Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park Report

If Affordable Housing Over Railyards Doesn't Work, Are "Politicians & Activists" to Blame? ( link ) Columnist criticizes unrealistic goals, but New York State backed developer Ratner's unwise (and renegotiated) Atlantic Yards plans with dubious reports.

Led by Council Member Crystal Hudson, ten local elected officials yesterday wrote to Gov. Kathy Hochul and Hope Knight, CEO of Empire State Development (ESD), urging them to start collecting $1.752 million in liquidated damages for the 876 Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park affordable housing units that were supposed to be built by May 31 The letter (bottom), was signed by Hudson and her colleague Shahana Hanif; Assemblymembers Jo Anne Simon, Robert Carroll, and Phara Souffrant Forrest; Borough President Antonio Reynoso; State Senator Jabari Brisport; and Congressional Representatives Dan Goldman, Yvette Clarke, and Nydia Velazquez.  The latter three officials have been far quieter about Atlantic Yards, for example not appearing at a press conference called by--or in a press release from--the coalition BrooklynSpeaks . Hudson posted the letter on BlueSky yesterday, prompting a report earlier today from Gothamist, which quoted ESD as reiterating that it would stop suspending the damages...

At a press conference last week organized by BrooklynSpeaks, as I wrote ( link ), Assemblymember Jo Anne Simon pointed to the state's failure to collect damages for unbuilt affordable housing "We want this housing," she said. "We want it built now. It was a public benefit that was promised to everybody and whether you like the project or not, whether you wanted it here, there or whatever, this is a public benefit that was promised to the people of New York and it has not been delivered on." She's right that, the longer the wait, the longer it takes to serve people vulnerable to displacement. Not so fast As I wrote, that statement deserves a "Yes, but." If the only way to get that housing is to build at Site 5 , catercorner to the arena, at unprecedented density, then, no, not everyone wants the housing. (Quick, who said of Atlantic Yards, exaggerating the numbers, "If it’s built the way it was approved, we’re going to end up with 16 60-story b...

We hear a lot now about "abundance" and the belief that the city must do anything to get more housing. It's a real problem--well, it's a regional problem that should be addressed with better state and tri-state leadership--but we shouldn't turn off our skepticism. Resorts World promotion For example, I recently got sponsored emails from two political publications, PoliticsNY.com (the Schneps Media politics vertical) and City & State, both with the subject line "Resorts World is Delivering Workforce Housing for New Yorkers, Starting Now!" The City & State message stated: Resorts World New York City is committed to addressing the housing crisis everyday working New Yorkers face today. To help solve the crisis, Resorts World New York City has formed a joint venture with Cirrus Workforce Housing to  invest in 50,000 units of workforce housing across the five boroughs. This pact represents a major investment from Resorts World New York City, the sing...

Modell's, Dec. 2024. Photo: Norman Oder As first announced last September ( link ), BSE Global--owner of the Brooklyn Nets, New York Liberty, and the Barclays Center operating company--will transform empty ex-Modell's store across from arena for its Brooklyn Basketball youth programs, at least until new towers are built. Modell's closed in the late summer of 2020, after the parent faced bankruptcy. A plan for two large towers at the parcel known as Site 5, which still has the operating P.C. Richard store, has gotten support from Empire State Development (ESD), the state authority that oversees/shepherds Atlantic Yards. The BSE Global rendering is suspiciously traffic-free However, that requires a new public process for approval, given the transfer of bulk from the unbuilt B-1 tower once slated to loom over the arena, and likely is entangled in the larger negotiation over the fate of the six railyard development sites. In other words, it's several years off. So this tr...

Bi-Weekly Digest: BrooklynSpeaks Frustration over Penalties; Quiet MTA Renegotiations ( link ) The lesson from Atlantic Yards, Borough President Reynoso warns city officials pushing the Brooklyn Marine Terminal Plan, is that commitments don't get enforced. 

The Association for Neighborhood & Housing Development (ANHD) has released its  2025 Housing Risk Chart, How is Affordable Housing Threatened in Your Neighborhood .  (The ANHD is a membership organization of New York City neighborhood-based community groups, community development corporations (CDCs), affordable housing developers, supportive housing providers, community organizers, and economic development providers.) I've highlighted the sections involving the four Community Districts in Brooklyn--CDs 2, 3, 6, and 8--in the orbit of the Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park project and in which local residents get a preference in affordable housing lotteries, at least for city-sponsored units (as opposed to those solely relying on a state tax break). CD's 3 and 8 are also the location of the sites in the Atlantic Avenue Mixed-Use Plan. Chart goals The chart, according to the ANHD, highlights and ranks 18 indicators of demographics and housing risk to inform targeted...

Sometime in the last week, the updated 2025 New York City Area Affordable Monthly Rents surfaced on the website  of the city Department of Housing Preservation and Development (HPD), with an increase of about 4.3% over 2024 figures, correlating with the rise in Area Median Income, or AMI. See more on this below (I wrote about the rise in AMI April 28.) Bottom line: for low-income units at 60% of AMI, which is the average affordable unit required under the 485-x tax break (likely for the next Atlantic Yards/Pacific Park towers) and under Mandatory Inclusionary Housing Option 1 in the recently-passed Atlantic Avenue Mixed-Use Plan (AAMUP), the 2025 maximum rents would be: studio: $1,701, up from $1,640 1-BR: $1,822, up from $1,747 2-BR: $2,187, up from $2,097 3-BR: $2,527, up from $2,422 HPD notes that those are the maximum rents, while specific rent amounts may vary by program. So it's likely those rent ceilings may not correlate to most or all of the units rented this year at 60...