In win for P.C. Richard, judge orders state to refrain from condemnation while related case is pending. Judge finds ESD "not credible."
A new court ruling adds a further complication to the long-delayed plan to build a giant two-tower project at Site 5, long home to P.C. Richard and Modell's (though the latter is closing ). In a win for retailer P.C. Richard, hoping to stay at Site 5 catercorner to the Barclays Center and gain a replacement store at a future project there, a state Supreme Court judge has agreed to stay a state condemnation action while a separate, related case proceeds. In that related case, P.C. Richard last year won the initial round; a judge ordered that original developer Forest City Ratner was required to deliver replacement space in the yet-unbuilt successor building at Site 5. That case is currently on appeal. Site 5 was approved for a 250-foot single tower but, since no "Miss Brooklyn" tower was built at what's now the arena plaza, the project developer has since 2015 aimed to move that unused bulk across the street for a much larger project, nearing 800 feet tall, whic