint that was spared. — Adam Zimmerman (@Adam_Zimmerman) May 16, 2022 (He later clarified that it was the fourth photo.) So why is this important? As I responded , most of that block, Block 1128, was omitted from the project footprint, rather than included and later spared. But it's not wrong to presume that the Atlantic Yards footprint would have been a rational shape, rather than one with an odd gap in the center: most of the...

Atlantic Yards and the problem of time: rise in (regional) Area Median Income means "low-income" two-bedroom apartment could now rent for $1,500

It's always useful to try to encapsulate some conclusions about Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park when I lead a walking tour, as I did recently for a law school class. One conclusion is that a judge's 2010 ruling upholding condemnation of remaining properties needed to build the arena has been proven even more wrongheaded. "Whatever the pace may be, the nature of those [public] benefits remains the same," he wrote, upholding a contention by Empire State Development---the state authority that oversees/shepherds the project--that projections of tax revenues, jobs, housing, and open space were legitimate, though the predicted ten-year buildout had been extended to 25 years. As I wrote at the time, "can't the pace for the delivery of public benefits ultimately change their nature? In other words, affordable housing delivered over a decade is far different than housing delivered over 30 years. Ditto for tax revenues." The same goes for open space, given that the ...

Flashback: in 2013 NYC visit, Greenland's Chairman Zhang also met with Goldman's Blankfein and the Times Company's Sulzberger

Remember how Zhang Yuliang, Chairman of Greenland Holdings, wouldn't sign the deal to buy a majority interest in Atlantic Yards from Forest City Ratner/Forest City Enterprises without gaining an October 2013 meeting with then-Mayor Michael Bloomberg? Well, let's add two more photos to that odd photo of Zhang and Bloomberg (who didn't look that enthusiastic). Another Greenland press release, which I either didn't notice years ago or was added somewhat later, is dated 10/11/13 and headlined, according to the imperfect Google Translate version, Chairman Zhang Yuliang called on the CEO of Goldman Sachs and the Chairman of The New York Times . They "held talks on deepening cooperation between the two parties on a global scale," which I assume is the translated version of enthusiastic Chinese corporate boilerplate. Meeting with Goldman Zhang and Blankfein, via Greenland That said, Greenland was very enthusiastic, and attributed support from Goldman. Here's the ...

From the latest Construction Update: platform work is supposed to start soon (June, right?), but permits required first

The latest Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park Construction Update (bottom), covering the two weeks beginning Monday, May 16, was circulated Friday at 12:04 pm (lead time) by Empire State Development (ESD) after preparation by Greenland Forest City Partners (GFCP), which is dominated by Greenland USA.  There's no new work--hence nothing in red type in the document below, though some previous utility work has apparently finished. But the essential message is hurry up and wait. Though I wrote two weeks ago that work on the Block 1120 platform--between Atlantic Avenue and Pacific Street, and Carlton and Vanderbilt avenues--was supposed to start within the two-week period, that was subject to the receipt of necessary permits. And the new document similarly says that such work would start, subject to permits, we learned at a North Prospect Heights Association meeting (and then the Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park Quality of Life meeting ) that the work won't start until June. Utility work pendi...

Official notes from January and March Quality of Life meetings finally posted; mostly accurate, but in some cases downplay neighbors' concerns

Well, the timing is just a bit suspicious. As I wrote 5/11/22, reporting on the most recent Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park Quality of Life meeting, the official meeting notes from the previous two bi-monthly meetings had not been made available on the website of Empire State Development (ESD), the state authority that oversee/shepherds the project.    ESD's Tobi Jaiyesimi said they were "currently under review by the project team to ensure the accuracy of the information that we presented and what was summarized from the previous meetings." As I wrote, it's unclear why that review now takes so much longer than previously. It also hampers the ability of meeting attendees to see a quick official summation of the previous meeting. And, I should add, it limits the ability to follow up on issues that might have been downplayed. Jaiyesimi said the meeting notes should be on the ESD's project website within the next week, and indeed they were  (also at bottom) ; I noticed ...

In slide from recent meeting, a new view of B4 tower, plus the site for the future B5

OK, sometime in the past few days Empire State Development (ESD), the state authority that oversees/shepherds the Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park project, posted the presentation from the 5/10/22 Quality of Life meeting, which I've added below, and also to  my coverage  the next morning.    There isn't much revealing in the slideshow, but I have excerpted, at right, one slide, which is a helicopter perspective, looking west/southwest, at the western end of the railyard and the B4 tower (aka 18 Sixth Ave., or Brooklyn Crossing), which flanks the Barclays Center. The arrow, which I added, points to the location of the planned B5 tower, the first one over the railyard. The railyard platform is expected to start next month. I suspect at least one foundation for the tower will also be installed by the June 15 deadline to qualify for the current 421-a tax break. The tower is expected to go vertical next year, and should take two years to build. B5 is slated to be about 77% of ...

Barclays Center plaza access to be limited (extent: unclear) June-Sept. for renovation work on pavers and lighting; subway entrance to remain accessible

This is the second of two articles about last night's Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park Quality of Life meeting. The first concerned the limited updates on platform construction, with no major project updates. In a brief presentation, Barclays Center's Mandy Gutmann, Executive Vice President, Communications and Community Relations, talked up the start of the New York Liberty's WNBA season ("a really fun family environment") and the Brooklyn Nets' renovation of a community center in Red Hook (more on that below). But her "one update from an operational standpoint" sounded significant. This summer, the arena operating company--remember, the building is technically owned by the state, to enable tax-exempt financing--plans paver and lighting updates "on our plaza," Gutmann said. (The privately controlled public space is officially the SeatGeek Plaza, named for the arena company's ticketing partner.) After all, those paving stones might be worn, ...

At bi-monthly meeting, developer/ESD avoid big questions about project (affordable housing deadline); fencing around platform work to last three years

This is the first of two articles about last night's Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park Quality of Life meeting. (Updated 4/13/22 with slides, at bottom.) The second concerned Barclays Center issues, including truncated access to the plaza. Sometimes the bi-monthly Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park Quality of Life meetings elicit some candor about the future of the project. But often, like last night, they don't. At last night's virtual meeting, which lasted barely 35 minutes and attracted just 15 attendees, representatives of developer Greenland USA and Empire State Development (ESD), the state authority that oversee/shepherds the project, focused mainly on plans to erect fencing around the first of two railyard blocks for the platform needed for vertical development.  None of the project's big questions, such as the 2025 affordable housing deadline, were addressed. Much of that information had been disclosed at a meeting the night before (my coverage ) of the North Prospect Heigh...

As construction starts for platform at first railyard block, pedestrian & traffic flow limited; parking truncated; questions about work hours, trucks, sanitation

The most important news, in my view , from last night's appearance of a Greenland USA executive at a meeting of the North Prospect Heights Association regarded the timetable for construction of the first phase of the platform, the first tower (B5), and the question marks over the remaining project. But Scott Solish was there to talk to the project's immediate neighbors about the significant changes to traffic and pedestrian flow from the establishment of construction fences around the perimeter of the first block of the MTA's Vanderbilt Yard, between Atlantic Avenue and Pacific Street, and Sixth and Carlton avenues. This could last three years. Both topics likely will be amplified at tonight's public, online  Quality of Life meeting , hosted at 6 pm by Empire State Development (ESD), the state authority that oversees/shepherds the project. Another close-up view of Block 1120 was also shown; see below Solish, the head of development for Greenland USA, noted he was approa...

Developer: B5 tower won't rise until Spring 2023, finish 2025; next rely on (unresolved) 421-a replacement; →more doubts re 2025 affordable housing deadline

Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park is moving ahead, belatedly, with plans to build a platform over the first of two railyard blocks, which will support three towers--but there are still significant clouds over the potential progress. Last night, a representative of developer Greenland USA appeared at an online meeting of the North Prospect Heights Association (NPHA), mainly to talk about the coming changes to neighborhood traffic and pedestrian flow (separate article coming) from construction at the first block of the MTA's Vanderbilt Yard, between Atlantic Avenue and Pacific Street and Sixth and Carlton avenues. That means construction of a platform and the start of the first of three towers, B5, at the western end of that block. It was a rare public appearance by a Greenland representative at a neighborhood meeting, separate from the bi-monthly public meetings hosted by Empire State Development (ESD), the state authority that oversees/shepherds the project. At far left, B4, already buil...

From City & State: the Tsais, who own the Brooklyn Nets, at #27 among NYC's "Asian 100"

From City & State NY, 5/2/22,  The 2022 Power of Diversity: Asian 100 , subtitled "New York’s Asian American trailblazers": 27. Joseph Tsai & Clara Wu Tsai Co-Owners, Brooklyn Nets Joseph Tsai / BSE Global This power couple found massive success in retail – Joseph Tsai as co-founder of Chinese retail giant Alibaba Group, Clara Wu Tsai as former Hong Kong general manager of Taobao, the largest online shopping site in China. They share both ownership of the Brooklyn Nets – which boasts superstars such as Kevin Durant and Kyrie Irving on its roster – and a commitment to philanthropy, dedicating $50 million to their Social Justice Fund, which works toward racial justice and economic mobility for minority communities in Brooklyn. Hmm, no mention of the turmoil regarding the Nets or Joe Tsai's reflexive support for the Chinese regime.  But it would be worth mentioning that they also own the New York Liberty, which, with lower ticket prices and a potentially broad fan ...

Former Nets/arena CEO Yormark on delayed move to Brooklyn ("I was a little naive") & signing Islanders ("we didn't know some of the dynamics going in")

"The Jon Schultz Podcast unpacks the lessons from industry leaders who refused to quit," so check below as Schultz, Co-Founder at Onyx Equities, Real Estate Investor, CRE Tech Influencer + Investor, interviews Brett Yormark, founding CEO of the Brooklyn Nets/Barclays Center operating company and now leading Roc Nation . There are a couple of nuggets in there, including Yormark's belated/partial admission of a few misjudgments, but he's not about to go too deep.     Moving to Brooklyn The segment embedded above begins with the host asking Yormark about his biggest challenge. Yormark: "So my biggest challenge was... and I kind of knew this going in, but maybe wasn't crystal clear, when I took the job as the CEO of the Nets, it was with the caveat that the team was moving to Brooklyn. I didn't know much about real estate, eminent domain, and the challenges and moving the team to Brooklyn. "I just knew that that was the ultimate goal." "So ...