Skip to main content

Posts

Featured Post

Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park FAQ, timeline, and infographics (pinned post)

Post, belatedly, notices Judge Catterson's complaint about no judicial oversight of eminent-domain proceedings; why not put EB-5 on the agenda?

In an article headlined Wrong from blight: Judge rips land grab , the New York Post reports three months late: In a little-noticed ruling that could pack a punch for property owners, a judge has blasted the city for abusing eminent domain in its bid to seize buildings in East Harlem -- yet says there's nothing he can do about it. In a searing statement, Justice James Catterson of the state Appellate Division accused the city of falsely claiming "blight" as a ploy to transfer private property to developers. But New York's lower courts are powerless to stop it, said Catterson, thanks to prior rulings from the state Court of Appeals on eminent-domain cases related to Brooklyn's Atlantic Yards development and Columbia University's West Harlem expansion. "In my view, the record amply demonstrates that the [East Harlem] neighborhood in question is not blighted . . . and that the justification of under-utilization is nothing but a canard to aid in the transfer o...

Mike Lupica, November 2005: "If Caring Bruce Ratner is still the owner of the Nets in five years, I'll eat my hat."

New York Daily News sports columnist Mike Lupica wrote 11/13/05: If Caring Bruce Ratner is still the owner of the Nets in five years, I'll eat my hat. A Nets hat, even. He doesn't want the team. He never really did. He wants the land. Dan Doctoroff thought he didn't have to buy people left and right to push his agenda with the West Side Stadium, he was Deputy Mayor. Ratner was much smarter about all this, which is why he's got all these "community leaders" on scholarship now. Lupica was right (though it doesn't look like he wrote a follow-up). The sale of a majority interest to Mikhail Prokhorov was announced in September 2009.

The Complaint Box follow-up: Atlantic Yards debate, governmental power, and more

Well, my brief Complaint Box essay in the Times, Powerless in Brooklyn , generated some debate, though more about certain parts of the argument than others. Several commenters seem to agree that Brooklyn lacks borough-wide media and local government, but there weren't many solutions. Here was one , from Raul Rothblatt: I am Executive Director of a group called the Four Borough Neighborhood Preservation Alliance, which promotes community input in land use decisions in mid- and low-density. We are an alliance of civic groups from around Brooklyn, Queens, Staten Island and The Bronx. We are currently working on facilitating cooperation between groups in Brooklyn, so this article is quite timely. If you would like more information, please contact me at rrothblatt [at] gmail [dot] com. I think we will start to see get more community oversight by old means, like meeting face-to-face, and by new means. I’m surprised at the success of my crowdsourcing website last month: http://...

New York Times Complaint Box essay: Powerless in Brooklyn (without meaningful local government and broad-based media, civic organizations)

I have a Complaint Box essay in the Metropolitan section of Sunday's New York Times, now online at CityRoom, headlined Powerless in Brooklyn . The gist: Of the boroughs outside Manhattan, Brooklyn gets the most buzz — as a tourist attraction, a “hipster brand” and an incubator of art and artisanal products. That has provoked a backlash from longtime Brooklynites and others wary of smugness from the borough’s Brownstone Belt. However entertaining these debates, Brooklynites — and, I dare say, all of us in the non-Manhattan boroughs — share one common problem: we’re essentially powerless. We lack meaningful local government, as well as broad-based media and civic organizations. Marty Markowitz, the borough’s president and its relentless cheerleader, says that Brooklyn has nearly everything a city needs and that fulfillment will arrive when a professional sports team, the Nets, finally moves to an arena here in 2012 or 2013. If only that were true. It's a bit of a depart...

Document shows that, after arena naming rights agreement was signed, it was amended twice, in 2008 and 2009

Thanks to an agreement (embedded below) between Barclays Capital and the Bank of New York Mellon, we have confirmation that indicated the arena naming rights agreement was negotiated not just from a reported $400 million in 2007 to $200 million-plus in 2009, but also with some unspecified interim amendments in 2008. (Note how arena renderings now prominently feature advertising on and around the building, though earlier renderings, below, did not. Does that meet design guidelines? The ESDC was vague .) The agreement concerns, among other things, the role of the naming rights fee in paying off bondholders, via PILOTs (payments in lieu of taxes). It does not specify the value of naming rights agreement. The state simply gave away naming rights to Forest City Ratner, which marketed them to Barclays. The bank is the trustee for the PILOTs; the document was found via ACRIS, the city's property database. Amendments in 2008 and 2009 The key text begins on the bottom of page 11 of the d...

In Brooklyn, hyperlocal news gets a boost with Patch (but we need much more)

The nature of the local new media is changing and, for Brooklyn, there may be some promise in Patch , the AOL-funded enterprise that's hiring do-it-all editors (without offices) in communities around the country--800 so far, with a goal of 1000. The editors are assisted by freelancers and other contributors and, in Brooklyn at least, form a bit of a network. Right now there's a Prospect Heights Patch , Park Slope Patch , Fort Greene/Clinton Hill Patch , Carroll Gardens/Cobble Hill Patch , and Bed-Stuy Patch . What, no Brooklyn Heights or Williamsburg? Maybe those communities were seen as already "taken" by the Brooklyn Heights Blog and culture blogs like Free Williamsburg . (Disclosure: I've done one freelance piece for Patch.) Not just news Patch, self-described as "your local source for news, events, business listings, and discussion," got some semi-skeptical treatment in a New York Times article January 17--an article that ignored Patch in New...

Daily Eagle columnist: "Reaction against innovative planning has marked the new millennium on matters like Atlantic Yards"

From Henrik Krogius in the Brooklyn Daily Eagle: Review and Comment: Idea for Gowanus? : We live in a changing Brooklyn that tries to cling to its (not always so sweet) past, in a time when the speed of technological change has unsettled many people. Reaction against innovative planning has marked the new millennium on matters like Atlantic Yards and the financing and design of Brooklyn Bridge Park, and yet individual towers not part of any considered community framework have sprouted willy-nilly. He's right that individual towers have sprouted thanks to the Downtown Brooklyn rezoning, but the lack of response--and anticipation--is at least partly because the rezoning was supposed to bring mainly office towers, not residential ones. But Atlantic Yards as "innovative planning"? Audacious design, maybe. The planning was non-existent; the project was imposed from on high, with the state overriding local land use review.

Yahoo columnist: Anthony deal, now off the table, was about marketing Brooklyn (and those unsold suites)

It can be tough to untangle the logic behind some basketball moves--did the Nets really want Yi Jianlian for his skills or for the China market?--and that issue has come up again, as the Nets have abandoned pursuit of Nuggets star Carmelo Anthony. The news came from principal owner Mikhail Prokhorov, as Yahoo columnist Adrian Wojnarowski put it , "[i]n a stunning and surreal declaration during a live, televised news conference," one that surprised Nets brass. Wojnarowski adds: When asked who had been driving the talks over the past several months, Prokhorov said, “It was purely on the basketball level.” Nevertheless, sources insist the Nets’ ownership and marketing sides had been relentless proponents of bringing Anthony to New Jersey as a prelude to their planned move to a new arena in Brooklyn in 2012. After all, they need to sell some suites .

Great moments in euphemistic coverage: the Wall Street Journal reports on Steiner Studios expansion, ignores EB-5

From the Wall Street Journal yesterday, regarding the expansion of Steiner Studios at the Brooklyn Navy Yard, Take Two for a Brooklyn Film and TV Studio : Doug Steiner, chairman of Steiner Studios, says about $65 million will come from private investors, $10 million to $20 million will come from Steiner and the rest will come from government programs. Those private investors are immigrant investors trading $500,000 for green cards for themselves and their family under the federal government's EB-5 program, as the New York City Regional Center (NYCRC) reminds us . The NYRCR is promoting another, more controversial effort to trade green cards for investments, involving Atlantic Yards .

State Authorities Budget Office still waiting for budget reports from ESDC and affiliate JDA

According to the state Authorities Budget Office (ABO), Public Authorities That Have Failed to File Reports in the Public Authorities Reporting Information System as of January 4, 2011 (embedded below), the Empire State Development Corporation (ESDC, aka Urban Development Corporation) and its affiliate, the Job Development Authority (JDA), did not file required budget reports 90 days prior to the start of the fiscal year. I asked the ESDC last week about the reason for the delay and the plans to comply, but haven't heard back. The ABO was beefed up somewhat after reforms strengthening oversight over public authorities, but it can't do its job if agencies don't comply. In July, I reported that the JDA had not filed an annual report; the latest ABO report suggests that it has since done so. I'm waiting for details on that, too. January 2011 Delinquent List

Panasonic HQ to unbuilt Atlantic Yards tower? There's nearly three times as much vacant space at MetroTech

Last week, as rumors surfaced that Panasonic might move its headquarters from New Jersey to Brooklyn--and Forest City Ratner's extant MetroTech or yet-to-be built Atlantic Yards office towers--I suggested that the tower at AY's Site 5 might be a better destination than Building 1. However, given available space at MetroTech, that seems like a more likely destination. Panasonic needs 250,000 square feet. Crain's, in a 1/16/11 article headlined Office vacancies grow in boroughs outside Manhattan , reports: Downtown Brooklyn saw the largest setbacks: NYSE Euronext moved out of roughly 387,000 square feet at 2 MetroTech Center, and J.P. Morgan Chase left about 352,000 square feet at 4 MetroTech... And because tenants in the outer boroughs tend to seek smaller spaces, leasing up emptied offices takes longer than it would in Manhattan. For instance, the tenant taking the most new space in the boroughs last year was the city's Department of Information Technology & Teleco...

As Nets continue pursuit of Carmelo Anthony, the Prokhorov backlash

Nets Daily rounds up the latest in the Nets' increasingly strained pursuit of Denver Nuggets star Carmelo Anthony, pointing to a very tough column by Yahoo's Adrian Wojnarowski: The New Jersey Nets had strutted around so full of themselves: big talk, blustery billboards and puffed-up promises. Even so, no one bought into the myth of Mikhail Prokhorov the way they did within that forlorn franchise. The Nets treat the Russian owner like some deity, like a Euro Mark Cuban, when he’s little more than an absentee landlord cutting big checks and delivering delusional proclamations of championship parades inside of five seasons. If the Nets truly need to sell Carmelo Anthony on accepting the trade and signing a contract extension, they’re a bigger lost cause than they’ve ever been. The Nets can’t let Prokhorov and Jay-Z get on a jet and go sell that now because this process has already cost them too much credibility – and because billionaires aren’t supposed to beg. Make no mistake:...

Washington Post re-launches Fact Checker column; CJR says every reporter should evaluate truth; what about KPMG's report to the ESDC?

The Washington Post has re-launched its Fact Checker column that previously concentrated on the presidential campaigns and "will focus on any statements by political figures and government officials--in the United States and abroad--that cry out for fact-checking." Writes Glenn Kessler: But we will not be limited to political charges or countercharges. We will seek to explain difficult issues, provide missing context and provide analysis and explanation of various "code words" used by politicians, diplomats and others to obscure or shade the truth. The Post will use the Pinocchio Test, which includes: One Pinocchio: shading of the facts, but no outright falsehoods Two Pinocchios: significant omissions and/or exaggerations, without necessarily a formal error Three Pinocchios: significant factual errors and/or obvious contradictions Four Pinocchios: whoppers Unalloyed truths--they will get "our prized Geppetto checkmark." And in New York? There's a cryi...

Made in Brooklyn: a 1993 warning about the loss of manufacturing for housing, more poignant today; is real estate really economic development?

The documentary Made in Brooklyn , about the importance of manufacturing and the shortsightedness of trading industrial space for housing and offices, was made in 1993, but the message remains valid, if ever more poignant. (The filmmaker is Isabel Hill, known for her subsequent Brooklyn Matters documentary on Atlantic Yards.) After all, Made in Brooklyn was filmed before this decade's real estate boom, and some of the manufacturers featured in the documentary, notably the Domino Sugar plant in Williamsburg (right), have closed, and the Domino site is slated to become the New Domino , a development second in size to Atlantic Yards in Brooklyn. The reviews and comments were mostly laudatory, though one critic pointed out Hill could have asked about salaries and benefits, and noted that some small manufacturers are sweatshops. Still, manufacturing has long been a source of good jobs for immigrants and others who may lack book learning but can use their skills. There's an argumen...

Yormark claims "disbelief that the Dodgers left... has been passed on from generation to generation"

On ESPN, True Hoop J.A. Adande listens to New Jerseyan Brett Yormark pontificate on Brooklyn : I chatted with Nets CEO Brett Yormark about what the arena means to Brooklyn, why the Nets need a superstar, the building of the brand and a man he calls Michael -- that would be Mikhail Prokhorov. “I’ve been engaged in this whole move for about six years,” Yormark said. “I’m in Brooklyn quite often, if not daily. The disbelief that the Dodgers left [in 1957], that underserved nature with respect to sports and entertainment, has been passed on from generation to generation." Not so. He needs to get out more. As I wrote in March 2009, Michael D’Antonio's revisionist biography of Brooklyn Dodgers owner Walter O’Malley, Forever Blue: The True Story of Walter O'Malley, Baseball's Most Controversial Owner,and the Dodgers of Brooklyn and Los Angeles , put Dodgers nostalgia in perspective, blaming it on Roger Kahn’s book The Boys of Summer. The Dodgers left in 1957. Consider this...

The decline in manufacturing is the worst eight-year drop in NYC history; one reason is rezonings

Remember how Brooklyn Borough President Marty Markowitz said the country needs to get back to manufacturing? Well, New York City has its niche manufacturing, but that niche is narrowing. Tom Robbins, soon to depart from the Village Voice, reports : This month, City Limits magazine reported that under Mayor Bloomberg's watch, manufacturing jobs in the city disappeared twice as fast as in the rest of the country. Almost 64,000 blue-collar positions vanished, a decline of 46 percent. It is the worst eight-year slide in city history, says Sarah Crean, who has kept an eye on these statistics for the New York Industrial Retention Network. Land rezoning is one reason, says Crean. Indifference is another. It might be added that, when rezonings were passed, the city didn't always predict things well, as with Downtown Brooklyn . And sometimes, as with Atlantic Yards, the city let the state override zoning.

After the last snowstorm, a better job on clearing sidewalks around the AY site (but still a few gaps)

After the most recent snowfall, Forest City Ratner cleared the sidewalks bordering Atlantic Yards--more or less. This contrasts with sidewalks left un-shoveled after the December 26 snowstorm. On Wednesday afternoon, January 12, I took a walk around the site, more or less, and saw most of the sidewalks had been cleared. Two stretches were not cleared: most of the east side of Sixth between Dean and Pacific, and about one-fifth of the north side of Pacific between Sixth and Carlton just east of Sixth. I checked with the Empire State Development Corporation (ESDC), which has overall responsibility for the site. Spokeswoman Elizabeth Mitchell responded: "ESDC received several complaints regarding snow removal last week, and directed FCRC to improve their efforts. We are pleased with their overall effort. Sixth Avenue between Dean and Pacific on the east side continues to be problematic due to the proliferation of illegally parked cars, prohibiting easy access for snow removal equipm...

Panasonic HQ to move from NJ to Brooklyn and FCR's MetroTech or Atlantic Yards? A few unanswered questions and some Site 5 speculation

The Wall Street Journal reports, in Panasonic Eyes N.J., Brooklyn : Panasonic Corp. of North America is in talks with New York City officials about relocating the company's headquarters and hundreds of jobs to Brooklyn, according to people familiar with the matter. The Japanese electronics maker's U.S. headquarters currently is located in Secaucus, N.J. On Tuesday, the New Jersey Economic Development Authority approved as much as $102.4 million in tax credits for Panasonic to move to Newark instead of a possible move to New York City. The plan would keep about 800 jobs in New Jersey. People familiar with the matter said that Panasonic is eyeing two sites in Brooklyn—the MetroTech Center development in Downtown Brooklyn and the new Atlantic Yards development, which is also the site of a new basketball arena for the New Jersey Nets. Both Brooklyn sites are controlled by Forest City Ratner. Panasonic might stay in Secaucus or move to other cities, so it's likely the company is...