Skip to main content

Posts

Featured Post

Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park FAQ, timeline, and infographics (pinned post)

Exclusive: New audio of arena project presentation shows NYCRC principals making same deceptive claims they admit their Asian affiliates should avoid

It's stunning how George Olsen, managing principal of the New York City Regional Center (NYCRC), could profess to be shocked, shocked that the firm's affiliates in Asia are deceptively marketing green cards in exchange for investments in Atlantic Yards. As Reuters reported last week: At a recent seminar in Seoul, an agent for the Kookmin Migration Consulting Co., working on behalf of the New York City Regional Center, told would-be investors if they invested in the company's latest project their permanent green cards were "guaranteed." He also implied the investors would be financing the construction of the new home for the New Jersey Nets NBA basketball team. In a subsequent interview with Reuters, George Olsen, managing principal of the New York City Regional Center acknowledged the claims were "not accurate" - the investors will finance the rebuilding of a rail yard and some related infrastructure near the new basketball court -- and promised he ...

In review, Vitullo-Martin says Encyclopedia of New York City entry on Atlantic Yards is "almost laughable"

In her review of the new edition of The Encyclopedia of New York City in the New York Post, Julia Vitullo-Martin mostly praises it, but finds that it runs aground in spots: The seemingly neutral, non-judgmental tone combined with the persistent use of the passive voice can become grating, even counter-productive. To write, for example, that the Atlantic Yards development in Brooklyn “encountered opposition from neighborhood residents concerned about potential crowds and traffic” is almost laughable. It’s rather like saying General Custer encountered a few Indians. In this instance, the courts have consistently ruled that the deeply subsidized project can go forward, but whether or not the project will ever get built is far from clear. My own guess is that the Indians — subdued by the courts though they have been — will triumph in the end. I don't think the Indians will triumph in the sense of blocking the arena, though it's possible a judge may require additional findings re...

From Planetizen: 10 Urban Planning Songs (plus two Atlantic Yards additions)

In 10 Urban Planning Songs , Planetizen's Abhijeet Chavan offers links, lyrics, and videos, including: I can't think of a more concise criticism of planning decisions than these incisive lyrics from Joni Mitchell's 1970 hit Big Yellow Taxi: They paved paradise And put up a parking lot In this live version she sings an extra verse: Late last night I heard the screen door slam And a big yellow tractor Came and took away my house, it took away my land Some following Atlantic Yards may remember that Mitchell's song, performed by John Wesley Harding, was a hit at Develop Don't Destroy Brooklyn's October 2006 walkathon . More songs, two on Atlantic Yards Chavan's list includes The Pretenders' "My City Was Gone" and Billy Joel's "Allentown," while readers add such songs as The Jam's "The Planner's Dream Goes Wrong" and Jay-Z's and Alicia Keys's "Empire State of Mind." In a comment , I suggested a coupl...

In novel Prospect Park West, "Atlantic Yards" is a screenplay about terrorism and a character has the arena on the brain

Amy Sohn's dishy novel Prospect Park West , optioned to be a mini-series starring Sarah Jessica Parker, has gotten lots of buzz for her satirical take on motherhood and Park Slope, with the park, the food co-op, the Park Slope Parents listserv, house envy, and more serving as the backdrop. (See local reviews pro and con from FIPS and OTBKB .) There are numerous real people and places in the book, but Atlantic Yards watchers may notice a few stretches: Lizzie and Jay's brick walk-up [on Park Place] was between Vanderbilt and Underhill, in the footprint of the developer Bruce Ratner's proposed Nets arena, which meant that it might be knocked down in order to build the arena. Actually, the project footprint doesn't go beyond Dean Street south to Park Place, nor does it go east of Vanderbilt Avenue. Atlantic Yards, the film? More entertaining is the name of the screenplay being written by Stuart Ashby, an Australian actor married to Melora Leigh, a Park Slope super-coup...

In the Brooklyn Paper, editor insists that the newspaper's covering Atlantic Yards

In a very interesting phone interview ( Vito speaks — sort of! ) with Vito Lopez, in which the beleaguered Assemblyman urges the Brooklyn Paper to cover affordable housing issues--good idea--editor Gersh Kuntman asks,"Assemblyman do you really think we aren’t covering the Brooklyn Bridge Park and Atlantic Yards and other issues?" Lopez says he doesn't read the paper, but I do, and I can say--sorry to sound like a broken record--that the Brooklyn Paper doesn't cover Atlantic Yards all that much any more. Yes, there's some good stuff about the census in this week's issue , and the Paper covers Atlantic Yards news when it emerges via press release and yes, it's shorthanded, but... Did the Brooklyn Paper cover the Empire State Development Corporation board meeting December 16 in which a 25-year project buildout was deemed not to have significant impacts or the subsequent court hearing December 22? Nope.

In Reuters investigation of EB-5 program, NYC Regional Center principal admits lies in arena project pitch, but blames affiliates. That's not so.

A major investigation of the EB-5 immigration visa program by Reuters, Special report: Overselling the American dream overseas , turns up numerous reasons for skepticism and an admission by a principal of the New York City Regional Center (NYCRC) that potential investors have been lied to about the Brooklyn Arena and Infrastructure project. Astonishingly, however, the NYCRC's George Olsen gets away with blaming immigration brokers in foreign lands--in this case, Korea, not China--rather than acknowledging, or being forced to acknowledge, that the same statements have been made, in documents and on video, by the NYCRC itself. In South Korea Reuters reports: At a recent seminar in Seoul, an agent for the Kookmin Migration Consulting Co., working on behalf of the New York City Regional Center, told would-be investors if they invested in the company's latest project their permanent green cards were "guaranteed." He also implied the investors would be financing t...

The dialogue (imagined) behind yesterday's court non-drama; what if someone challenged Justice Friedman on the Development Agreement?

I wasn't privy to the discussions among lawyers yesterday before state Supreme Court Justice Marcy Friedman, so I don't think this was the discussion that led to the lifting of a request for a stay on project construction . I suspect the discussion was far more limited and politic. But this is what might have happened had there been a law clerk in the room raising inconvenient arguments. Dramatis personae include: State Supreme Court Justice Marcy Friedman (MF) Develop Don't Destroy Brooklyn attorney Jeff Baker (JBa) BrooklynSpeaks attorney Al Butzel (AB) Empire State Development Corporation Phil Karmel (PK) Forest City Ratner attorney Jeffrey Braun (JBr) Friedman's imaginary, impudent law clerk (LC) MF: OK, so you asked for a stay-- JBa: Right. MF: Until they completed a response and they-- PK: Did just that . We submitted it. AKRF works very fast. AB: We just think it's vastly inadequate . They completely ignored the real impacts of 25 years of construction. JBa:...

The Observer's Power 150: many Atlantic Yards connections, with Prokhorov somehow well ahead of Ratner

The New York Observer has issued its "purely subjective" ranking of the city's Power 150 , and it's worth a look to see how many intersections there are with Atlantic Yards. In the top 50 , Mayor Mike Bloomberg is #1, while Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver ranks #9, and Kathryn Wylde, CEO, Partnership for New York City, snags the #11 spot. Wylde testified for Atlantic Yards, while Department of City Planning Director Amanda Burden, at #30, played a peripheral role. At #38 comes Mikhail Prokhorov, pictured with a Nets logo in the background; he "embodies a new Russian elite swarming the city." Well, billionaires embody things slightly differently than the rest of the world, but it's hard to think Prokhorov has more local juice than a developer like Bruce Ratner who's built relationships over decades. Prokhorov's billboard partner, Jay-Z, ranks #46, cited for remaining "a relevant musician while commanding a growing empire worth almost half a b...

Atlantic Yards down the memory hole: "Isn't it crazy how such a big piece of prime Brooklyn land was left empty until this project came along?"

From Curbed, Atlantic Yards Actually Looks Like Something Now : Isn't it crazy how such a big piece of prime Brooklyn land was left empty until this project came along? (Photo via Tom Kaminski/WCBS 880.) Well, there was a working railyard at the northern half of the arena site (the bottom of the photo at right), which had to be put up for sale--not that Forest City Ratner didn't have the inside track to get the railyard, and to get the deal renegotiated. And there were three rows of buildings, on Dean and Pacific streets, as well at along Flatbush Avenue, at the southern half of the arena site. I suspect we're going to see a lot more of this. Below, a reminder, from photographer Tracy Collins .

No stay on construction, as petitioners in timetable case agree to withdraw motion in light of ESDC's report; will file new motion next month

There will be no stay on Atlantic Yards construction for now and, given the momentum of time, the bar grows higher. Two community coalitions sought a stay on some if not all Atlantic Yards construction because of the Empire State Development Corporation's (ESDC) failure to analyze the impact of a 25-year construction schedule. But last week, the ESDC issued findings that no Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS) is necessary and, while petitioners Develop Don't Destroy Brooklyn and BrooklynSpeaks consider that analysis vastly inadequate, it was too soon to argue that in court. So, in a very brief hearing today before state Supreme Court Justice Marcy Friedman in New York County Supreme Court, the parties--the petitioners as well as the defendants, the ESDC and Forest City Ratner--agreed that the request for a stay would be withdrawn. "They acted last week," BrooklynSpeaks attorney Al Butzel said of the ESDC decision, "and there's a presumption...

The Atlantic Yards timetable, and the significance of a decade unstudied

As I wrote 12/15/10, noting that the Empire State Development Corporation (ESDC) did consider a potential five-year delay in the Atlantic Yards timetable, ESDC attorney Philip Karmel stated in a legal affirmation: Remarkably, the five-year legal battle over Atlantic Yards has thus come down to this: a dispute as to whether the 2009 Technical Memorandum should have assumed a 25-year build out instead of a 15-year build out in its analysis of the environmental impacts of a market-driven delay in the schedule for the Project's development. He seemed to be suggesting that ten years is an insignificant interval, even for an interim surface parking lot. The timetable case will be heard today at noon in Manhattan Supreme Court before state Supreme Court Justice Marcy Friedman, at 60 Centre Street , IAS MOTION Part 57, Room 335 . The significance of a decade As for Karmel's statement, it all depends on perspective, right? Consider some alternatives in which the difference between 15 ...

A developer (not Ratner) described as "in full marketing mode"

There was an unusually skeptical close to an article in yesterday's New York Times headlined Council Approves West Side Apartment Towers : Work on the new buildings may not begin until 2012, the developer said. “It will be the capstone for the newest and most vibrant neighborhood in the city,” Mr. [Gary] Barnett said, in full marketing mode. What about AY? If only reporter Charles Bagli made similar observations when he covered Atlantic Yards. Consider this quote from an 11/25/09 Times article headlined Ruling Lets Atlantic Yards Seize Land : Mr. Ratner called the court’s ruling a “light-switch” kind of decision for the long-stalled project. “I look at this as the last major hurdle; now we can proceed as we’ve wanted to for the last three years,” he said on Tuesday. “The courts have made it clear that this project represents a significant public benefit for the people of Brooklyn and the entire city.” As I pointed out at the time, the courts had not made such a thing clear; they d...

In timetable case, petitioners say ESDC's "illegal" actions shouldn't be rewarded; FCR argues against stay, but, if granted, bond should be $100M

In the courtroom argument tomorrow over the request in a stay in Atlantic Yards construction and a re-evaluation of potential project impacts over 25 years, the battle seems to be this: Can charges of bad procedure and dereliction of duty overcome the facts of an official document in hand and ongoing construction--construction that developer Forest City Ratner thinks requires a $100 million (well-nigh impossible for community groups) to pause? The hearing will be at noon in Manhattan Supreme Court before state Supreme Court Justice Marcy Friedman, at 60 Centre Street , IAS MOTION Part 57, Room 335 . Friedman made a preliminary ruling November 9 that the Empire State Development Corporation (ESDC) make "findings on the impact of the Development Agreement and of the renegotiated MTA agreement on its continued use of a 10 year build-out for the Project, and on whether a Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement [SEIS] is required or warranted." (The Development Agr...

Number of construction jobs should peak at 600 (plus "hundreds" offsite), says FCR; however, ESDC in 2006 estimated 3710, in 2009 predicted 1954

How many construction workers will be working on the Atlantic Yards site? According to an affidavit (p. 244 of the document below) by Forest City Ratner executive MaryAnne Gilmartin that's part of the case challenging the Atlantic Yards timetable, the Number of workers will rise to about 600 or more when construction activities reach their peak: Under the current schedule for building the arena, the census of approximately 120 union workers who are actually employed at the site is expected to increase dramatically, and will rise to about 600 or more when construction activities reach their peak. And there are hundreds of other workers now employed for the Project off-site. Previous estimates That's far fewer than the Empire State Development Corporation (ESDC) predicted in 2006 and again just last year. The Technical Memorandum issued in June 2009 by the ESDC offers quarter-by-quarter construction jobs estimates over an elapsed time of 13 years, as shown below. The peak, ...

DDDB attorney: ESDC denied documents before board meeting, conducted illegal session, admitted role as "rubber-stamp"

In a legal affirmation (embedded below) in the case regarding the Atlantic Yards timetable, Jeff Baker, attorney for Develop Don't Destroy Brooklyn, takes aim at the Empire State Development Corporation's (ESDC) board meeting last Thursday, saying the ESDC denied the public access to documents and conducted an illegal meeting. Baker states: Nevertheless, it is important for the Court to understand the extent of the deliberations by the ESDC Board of Directors to understand the cursory review they conducted and recognize that instead of customary deference, ESDC's actions should generate skepticism and the Court should grant the stay pending a final review of ESDC's compliance with SEQRA [State Environmental Quality Review Act]. Where's the report? Anticipating that the ESDC would prepare a report complying with Supreme Court Justice Marcy Friedman's ruling and thus indicating that a 25-year project buildout would not be unduly burdensome, Baker sought such docu...

When will the arena open? The goalposts are already shifting slightly, thanks to "current schedule disputes"

When is the Barclays Center arena expected to open? According to an affidavit from Forest City Ratner executive MaryAnne Gilmartin, arguing against any stay in construction, work is carefully timed so the arena can be finished by the summer of 2012 so it then be "commissioned" to open for the basketball season in October 2012. However, there are apparently some delays in the schedule separate from any potential delays caused by litigation, as consultants report, detailed below. It's also unclear when an arena not-yet-commissioned for basketball could open before the season to accommodate concerts (such as for Jay-Z) and other events, though presumably such events are planned and basketball is the most complicated to stage. The statement, and a precursor On p. 241 of the file at bottom (p. 30 of Gilmartin's affidavit), she states: All of the various construction-related activities described above are part of a carefully developed and very intricate sequence of work t...