Skip to main content

Posts

Featured Post

Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park FAQ, timeline, and infographics (pinned post)

Affordable housing plan at Brig site results from community-driven development

Yesterday, the city's Department of Housing Preservation and Development (HPD) announced the selection of a developer for the redevelopment of the Navy Brig site in Wallabout, north of Fort Greene, bounded by Flushing Avenue to the north, Park Avenue to the south, Clermont Avenue to the east, and Vanderbilt Avenue to the west. About 77% (or 334) of the 434 residential will be affordable to families earning between 30 percent and 130 percent of the Area Median Income (AMI), which is equivalent to a salary range of $21,250 to $92,170 for a household of four--a slightly narrower range than in the Atlantic Yards plan, where the AMI goes up to 160 percent. Of 179 co-op units, 75 percent will be affordable to households earning up to 130 percent of AMI. (Atlantic Yards would have 200 affordable for-sale units on site, with the income range unspecified.) Of 231 rentals, 97 will be for supportive housing affordable to individuals earning up 60 percent of AMI. That's absent from the At...

The silence of PlaNYC regarding Atlantic Yards (and the right way to develop railyards)

Yesterday, when discussing PlaNYC: A Greener, Greater New York, Mayor Mike Bloomberg called congestion pricing "the elephant in the room." When it comes to the housing section of the plan, however, the elephant in the room is Atlantic Yards. Among the tactics to create hundreds of thousands of new homes are upcoming rezonings to direct growth; the use of transit extensions to spark growth; the pursuit of partnerships with City and State agencies, identification of underutilized areas across the city that are well-served by transit; and exploration of opportunities to create new land by decking over rail yards, rail lines and highways. While numerous examples of past, present, and future projects are provided in the Housing chapter , Atlantic Yards is conspicuously unmentioned. Given that the project remains high on the mayoral agenda , the omission is curious. Is Atlantic Yards so controversial that it's wise to avoid it? Or has the production of the new plan pointed ou...

Congestion pricing plan announced; backlash continues

Mayor Mike Bloomberg yesterday presented PlaNYC: A Greener, Greater New York, which includes 127 separate initiatives, among them housing an additional 1 million New Yorkers affordably; increasing access to parks, playgrounds and open spaces; reclaiming brownfields; developing critical backup systems for our aging water network to ensure reliability; providing additional reliable power sources and upgrading our existing power plants; reducing water pollution so we can open our waterways for recreation; and reducing our greenhouse gas emissions by 30%. But the big one is a congestion pricing pilot scheduled to begin by Spring 2009, aimed to charge drivers who enter the Central Business District in Manhattan in certain hours. The money would be directed toward improving public transit and thus offer opportunities to those most burdened by the charge, though obviously the transition period could be dicey. Successful congestion pricing programs exist in London, Singapore, and other cities...

Flatbush Avenue BRT: not until 2015?

While the city plans to pilot five bus rapid transit routes, one in each borough, in the next few years, the first one in Brooklyn would be Nostrand Avenue . A second round of five routes, likely including Flatbush Avenue, would not be completed until 2015, according to p. 4 of Appendix B to the mayor's PlaNYC report, issued yesterday. There may be room for certain routes in the second round, including Flatbush Avenue, to open before that date. Still, transportation advocates believe that BRT is part of a package, including congestion pricing (which the city hopes to begin by Spring 2009) crucial to make any Atlantic Yards transportation plan work. The arena is scheduled to open in 2009, though that schedule seems unlikely .

City plans new push for solar energy; could "solar zoning" emerge?

New York City's energy-related initiatives within PlanNYC2030 include a new push for solar energy: --a property tax abatement for solar panel installations --support for the city's first carbon neutral building, primarily powered by solar electricity --creative financing to increase the use of solar energy in City buildings --"work with the State to eliminate barriers to increasing the use of solar energy in the city." One of those barriers is shadows caused by tall buildings, such as those planned for the Atlantic Yards project, which have already scotched the Fifth Avenue Committee's plan to implement photovoltaics in a new building just north of Atlantic Avenue. Might the city entertain the notion of "solar zoning" ? No such proposal is specified; however, the exploration of the tension between scale and solar likely will increase.

Congestion pricing, AY, and Bloomberg's sustainability plan

Mayor Mike Bloomberg is set to announce his PLANYC 2030 sustainability initiatives today and congestion pricing, a policy he until recently had avoided, seems to be on the agenda. And congestion pricing--which would impose charges for entering the Central Business District at certain times--would deter a significant amount of traffic detouring through Downtown Brooklyn to use the free bridges. It's been recommended by analysts critiquing the Atlantic Yards transportation plan. [A.M. Peak (6–10 A.M.) congestion graphic from Bruce Schaller's Battling Traffic: What New Yorkers Think about Road Pricing , published by the Manhattan Institute in December. Note significant congestion in Brooklyn around and leading to the planned Atlantic Yards site.] Bloomberg said on his radio show Friday: And we have to do a much better job of providing mass transit in parts of the city where the city never invested in the past, and now we’re paying for that. Places way out in Queens, places State...

Anatomy of a New York Times AY error

1. In an April 5 round-up article on Atlantic Yards, an underinformed Times reporter, abetted by underinformed editors, describes Develop Don't Destroy Brooklyn (DDDB) as an organization "which opposes the scale of the plan." 2. The Times does not publish a correction, which would be attached to the previous article in the archive, but instead, on April 12, publishes a letter from DDDB's Dan Goldstein explaining "Our organization does not merely oppose the scale of the plan, we oppose Forest City Ratner’s project itself on many principled grounds." 3. Another even more underinformed reporter, who has no experience covering AY but (likely) just happens to be available on a late Friday afternoon, is handed the assignment of describing, in a paragraph, the decision by Justice Joan A. Madden to reject a temporary restraining order regarding demolitions. In Saturday's paper, abetted by underinformed editors, he writes that the TRO "had been requested ...

Judge denies TRO; demolitions, protest to begin Monday

State Supreme Court Justice Joan Madden yesterday refused to issue a temporary restraining order (TRO) that would have blocked Forest City Ratner (FCR) from continuing demolitions of properties it owns within the Atlantic Yards site before a preliminary injunction can be argued in court on May 3. That means that demolitions of four properties, which had been scheduled to begin Wednesday but were postponed pending Madden's decision , can proceed on Monday, as will a protest organized by Develop Don't Destroy Brooklyn (DDDB), which leads the coalition of neighborhood and civic groups challenging the environmental review. The protest will be in front of 191 Flatbush Avenue, between 5th Avenue and Dean Street, at 8 a.m. (At right, three of the four buildings at issue.) Four other buildings are scheduled for demolition before the May 3 hearing. Madden noted that she was not making a decision on the ultimate merits of the case, but noted that a "TRO is a drastic remedy which s...

Why the CBA Coalition is not like the ESDC

Two weeks ago, we saw the New York Times bizarrely try to compare the Brooklyn Public Library to Bruce Ratner because both might be involved in eminent domain cases. Yesterday, in Metro , Delia-Hunley Adossa of the Atlantic Yards Community Benefits Agreement (CBA) Coalition, bizarrely tried to equate the coalition with the Empire State Development Corporation (ESDC). Metro reported how Hunley-Adossa complained to local politicians that they should have gone through the coalition to express concerns about demolitions of buildings for interim surface parking: “We told them, ‘Our concern is you never came to us. You jumped and went straight to the ESDC, to the new guy,” she said after the meeting. “Had you come to us, you would have known we are addressing these issues.” CBA vs. ESDC Well, the CBA signers have never held an open public meeting to answer questions from the community they represent. They are significantly funded by developer Forest City Ratner, though the developer won...

FCR's Beekman tower, AY face same problem: scarce tax-exempt financing

Forest City Ratner's annual report acknowledged "the potential for increased costs and delays" to Atlantic Yards as a result of, among other things, "our inability to obtain tax exempt financing or the availability of financing generally." That looks to be an increasing concern. Take the example of the developer's other Frank Gehry-designed tower, on Beekman Street in Lower Manhattan. In this week's New York Observer, in an article headlined Ratner Scrambles for Funding for Gehry-Designed Tower , Matthew Schuerman reports: One portion—presumably the top—would be entirely market-rate rentals and could be financed with Liberty Bonds, which continue to be reserved for the project. The middle portion would consist of mixed-income rentals, 20 percent of which would be priced for low-income households. The school would occupy the lowest five floors, along with retail and possibly a medical facility. In a request filed last year with the H.D.C., Forest City s...

Will DOT come clean on the closure and "demapping" of Fifth Avenue?

In my article in this week's Brooklyn Downtown Star, Closing Fifth Avenue for Atlantic Yards, But Why So Soon? , I expand on my previous coverage of the plan to close Fifth Avenue between Flatbush and Atlantic avenues to accommodate Frank Gehry's flagship Miss Brooklyn skyscraper. I contacted the Department of Transportation (DOT) four times to ask about the timing of the closure--why so soon, by May 27?--given that the construction schedule will inevitably be delayed by litigation. I also asked whether the street could actually be demapped by then. I got an acknowledgement of my query but no answers. (DDDB called it "Closed Streets. Closed Mouths." and linked Jonathan Cohn's photo and graphic below.) Demapping? And though a New York City Transit (NYCT) official cited "the closure and demapping of Fifth Avenue," the street can't be demapped until it's been acquired by the Empire State Development Corporation (ESDC). As I write: So, Chapter 1 of...

Delay demolitions? Not in public interest, say ESDC, FCR

The Empire State Development Corporation (ESDC) and developer Forest City Ratner (FCR) have responded forcefully to the lawsuit trying to invalidate the environmental review for the Atlantic Yards project. In doing so, they argue against the temporary restraining order (TRO) sought by Atlantic Yards opponents and critics to block planned demolitions of some 15 properties owned by the developer, saying that it would not be in the public interest and that the chances of getting a preliminary injunction in court next month are low. A decision on the TRO is expected by Friday. The preliminary papers filed this week will be followed up by more extensive legal arguments from both sides. An affirmation filed by Philip Karmel, an attorney representing the ESDC, points out that the ESDC determined that Atlantic Yards “would achieve significant public purposes;” thus, the “petitioners’ assertion that the public will not be harmed by any delay in the Project is self-serving.” FCR attorney Jeffr...

Would stay on demolitions unduly delay arena? FCR is already behind pace for 2009 opening

In court papers filed earlier this week opposing a temporary restraining order to block demolitions on the Atlantic Yards site, Forest City Ratner VP Jim Stuckey says the developer would face significant losses even over a few months—and that a delay would jeopardize the planned 2009 opening of the arena. However, as lawyers for the plaintiffs point out, the developer “appears to already have virtually abandoned the construction schedule” published in the Atlantic Yards Final Environmental Impact Statement that would lead to a 2009 arena opening Indeed, according to the schedule (from the Final Environmental Impact Statement, Chapter 17), demolition of buildings on blocks needed for the arena was to begin 11/1/06. This page was dated 7/10/06 yet included in the FEIS released 11/27/06 . Click on the graphic below to enlarge, or go to the original PDF . The demolition was to be completed by 7/2/07. However, several buildings in the arena footprint undoubtedly will remain enmeshed in liti...

Forest City Ratner's $5.6 billion lie, in court papers, is attributed to ESDC

In the lawsuit over the Atlantic Yards environmental review, both plaintiffs and defendants are doing their best to cite relevant precedent and spin the case to their favor. But Forest City Ratner executive Jim Stuckey takes it one step further, in an affidavit claiming (right) that the Final Environmental Impact Statement (FEIS) issued by the Empire State Development Corporation estimated that the project would generate $5.6 billion in new tax revenue and $4.4 billion in net tax revenue. There's nothing of the sort in the FEIS . There's no total at all, nor is there an attempt to calculate net revenue, which subtracts costs. Rather, another document issued by the ESDC, the General Project Plan , does calculate new tax revenue and net revenue. However, that net revenue is just $944 million. My discovery last December of that figure , which represented a reduction of nearly 50% from previous estimates, led to widespread media coverage and expressions of concern by the Citizens...

What's a "reasonable worst-case scenario"? ESDC considered terrorism, just not in EIS

Critics of the Atlantic Yards environmental review had previously been told by the Empire State Development Corporation (ESDC) that post-9/11 terrorism was beyond the scope of the law: Emergency scenarios such as a large-scale terrorist attack similar to the World Trade Center attack, a biological or chemical attack, or a bomb are not considered a reasonable worst-case scenario and are therefore outside of the scope of the EIS. However, as indicated in Chapter 1, “Project Description,” the proposed project would implement its own site security plan, which includes measures such as the deployment of security staff and monitoring and screening procedures…. Consultation with NYPD and FDNY has been taking place and would continue should the project move forward. Disclosing detailed security plans is not appropriate for an EIS. Now there's a response from Forest City Ratner in the ligitation challenging the environmental review and seeking a temporary restraining order to block demolit...

Lifting the Markowitz fig leaf from the Atlantic Yards creation myth

Updated 5/10/11 with graphic and clarification. According to at least two accounts, Atlantic Yards developer Bruce Ratner didn't start thinking about an arena near the corner of Atlantic and Flatbush avenues until the summer or fall of 2002. And, according to Borough President Marty Markowitz, Ratner needed prompting from him to consider the opportunity. That's highly unlikely--and it seems to contradict been backed up by some recent statements by Forest City Ratner lawyers. They have claimed, in oral argument and legal papers in the Atlantic Yards eminent domain case, that the developer did not, as charged, initiate the project. I had written that the claim seemed true only if it were narrowly interpreted as reflecting Markowitz's idea for an arena, since surely Markowitz didn't initiate the idea for a 22-acre development. Now it's questionable that Markowitz even initiated the idea for the arena near Downtown Brooklyn. The March 2002 registration See, Forest Ci...

Demolitions postponed, at least briefly; protest may be Monday

Hold everything, at least a few days. At a hearing today before Supreme Court Justice Joan A. Madden, lawyers for the coalition challenging the legitimacy of the Atlantic Yards environmental review argued for a temporary restraining order (TRO) to block demolitions on the Atlantic Yards site. After consultation, developer Forest City Ratner, which had scheduled demolitions to begin tomorrow, agreed not to begin such demolitions this week, and the judge said she'd have a decision on the TRO by Friday. (I wasn't at the hearing, but this was relayed to me by a courtroom observer associated with the plaintiffs.) In light of that, Develop Don't Destroy Brooklyn, which had scheduled a protest rally for 8 a.m. tomorrow, has postponed the rally pending the judge's decision. If a TRO is not granted, the rally will be Monday.

From FCE, (boilerplate) doubt about AY timing; Nets losses prompt $13M loan

While Atlantic Yards supporters have criticized opponents for delaying the project by filing a lawsuit challenging the environmental review, it turns out that developer Forest City Ratner has much more than legal delays on its mind. Also, while the rate of losses for the New Jersey Nets has slowed, the parent company must still offer a $13 million loan to fund the team this year. According to the annual report issued at the end of March by parent Forest City Enterprises, other factors, including increased construction costs and the availability of tax-exempt financing, also play into potential delays. The language is required boilerplate, but it does stand in contrast to the sunny predictions , despite countervailing evidence, that the project will be completed in the promised ten years. The annual report states: Brooklyn Atlantic Yards. We are in the process of developing Brooklyn Atlantic Yards, a $4.0 billion mixed-use project in downtown Brooklyn expected to feature an 850,000 sq...