Skip to main content

Posts

Featured Post

Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park FAQ, timeline, and infographics (pinned post)

DDDB walkathon raises more than $100,000

The Walk Don't Destroy 2 walkathon fundraiser for Develop Don't Destroy Brooklyn (DDDB) yesterday raised more than $100,000 toward legal battles over the Atlantic Yards plan. The event at Prospect Park generated nearly double the amount raised at the first walkathon last November. Organizers said that some 1100 people contributed, with more than 300 participants. That money should (presumably) help build a legal fund sufficient to get fights against eminent domain and perhaps other issues off the ground. But lawyers are expensive, so fundraising undoubtedly will continue. I missed the walkathon, so when I arrived at the corner of 9th Street and Eighth Avenue--a block from the park bandshell--many people in yellow DDDB t-shirts were making their way down the block to catch trains, walk home, or go to a restaurant. So I missed the person who dressed up as a Brooklyn bride--in a wedding dress--a commentary on Frank Gehry's planned "Miss Brooklyn" tower. A crew from...

"Gentrification subsidy": proposed 421-a reform seems tentative

A city task force has issued recommendations to modify the 421-a tax break in order to generate at least $200 million for affordable housing. The question, however, is whether the changes endorsed by Mayor Mike Bloomberg go far enough, since the tax break would still support luxury construction in neighborhoods like Park Slope and Fort Greene and Prospect Heights without requiring affordable housing. A study issued earlier this year by calculated that $320 million in subsidies was unnecessary. Currently, developers who get tax breaks in the 421-a exclusion zone--Manhattan from 14th Street to 96th Street and the Greenpoint-Williamsburg waterfront--must include at least 20 percent affordable housing. The program would expand to parts of Harlem, Lower Manhattan, DUMBO, Brooklyn Heights, and parts of the Brooklyn/Queens waterfront. In other words, there would be no requirement to build affordable housing on the non-railyard blocks of the proposed Atlantic Yards site. Note that the altern...

Atlantic Yards housing subsidies: how much?

From today's Times, an article headlined City Plans Middle-Income Project on Queens Waterfront : Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg announced plans yesterday to buy 24 acres of Queens waterfront property for a towering development, which would be the largest middle-income housing complex built in New York City in more than 30 years. Under the proposal, the city would bring as many 5,000 new rental units to a largely industrial area of Long Island City, where chic restaurants are just beginning to appear amid low-slung factories and three-family homes. The new apartments, Mr. Bloomberg said, would be for families of four earning between $60,000 and $145,000 a year, who would pay $1,200 to $2,500 a month in rent. This would be a lot more than the 2250 affordable rental units promised for the Atlantic Yards project, which would have more than 6000 total units. However, about half of those rental units would be available to families earning under $60,000. Cost per unit The Times reported that...

The ESDC acknowledges some costs, Times offers some skepticism, story downplayed

More than a day after the Empire State Development Corporation released a sketchy fiscal impact analysis for the Atlantic Yards project, the agency offered some backup calculations--which do allow for nearly $500 million in costs, but still fail to fully account for all costs, including housing subsidies. The New York Times, in an article headlined Study Shows Data for Claim of Atlantic Yards’ Benefits , offered the agency's explanation: Because it is hard to determine how many residential tenants of the project would be new to New York, the analysis excludes them as a source of new revenue, as well as the cost for possible increases in municipal services they might require. Unmentioned by the Times is that the Independent Budget Office and Forest City Ratner's own consultant, Andrew Zimbalist, tried to calculate such costs. The Times did point out that the ESDC had done an about-face after Chairman Charles Gargano had told Channel 13 that the document wouldn't be released....

Spitzer backs Atlantic Yards, calls 8% cutback "appropriate"

Gubernatorial frontrunner Eliot Spitzer yesterday said that he considers the promised 8% reduction in the Atlantic Yards project a "reasonable compromise," thus suggesting he has no idea that the cutback would bring the project back to the square footage originally proposed. Then again, if he relies on the New York Times, he doesn't know better. The newspaper last month published a front-page scoop--the lead story of the day --about the planned cutback without pointing out that the move would essentially return Atlantic Yards to square one. (That square footage would be over one additional acre.) Follow-up clarifications were buried. Spitzer made his comments during an interview on WNYC's Brian Lehrer Show. ESDC performance Lehrer raised the issue of the Empire State Development Corporation (ESDC), the state agency that manages major projects, including Atlantic Yards.. BL: On development in general, you said Governor Pataki’s’ ESDC has spent too much money on the w...

ESDC releases fiscal "impact analysis," but it only acknowledges benefits

Can we trust the Empire State Development Corporation's (ESDC) fiscal impact analysis regarding Atlantic Yards? Nope. For three months, the agency had refused to release the document behind the claim , in the General Project Plan, that the AY project "will generate $1.4 billion in net tax revenues in excess of the public contribution to the Project." In a WNYC TV segment broadcast earlier this month, Chairman Charles Gargano reiterated the refusal. Today, after queries from the press, Atlantic Yards opponents, and Assemblyman Jim Brennan, the ESDC released the seven-page document . It's deeply unconvincing. Despite the phrase "public contribution" noted above, there's no reference to public contributions or public costs. In other words, it's a fiscal benefit analysis, not an impact analysis. [Update: though they're not in the document, some costs are acknowledged by the ESDC.] The New York City Economic Development Corporation did the same th...

The Shiffman solution: a timeout for megadevelopment projects

A recently broadcast CUNY Forum TV program, Megadevelopment in New York City , featured some lively discussion about major projects like Atlantic Yards and Columbia University's expansion in Manhattanville. Notably, pointing to the advent of a new governor, longtime community planner Ron Shiffman called for a timeout on megaprojects like Atlantic Yards so they don't get snagged in an eminent domain battle but rather emerge from a truly public process. "New York City is expanding in population," acknowledged Shiffman, who formerly headed the Pratt Institute Center for Community and Environmental Development (PICCED) and now teaches at Pratt. "We’re going to need higher density development. But we should do it in a way that we don’t overwhelm the local physical social and economic infrastructure. The only way to do it well is by engaging the people who live in the area, as well as citywide interests." State control Council Member Melinda Katz of Queens, who c...

"Brutally weird": Errol Louis on CBGB, AY, and the homeless

In the Daily News, columnist Errol Louis has to write tight, sometimes simplistically so. He just doesn't have much space. In his "Commerce and Community" column in the twice-monthly Our Time Press , he's got more column inches, but he usually breaks up his effort into two or even three items. Louis devotes his latest Our Time Press column (reproduced below, in full) to Atlantic Yards. That allows him to stretch stylistically before he resolves his chords, as always, into a familiar Atlantic Yards song. But he still doesn't bother with much research. It's quite a performance, notably his mangling of history and his casual dismissal of the question of subsidies. It sure makes you wonder: this is the guy recently honored by the North Star Fund for "help[ing] us to see alternatives that are rooted in our democratic ideals"? The problem is... hipsters? Under the headline Chronicle of a Defeat Foretold , Louis begins by citing a speech given by noveli...

Belated Boyland filings show she outraised Montgomery, used same firm as Ratner

So much for the " $100 mystery campaign ." Overdue campaign finance filings from 18th Senatorial District candidate Tracy Boyland, who unsuccessfully challenged incumbent (and Atlantic Yards opponent) Velmanette Montgomery , show that the former City Council member, despite a candidacy launched two months before the September primary, indeed raised more than the $100 she reported at election time. In less than three months, Boyland outraised Montgomery, $92,177 to $91,427, relying significantly on the building industry. (Montgomery's total covers two years, and she outspent Boyland overall; see below.) Was Boyland, in fact, the "Ratner candidate," as some charged? Not exactly, but there were some signficant intersections. As predicted by a source in the Crain's Insider, Boyland indeed used the same consulting firm-- Knickerbocker SKD --that FCR uses for its deceptive Atlantic Yards mailers. (As noted , Boyland told the Brooklyn Papers that she's frien...

Blight and the Courier-Life's "visual walk"

It's not online yet, but in this week's Courier-Life chain, Stephen Witt offers a rather, uh, incomplete account of the blight fight regarding Atlantic Yards. [Update 10/17/06: here's the article .] He summarizes it as such: DDDB and opponent bloggers and journalists contend the area is not blighted, citing published reports of how parts of Prospect Heights are being revitalized. Meanwhile, a visual walk around the rail yard portion of the footprint reveals homeless people still in the area as well as overgrown weeds, broken glass and litter. But what if the Courier-Life allowed its readers to actually read more about those issues, linking to some of the writings briefly referenced? (Try here , and here and here . Or a more detailed summary .) Would readers be less impressed by the conclusions of the "visual walk" if they were reminded that litter and weeds could be cleaned up by the MTA? Or if they learned that Develop Don't Destroy Brooklyn (DDDB), which sp...

Park Slope Civic Council opposes AY as currently proposed

The Board of Trustees of the Park Slope Civic Council (PSCC) has agreed, nearly unanimously, that it "cannot support" Atlantic Yards project as currently proposed. In doing so, it cited an undemocratic public process, a poorly conducted environmental review, the inappropriate use of eminent domain, and the affect on the area's quality of life. Still, the compromise statement adopted Oct. 5 allowed that PSCC could support the project if changes were made, as per the BrooklynSpeaks campaign that PSCC has already endorsed, including a "substantial reduction of the project and the creation of truly public open space," improvements in transportation and transit, a better affordable housing plan, and a "truly public process." Close look raises concerns The vote, 19-1, with one abstention, came after the PSCC Atlantic Yards Committee discussed its extensive and rigorous submission in response to the Draft Environmental Impact Statement (DEIS), citing nume...

Footprints or fragments, gallery show evokes a piece of Prospect Heights

So a couple of hundred people--Brooklynites, artists, friends of artists, all of the above--wandered down to the Grand Space gallery last night for the opening of Footprints: Portrait of a Brooklyn Neighborhood . (The gallery is at 778 Bergen at Grand, just east of Washington Ave.) Brooklyn artists were asked to explore the neighborhood that would be the site of the proposed Atlantic Yards project, and the results were varied: portrait and documentary photography, abstract and representational painting, creative and crude symbols. Yes, there was a portrait of Develop Don't Destroy Brooklyn spokesman Daniel Goldstein , but equally striking were photographs of residents of rent-stabilized buildings, like the Santiago family (right), in a portrait by Nura Qureshi. Qureshi comments , "These images document residents of 810/812 Pacific Street who are directly threatened by the “Atlantic Yards” redevelopment project. By narrowing my focus to this corner of the Footprint I hoped to o...