Skip to main content

Posts

Featured Post

Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park FAQ, timeline, and infographics (pinned post)

Last month, Bloomy was offering a boilerplate defense of AY

Mayor Mike Bloomberg seems to be coming to the realization that the Atlantic Yards project shouldn't get a special tax break and is apparently threatening to withdraw some pledged subsidies. Is that a belated recognition that Atlantic Yards might be a drain on the public coffers or should not get special benefits? Is it part of a larger tactic to resist the state's revision of the 421-a tax break? Or is it something else altogether? It is clear, however, that until recently, Bloomberg was offering a boilerplate defense of the project. A month ago, after Brooklyn resident Michael D.D. White wrote a thoughtful and pointed letter of complaint to the mayor, he received the following canned response, which he forwarded to me. (The original letter is at bottom.) I've interpolated some commentary. A token reduction Dear Mr. White: Thank you for your recent letter about the Atlantic Yards project. Many Brooklyn residents, and especially those who live in the neighborhoods that di...

The ($$$) Gehry archive and Atlantic Yards

Starchitect Frank Gehry, we learn from a front-page New York Times article yesterday headlined For Architects, Personal Archives as Gold Mines , is considering selling his archives for "multimillion dollars." His explanation: "I don’t want to give it away — it’s an asset,” Mr. Gehry said. “It’s the one thing in your life you build up, and you own it. And I’ve been spending a lot of rent to preserve it." Not every architect or archivist shares that ethos--after all, even a donated archive costs money to maintain and the preservation into posterity is of value to the donor. As the Times reported: The architect Charles Gwathmey said about selling archives: “I think it’s wrong. Archives are part of the record. How do you put a value on it even?” Then again, that record can be eclectic: Robert A. M. Stern, the dean of the Yale School of Architecture, said that architects even preserve telephone logs of calls to and from contractors and clients because they can offer an e...

With missing building (322 condos), AY financial projections have huge hole

What's missing from this 10/10/06 Forest City Ratner document (below) that purports to cover the phasing of the Atlantic Yards project? One of the 16 towers, the substantial Site 5, 250 feet tall (once planned at 350 feet , as in the renderings, apparently) and 439,200 square feet , which would occupy well more than 5% of the project's square footage. Rising on the site now occupied by P.C. Richard/Modell’s between Flatbush, Fourth, and Atlantic avenues, and Pacific Street, it would apparently contain 322 condos, far more lucrative for developer Forest City Ratner than the rental housing. The omission is important. We know that the Atlantic Yards financial projections unearthed by the lawsuit filed by Assemblyman Jim Brennan and State Senator Velmanette Montgomery, in which the phasing document was included, were snapshots and not definitive. Missing numbers Still, the numbers have been used in the projections made by Forest City Ratner and in the KPMG report (large PDF) com...

In the Times: the Public Editor looks at the Times, an affordable housing delay, and no response to "Cracker Barrel 2.0"

In today's New York Times, new Public Editor Clark Hoyt, in a column headlined Tiptoeing Around the Family Business , examines how the Times has had trouble covering the challenge by a major outside shareholder to the stock structure that leaves the Ochs-Sulzberger families in control of the company. Hoyt observes: Amid all this turmoil [in the news industry], aggressively reported and analyzed in The Times, there has been a comparative silence in the paper about its own owners, their challenges and their strategy. From Arthur Sulzberger Jr. to Landon Thomas Jr., a business reporter who has been assigned stories about The Times, everyone acknowledges a fundamental truth: It’s hard to write about yourself. He could have gone even further to discuss the Times's sketchy coverage of its own real estate deals, in selling its old building and acquiring land for the new Times Tower, built by the parent New York Times Company and developer Forest City Ratner. And that might have led to...

In Newark, an eminent domain decision with some echoes for Brooklyn

A 14-acre plot of land one block from an urban sports arena, with modest lots, homes, and businesses, some of them empty. A redevelopment proposal with mostly luxury housing. A politically connected developer. A plan to use eminent domain. A questionable finding of blight. And a lawsuit. Sounds like Brooklyn and Atlantic Yards? Nope, it's the Mulberry Street Redevelopment Project in Newark, where, on Thursday, a state judge shot down the plan by calling the government's finding of blight and underutilization not credible. (See Mulberry Street Area Property Owner's Group v. City of Newark , 3.8 MB PDF.) There's little if any applicability to Brooklyn, given that the decision was based on state rather than federal law. The plaintiffs in Goldstein v. Pataki , the Brooklyn eminent domain case , draw on the U.S. Supreme Court's 2005 Kelo v. New London decision, but have so far been stymied in trial court. Still, the case has some significant echoes for Atlantic Yards w...

Catching up: a 421-a scaleback (?) for Ratner, more AKRF concerns, and some oversight of oversight

Worth checking out: NoLandGrab on the putative reduction in the 421-a revision pending before the State Legislature The Council of Brooklyn Neighborhoods on AKRF's role working for Forest City Ratner and then the Empire State Development Corporation Develop Don't Destroy Brooklyn on the Daily News's story regarding the ESDC's delay in implementing planned Atlantic Yards oversight. (It ran only in the Brooklyn section, as noted on Brownstoner.)

Congestion pricing still looms as an AY issue

Both supporters and critics of Forest City Ratner's Atlantic Yards plan have to be concerned about the choppy progress of Mayor Mike Bloomberg's congestion pricing plan in the state legislature; while legislators did not approve Bloomberg's initial proposal, a commission was established to hold hearings and submit a plan to the city and state by January 31, 2008. Given the significant amount of traffic detouring through Downtown Brooklyn to use the free bridges, a congestion charge would both raise revenues for public transportation and impose a rational cost for access. In a Brooklyn Daily Eagle commentary this week headlined Congestion Pricing: A Phoenix That Is Sure to Rise Again , Dennis Holt observes that the prominent placement of New Yorkers in Congress should help when a plan is resubmitted. Developers know Also, Holt takes note of a dirty little secret: The development community in Brooklyn doesn’t go out of its way to admit that Downtown Brooklyn traffic is bad ...

Marty's base includes Brooklyn developers (but not Ratner*)

Brooklyn Borough President Marty Markowitz, contemplating a run for mayor but not yet declaring for the race, has raised a respectable sum of money but remains well behind several rivals, as the Brooklyn Paper reports this week. Among the donors of the maximum $4950, as the Brooklyn Paper notes, are developers Joe Sitt, Shaya Boymelgreen, Joshua Muss, and Dolly Williams, who just happens to be Markowitz's appointee to the City Planning Commission. (As an investor in the Nets, Williams recused herself from the Atlantic Yards discussion.) New York City Campaign Finance Board data show that other members of the Sitt and Boymelgreen families also contributed to Markowitz, as did developer Gregory O'Connell, who has several projects in Red Hook. One Atlantic Yards connection And where's the heavyweight, Forest City Ratner? We know that Bruce Ratner stopped giving campaign contributions but his brother Michael Ratner and sister-in-law Karen Ranucci, both Manhattan residents, ha...

Revamping Empire State Development: stop playing politics, says report

A consultant's study was issued Tuesday calling for reform of Empire State Development (ESD), the state's chief economic development agency, which encompasses the Empire State Development Corporation (ESDC), the agency that has shepherded and approved the Atlantic Yards plan and oversees other large development projects. The focus, in press coverage, was on technical fixes and a failed job-creation program. Only a close look at the report shows that, in key places, the analysts blame certain ESD/ESDC failures on "political patronage," "political convenience," and the "practice of favoring political over economic criteria." In other words, a report commissioned by the administration of new Gov. Eliot Spitzer , a Democrat, takes strong issue with the practices of ESD/ESDC under longtime Gov. George Pataki, a Republican. The report doesn't mention Atlantic Yards, but there's certainly evidence that the ESDC's board, which I described as...

In move to Brooklyn, average Nets ticket price would leap

Thanks significantly to 170 new high-priced suites, the “blended average ticket price” for Nets games would go up dramatically, 73% for regular-season games and 64% for playoff games, upon the team's move from the Continental Airlines Arena in the Meadowlands to the planned Barclays Center arena. The leap: from $74.98 to $129.72 for regular and preseason games (above), and from $90.71 to $149.18 for playoff games (below). Click to enlarge. The price of most tickets likely wouldn't rise as sharply as the "blended average"--which would be distorted by the nearly sixfold increase in suites --but the projected boom in ticket revenues suggests one reason for a new arena. The projections surfaced in a document provided by developer Forest City Ratner and unearthed by the lawsuit filed by Assemblyman Jim Brennan and State Senator Velmanette Montgomery. The document, titled Nets Income Statement Detail, is part of Brooklyn Arena/Nets Financial Projections , dated 10/10/06. I...

Waiting for Madden: judge indicates AY decision won't come 'til September

While pre-construction demolition and other activities continue in the Atlantic Yards footprint, a decision in the state lawsuit challenging the environmental review of the project probably won't come until September, the judge has indicated. A memo to attorneys released yesterday indicated that Supreme Court Justice Joan A. Madden has changed the case from "Standard" to "Complex" and now has 120 days from the date of the oral argument, May 3, to make a decision. Any interpretation of that memo is speculation, but it suggests that, while lawsuits challenging environmental reviews routinely fail, this one poses particular challenges. Indeed, Madden is faced with an almost absurdly voluminous record: 20,000-plus pages. Some skepticism During oral argument regarding the case, Develop Don't Destroy Brooklyn et al. v. Empire State Development Corporation et al. , Madden expressed skepticism regarding the state's assertions of "blight" and whether t...

Revolving door: consultants AKRF and Habib worked for Ratner, then ESDC

Columnist Michael Kinsley once observed trenchantly about politics in Washington, "The scandal isn't what's illegal; the scandal is what's legal." The same might be said about development in New York State--though a judge has recently raised some questions about the process, as I'll discuss below. Here it is apparently OK for: 1) a developer (in this case Forest City Ratner) to hire consultants (in this case AKRF and Philip Habib and Associates ) to advise on a development plan 2) those consultants to later evaluate the environmental impact of that development plan on behalf of a state agency, the Empire State Development Corporation (ESDC) 3) that agency to pursue the potentially conflicting goals of fostering economic development and evaluating the environmental impact of such development, and 4) the consultants' work for that agency to be reimbursed by the developer. (Above right, the cover of the Final Environmental Impact Statement. Click to enlar...

Brennan: many questions remain, fresh look needed

Assemblyman Jim Brennan, whose lawsuit (with State Senator Velmanette Montgomery) unearthed numerous Atlantic Yards financial documents, has more questions than answers for now about the viability and future of the Atlantic Yards project. His main conclusion , expressed two weeks ago, is that a reliance on a steadily rising market for rentals could threaten the completion and timing of the project, notably the affordable housing component. The New York Times, probing further , suggested that developer Forest City Ratner’s price expectation for condos was unrealistic and could also stall the project. Meanwhile, Brennan thinks that the state should revise the 421-a tax break to reopen discussions about the contours of the project, as I reported on Saturday. He also pointed to a fundamental contradiction that deserves further study--on the one hand, the condos would be much more expensive to build than the rentals; on the other, most of the condos are expected to be much more profitable...

City Council member items and the work of the CBA

The Atlantic Yards Community Benefits Agreement (CBA) was set up, advocates said, to provide worker training for locals and to support minority-owned businesses. Those may be worthy goals, though CBAs are coming in for criticism , in part because the benefits they provide might better come from a more accountable and transparent source: government. City Council funds job training The budget passed this year by the New York City Council includes several items touching on issues raised in the CBA and the City Council, which has not been the most transparent agency in the past, more clearly spells out who's funding what. The budget includes $1.5 million for the MWBE Leadership Association--an organization I couldn't find on the web--to provide "entrepreneurial training on the process and procedures for doing business with the City and/or on the major public works projects." It also will provide $150,000 for Non-Traditional Employment for Women (which has supported At...

The changing face of Pacific Street, and a shrouded Ward Bakery

Not so long ago there were open sidewalks and no scaffolding on Pacific Street between Carlton and Vanderbilt avenues, the center of the eastern segment of the Atlantic Yards footprint. Then, after a parapet fell from the Ward Bakery, scaffolding was erected. Now, as Adrian Kinloch (Brit in Brooklyn) shows , the bakery building (back, right) is shrouded--for safety reasons, I assume--but you still have to walk under the scaffolding. The entire opposite sidewalk is blocked off, as pre-construction work continues on the railyard opposite. Additional explanation (updated 4:40 pm) ESDC says in a construction update : • Beginning Monday, June 25, 2007, the northern sidewalk and parking lane of Pacific Street between Carlton and Vanderbilt Avenues will be closed. These closures are required to allow for support of excavation activities associated with the LIRR relocation. • Beginning Monday, June 25, 2007, jersey barriers will be set up as the fencing of the construction area and steel to ...

On 421-a, Brennan revises stance, FCR’s Bender distorts history

As Assemblyman Hakeem Jeffries and State Senator Velmanette Montgomery this week called for developer Forest City Ratner to abandon the “Atlantic Yards carve-out” in the reform of the city’s 421-a tax exemption, Assemblyman Jim Brennan, who’s been a critic of aspects of the project, seemed like the odd man out--until now. The State Legislature has passed the revised bill but it has yet to be signed by Gov. Eliot Spitzer. Various forces, including the city administration, are calling for a revision or a veto. Brennan had told the New York Observer’s blog The Real Estate Observer that “It’s not a carve-out… The only thing that happened was that Atlantic Yards got grandfathered in.” That seemed inaccurate, given that there’s a special provision that could only apply to Atlantic Yards, allowing the requirement of 20 percent affordable housing to be spread over the project as a whole rather than applied to each building, as the law otherwise would require, and also nudging up the income l...

NYC (it seems) might lose money on the arena, as added pledge upends IBO prediction

The Atlantic Yards arena, once estimated (right) by the city's Independent Budget Office (IBO) to net $107 million in new revenue, now looks much closer to a wash--and worse for the city. A September 2005 IBO report , which focused not on the Atlantic Yards project but on the arena alone, concluded that the arena would "likely to generate a modest net positive fiscal surplus for the city, state, and MTA, measured in present values discounted over the 30-year financing term." But that surplus, a large majority going to the state rather than the city, was calculated before the city more than doubled its pledged $100 million contribution. Now, the city would provide $205 million for infrastructure and to reimburse developer Forest City Ratner for the acquisition of land. (About $100 million would be used for land, though the tab was $135 million as of January. Not all of the remaining $105 million would go to infrastructure for the arena block alone, but a significant fract...