Skip to main content

Posts

Featured Post

Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park FAQ, timeline, and infographics (pinned post)

Looking back at the unanticipated impacts of the Downtown Brooklyn rezoning

It’s well-known that the 2004 Downtown Brooklyn rezoning resulted in some very different outcomes than expected, given that the hot residential real estate market, coupled with changes in the back-office needs of large companies in Manhattan, made it far more lucrative to build luxury housing (and hotels) than the office space (and jobs) that the rezoning was intended to foster. A new report, Downtown Brooklyn’s Detour: The Unanticipated Impacts of Rezoning and Development on Residents and Businesses, prepared by the Pratt Center for Community Development for FUREE (Families United for Racial and Economic Equality), points out how much has changed in four years, raising concerns about the displacement of lower-income retail and residential tenants. It doesn’t suggest particular strategies, however. (Solutions aren’t simple; perhaps that’ll be another report.) The report does remind us that an EIS (environmental impact statement) is hardly infallible, as we’ve also learned in the case...

Higher-resolution arena renderings suggest how close glass would be to the street

The 2008 edition of the New York Post's Brooklyn Tomorrow advertorial reproduces Frank Gehry renderings already in the Image Gallery on the Atlantic Yards web site, but the higher-resolution versions in the publication offer a clear reminder: the arena's glass walls would be quite close to the street, raising security concerns. (Click to enlarge.) Remember, last fall, only after much prodding by the New York Times , Forest City Ratner acknowledged that the arena would be just 20 feet from the street at Flatbush Avenue and Atlantic Avenue, [ corrected : closer than 25 feet] in Newark, where officials have decided to close streets during arena events. The Times posed a question that lingers: What makes the Atlantic Yards arena sufficiently different from the Newark arena that it will not require street closings? Setbacks too short Alan Rosner, who wrote a July 2005 White Paper, titled Terrorism, Security and the Proposed Brooklyn Atlantic Yards. High Rise and Arena Development ...

At MCNY panel, defending dissent and promoting the better way to develop (not like Atlantic Yards)

A panel discussion last Thursday night held at the Museum of the City of New York was supposed to focus on the Westway proposal of the 1970s and the transformation of the Huntington Hartford Museum at Columbus Circle into the Museum of Art and Design. But the Civic Talk, sponsored by Henry Stern’s New York Civic and titled “What If? Battles Over Development,” was notable for some rhetorical disagreement about the nature of civic opposition and some strong opinions on the right way to develop in New York. And Atlantic Yards came up not as a good example but as something to be avoided. Channeling Moses In an echo of some of the Robert Moses revisionism that has surfaced in the past few years, Adrian Benepe , the city’s Commissioner of Parks & Recreation, set the stage by wondering whether some great public works produced by master builder/power broker Moses, such as Orchard Beach, Jones Beach, and 11 public pools, could be built today. It will cost hundreds of millions of dollars, ...

Asking feds not to approve tax-exempt bonds for AY arena, DDDB criticizes city/state letter

In a letter (right), Develop Don’t Destroy Brooklyn (DDDB) has urged the Department of the Treasury and the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) not to believe the 5/8/08 letter (below) sent to them by the New York City Industrial Development Agency (IDA) and the Empire State Development Corporation (ESDC) urging that federal government allow PILOTs (payments in lieu of taxes) to be used for the planned Atlantic Yards arena. Some of those criticisms were first reported in this blog: the letter overstates how much land Atlantic Yards developer Forest City Ratner actually controls and it fails to point out that, at least according to available evidence, the foregone property tax might be much less than the anticipated PILOT payment. Also, DDDB points out that the city and state overstate the amount of progress achieved on the project. Closing the “loophole” The chief counsel of the IRS has said the agency wishes to close a “loophole” that allowed use of PILOTs to pay back tax-exempt bonds f...

On the new Yankee Stadium, two very different calculations in the NY Times (Zimbalist vs. deMause)

From a 1/22/06 op-ed in the New York Times by sports economist Andrew Zimbalist, headlined Fair Ball : The Yankees are proposing a fair financial deal to the city. Nationally, during the last 15 years, the public share in stadium development costs (that is, the stadium plus roads, utilities and so forth) for professional sports has averaged around 75 percent. The Yankees are planning to spend $800 million of their own money on the new stadium (no major league baseball team has spent more than $300 million on their own playing field). The city and state together will spend about $210 million for improvements in the neighborhood. By this reckoning, the public share is only about 21 percent. A different view From a 7/17/08 essay by Tommy Craggs, headlined G oodbye Ghosts, Hello Hefty Tax Bill : As the excellent book "Field of Schemes" by Neil DeMause puts it, Steinbrenner’s tenure has been "little more than one long plea for a new city-financed ballpark," a wish that w...

Will Olin's open space designs surface in September? Probably not

Shortly after new designs for the Atlantic Yards arena and one building were released on May 5, I wrote on May 8 that the magazine Landscape Architecture, published by the American Society of Landscape Architects, predicted coverage of Atlantic Yards in the June and September issues. The June issue is out and the Design section did not include an article on Atlantic Yards. When's it coming? Should we wait until September? Nope. A revised editorial calendar , as of 6/5/08, makes no mention of Atlantic Yards. So we're left wondering what Olin plans as temporary landscaping for empty lots that, as the Municipal Art Society suggested, might turn into Atlantic Lots.

National ACORN's (episode of) scandal, and NY ACORN's dubious Brooklyn stadium deal (in 2000)

This includes the fourth of a multi-part interview (conducted May 28) with Neil deMause, the Brooklyn-based co-author of the book Field of Schemes: How the Great Stadium Swindle Turns Public Money Into Private Profit , and writer of the companion web site . He testified at a 3/29/07 Congressional hearing that questioned taxpayer financing of stadiums, convention centers, and hotels. The national housing and advocacy group ACORN (Association of Community Organizations for Reform Now) has been in the news for covering up (for eight years) an embezzlement by the founder’s brother, and while that doesn’t necessarily put a cloud over New York ACORN, the state affiliate, some defenses of ACORN deserve challenge. Lawyer and activist John Atlas, who’s writing a book on ACORN, wrote on The Huffington Post that ACORN has been subject to “vicious attacks from business lobbyists, conservative politicians, and right-wing media.” He later added, “It also has critics on the Left, some of whom are ...

A 311 call to Bloomberg: why is my AY-related FOIL request languishing?

A July 7 New York Times article, headlined Titans Seek New York Mayor in Bloomberg’s Mold , described how business leaders in New York seek a mayoral candidate in the mold of nonpartisan, business-oriented two-term Mayor Mike Bloomberg. It offered these statistical examples: Under the Bloomberg administration, residents became “customers” who could call in rants, requests and inquiries to 311, a new nonemergency hot line. New Yorkers also have access to up-to-the-minute feedback on city services. The city tracks and publicizes how long it takes to fill a pothole (2.7 days), how fast ambulances respond to an emergency (6 minutes 37 seconds, down 17 seconds from 2006) and how long it takes 311 phone operators to answer a call (7 seconds). Another pair of statistics Here's another pair of statistics: the legal requirement to respond to a Freedom of Information Law (FOIL) request (20 business days) and how long my request has languished (40 business days). I filed a FOIL request with ...

In court, the not-so-credible Professor Zimbalist gets shredded twice

Sports economist Andrew Zimbalist, author of a dubious study of the economic impact of Atlantic Yards, is hardly unerring, as listeners of the Brian Lehrer Show learned Monday, but his credibility was further undermined last month when he testified as an expert witness in a trial in Seattle over the departure of the Sonics for Oklahoma City. The sides ultimately settled before a verdict, with the team’s new owners agreeing to pay $45 million (and $30 million more, if the legislature ponies up $75 million) to terminate the lease in Seattle—well more than originally offered but far less than the the city likely hoped for, given that a witness claimed ( dubiously ) that the team was responsible for $188 million in economic activity a year. (More from Field of Schemes and the Post-Intelligencer . The Sonics, who offered the unusual--for sports teams--argument that the team had no economic benefit on the city it was leaving, saw their expert, Brad Humphreys, challenged as well. And the j...

Author deMause on Zimbalist: "a lot of people don't take him as seriously"

This is the third of a multi-part interview (conducted May 28) with Neil deMause, the Brooklyn-based co-author of the book Field of Schemes: How the Great Stadium Swindle Turns Public Money Into Private Profit , and writer of the companion web site . He testified at a 3/29/07 Congressional hearing that questioned taxpayer financing of stadiums, convention centers, and hotels. One curious thing I noticed about the new edition of Field of Schemes is that it appears with a prominent blurb from Smith College sports economist Andrew Zimbalist, one of the scholars on whom deMause and co-author Joanna Cagan relied for the first edition of the book. Zimbalist, of course, is notorious for writing a "promotional" study of the economic impact of the Atlantic Yards project, paid for by developer Forest City Ratner, and defending it poorly, as on the Brian Lehrer Show Monday. deMause v. Zimbalist It's safe to say that Zimbalist would not blurb the revised and expanded edition, since...

Appellate court upholds ESDC/AKRF conflict in Columbia case

So, according to the New York Times , a state appeals court, by a vote of 3-1, upheld a State Supreme Court Justice's ruling that it was improper for the ubiquitous consultant AKRF to work simultaneously for Columbia University on its expansion project and also for the Empire State Development Corporation (ESDC) on its end of the Columbia project. [Here's the decision .] So the ESDC must turn over some but not all papers requested by the plaintiffs in West Harlem Business Group v. Empire State Development Corporation . The court found some documents were exempt. In a somewhat similar case regarding Atlantic Yards, a Supreme Court Justice ruled that it was improper for a lawyer to work simultaneously for developer Forest City Ratner and the ESDC--but the ruling was overturned when the appellate court found the representation was consecutive rather than simultaneous. Unresolved: what exactly are the ESDC's guidelines regarding consecutive representation? How much of a gap m...

Deconstructing Professor Zimbalist's dubious defenses of his radio appearance

After his appearance on The Brian Lehrer Show Monday, sports economist Andrew Zimbalist wrote in to defend himself. I'll divide his response up into sections. Not in the Yankees' pocket AZ: I want you to know that I have never received a penny of compensation from the Yankees. If I had, I would have made it known before I commented. Fine. But if he's a scholar, rather than a promoter, he should grapple with contradictory information from Good Jobs New York and Neil deMause. West Side Stadium AZ: I am also not sure about the comment that one of your listeners made regarding what I said about the West Side Stadium. If I said that I did not think it should get public financing, it was because I thought it was a bad plan to build it. I don't see how this in any way contradicts anything I said on your show. Well, part of the reason he thought it was a bad plan was that he severely criticized PILOTs, or payments in lieu of taxes. He thinks PILOTs are fine if the land previ...

Sports economist Zimbalist criticizes "bogus" economic impact studies, fails to look in mirror

So there he was, sports economist Andrew Zimbalist, on the Brian Lehrer Show yesterday to talk about the All-Star Game, and suddenly he had to defend his public statements supporting the Yankee Stadium deal and his not-peer-reviewed study endorsing Atlantic Yards. Had there been an equal debate, Zimbalist would have been flattened. He continued to insist that the Yankees deserved praise for paying for their stadium, without acknowledging the host of special benefits to the team. He continued to insist that Forest City Ratner was using only as-of-right benefits for Atlantic Yards, despite ironclad evidence to the contrary. And when challenged to resolve the inconsistency between his criticism of the West Side Stadium deal and his support for Atlantic Yards, he became defensive and suggested that the former might have emerged a decade ago, when it was actually several months after he issued his report for Forest City Ratner. The action began at about 2:55 of the show. Tax-exempt...