Skip to main content

Posts

Featured Post

Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park FAQ, timeline, and infographics (pinned post)

Empire State Development statement: Cuomo announces plan to accelerate Atlantic Yards development

Below, the verbatim statement ( link ) issued by Empire State Development, notably with quotes from several elected officials: GOVERNOR CUOMO ANNOUNCES COMPREHENSIVE PLAN TO ACCELERATE THE DEVELOPMENT OF ATLANTIC YARDS PROJECT AND ENSURE TIMELY DELIVERY OF PUBLIC BENEFITS Plan Includes Commitment to Build 2,250 Affordable Apartments by 2025 instead of 2035 Governor Creates Atlantic Yards Community Development Corporation, Fourteen Member Board will Monitor and Oversee Atlantic Yards Project and Advise ESD Board Governor Andrew M. Cuomo today announced a comprehensive plan to accelerate the development of Atlantic Yards, including a fast tracked timeline for delivery of affordable housing. The new plan will shorten the completion timeframe to build 2,250 affordable apartments by ten years, from 2035 to 2025. Additionally, the deal will create a board, the Atlantic Yards Community Development Corporation, to provide input on development, housing, and community impact throughout t...

Dean Street Block Association statement: Community group says new Atlantic Yards accord leaves them at risk

A statement from the Dean Street Block Association: Community group says new Atlantic Yards accord leaves them at risk Neighbors who live closest to Atlantic Yards and absorb the most adverse impacts from it are not satisfied with the new Atlantic Yards accord between the State and a number of local civic organizations and groups. Because the oversight created is just advisory and insufficiently defined, Dean Street Block Association, 6th Avenue to Vanderbilt spoke against its approval today to the Empire State Development board. “The oversight regime created as a product of the 5th Avenue Committee/BrooklynSpeaks agreement is not adequate to the concerns our block association members and their neighbors raise,” Rhona Hetsrony, the block association’s President said. The residents in the area of Dean Street were defined as most impacted by adverse construction impacts in the court-ordered SEIS the State adopted two weeks ago. Much of the 1200 page document is about impacts to ...

BrooklynSpeaks/Fifth Avenue Committee press release on Atlantic Yards agreement

I'll have more coverage from this morning's meeting of Empire State Development, including quotes from some more skeptical about the deal and an interview with the Fifth Avenue Committee's Michelle de la Uz. But first this press release from BrooklynSpeaks, published verbatim below. Community groups and local residents reach historic accord with New York State and developers of Brooklyn’s Atlantic Yards Project Agreement calls for delivery of 2,250 promised units of affordable housing ten years earlier than previously agreed; imposes penalties for failure to meet deadlines; creates tenant protection fund and special oversight subsidiary Today, following weeks of intense negotiations,  BrooklynSpeaks  sponsor organizations and local residents announced they have reached a landmark settlement with Forest City Ratner Corporation (FCRC), the developer of the Atlantic Yards Project in Brooklyn, and the Empire State Development Corporation (ESDC), with the support of the City...

Facing pressure from potential lawsuit, Forest City agrees to accelerate affordable housing to 2025; formation of new subsidiary hailed, but leaves closest neighbors unhappy

On the eve of the final state approvals for Atlantic Yards, developer Forest City Ratner, apparently threatened by a prepared but never filed civil rights lawsuit that jeopardized the pending joint venture with a crucial new investment partner, has agreed to accelerate the construction of affordable housing in the project to finish all 2250 units by 2025, rather than 2035 as state documents would permit. That's significant progress on the affordable housing issue, implying (though not guaranteeing) an accelerated deck over the "blighted" Vanderbilt Yard, and implies government commitment to continued housing subsidies. But it does not mean 2035 was the "schedule," however, as depicted in the scoop spoon-fed to the New York Times, headlined Plan Expedited for Affordable Units at Atlantic Yards near Downtown Brooklyn . As the project approvals were pending in 2006 and 2009, Forest City long pledged a ten-year buildout, and project benefits were always calcul...

So, what happened to my question about hockey games as a worst-case scenario for arena traffic analysis?

From the  Board Materials  for today's Empire State Development Board Meeting: At the Directors meeting on June 12, 2014, one commenter informed the Directors that one of his comments had been omitted from the FSEIS [Final Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement] and provided a copy of that comment to the Directors. The comment raised the issue of whether the SEIS should have considered a New York Islanders hockey game at the arena, rather than a Brooklyn Nets game, as the reasonable worst-case scenario in the traffic and transportation analyses. Subsequent investigation by ESD staff determined that this comment had not been included in the FSEIS because ESD’s computer system had quarantined the comment, preventing it from being delivered to the Atlantic Yards mailbox and considered by ESD staff. Nevertheless, in preparing the DSEIS, ESD’s staff and its environmental consultant had considered the issue raised by the commenter and determined that a Nets game, rather ...

On ESD agenda today, Atlantic Yards is first item; Board Materials finally posted, recommend approval of Greenland deal (to avoid ambiguity), support reduced parking (updated)

Atlantic Yards is the first item (after the approval of minutes) on the agenda at the 9:45 am meeting today of the board of Empire State Development: Atlantic Yards Land Use Improvement and Civic Project – Adoption of Findings Pursuant to New York State Environmental Quality Review Act; Adoption of Court Ordered Findings as to Phase II of the Project; Affirmation of 2014 Modified General Project Plan; Determination with Respect to Greenland Joint Venture; Adoption of Proposed Essential Terms for Modification of Project Documents; Authorization to Take Related Actions For weeks, it wasn't clear if that means ESD must approve the joint venture with the Chinese government-owned Greenland Group--which will pay Forest City Ratner $200 million for the right to develop 70% of the remaining project (not the arena or first tower) going forward-- or determined it need not do so. I never got an answer to my query. Updated : the 1252 pages (!) of  Board Materials  were not...

Forest City executive on CBA signatory BUILD: "THEY WORK FOR US" (plus, criticism of state's owner's representative)

One issue in the pending lawsuit filed by trainees in the coveted pre-apprentice training program led by Atlantic Yards Community Benefits Agreement (CBA) signatory Brooklyn United for Innovative Local Development (BUILD), is how much the organization was controlled by and linked to its funder, Forest City Ratner. Participants claim they were promised jobs and union cards by not only by BUILD but also by representatives of Forest City Ratner. Forest City blames BUILD for making overbroad promises to the trainees and says it was not--a crucial issue under labor laws--a joint employer and thus not liable for any of those promises. Nor, says Forest City, did the developer devise and run the training program. Those issues--with evidence that each side can claim in its favor--are teased out in legal papers, which I will analyze further before the July 11 hearing in federal court in Brooklyn. However, one email, from Forest City Ratner construction chief Bob Sanna, lays out th...

Forest City's own consultant: CBA signatories were compensated for community support, not program goals, and perceived as "fronts"

More legal documents have been filed in the pending lawsuit filed by trainees in the coveted pre-apprentice training program led by Atlantic Yards Community Benefits Agreement (CBA) signatory Brooklyn United for Innovative Local Development (BUILD), which faces a July 11 hearing date. Participants claim they were promised jobs and union cards by not only by BUILD but also by representatives of Forest City Ratner. At one point, according to a motion filed by the plaintiffs, Forest City hired a consultant specializing in nonprofit management, Ritchie Tye Consulting, to evaluate the eight groups that signed the CBA. The report--referred to in several documents but not made public--was apparently scathing. The consultant essentially validated the widespread critique of the CBA: that most groups had no track record in the community (I'd note that individuals associated with groups did have a record) and were set up to support the project. The report even said that an effort ...

Bruce Ratner on why Independent Compliance Monitor was never hired: "I don't know why not"

More legal documents have been filed in the pending lawsuit filed by trainees in the coveted pre-apprentice training program led by Atlantic Yards Community Benefits Agreement (CBA) signatory Brooklyn United for Innovative Local Development (BUILD), which faces a July 11 hearing date. Participants claim they were promised jobs and union cards by not only by BUILD but also by representatives of Forest City Ratner. One exchange in a deposition, excerpted below, includes developer Bruce Ratner's answer to the question about why the Independent Compliance Monitor promised in the much-touted CBA, signed in June 2005, was never hired. His answer: "I can't really answer why not. I don't even know why not." The full answer is cut off, but Ratner's suggestion that it might have been "covered in other way" belies the plain fact of the CBA requirement. And the failure to hire the monitor exemplifies a lack of accountability regarding the project. ...

MTA board uneventfully approves Forest City's proposed changes to Vanderbilt Yard plan

With no discussion or drama, the board of the Metropolitan Transportation this morning approved revised deal terms regarding the Vanderbilt Yard. That will allow the Atlantic Yards developer, Forest City Ratner--and, presumably, the nearly finalized joint venture with the Chinese government-owned Greenland Group-- to move ahead  on building the platform needed for vertical development over the Vanderbilt Yard, while getting the timetable to finish the permanent railyard extended 15 months. The extension is not crucial to the MTA, because the plan for East Side Access--the service for which the yard will become more important--has been delayed. As I wrote , a Technical Memorandum states that, despite the nine-month extension of time for foundation work, the foundation work would be less extensive, since it would require fewer trucks. However, unlike in past plans, the work would require installation of 95 caisson piles, each taking two days to install, using two drill rigs...

From the latest Atlantic Yards Construction Alert: work starts as soon as June 30 that will constrict Atlantic Avenue, limit Pacific Street; modules up to 165; still snags

According to the latest two-week Atlantic Yards Construction Alert (below), dated June 23 but distributed yesterday at 2:30 pm--more than a day-and-a-half late--by Empire State Development after preparation by Forest City Ratner, major work will start on or around Monday, June 30 to enable railyard renovations and later work on the Barclays Center's green roof. The work includes removal of existing concrete medians on Atlantic Avenue beginning at Fort Greene Place, and shifting/altering of traffic lanes (3 westbound lanes and 2 eastbound lanes) during MPT (maintenance and protection of traffic). It also includes partial blocking of Pacific Street east of Sixth Avenue; Pacific Street will become one way (westerly) between Sixth and Carlton Avenues.  Module deliveries up to 165 Over two weeks, the number of modules delivered to the B2 residential tower  rose from 117 to approximately 165, which means 48 were delivered and installed over two weeks, an average of...

ESD meeting Friday to approve Atlantic Yards revision; amount of parking at issue; big joint venture announcement coming?

The board of Empire State Development (ESD), the state agency overseeing/shepherding Atlantic Yards, will meet Friday, June 27, 2014, at 9:45 am: Empire State Development 633 Third Avenue – 37th Floor Conference Room New York, New York 10017 The agenda should be posted with one day's notice here . Among numerous other items, the board is expected to approve a revision to the Atlantic Yards Modified General Project Plan, which would shift bulk from Phase 1 to Phase 2 and reduce parking onsite from 3,670 spaces to either 2,896 parking spaces or (I'd bet) 1,200 spaces. (The General Project Plan was passed in 2006 and first revised in 2009, to allow, among other things, phased acquisition of property, which saved Atlantic Yards developer Forest City Ratner cash flow.) Sometime after that, I expect a big announcement of the planned but not yet finalized joint venture between Forest City and the Chinese government-owned Greenland Group and then, on or after Monday, the b...

MTA committee smiles on Vanderbilt Yard plan; new memo discloses longer time frame, less intensive work overall (but 95 caisson piles using drill rigs)

Discussion of Forest City Ratner's proposal to move ahead on building of the platform needed for vertical development over the Vanderbilt Yard, while asking for 15 months' delay in the required completion of a permanent railyard proceeded uneventfully at the Metropolitan Transportation Authority's Long Island Rail Road Committee yesterday. Following the receipt of a Staff Summary indicating the work would be helpful while the delay not harmful, LIRR President took a few questions from committee members. The concurrent work, he said, means Forest City doesn't "have to come back after the fact and disrupt the yard and disrupt the foundation." The delay affects full use of permanent railyard, he said. "It is not delaying the overall project. In fact it helps it." No raised the potential pitfall, as I suggested , that the agreement might make it more difficult to unwind the deal should Forest City and its joint venture partner, the Chinese govern...