Skip to main content

Posts

Featured Post

Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park FAQ, timeline, and infographics (pinned post)

Newsday critic: project would be west (?) of Atlantic/Flatbush intersection

In his 5/22/06 assessment of Frank Gehry's Atlantic Yards project, headlined Time to catch the wave , Newsday critic Justin Davidson makes two basic factual errors. First, he describes the project as 16 buildings covering 21 acres. Actually, it's 17 buildings (16 towers + arena) covering 22 acres. He makes a more fundamental error, writing: The developer Bruce Ratner wants to import the New Jersey Nets and erect for them a majestic yet intimate arena on the arrowhead-shaped lot where Atlantic and Flatbush avenues cross. Stretching to the west would be a high-rise Xanadu of offices, apartments, stores and restaurants, turning a dingy-chic wedge of city into a bright new campus. (Emphasis added) Now that error could have been averted had the critic spent a minimal amount of time reading the documents associated with the project or walking around the proposed footprint. If he can't get the basics right, how could we expect him to engage the broader issues ? Questions of scale...

"Sketches" of Gehry, but unencouraging hints for Brooklynites

The ads for Sydney Pollack's new documentary Sketches of Frank Gehry excerpt words from reviews: “absorbing,” “seductive,” “superb,” and “a very fine documentary about our era’s master builder. Refreshing, instructive, and satisfying.” Yes, Gehry’s designed some terrific buildings and had an important influence on architecture--and the camera loves the curves of the Guggenheim Bilbao and other sinuous structures. But international fame does not equal responsiveness to the community. While the film makes no reference to the Atlantic Yards project, but, viewed through a Brooklyn-centric lens, it offers offers some unencouraging hints: Gehry comes off as artist, not urban planner, is shown to possess a monumental ego, and appears to have been more concerned about being a "good neighbor" in Los Angeles than in Brooklyn. (At left, the director and his subject, old friends.) [Architect Jonathan Cohn has some more reflections today on the role of the architect and the sc...

The Times Magazine on architecture, Columbia, and (erroneously) AY

The New York Times Magazine today offers The Architecture Issue , under the cover line Building to a Fight: Why Architecture Is the Only Art Form We Still Battle Over . It's understandable that the Atlantic Yards project isn't a focus; Frank Gehry's revised designs were unveiled only ten days ago. The main article set in New York, headlined The Manhattanville Project , concerns tensions over Columbia University's plans to expand into West Harlem. It seems like a well-reported article, with a thoughtful exposition of Columbia's challenges and also the community's concerns. Then again, a brief mention of the Atlantic Yards plan contains three errors: Still, Mayor Michael Bloomberg has come out in strong support of eminent domain--which also figures in the developer Bruce Ratner's controversial efforts to construct a basketball stadium and condos in the Atlantic Yards area of Brooklyn. First, it's an arena (indoor facility, with a floor or rink), not a sta...

Simon Liu's art supply business to move after deal with Ratner

Simon Liu Inc., a highly-regarded art supply business with 25 employees on Dean Street within the proposed Atlantic Yards project footprint, has long been mentioned as a business threatened by eminent domain. Liu last year told the Daily News that he was seeking a new building but that all options were too expensive. (The 6/24/05 article, headlined Unfair & un-American, biz cries , came after the Supreme Court's Kelo eminent domain decision, and focused on another business outside Brooklyn.) Now, however, Liu plans to move; the Brooklyn Papers reported, in an article this week headlined For gallery's last show, look up in the sky (p. 4), that Liu sold his building to Ratner several months ago. (The terms have not been disclosed; will Liu be allowed to discuss the deal with the press?) "It's a real tragedy," gallery manager Leon Kalas told the newspaper. "Simon's gallery had become an important gathering palce for artists, and now it's all bein...

Two Urban Land Institute awards go to Forest City projects

Two subsidiaries of Forest City Enterprises, the parent company of Forest City Ratner, are among the ten winners of the Urban Land Institute's (ULI) Awards for Excellence: The Americas competition, which is the land use industry’s most prestigious award. According to ULI's press release, those honored include: Stapleton District 1, Denver, Colorado (Forest City Stapleton, Inc.) The first phase (489 acres) of this 4,700-acre master-planned community contains four schools, 2,100 residential units, 100 acres of parks and open space and 320,000 square feet of commercial space. Upon buildout, the former airport will include 12,000 homes. Victoria Gardens, Rancho Cucamonga, California (Forest City Commercial Development; Lewis Group of Companies) This 175-acre project provides a new downtown district for a community that had grown up without one, and is notable for its large-scale introduction of an authentic urban center by a private-sector developer. Looking at the broader picture...

From Forest City Enterprises' annual report: optimism and caveats

In the front narrative of Forest City Enterprises' 2005 annual report, there's an optimistic take on the Atlantic Yards project, with hints that it could stimulate further development . This document, like the 10-K document referenced below, refers to the year ending 1/31/06, though the latter was signed 3/28/06: In Brooklyn, we acquired much of the land for the development of our Atlantic Yards mixed-use community, which is expected to include a new arena for the Nets basketball team, in which we are an investor. As expected, the team operated at a loss, but our long-term objectives are to build a great franchise, move it to Brooklyn (a city of 2 million people), and develop a large-scale, mixed-use project with the Nets and a Frank Gehry-designed arena as catalysts for the project and the further revitalization of downtown Brooklyn. In the attached 10-K filing , where the company must disclose risks, the language is, as is typical in such disclosures, far more sober: Brookly...

Thousands of million-dollar condos, the AY scale, and FCR's bottom line

Forest City Ratner executive Jim Stuckey, in a radio interview Monday, defended the size of the Atlantic Yards project, saying "Unfortunately, if you want to build on this site, the infrastructure costs and the land costs are so significant that it does require that you build to a certain scale." His unverifiable statement raises several questions about costs and revenues, statistics that Forest City Ratner won't discuss publicly. But some back-of-the-envelope calculations suggest that just the housing revenues could go far toward recouping the costs of the project. First, the most expensive arena ever obviously drives up the project cost. Second, the cost of acquiring and operating the Nets. Third, the cost of land acquisition includes a relatively inexpensive price for the 8.3-acre railyard ($100 million), and some relatively expensive deals for specific buildings occupying smaller plots on the 22-acre site, such as $ 44 million for two properties. Note that the long...

Raising hell? Allan Temko and the "foxes" critiquing architecture today

So, are architecture critics raising hell the way Allan Temko used to? Not quite, according to those gathered two weeks ago for the 2006 Temko Critics Panel in honor of the recently-deceased San Francisco Chronicle critic, who felt that architecture criticism should not be reactive but proactive, to “get in and fight before the damn thing is built,” as Daniel Rose, chair of the Forum for Urban Design, said in his introduction. In Temko’s 1/26/06 obituary in the Chronicle, former Chronicle Executive Editor Matthew F. Wilson said, "Allan had a dramatic effect on the skyline of San Francisco and beyond. Architects, city planners and politicians took his criticism very seriously. Often when there was (an official) plan and he espoused a different approach, things got changed." The panel included Robert Campbell of the Boston Globe, John King of the Chronicle, Nicolai Ouroussoff of the New York Times, and Paul Goldberger of the New Yorker. Robert Ivy of Architectural Record mode...

High-rise vs. low-rise; the Times resists corrections, maintains false dichotomy

When Atlantic Yards architect Frank Gehry said last Thursday that Brooklynites wary of the Atlantic Yards plan would have picketed Henry Ford, and when landscape architect Laurie Olin said they were " frightened " of change, the two designers set up a simplistic dichotomy between progress and Luddism. The misrepresentation was compounded by some shorthand in the Times's 5/12/06 report: "They [opponents] have backed alternative plans for the site, including proposals by rival developers that would include mostly low-rise buildings and would not require eminent domain." That continued the false dichotomy. Opponents have helped formulate the UNITY (Understanding, Imagining, & Transforming the Yards) plan, which serves as a set of principles for development, not a funded alternative. UNITY plan principles were adapted by the Extell Development Corp., the sole developer that responded to the Metropolitan Transportation Authority's RFP for the Vanderbilt Ya...

ESDC's Gargano: "We didn't really have to use eminent domain" for Atlantic Yards (?!)

In a Q&A today with the tabloid Metro, headlined Letting a thousand projects bloom , Empire State Development Corporation (ESDC) Chairman Charles Gargano, was asked: What do you say to Brooklynites concerned about the Atlantic Yards? His response: The facts are that we didn’t really have to use eminent domain because there were friendly condemnations done. The amount of condemnation that we had to do was very small. I grew up in Park Slope, and another big blunder by the city was we lost the Brooklyn Dodgers. They wanted to build a new Ebbets Field at the Atlantic Yards. And because of that blunder in the ’50s, we have had a blighted look in the Atlantic Yards for nearly 50 years. There will always be people who object because everybody has different personal interests, and that’s OK. But I think what you have to do is do it for the majority. Friendly condemnations ? There have been some friendly buyouts or property owners, but no condemnations as of yet (unless he's conflatin...

More on the Atlantic Center mall towers: hints but no details

During the Brian Lehrer Show Monday, the host asked Forest City Ratner executive Jim Stuckey about the company's plans to build new towers above the Atlantic Center mall, which were hinted at by models displayed at the press conference last Thursday. (Photo of 2005 model from Courier-Life chain.) Stuckey replied that, when the Atlantic Yards Memorandum of Understanding was signed in February, 2005, "we signed a Memorandum of Understanding to build over the Atlantic Center mall as well." What he didn't say was that the first MOU was announced publicly, and the second--which transfers some rights to build at Site 5 across Flatbush Avenue (currently home to P.C. Richard/ Modell's)--was not announced until Develop Don't Destroy Brooklyn discovered it through a Freedom of Information Act request. The Downtown Brooklyn EIS Stuckey told Lehrer, "The fact is that this was studied in the downtown plan’s EIS." Well, the proposed construction was incorpora...