Skip to main content

Posts

Featured Post

Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park FAQ, timeline, and infographics (pinned post)

Getting ready for modular construction? NYC Building Trades Employers' Association asks unions to drop restrictions on off-site work

Modular construction, apparently, is one of the negotiating points between contractors and union workers. Union radical Gregory Butler, on his Gangbox News blog, recently posted THE BUILDING TRADES EMPLOYERS ASSOCIATION'S 26 POINT ULTIMATUM TO THE NEW YORK BUILDING TRADES , from the Building Trades Employers' Association (BTEA), which represents "1,700 construction managers, general contractors and specialty subcontractor firms in New York City." It included cuts in wages, no overtime for make-up work, a cut in overtime pay from double to time-and-a-half, and rule changes, but the key passages, at least regarding Forest City Ratner's plans for modular construction of towers at the Atlantic Yards site, are these: 6. No limitations on materials, supplies or equipment, regardless of their source or origin; 7. Elimination of prohibitions of or restrictions on work which is performed off-site on materials or products modified or fabricated for installation on the pro...

Where should architects draw the ethical line? In discussion, Gehry and Ratner inevitably come up

On the Glass House Conversations web site (connected to the Philip Johnson Glass House), writer Mark Lamster recently raised a question about architectural ethics, and of course Frank Gehry and Atlantic Yards came up. Lamster posed the question: How do we choose our clients? On this subject, Philip Johnson, self-professed "whore," was apt to quote H. H. Richardson's admonition that the "first principle of architecture is to get the job." That is rather cynical, perhaps, and in fact there were some clients (the mafia, for instance) for whom even Johnson would not work. But how do the rest of us know when and where to draw the line? Is it acceptable to work for a government with a spotty record on human rights? How about a corporation with a poor environmental history? How do we balance commercial imperatives with a desire for a moral practice? To be a design professional is to navigate ethical territory that is rarely black or white, but some shade of gray. Wha...

Fair warning from 2010: the Atlantic Yards story is not ovah (and now look at the news); What about the EB-5 angle?

The Atlantic Yards story is still going strong , isn't it? As Michael D. D. White writes in his Noticing New York blog: The Times is having a harder and harder time not covering Atlantic Yards. That’s partly because Atlantic Yards is a bigger story than the paper has heretofore rightfully acknowledged. Last year, when press and public attention diminished, it shouldn't have. I wrote 8/24/10, about the lack of press attention to the appointment of Arana Hankin as the Empire State Development Corporation's Atlantic Yards project manager: Perhaps, they think, the Atlantic Yards story is ovah . Except it's not. I wrote 11/30/10 about the failure to follow up on the last Atlantic Yards court case and the Community Benefits Agreement: Journalists and others who think the Atlantic Yards story is ovah simply have closed their minds. And I wrote 12/7/10 about the New York TImes's curious failure to cover Atlantic Yards news: Instead, in the last month, we've see...

LIU basketball team may play at Barclays Center; that puts the LIU provost's enthusiastic, unquestioning support for AY in context

An an article labeled "Exclusive," the Brooklyn Paper reports Barclays Center will be nest for the Blackbirds , which, as I explain below, helps put in context the hyperbolic support for Atlantic Yards recently expressed by the provost of Long Island University. (The article also appears in the sibling New York Post.) The newspaper reports: The Blackbirds are looking to nest with the Nets. The suddenly world-class Long Island University men’s basketball team is in negotiations to play a portion of its home games at the Barclays Center, catapulting the plucky squad to a national audience when the arena is completed next year. “LIU [is part of] a strategic partnership that will encompass many areas of our business, including having several LIU games played at the Barclays Center,” said Nets spokesman Barry Baum. The LIU cagers were valiant in their ultimately futile first-round loss to North Carolina in the NCAA men’s basketball tournament last week — but Coach Jim Ferry thin...

Atlantic Yards documentary film "Battle for Brooklyn" to debut at Toronto's Hot Docs Festival April 30

First came The Civilians' documentary play In the Footprint: The Battle for Atlantic Yards , which opened last fall. Now comes the documentary "Battle for Brooklyn" (working title "Battle of Brooklyn"). The Hollywood Reporter, in Hot Docs Unveils 18th Edition Film Slate , reports: TORONTO -- The Hot Docs Canadian International Documentary Festival's 18th edition is to open April 28 with Morgan Spurlock's POM Wonderful Presents: The Greatest Movie Ever Sold. Spurlock's feature doc on advertising and product placement paid for entirely by advertising and product placement comes to Toronto for a Canadian premiere at the Winter Gardens Theatre by way of Sundance and the SXSW Film Festival... Sean Farnel, Hot Docs director of programming, said the main film themes this year include the arrogance of power, problematic families and "directors becoming fictional characters in thelr own films." There's also a world premiere for Michael Galinsky...

Brooklyn Paper: some contradictions in the Prime 6 story about bottle service; Capital NY: owner leaning toward "California cuisine"

The Brooklyn Paper reported yesterday, in In Prime 6 fight, the bar owner has two faces : The owner of a controversial new bar in Park Slope maintains that his place will be a local eatery — but he told state liquor officials that the two-story, 230-person “lounge,” will hire four “security guards,” offer “bottle service” and have an outdoor “stand-up bar.” Prime 6 will be a live music venue that caters both to Brooklynites and, “out-of-town patrons in anticipation of the Barclays stadium” that is rising one block away, according to a booze permit application filed by owner Akiva Ofshtein last year with the State Liquor Authority. “It will offer several rooms for private parties, including a basement lounge [and] a large outdoor secluded-dining backyard to be enjoyed during the spring,” the application continued. The hip hop controversy And let's not forget Capital NY's piece last week, Flatbush Avenue freakout: How a race-baiting hoax hooked Bobo Brooklyn, briefly : Two days a...

New bio of Jay-Z: some good business anecdotes, "loyalty to his money," a suggestion he got a discount on the Nets; an AY chapter riddled with errors

While Zack O'Malley Greenburg's Empire State of Mind: How Jay-Z Went From Street Corner to Corner Office , is billed as "The Definitive Jay-Z Biography," it focuses, as the author acknowledges, on business, not music. Thus there's less analysis of Shawn (Jay-Z) Carter's creativity and cultural impact, and no pick-up from the star's own 2010 book Decoded , which is both insightful and cryptic , leaving some lingering questions about the star's ethics. There's a potted history of Jay-Z's involvement with Atlantic Yards, which offers some intriguing numbers regarding the value of Jay's investment, but is unfortunately riddled with errors. And Jay-Z wouldn't talk to Greenburg; the author suggests that "Jay-Z doesn't like to share the proceeds of projects he feels he can execute on his own." "His loyalty is to his money" That said, Greenburg did crib from other interviews, talk to other journalists, and interview sev...

Would modular construction require a new environmental review? ESDC says there's no official plan, so speculation is unwise

On March 17, I asked this question publicly: Does modular construction mean a new environmental review is needed for Atlantic Yards? I suggested it might, given that the delivery of 900 modules, "lifted into place by crane and bolted together at the corner of Flatbush Avenue and Dean Street," as the Times described it, could introduce a different set of impacts on traffic, or on street closures. Querying the ESDC I followed up by posing the question to the Empire State Development Corporation: Would the introduction of modular construction at the Atlantic Yards site require a new environmental review or technical memo? Spokeswoman Elizabeth Mitchell responded: The fact that the building would be modular as opposed to conventional construction would merit another environmental review only if the design guidelines or any other MGPP [Modified General Project Plan] requirement could not be met using the modular approach. If such a decision would be made to adopt modular construc...

ESDC CEO Ken Adams has a Senate confirmation hearing; here are some questions about Atlantic Yards

On Tuesday at 10:30 am, the New York State Senate's Commerce, Economic Development and Small Business will hold a confirmation hearing for Kenneth Adams , Commissioner of New York State Department of Economic Development and CEO of the Empire State Development Corporation. The hearing, to be held in Albany, will be streamed on the Internet. The Chair of the Committee is Sen. James Alesi (R-Rochester), who at least knows something about Atlantic Yards after joining Sen. Bill Perkins (D-Harlem) at a January 2010 oversight hearing in Harlem on eminent domain. Only an hour has been allotted, and surely there are many things on the minds of the Senators and of Adams, but they still should ask a few questions about the ESDC's most controversial project. Some Atlantic Yards questions Here are a few suggestions: Does Adams support a governance entity to provide some oversight and continuity regarding the project? Given that the ESDC has acknowledged that the project won't be c...

"Gray Lady Down," a debate on the Times, and an AY mention

Having read William McGowan's book Gray Lady Down: What the Decline and Fall of The New York Times Means for America , I knew it does not address such relatively local issues at Atlantic Yards (built by the Times Company's business partner on the Times Tower, Forest City Ratner), but instead more ideological issues such as gay marriage, immigration, the Duke "rape" case, and the war on terror. So McGowan didn't bring up Atlantic Yards during a debate last month with Michael Tomasky, American editor-at-large for the Guardian, at St. Francis College in Brooklyn Heights. (Tomasky's main point was that the allegedly halcyon days of the past featured flawed coverage, especially in scope, of a different stripe.) An AY question During the Q&A , at 1:08:34 in the video below, Noticing New York blogger Michael D. D. White brought up Atlantic Yards: "Is the Times earnest and philosophically consistent, or is it making calculated decisions about its financial ...

Times devotes seven reporters to Kruger-Turano investigation; what if they applied same resources to Forest City Ratner's EB-5 venture?

In A Senator’s Shadow Family , the New York Times today assigns seven reports to look at the complicated relationship between accused (of corruption) state Senator Carl Kruger and the Turano family, who live in an over-the-top house in Mill Basin: In the days since the criminal complaint was filed on March 10, the four central characters in this drama have declined to talk extensively to reporters. But interviews with two dozen people who know them, along with previously undisclosed court and city records, reveal a strange symbiosis. Mr. Kruger vaulted the Turanos into his spheres of power and influence, prosecutors say, landing Dorothy a plum job and, later, funneling hundreds of thousands of dollars into her sons’ bank accounts to finance a $200,000 Bentley and pay down a $1.2 million mortgage. The Turanos, in turn, provided the senator companionship, and prosecutors say the brothers helped conceal his growing payoffs from lobbyists and corporations. Imagine what seven reporters coul...

New York Post notices contributions from Michael Ratner and wife to Kruger, discovers other Nets investors who gave

When, in September 2006, I first wrote about lawyer Michael Ratner's campaign contribution in apparent furtherance of the goals of Forest City Ratner (run by his brother Bruce), nobody in the press seemed to care. When news of corruption charges against state Senator Carl Kruger first surfaced this month, I mentioned that Kruger had received FCR-related campaign contributions, and on Friday I wrote again about Michael Ratner. Exclusive? Today, in an article labeled "Exclusive," the New York Post offers Kruger's campaigns see big 'Net' gains : State Sen. Carl Kruger -- who, the feds charge, directed state money to the Atlantic Yards project, which includes a new Nets arena -- took thousands of dollars in campaign cash from deep-pocketed donors connected to its developer, the team and the arena. (Actually, he directed state money toward a Prospect Park project pushed by Forest City executive Bruce Bender.) Nets investor Michael Ratner and his wife, Karen Ra...

Times Magazine takes look at architect Scarano: NYC Department of Buildings was overwhelmed during boom, and relied on self-certifications

In a fascinating article headlined The Supersizer of Brooklyn , the New York Times Magazine explores the curious case of now-disgraced Robert Scarano, who became the architect of choice for developers looking to capitalize on the outer-borough building boom, especially in gentrifying Brooklyn neighborhoods like Williamsburg, Greenwood Heights, and Park Slope's Fourth Avenue. Scarano's specialty: he found ways to build not only eye-catching modernist designs, but to work around the zoning code, building loft mezzanines that qualified as storage space, thus adding secret space to a more cramped (on paper) apartment. (Ahead of the curve, the late Bob Guskind wrote about Scarano a ton .) Self-certification Clearly, gentle city procedures, allowing architects to proceed on the honor system, enabled Scarano's tactics. The Times reports: Scarano boasted that he knew every nook and cranny of the zoning code, and few thought to question his expertise. He had a genial relationship w...

Seven years ago, Brooklyn Paper house ad touted "the most complete and honest coverage" of Atlantic Yards and "changing face of Brooklyn"

From a house ad in the 3/20/04 Brooklyn Papers (now the Brooklyn Paper): 2 massive Urban Renewal projects would change the face of Downtown Brooklyn forever — turning both quaint and gritty neighborhoods into high-trafficked walled communities, and massively impacting life in the surrounding residential neighborhoods. The proposed Nets arena is just a small part of the master plan, the most expensive Urban Renewal and property condemnation in Brooklyn’s history. Only The Brooklyn Papers has asked: Is this the Manhattanization of Brooklyn ... or the “depeopling” suburbanization of our streets? Are these projects good for Brooklyn? YOU'LL FIND THE MOST COMPLETE AND HONEST COVERAGE OF THE CHANGING FACE OF BROOKLYN ONLY IN THE BrooklynPapers. Looking back In retrospect, I'm not sure the question was Manhattanization vs. suburbanization, though it's more the former. Rather, it's whether the public sector would prove to be a tenacious defender of the public in...

At tense Council hearing, James, Lander cite AY delays, construction changes, press NYC EDC's Pinsky on need for updated cost-benefit analysis

Two Brooklyn City Council Members yesterday grilled Seth Pinsky, president of the New York City Economic Development Corporation (NYC EDC) about Atlantic Yards, but Pinsky both defended Forest City Ratner’s potential plan to build modular housing for the project, and argued that it, along with delays in tax revenues from a longer buildout, would not necessarily affect the city’s cost-benefit analysis of the project. The latter statement, which Pinsky repeated in several ways, left Council Member Brad Lander dismayed and dumbfounded, calling Pinsky’s answers to Council Member Letitia James “deeply inadequate” and warning that the city has “misplaced confidence” in Forest City Ratner (FCR). I'd also suggest that it requires an independent cost-benefit analysis, by the Independent Budget Office, rather than a self-serving one by the city. The tense exchanges punctuated an other cordial hearing of the Council’s Economic Development Committee , meeting yesterday morning at 250 Br...

Noticing New York: if Ratner was considering modular construction for a year, that plan was hatching even as he saluted unions at the groundbreaking

Noticing New York's Michael D. D. White, in The Real Question to Ask About the Ratner Bait-and-Switch Approach on Atlantic Yards , offers a partial list of bait-and-switches (e.g., Frank Gehry, timetable, railyard, less money down) facilitated by the government. Notably, White points out that Ratner was already considering a modular construction plan that would "shaft the unions" even as he saluted them at the groundbreaking last year. Also, in a second post , White suggests Ratner might be bluffing the unions, as he did with the Beekman Tower, which was halted at the half way point for renegotiation. Below, a couple of excerpts from the first post. First, who's in the driver's seat? Ratner’s Preintention When It Comes to Bait-and-Switch I am not surprised that the first thing a friend asked me upon hearing of this latest bait-and-switch was: “Do you think that Ratner intended this all along?” Whether Ratner intended this particular bait-and-switch all along...

Look at the graphics: Times devotes less space to EB-5 controversy than to puff pieces about Nets promotions

Yesterday, the New York Times briefly mentioned Forest City Ratner's effort to raise $249 million from immigrant investors, as if no questions or controversy were connected. I've scanned the print article, to contrast the amount of coverage with the significant space the Sports section has devoted to covering Nets promotions of dubious value. (Click on all graphics to enlarge and clarify.) Yes, Metro is different from Sports, but people read the Times as a whole. (And, I should add, today's Times has a Metro section feature on the move of Freddy's from Prospect Heights, displaced from the arena block, to an address that's either the South South Slope, Greenwood Heights, or northern Sunset Park: The Transmigration of a Brooklyn Saloon . It's not uninteresting, but it's also soft news, not hard news that requires some analysis.) The two paragraphs the Times devoted to EB-5 are also dwarfed by a Sports section photo of Nets dancers and a puff piece about a pro...