Skip to main content

Posts

Featured Post

Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park FAQ, timeline, and infographics (pinned post)

In latest city lobbying report, real estate firm Cirrus reports targeting Mayor's office, NYC EDC, and NYCHA. That suggests it's (also) looking beyond Atlantic Yards.

I wrote July 11 ( link ) that Cirrus Real Estate Partners, which is expected to lead a pending joint venture to develop the rest of Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park, has not only used its own staff to lobby, but last month hired the major lobbying firm Bolton-St. Johns. Cirrus's reports  on state lobbying, from March through June, indicate--as I've previously reported --that it has lobbied Attorney General Letitia James, Assemblymember Jo Anne Simon, state Sen. Jabari Brisport, Comptroller Thomas DiNapoli, and various ESD executives, regarding state land use, entitlements, and tax abatements. Those are key to the finances of the future project. Cirrus's lobbying report to New York City indicates that, in March-April, its staffers lobbied three people in the Mayor's office (Senior Advisor Nate Bliss, Seth Bynum, Leila Bozorg), Comptroller Brad Lander, Borough President Antonio Reynoso, and Council Members Shahana Hanif and Crystal Hudson. That clearly was related to Atlantic...

After press conference and letter from elected officials, BrooklynSpeaks launches petition asking NY State to enforce penalties for missing affordable housing

New York State could have started collecting more than $1.75 million a month in damages starting June 1, given the failure of Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park developers to deliver 876 (of 2,250) promised affordable housing units, but it hasn't, instead suspending the penalties while it negotiates with a new developer. That new joint venture apparently involves Cirrus Real Estate Partners, Fortress Investment Group, an affiliate of the U.S. Immigration Fund (USIF),  the firm LCOR, and existing developer Greenland USA, surely will seek to revise obligations and gain concessions, while likely making new promises of deferred public benefits. New petition The coalition BrooklynSpeaks, which in a 2014 settlement gained that commitment of $2,000/month damages for each missing unit, has previously protested the failure of enforcement (but hasn't yet pursued a lawsuit) and helped  influenced local elected officials in  writing  Gov. Kathy Hochul and Empire State Development (ES...

BSE Global CEO Zussman: Barclays Center should offer a "Brooklyn DNA-based experience." (OK, sure.) Says Tsais are "long-term builders."

A recent brief interview on the Bloomberg Businesweek Daily  podcast  featured BSE Global's CEO Sam Zussman. The summary: BSE Global, the parent company of the NBA's Brooklyn Nets, the WNBA's New York Liberty, as well as their home arena, Barclays Center, has built a business model across sports, entertainment, hospitality and media. The company believes that its array of multiple businesses enables it to enjoy operational leverage and extract cross-functional synergies. Sam Zussman, CEO of BSE Global, explains how Brooklyn's unique culture and history make it the ideal home base for the "experiential" powerhouse. Sam speaks with Tim Stenovec, Emily Graffeo and Randall Williams on Bloomberg Businessweek Daily. They didn't explain cross-functional synergies, but perhaps we'll see that as, for example, the Planet Brooklyn festival emerges next month. Event total Zussman described the arena as "open roughly 190 nights a year." Is that accurate?...

Atlantic Yards CDC advisory meeting cancelled for lack of a quorum, but the topics could've been/could be discussed publicly, right?

Yesterday's scheduled meeting of the (purportedly) advisory Atlantic Yards Community Development Commission (AY CDC)--my preview --was cancelled at the last minute, due to the lack of a quorum, and will be rescheduled. It wasn't the first time. The AY CDC has eleven listed Directors , but a couple have checked out, a few attend more sporadically, and, of course, it's not easy to get people together in the summer.  The board is supposed to have 14 Directors , as established in a 2014 settlement between the state and the BrooklynSpeaks coalition, but it's been difficult to fill those slots, especially the nine gubernatorial appointees. While some Directors have pressed the parent Empire State Development (ESD), the state authority that oversees/shepherds the project, for more information, the board is too often disregarded or disengaged. One example: why didn't ESD explain, at the previous AY CDC meeting, why the "Pacific Park" open space needed work, as I ...

How could 303-unit 38 Sixth Avenue open without an on-site super, but rather one 1,100+ feet away? Has it been out of compliance for eight years?

This is the first of two articles about 38 Sixth Avenue. Last July 24, City Limits published my article about troubles at 38 Sixth Avenue (B3),  Despite New Owner’s Promised Upgrades, ‘100% Affordable’ Atlantic Yards Building Endures Hot Water Outages, Broken Door, Even Bees . While some of the problems mentioned have been addressed, albeit belatedly, new issues have emerged, which I'll write about separately.  Still, a fundamental question persists about 38 Sixth, which was built by Greenland Forest City Partners, the joint venture involving Greenland USA and original developer Forest City Ratner, and opened in 2017.  (The building, along with similar "100% affordable" 535 Carlton Avenue, was sold by the joint venture in May 2022 to Irvine, CA-based Avanath Capital Management.) Looking south at 38 Sixth. Photo: Norman Oder Why no super? How could a 23-story building with 303 apartments open without an on-site superintendent?  It was never a secret, but evidence sugg...

Agenda for Atlantic Yards meeting: "public engagement process planning." Also, developer Cirrus ramps up lobbying, both city and state.

So Empire State Development (ESD)  has released the Agenda for the July 15 meeting of the purportedly advisory Atlantic Yards Community Development Corporation (AY CDC), and the scope is beyond what I suspected when I initially wrote about it. While ESD, the state authority that oversees/shepherds the project, may (as I suspect) announce that it has approved a permitted developer for at least the railyard development parcels--a joint venture involving Cirrus Real Estate and others--it also will discuss "Public Engagement Process Planning, as shown in the screenshot at right. That sounds like the outline to a process, aiming to find a way to ensure legitimacy to a project that now faces widely embedded skepticism.  AY CDC Director Gib Veconi had previously asked, backed by a board majority, to request a review of the scope before it's finalized. (Note that the meeting is at 3 pm, not 3:30 pm, as initially stated.) Also, as explained below, Cirrus has ramped up lobbying with s...

As new Trump Kings County Republican Club slams Atlantic Yards for "systemic failure," remember: it's bipartisan (& developer Trump worked the system, duh)

Atlantic Yards has had its history of strange bedfellows, such as when opponents of the project allied themselves with libertarians challenging eminent domain. (Well, liberal jurisprudence, especially in New York, has stood for unfettered power for condemnors, including dubious "blight.")   Another example recently surfaced in this harsh tweet from the new, Bay Ridge-based Donald J. Trump Kings County Republican Club : The criticism is valid: Atlantic Yards was supposed to bring 2,250 affordable units to Brooklyn. Fast-forward nearly two decades... and 876 units are still missing. What’s the solution? Extend the deadline. Postpone the fines. Bend the rules. The people of Brooklyn were promised real homes. Instead, they’re getting real estate bait-and-switch. Let’s be clear: Penalties were meant to protect the public. Now they’re being “paused” to protect the developer. And you wonder why trust in government is gone? This is what systemic failure looks like, dressed in bu...

Something's brewing. (A new permitted developer?) State sets July 15 for meeting of advisory Atlantic Yards Community Development Corporation.

Note: despite initial conflicting information, the meeting will start at 3 pm, not 3:30 pm. More than six weeks state officials suspended a deadline to enforce $2,000/month penalties for each of the remaining 876 (of 2,250) required Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park affordable housing units, saying they wanted to see a new proposal from a new development team, a moment of (perhaps limited) transparency may emerge. Empire State Development (ESD), the state authority that oversees/shepherds the project, has set a July 15 meeting of the (purportedly) advisory Atlantic Yards Community Development Corporation (AY CDC) at a Brooklyn location, thus more accessible for Brooklynites, though it is during the workday.  No agenda has been released; such agendas are typically opaque and released closer to the meeting date. The meeting will be: Shirley A. Chisholm State Office Building, 55 Hanson Place – 3rd Floor Conference Room, Brooklyn,  Tuesday, July 15, 3 :30 pm Due to purported building ...

How a ethically dubious Emirati sheikh and the investment fund he chairs own, via Fortress, a slice of Atlantic Yards

A June 29 New York Times article,  The Sheikh Who Conquered Soccer and Coddles Warlords , offers a skeptical portrait of the enigmatic Sheikh Mansour bin Zayed al-Nahyan, whose older brother rules the United Arab Emirates. About the younger one: The Emirati vice president is best known as the owner of Manchester City, a top English soccer team. Behind the scenes, he has been described as the “handler” guiding his country’s secret foreign wars. More on that: Yet in interviews with more than a dozen American, African and Arab officials, he is described as being at the sharp end of his country’s aggressive push to expand its influence across Africa and the Middle East. In places like Libya and Sudan, they say, Sheikh Mansour has coddled warlords and autocrats as part of a sweeping Emirati drive to acquire ports and strategic minerals, counter Islamist movements and establish the Gulf nation as a heavyweight regional power. The Fortress connection From the Times: As deputy prime m...