Skip to main content

Posts

Featured Post

Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park FAQ, timeline, and infographics (pinned post)

A New Jersey decision on blight, and the echo for Atlantic Yards

A unanimous decision June 13 by the New Jersey Supreme Court, which overruled a loose application of blight in an eminent domain case, doesn’t apply in New York, but it’s still instructive, since state courts often look to trends in other states. Bottom line: were the lawsuit challenging the Atlantic Yards environmental review transposed to New Jersey, the government would have a much tougher—though perhaps not impossible—task asserting blight. However, the New York State Legislature and state courts, unlike those in many other states, have been slow to revise eminent domain laws in response to public concern. Blight remains a loosely defined and highly contested issue, as in the hearing May 3 regarding the challenge to the Atlantic Yards environmental impact statement. A decision is pending in that case. Notably, one of the blight characteristics asserted in Brooklyn--that buildings are unproductive because they don’t fulfill 60% of allowable development rights--likely wouldn't ...

Seamless transition? FCR's new AY head seen exploring the footprint

Last Wednesday, when Forest City Ratner announced the surprising departure of Atlantic Yards point man Jim Stuckey, the company said in an announcement: For the past few weeks FCRC has prepared for Mr. Stuckey’s departure to create a seamless transition and named MaryAnne Gilmartin, Executive Vice President and Director of Commercial & Residential Development for FCRC, as head of the Atlantic Yards development team. The implication was that Stuckey's departure was not precipitous, contra to some prevailing suspicion, given the developer's failure to praise him for his service. Some confirmation for the latter theory comes from a tipster, who reports spotting Gilmartin at about 8:30 a.m. today, standing at the corner of Dean Street and Sixth Avenue, across from Freddy's Bar & Backroom, the epicenter of the Atlantic Yards opposition. It looked, the tipster said, like she was being briefed for the battlefield. Had the departure been long planned, wouldn't Gilmarti...

EDC criticizes Coney developer's demand for "huge" $100M+ subsidy

A New York Times article today headlined Coney Island Plan Is Scaled Back, but Critics Are Skeptical discusses developer Joe Sitt's revised proposal, with criticism from Robert Lieber, president of the New York City Economic Development Corporation (EDC). The Times reports: “He came in last week and presented a plan that had essentially the same density, but dressed it up with hotels and time shares,” Mr. Lieber said on Friday. “The building heights still exceed the 271-foot Parachute Jump,” a Coney Island landmark. “And he’s looking for a huge subsidy from the city. North of $100 million .” (Emphasis added) Would make the $205 million city subsidy for Atlantic Yards "more than huge"?

At the street fair, FCR and the Nets play pretend

Wandering by the Forest City Ratner/Nets booth yesterday at the Seventh Heaven street fair in Park Slope, I was struck by some examples of omission and misdirection. First, there was no attempt to promote Atlantic Yards, the project. (Is massive Miss Brooklyn, which dominated the cover of Brooklyn Tomorrow , just imaginary?) There's nothing to sell, now, and Forest City Ratner must recognize that the neighborhood is more likely wary of or opposed to the project. Also, a promotional card for the Barclays Center claimed that "history will be made in Brooklyn in 2009" even though the likelihood of the arena opening by that date is low, as even Forest City Enterprises executives have acknowledged . Notably, a free keychain with a rubber basketball offered only "Brooklyn" as a logo, with no mention of the team name. (For the purposes of the photo, I placed the keychain on the card.) I haven't been tracking keychain offerings steadily, but the last time I picked u...

Remember the Brooklyn Standard? The permanent campaign adjusts

Remember the Brooklyn Standard? It was supposed to be published way more often. Two years ago, on 6/17/05, Forest City Ratner announced : FOREST CITY RATNER LAUNCHES THE BROOKLYN STANDARD TO KEEP BOROUGH INFORMED ABOUT ATLANTIC YARDS PROJECT Forest City Ratner Companies (FCRC), the developer of the Atlantic Yards project over the Long Island Rail Road yard at the intersection of Atlantic and Flatbush Avenues, today announced the publication of The Brooklyn Standard, a periodic publication providing updates on the project and information about other relevant news and events in the borough. (Of course the project is not simply “over” the railyard.) Here's the first issue . "Every few months" The press release offered a prediction of publication “every few months”: “We want The Brooklyn Standard to be informative and to the point on issues related to the Atlantic Yards project,” Bruce Bender, the FCRC executive vice president for government and public affairs. “...

Two from BrooklynSpeaks member groups join Bloomberg's administration

Mayor Mike Bloomberg's administration, as part of its long-term sustainability initiative, has hired some well-respected analysts and advocates who've spent a long time on the outside looking in. As Streetsblog has reported , Project for Public Spaces (PPS) vice president and transportation program director Andy Wiley-Schwartz will join the Department of Transportation's (DOT) new Office of Long-Term Planning and Sustainability, reporting to new Deputy Commissioner Bruce Schaller. And Jon Orcutt, former director of the Tri-State Transportation Council (TSTC) has joined DOT to serve as senior policy advisor to the new commissioner, Janette Sadik-Khan. Aaron Naparstek of Streetsblog calls it "totally unimaginable just a few months ago." Both PPS and TSTC have offered savvy criticism of Atlantic Yards both independently and as part of the BrooklynSpeaks coalition. Should the project continue to move forward, at least some city government officials will have taken...

"If the blight comes through": Radio Golf on Broadway, for two weeks more

  When I wrote about the script of playwright August Wilson's final work, Radio Golf , in January 2006, the most striking passage was the exchange between two black businessmen about the wisdom of allying with a white multi-millionaire to help the latter get minority tax credits when buying a radio station. Real estate developer Harmond Wilks, a candidate for mayor, is skeptical about the idea, but his friend and business partner, bank VP Roosevelt Hicks, is more positive about Bernie Smith. For Atlantic Yards watchers, Hicks might evoke former State Assemblyman Roger Green and ACORN president Bertha Lewis, prime movers on the AY Community Benefits Agreement, and Smith might recall Forest City Ratner president Bruce Ratner. Wilks wonders if Hicks is "just the front," but the latter responds, "I get to get in the door... I don't care if somebody else makes some money 'cause of a tax break. I get mine and they get theirs... The window of opportunity is already...

Marty Markowitz and the Navy Yard straw man

Brooklyn Borough President Marty Markowitz's recent interview with City Hall News has him waxing indignantly about Atlantic Yards opponents, then offering a straw man about the Brooklyn Navy Yard and some rather selective thoughts about zoning, which deserve a closer look. Markowitz was asked : Do you think that mega projects like that are appropriate else here in the city? MM: Listen, the answer to that is market driven. For all these years, the issue of over development is a serious issue in many Brooklyn neighborhoods. And that’s why I enthusiastically support down zoning those neighborhoods to preserve the residential quality in those communities of Brooklyn that are single or two family homes, detached or semi-detached. For years, in many of those neighborhoods, developers could have built as of right. As of right. But the demand isn’t there. Today, the demand for the people moving into the city has never been higher. It’s incredible the demand of housing. Therefore, it is im...

Brooklyn Tomorrow: synergy and puffery

It's a document for our times, a promotional magazine inserted in yesterday’s New York Post , not labeled advertorial though it certainly reads as such. Brooklyn Tomorrow is subtitled “The changing face of the bustling borough’s dynamic communities,” and features advertising and cheery articles mainly about major development projects. Produced by the Post’s Community Newspaper Group, and written by staffers from the Courier-Life chain the Post purchased, Brooklyn Tomorrow reads like the return of Forest City Ratner's promotional Brooklyn Standard , but under the imprimatur of an actual newspaper rather than as a “publication.” And, of course, FCR's Atlantic Yards project gets royal treatment. The cover boasts a full-frontal close-up of Frank Gehry’s Miss Brooklyn, which could be described as "massive" or perhaps "striking," rather than “elegant," as stated. On the back cover, another view of Miss Brooklyn, in the Barclays Center advertisement tha...

"Stop Payment": Groups say city's $100M shouldn't buy Ratner land

Maybe it was a little quixotic, since the City Council and Mayor Mike Bloomberg had come to a budget agreement on Monday, but a somewhat unusual coalition of Brooklyn community groups gathered yesterday to protest the apparent allocation of $100 million of city funds to buy land for the Atlantic Yards project. (Photo by Shane Miller) "'Stop Payment' for private property acquisition," read the oversized checks displayed at the press conference outside City Hall, organized by the BrooklynSpeaks coalition, which has called for significant changes in Atlantic Yards but has avoided litigation opposing the project. Likely because of the budget agreement, City Council Members Letitia James and David Yassky, who have criticized the city's allocation decision, were not present at the press conference. The $100 million is part of $205 million in city support for Atlantic Yards, which is $105 million more than contemplated in a February 2005 nonbinding Memorandum of Unders...

Goodbye, Mr. Stuckey; Atlantic Yards head departs for "new challenges"

Jim Stuckey, president of the Atlantic Yards Development Group for Forest City Ratner and the developer's point man for more than three years on the project, has resigned from the company, "effective immediately, citing personal reasons and a desire to pursue new challenges." (Photo from PBS Newshour .) Atlantic Yards, the company stated in a press release (below) issued today via spokesperson Howard Rubenstein, "remains on target." That's of course a relative term, given that parent company Forest City Enterprises has acknowledged a myriad of factors, including ongoing negotiations with governmental authorities, environmental remediation, various lawsuits, increasing construction costs, scarcity of labor and supplies, the difficulty in obtaining tax exempt financing, and increasing rates for financing. Stuckey will be succeeded by MaryAnne Gilmartin , the developer's executive VP and director of commercial & residential development. An observer I s...

Boombox: race, class, and real estate

Gabriel Cohen’s second novel, Boombox , is set in Boerum Hill, but as the title suggests, it echoes Spike Lee’s Bed-Stuy-based Do the Right Thing (remember Radio Raheem ?) as much as the ur-gentrification novel, Jonathan Lethem’s The Fortress of Solitude , also set in Boerum Hill. When a black teenager blasts gangsta rap, and a white yuppie hits the boiling point, reaching for the firearm acquired after he was victimized by a mugging, well, we all know Chekhov’s dictum about guns . Despite the denouement, Boombox is a snappy and engaging read. Though it lacks the depth of character description and neighborhood texture that makes Lethem’s book enduring literature, Boombox captures a tension perhaps most peculiar to post-millennial Brooklyn, yuppies and "urban youth" sharing streets that have ever-precious brownstones on one side and ever-permanent housing projects on the other. (Cohen's reading tonight in Park Slope, as The Gowanus Lounge reports .) Borough changes...

The battle over Queens West: the developer, the process, and the income mix

The process behind a huge affordable housing development planned for Queens West, a 24-acre site the city plans to buy from the Port Authority, presents some interesting contrasts to Atlantic Yards, as well as some potential portents. (Graphic from New York Times) First, the city announced plans for the project without anointing a developer, though it has had "secret talks" (in the Times's phrase) about a sole-source process regarding a nonprofit arm of the powerful Real Estate Board of New York (REBNY). Secondly, the city's initial plan for an all-subsidized project geared to moderate- and middle-income families was criticized for bypassing low-income families. Now the city is considering making 40 percent of the project market-rate. It's another sign that the numbers behind an affordable housing project are constantly shifting; if costs (or pressures for profit) go up, something has to give, and it can be the amenities in the project or, most easily, the income ...

Developer Ross on the undertaxed rich, 421-a subsidies, and "workforce housing"

Stephen M. Ross, one of the city’s leading developers, is bullish on New York real estate, pointing to continued demand for high-end condos and office space. At the same time, as the chairman, CEO, and founder of Related told an audience at New York Law School (NYLS) three months ago, the market is pressed by escalating land and construction costs, and the city can’t keep pace in building middle-income “workforce” housing. And Ross (right), who became chairman of the powerful Real Estate Board of New York (REBNY) in January, identified a new bogeyman in the quest to build affordable housing. He criticized the phase-out of 421-a subsidies—long seen by critics as fueling market-rate construction in city neighborhoods that need no incentives—as jacking up the cost of new buildings. “The burden of the real estate tax system is placed on new construction,” he said in his March 13 speech, suggesting that residents on tony blocks like Park Avenue, Fifth Avenue, and Central Park West get are...